Amazing thin crust pizza! Wonderful fresh tasting toppings and lots of them. The service is a little odd cuz we could never actually figure out if there was table service or order at the counter. The table service was definitely not great, so we'll give some Grace and assume it's supposed to be counter service. With paper plates. Great location in Surf city and a nice change from seafood. Normally chains don't warrant a second look for pizza, but this is definitely not the case with this location. We will definitely be back. read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Pizza- pepperoni, olive, extra cheese - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

See all

Nothing exciting. Service was fine, we were the only customers. Flavor wise there wasn't any. Grocery store pizza had more flavor. Not impressed at all. read more

We finally went to Michaelangelos and the pizza was AMAZING !!!! It was the perfect blend of crispy crust on the bottom and yummy toppings . We will be back soon. read more

The food is one of my favorite parts about being at the beach. My kids ate the MOST pizza I've ever seen. My sub was delicious as always. Man of the group grunted in agreement that it's the best pizza we can find!!!! We will always be back! PS And your water doesn't taste like beach. (I'm from the city...) yay! read more

We ordered online from a phone and it was super easy to do!! We ordered 3 pizzas, all 14" and they were great sizes! I was pleasantly surprised by the cheese and toppings, well worth the $15-20 per pizza. When we picked up the pizzas, they were helping pick up orders first, so we highly recommend ordering in advance since they were busy and not much room to park. The buffalo chicken pizza was on point, pepperoni was good and the white pizza was different but overall great flavor. Would recommend this place!! read more

See all

The pizza was THE highlight dinner of our whole week on the island, it's nostalgic NY style pizza taste with the guts to be bigger & bolder, if you decide to eat pizza leftovers instead of going out because it's that good....Michelangelo's Pizza. read more

We did a takeout order and everything was delicious. The only reason I gave it 4 stars for the rating. The staff was friendly when we called and went in to pick up. We will order again! read more

See all

Great place. Good pizza. Glad I was able to give them a laugh. Service was great.

The pizza here is excellent and one of our favorites in Surf City and Sneads Ferry. Actual New York style with yeasty crust. Other than the service being a little sketchy at times and the obvious problem with the pizza boxes they have being too small for that largest size pizza. Sandwiches good and the shoestring french fries are awesome. read more

This is the only place in Surf City that serves an actual pizza. And the staff are very accommodating.

Love it and always will!!! Man loveMm michelangelos kills it every time and order pick up. It's ready in 20 minutes. read more

See all

I'm not a big pizza eater but when I crave Pizza I want an amazing Pizza. That's what I thought I was going to get when I ordered from Michelangelo's this past weekend. However, I was terribly disappointed and mad and aggravated and lied to by the end of my delivery. The food was cold. The pizza had grease hardened on the top that is how cold it was. The lasagna had a piece of provolone cheese on the top that was not melted at all. Besides salad was slimy, so gross. I did call the store and complained. They said they would refund my money and was closing soon at 9:00 p.m. and would have the delivery driver bring back my money. To say the least, I went to bed hungry and pissed off without my money! I did however speak with a nice woman by the name of Jessica who helped me tremendously. I did get my money back eventually and a hard lesson learned. DON'T ORDER FROM HERE!!!!! read more

It took 30 minutes just to get our appetizer and 1 hour to get our food. The pictures on the walls were nice to look at while it took SO long for our food. Do not recommend. read more

Love the cheese pizza! Service is amazing. Very friendly and quick. Great place to grab some pizza and a beer. Reasonably priced too!

