The stafff were very nice and made us cheese pizza upon request. The pizza is too cheesy. The crust is too thin. The tomato sauce tasted like paste- it could be sweeter and more flavorful. The cheesy bread was too dry- it didn't even taste cheesy. The cold pasta and salad were good.. I would recommend games for children and more desserts.. There also needs to be repairs made on the ceiling. This place has potential, but needs some definite changes. read more

Mazzio's Italian Eatery - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Duncan, Oklahoma

See all

the pizza toppings are fine. the people are nice. the store is clean. however mazzios has a very bad habit of undercooking the pizza and the center crust is gummy. we used to order supreme but the hand tossed crust wasnt crispy. so we switched to 3 ingredient hand tossed thinking there were too many toppings for it to crisp. that didnt work. so tonight i ordered 3 ingredient thin crust and it was even gummier than usual and we couldnt eat it. so tomorrow i will try to crisp it at home. i dont know if they turn the ovens off early--tonights order was picked up at 815 pm or if the cook is not watching the time, or oven setting is off or if their oven is not working as it should. we are long time mazz duncan pizza fans but after tonight it will be a long time before i try them again. their sandwiches are fine tho so long as you specify extra meat. without extra meat choice they have almost no meat. if they are trying to save electricity by running a too cool oven or cutting it off early they are making a large mistake. read more

tonight ordered the large combo with coupon from their site. coupon price was $14.99 coupon number 102. the mazios person said it woould be $17.68 with tax, wife picked it up and the charge was $21 with tax. wife picked it up amd she didnt know what the mszzio order person told me. so magically the price went up about $3 despite the order person accepting my coupon and confirming a final price includind tax.theres something wrong when the agreed stated price goes up three bucks. i would dig into the price change manipulation if i was the okc mgr. why was the price increased 3 bucks? who got the 3 bucks.???? why the change? its like they charged us regular price and pocketed the difference. this the most logical scenario to me. basically skimming profits, as far as pizza goes we ordered hand tossed and wife and i thought it was crummy. we order maz duncan a lot. usually very good. maybe 2nite they gave us a heavy dough which we hate and didnt order. also normally the pizza sauce is about 3 tablespoons to a whole pizza which is far too little. but tonight it was just swimming in sauce, very bad,maz management needs to control this, root cause is poor corporate training. i dont blame the store employees store is clean, people are nice. but as an old auditor when people accept coupon price and magically the final price reverts to the normal menu price then i suspect fraud. i say thid as a certified internal auditor and cpa. if mazzios wants to discuss this privately i am willing and have a few suggestions 4 read more

It's has great food has a great atmosphere and it's very good food and it worth the price and it's very affordable

Tried this place again, not real busy but 45 minutes after opening time had to wait on pizza on the buffet. The girl who runs cash register stays on her phone most of the time we were there, she keeps going outside to talk to someone in parking lot. The lady cooking pizza goes outside to talk to same person. This so poorly managed and run, once again back tables are dirty from night before. They just block off back part. It's hard to believe whoever owns this franchise doesn't even care. They better hope health board doesn't show up . read more

Love their pasta. The 6 cheese penne & lasagna were both awesome! Excellent service.

We were house hunting and stopped by for lunch. I wasn't sure of the Italian food since I've never eaten here, but figured you usually can't go wrong with pizza. Unfortunately, we did not care for it. The staff was friendly and the restaurant appeared clean, so I wanted to like it since we were moving here, but it just wasn't for us. read more

Have tried to have this place more than once and every time the service has been less than stellar. Picked it up tonight and food wasn't under a warming plate when picked up. The worker working the window thought a tip was required before getting our food. Really want to like the place but they need to definitely work on the customer service as well as ethic towards customers. read more

Mazzios have been over priced and disgusting for at least 15-20 years now. Was great in the 90s, unfortunately times change.

