Well, is this or the Slippery Noodle the true oldest bar in the state?…read more I sure hope it's Knickerbocker Saloon, because the place is great. Good drinks, good beer selection, friendly (if seriously busy) bartenders, decent patio and fantastic inside seating. The decor is wonderful - love the belt-driven fans and the tin ceiling. And the food is really good - the pork tenderloin (brought down from sister bar Digby's was a "grown up" version with flavorful marinated meat encased in a nice breading that refused to crumble off, topped with a mustard sauce and house-made cucumber, onion and jalapeño pickles on a brioche bun that stood up to it all. It's not the tenderloin I had as a kid, but it's a delight for a grown-up. I really like this place, and so does my wife.

Had to stop in since I was in the area with some time on my hands. I've been to the bar in Indy…read morethat claims "oldest bar in Indiana" as well. Now, whichever it is, I've been there. The bartender was friendly & attentive. The surprise was that food comes from the bar across the street! There is no kitchen here, but they own the other bar. I got their (bar across the street) namesake burger & chips. Both were very good. I could see going back, but maybe to the bar across the street, since that's where the food comes from anyway.

For the record I only go here for lunch since it is down the street from my office. I have yet to…read morehave a bad meal here. The daily specials are REALLY specials. The double cheeseburger&fries for $6, Taco Tuesday, Rib Wednesday (my FAVORITE - $1 a bone!), and Wing Thursday. Now they have been known to run out of Ribs, and have on occasion not had something available that is on the menu, but that is rare. I have never had any problems with service and the food was always very good. Definitely glad I finally decided to start stopping in. And the ambience! The music that is streaming is absolutely fantastic. 60s-80s serious rock. Reminds me of the old AOR stations from the 70s.

308 is one of those places that has grown on me the more I go. A newer entry to the Purdue bar…read morescene, 308 is deceptively large and modern inside, with three (four?) distinct areas. The basement has a nightclub vibe, with lots of good EDM/rap music playing throughout the night. It's fairly large, and has good lighting/party effects. There is a bar and bathrooms down here as well. There isn't much seating downstairs as it is more for dancing. The first floor now contains two bars, and has plenty of seating. This is where you'll probably want to be if you want to sit and order some food, while also being in the bar environment. There are usually a decent amount of people on the first floor. The second floor has more of a lounge vibe, with a bar and a ton of seating. There is a beer pong table, and I think they sometimes do karaoke up here. If you just want to sit and chill, without loud music and lots of people, the second floor is where to go. 308 also has food, and I was surprised by how good it is. I have had a couple of their sandwiches, and for a bar, it is pretty darn good. It's not somewhere I would go out of my way to eat at, but it is good. The drink specials are generally pretty good; some notable specials they run are the $1 "you call it" shots, where the bartender just kind of pours whatever they want, and the $4 Titos specials. They have just about every type of liquor imaginable. The bathrooms here are kind of weird, and it can get very backed up when it's busy. The second floor one is particularly bizarre, being a unisex bathroom with a lock that also has multiple urinals/stalls, with no real divider between them. I'm not entirely sure how that one is supposed to operate. Overall though, 308 has become somewhere I go to semi-reguarly, particularly due to its multiple offerings. (Want to dance? Go to the basement. Want to just chill? Second floor. etc.) It's not a bad choice by any means if you're in the Purdue/West Lafayette area.

Must try the SHRIMP PO-BOY. Delish especially now that it's getting warmer outside, it's not so…read moreheavy. It has a little kick but not too spicy, great seasonings, and they do not get stingy with the big fat massive shrimps. They load this sammich up. And reasonably priced. Also, u can load the fries but honestly the fries are good by themselves! 10/10 stars !

Tasty food! I order this twice in a day! Heard they are closing and that's a bummer! One last taco…read moreTuesday for us all

I love this place especially the spanky burger and fries. Highly recommended for any newcomers.read more

Great food & service with even better prices! It's our favorite place to go, especially on a…read moreFriday night for $1.25 beer!

There are rare opportunities that I actually enjoy karaoke. I was visiting friends about an hour…read moreout of Indy. We headed out for a couple drinks at a place called (Bar Noble?). This DJ kept the music going, and controlled the mic volume as needed (thank goodness), and made the night quite enjoyable. He was interactive, and hit some high notes that you don't expect from a guy with his presence (you'll understand when you meet him) I may give karaoke another chance.

From the owner: Providing quality service to those within a 3-4 hour radius of Cayuga, Indiana; including parts of…read moreIllinois, Missouri, Ohio, Kentucky, Michigan, and Wisconsin. Mobile DJ, Emcee, and Karaoke services for events such as Weddings, Corporate Functions, Proms, Greek Parties, Block Parties, Children's Parties. I am also a Licensed, Ordained Minister Lighting and Sound Services

I absolutely love going to Old Buff! They have great food; a full bar; and friendly, hard-working…read morewaitresses. The rustic decor is welcoming, and their patio is large and beautiful. I am always recommending this bar/restaurant to friends!

Really enjoyed our first visit! We ordered the spiced old fashioned cocktail special. I was a…read morelittle skeptical because they use small ice cubes, which can tend to water down the drink, but they were really good! I had two! Sufficiently strong and not watered down. The onion rings appetizer were really good. Make with real onion, not chopped, pre-processed. Nicely breaded and crispy. My husband and a friend had the Thursday bbq rib special with Mac & cheese and slaw and they cleaned their plates. I got the traditional wings and requested them well done. They cooked them perfectly. The buffalo sauce is different, but really delicious! Maybe the best I've had! Towards the end of our meal we discovered it was bingo night! We played and it was fun! The only problem for us was being seated near the front of the restaurant so it was a little hard to hear the gal calling. Perhaps an extra speaker near the bar would help. Overall, our first visit to Old Buffalo was a success! It won't be our last!

Great service. Good specials. And this pizza was awesome! We came in with a coupon but will come…read moreback without one!

Came in having heard good and bad, and overall, it was very average…read more Pros - Boneless wings are made from scratch! (I got Louisiana hot honey and their secret sauce, both of which were very good). Also got fries that weren't bad. - Lots of TVs to watch college football - Price wasn't terrible for what you get Cons - Noise...louder than Bdubs with 1/3 the people - Service was slow and inconsistent. If you aren't sitting at the bar and want a refill, just go to the bar, it'll be easier - Food was lukewarm when we got it - Semi-clean Random, but almost saw a fight break out over the ending of a football game, so there was that...

Basic American bar with all the old school trappings, constant haze like Indiana overcast skies…read morehugging the lights, predictable limited selection of brews, no drafts, fun menu highlighting the outgoing diner eager to promote karaoke nights and after work eats. Us three guys wondered in a Wednesday evening to sample the casual dinner. Found the menu with all the usual fare, traditional and reunion familiar, Lacks the adventurous spirit of other local taps like AJs and Town and Gown, but there are few places in town to fully let loose and ensure the kids don't show up. We found the mac n cheese a bit watery, lacking the punch of full flavors, more budget Kraft than craft. Beef Manhattan did better with some echos to vintage cooking however better options abound in the area. Service was done right, sense of family here and enjoyable long night community.

The peanut butter burger may sound funny and yuck. But good ol mighty it's the shizzz!! Friendly…read morestaff. Although, there is one bartender who isn't very pleasant, rude and snotty. And not mentioning names bc she knows who she is. But all around it's pretty fun environment otherwise