It has been years since I have been to this restaurant. Last time I was there I would have given it a negative if I could. But now I can honestly say it is definitely hovering around a 3 star. I used multiple different things in order to form my current "star" judgement including the attitude of staff, cleanliness, parking, taste of food, and was the taste worth the cost or the hassle. So first the attitude of the staff. Immediately when I walked in, I was greeted by two very lovely waitresses, who told me I could sit anywhere I liked. I chose to sit at the bar where I could see into the kitchen. The waitress behind the bar quickly took my drink order and handed me a menu. After some internal debate I ended up ordering quite a bit of food so I could sample a little of everything. Yes, you guessed it, I will be eating leftovers tomorrow too. I ordered a MUG rootbeer, slice of pepperoni, ham & mushroom, an order of fried pickles, 2 meatballs with mozzarella, a chef salad, and limoncello cake slice. I also explained that I have a severe deathly allergic reaction to onion so nothing can touch onion. Upon asking, she explained the salads are premade daily. the difference between the chef salad and the house salad is the ham, turkey and salami sandwich meat that comes cut up on top. So for this the staff would get a 4.5 stars. Now we move on to cleanliness. Obviously I didn't get out a set of white gloves or inspect the kitchen, but all the dirty dishes were picked up, the tables wiped off, the floor swept. Everything looked very sanitized. I would give them a 4 on cleanliness. Now comes the parking. This restaurant is located in a beach town that is 15 minutes down the road from the biggest Marine Corps base on the East Coast. Between all the Marines, Civilians, and contractors, and their families, then you throw tourists in the mix, having an exceptionally small parking lot that is shared by 3 restaurants is an absolute disaster. I have attached a picture of google earth with labels of the restaurants and the employee parking for the one set of restaurants. On to the fun part, the Food!!! Chef Salad - I like my salad to be green. Today I received a salad where most of the lettuce was almost the same color as the cheese: white, white, white. It had 4 small tomatoes, cheese, and sandwich meat that had been rolled and cut so it was spiraled like a pinwheel. To me, definitely not worth the $6.99 price tag. Pizza slice - over all not bad. Michaelangelo's cooks New York style pizza which has a tendency to be real chewy. The pizza surprisingly wasn't like chewing on a rubber dog toy, and had a decent flavor. The toppings were good as well. I did have some grease but that is to be expected. Yes it is worth the $3.50 for a slice. Limoncello cake - probably the biggest disappointment. I love all things lemon, but the slices are taken put of their original packaging, put onto new packages that are individual packages and placed in the refrigerator to keep them fresher longer. One problem with this is, like my slice today, the frosting is great, but the cake itself is soggy and mushy. Was definitely, hands down, 100% not worth paying $5.25! MUG rootbeer - well it is my favorite rootbeer and the machine was in good working condition so no issues on that front. Meantballs - these were super yummy. They were also a pretty hefty size coming in at just a little smaller than a tennis ball. Definitely worth the price! Fried Pickles - I was surprised to find that the batter on these was a bit on the spicy side. I love spicy food so its wasn't an issue for me, but it was a shock. I can imagine it being an issue if someone who doesn't like spicy foods orders them though. And, they were good, but they didn't leave you with that super amazed feeling. I was left with, meh it was good. Definitely not good enough to fight the parking lot battle to come in and pay $8.50. I think if I was there with friends and we were getting pizza I might entertain getting them if it were $6 but not $8.5 So again to recap, the service was excellent, the parking stinks and the food is hot and miss on what's good, what's meh, and what's in the "just don't eat that" category. read more

See all

SUCH A LONG WAIT!! Horrible systems in place here. We placed an order online and it said it would be ready in 20 minutes. We waited in the store for OVER AN HOUR waiting for our order. Please update your systems so they reflect the true wait time. The pasta was mediocre but the chicken parm sub was good. Definitely nothing special to spend so much time waiting around for. read more

It was pathetic. This is my first review ever. I should call the police. I feel that I was robbed of $19.50. The chicken Parmigian was worse than spaghettios. Served in tin foil. Lots of fat, overboiled spaghetti. A few diced chicken chunks. Perhaps 2 ounces total I knew that I was making a mistake. A big sign in the window with childish writing advertising for cooks, dishwashers, cashiers, etc. You order at the counter. Zombie employees on their phones sitting on the other side of the counter. A polite cough to get their attention. Nothing. A hard slap of the counter. Nothing. Yelling TELEPHONE GIRLS, and the bigger teen looks up read more