Food is great. I especially like the Chicken Alfredo pizza. I have eaten there every Sunday for 20 years and frequent problems are, guests having to clean their own tables, and almost every Sunday, they run out of forks. Service is great for the most part, besides having to clean your table yourself. If you ask the staff to come do it, they do it promptly. It's just frustrating to have to go ask them to do it or ask for a washcloth. read more

Love this place but decided to try the buffet what a terrible experience the food was cold and old staff was standing around like they wanted to be somewhere else the girl who took our order suggested the buffet we won't be back read more

Very good pizza we picked up our order, nice employees, very flavorful pizza way better than my use to be favorite pizza hut which is slipping these days. The salads were also fresh and the ranch was awesome read more

Pizza was overly sauced, chicken "wings" (boneless) tasted stale and were dry. CHICKEN Alfredo, lacked chicken and what small pieces I did get were hard or chewy. read more

Below is my order. QTY NAME PRICE EXT. PRICE 1 Each Mazz Meal (Specialty) Bun $ 22.00 $ 22.00 1 Each Works Pizza Bundle $ 0.00 $ 0.00 Original Mazzio's Traditional Red Mozzarella Canadian Bacon Italian Sausage Pepperoni Sausage Beef Black Olives Green Peppers Mushrooms Red Onions Parmesan Cheese Packet Red Pepper Packet 1 Each 10 Traditional Wings Bund $ 2.65 $ 2.65 Tossed Mach 1 2x Bleu Cheese Dipping Sauce 1 Each Small Cheese Dippers Bund $ 2.80 $ 2.80 Four Cheese 2x Sweet Red Marinara Bleu Cheese 2x Ranch Subtotal: 27.45 Tax: 2.33 ---------- Total: $ 29.78 Payments: $ 29.78 Issues and problems with order........... #1: Pick up time was scheduled at 4:45pm, still had to wait an additional 15 minutes although it was prepaid! #2: Pizza was less than mediocre, lots of toppings but not flavorful. #3: Did not receive Parmesan cheese packets, red pepper packets for the pizza and order clearly states. Only received 1 blue cheese for wings, did not receive marinara or ranch or blue cheese for cheese dippers. To me, I could move past the unflavored pizza because the wings were good and the cheese dippers were good as well, but I hate ordering something and not receiving the items. read more

Took 50 minutes for them to make two medium pizzas. Pizza was beyond mediocre. It's similar to the type of pizza you'd find at a gas station. read more

Had Mini Meatball Bake. Yummy! Service a little slow but food quite tasty. Had it to go and it was still hot when I got back to the hotel room. read more

Mazzio's Italian Eatery - Mini Meatball Bake - yum - Pizza Near Me - Duncan, Oklahoma

Wow! Do I miss Mazzio's Pizza! We don't have Mazzio's in Colorado! Their pizza is fabulous for a chain restaurant. I really liked the pepperoni! The salad bar was always good too! read more

We came to drive thru had to think and was kinda slow. However when we got home, me and my mom shared a calzone ring and it was average. My step dad ordered a medium supreme pizza and said they put most of one of the meats on like two of the pieces. It was still pretty cheap and like I said before average. read more

I placed my order online, waited 20 minutes before leaving then drove 10 minutes to get my pizza. I was greeted as soon as I walked in, however the order still wasn't ready. I'm waiting and the girl who greeted me starts to pack a delivery order. I'm doing so she uses her hands as salad tools to package the salad for a delivery order. I report what I see to a man behind the counter who questions if it's what I've really seen. I reassured him I watched her in disbelief over and over again picking up salad ingredients and placing them in the container to be taken to another customer. He rolls his eyes walks away without saying anything to me and leaves the salad there on the counter. He walks around and then while he thinks I'm not paying attention I see him out of the corner of my eye put the salad in the delivery bag. I was in complete shock. I went to my car and called the store asking for a manager and the girl who answered informed me he had just walked out the door to do a delivery. It was the man I spoke to about the salad in the first place. I am not one to make a huge deal but in the middle of a pandemic using our hands as kitchen tools is not acceptable. I'll be calling corporate Monday to voice my concerns. read more

I placed an order to be delivered. 2-1/2 hours it still had not been delivered. I called in and was told there was a 3 mile radius for deliveries. What a joke. 1-1/2 miles ieach direction. You must be missing out on a lot of orders. Also, no one bothered to call me and tell me any of this. I was told after I called in to see where my Order was. And by the way, I had a $10.00 tip waiting for the delivery person. Won't be eating Mazzios Pizza anymore with that kind of customer relations. read more

Lunch buffet is outstanding for the price. You absolutely CANNOT beat this place. Do not leave without trying the cinnamon stick things. YUMMM! read more