Not terrible if you're in a pinch for something to eat. We were working and not familiar with the area. Staff was friendly and food was okay. Hoping for something a little bit healthier, I ordered the chicken pita with no ranch. I was so disappointed when the pita came and it was fried. It doesn't say anything on the menu about it being fried. I was assuming it was grilled chicken. My suggestion would be to put in the menu that it is fried chicken. read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Chicken pita (be warned, it is fried chicken) - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

Pizza was pretty decent, pasta was terrible. Lasagne & spaghetti we're a no go for us. Ok atmosphere, nothing terrific. read more

There is no service. Menu at the counter, you do it all. Soda.. 2 liter, when I asked what kind I was told 2 liter 3 times. Prices are high, especially for no service and rude staff read more

Service was not bad. The pizza is just like any other place. Not sure I would recommend or return.

Called for delivery had to wait over an hour but well worth it. Hand tossed with pepperoni, peppers, onions, & mushrooms. Very good and very large. Would recommend for your hungry crew. read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

Ordered two Pizzas, NY style, for takeout. They were perfectly cooked, sauce had the right amount of seasoning, and perfect amount of Cheese. The dough was nice and crisp on the bottom without being brittle, nice chew. Highly recommended and will definitely order again. read more

Delish! Their cauliflower pizza is amazing. They have a small for $10.99. They have a nice eat in restaurant as well as delivery. It's the same pizza and subs as every other one on the franchise and it's pretty darn good! read more

See all

I'm sitting here as I write this review... I do not recommend eating here if you want good pizza, this is less than sub par in my opinion. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom slice, the mushroom were cut up and just placed raw on top, didn't heat them up or cook them on it. The pepperoni and onion slice was the same way- pulled the pre-made pizza out of the warmer and threw some raw onions on it, not warm or cooked on top. HIGHLY disappointed and feeling robbed of my $20 spent here. It used to be really good but just looks like a bunch of young kids running the place now. No gloves, rust all over the condiment holders in the center of the table, not to mention their 93.0 health score. We used to come here all the time but won't be coming here anymore. Such a disappointment :( read more

I ordered pick up from here, and the calzone I got was great! Great service, and quick turn around time! It's the hot dog we got that things started turning south. The bread had a small spot of mold on it. Being sensible people, we just pinched it off; but, the bun tasted moldy. Wish I had taken a picture. The bun being fashioned out of sub bread was fine with us, but being that it was sub bread is a cause for concern. Keep in mind, I am writing in the off-season. read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Pinched off Bread - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

See all

Horrible experience here!! Came in to watch the USA WOMEN'S World Cup, and they refused the play the game with the sound. Literally, there were 4 ppl in there when we arrived. They were playing espn on the channels, but not the World Cup match. I asked them to turn on the game, and if they could let the game play through the speakers. When I asked for the sound, the sexist chef said "absolutely not!" WTF?!?!?? I asked why not, and he just kept repeating "it's not a sports bar." I said it's the finals match, and it's the USA playing?!? He refused in the most impolite way and just said no. The food here is decent, but the service is horrible. The chef behind the counter should feel like a POS. IMO, he's unAmerican, sexist, and a traitor. Seriously, he's what's wrong today. I bet he wouldn't say "it's not a sport bar" for the Super Bowl. Are they gonna be playing Jack Johnson then too?? This place seriously needs to reprioritize it's values. Simply a disgrace read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Pizza Menu - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

See all

We wanted delivery after a long day at the beach. This was the only place we could find for pizza delivery on Topsail Beach. Pizza was just okay, sauce and toppings were good. The crust was a little tough and lacked good flavor. read more

I ordered a large supreme pizza and was quoted $21 over the phone. I show up and they charged me $42 for a pizza. I let the associate know and he did nothing. Not only is that outrageous for a pizza, I was quoted the wrong price over the phone and they still insisted on charging me $42 for a large pizza. We live in the area and will never be coming back. Such a disappointing experience with terrible customer service. There are plenty of other pizza places in the area. Do yourself a favor and don't go here. read more

Stopped in here looking for a local pizza spot. We ordered mozzarella sticks and pepperoni pizza. Everything was delicious and the staff was friendly. read more

Owner was offering a new flavor of pizza...offered us a complimentary piece. It was delicious! It was a gyro inspired pie! Yummy. Definitely will be back! read more

The first and last time I ever ordered a pizza here, when I went to pick it up I saw the guy who was making the food have to hike his pants up like half a dozen times during the few minutes it took the over-worked waitress to charge my card. It just didn't look hygienic. Too bad, it's the closest place to my house with few to choose from. Maybe I'll give it another try in a few years. I think it looked like it would have been good. read more

Worst food ever!!!! Meatball subs were disgusting. I'm pretty sure the meatballs were bad. One bite and I was done. The pizza was nothing special. It appears they could only cook one item at a time as our order came out in 20 min increments. The place itself was dirty. The salt and pepper shakers had so much crud on them my fingers stuck to them. Nasty!!! Save your money and go some place worthy. read more

Good za.. good fried pickles.. quick pick up order. Great name too. You're going to pay for many things that are quite as good. Inflation you know.. thanks a lot O'Biden. read more

Possibly the worst customer service experience I've ever had. I ordered my pizza and waited an hour for it to arrive. When it arrived the toppings were not what I ordered. No problem, I figured I'd call and have it sorted. I called back and spoke with a manager. This is where it went down hill. I explained the issue and asked if it could be corrected. I was told I had to give them back the incorrect pizza. Not an issue, however when I asked how long it would take to get the new pizza, I was told "however long it takes". I said I've waited an hour already and can't wait another hour for a new pizza. Again "when it's ready and I have a driver you'll get it". I asked for a shop credit instead as I have a 7 year old I need to feed dinner too and he won't eat these toppings. I was told no store credit, I still need to give back the pizza, which would take an hour to come pick up. I'm sorry, but you messed up my order, refused to help me. At minimum you should have offered to remake the pizza and if you didn't have a driver, you should have had a manager bring it to me. $25 for the wrong pizza down the drain. I'll stick with Santinos or Denoias. read more

The only place I order pizza from. Easy to order online. Crust is fabulous. Staff are very pleasant each and everytime. Ordered from major pizza chains in the area and they do not compare. My go to pizza place read more

We were hungry for pizza so I looked on line for local pizza shops. We've lived here for 11 years and never considered Michelangelo's for pizza! So I pulled up the online menu and we ended up ordering a calzone and a Stromboli for pick up. On arrival the staff was very attentive and took care of business immediately. Our food was ready to go right on time and hot out of the oven. And let me say the food was fantastic! The crust was delicious and the ingredients blended very well. We were quite impressed by this local gem to the point of being sorry we haven't tried it out sooner. Looking forward to Friday night pizza so we can actually give that a try. Well done! read more

Our family enjoyed the couple of pies, all had good flavor. We had ordered pepperoni/mushroom, plain cheese and Hawaiian, all had a good amount of toppings and the crust was good! We would definitely eat here again. read more

Michaelangelo's desserts are awesome! I had these delivered by ordering online. The online ordering was convenient and they were easy to work with as I ordered in the morning for an evening delivery. The prices were reasonable and they made this dessert for my in-laws anniversary a sweet surprise during our surf city vacation. We didn't order pizzas or subs but next time we are in town, we definitely will be returning to Michaelangelos! read more

Michaelangelos Pizza and Subs - Desserts delivered to our condo. This was all so tasty! Limoncello and tuxedo cake were moist and delicious. - Italian Near Me - Surf City, North Carolina

I'm not sure this place deserves the reputation it gets. I really like the food. Service wasn't good, but i did like the pizza