Michelino&#x27;s Pizzeria

Delicious pizza from the wood fire oven. Friendly service from everyone who works here. The space…read moreis cozy and inviting, making it great for a large gathering or smaller group.

Upon arriving to Rahway, my coworker and I were starving. We didn't have lunch due to our long…read moreflight, so I was very excited about this Italian place. And surprisingly, this happened to be a very well known restaurant as our other coworkers knew about it! It's located across of CubaNu Restaurant & Lounge on the corner of Lewis St and Main St in downtown Rahway. There's paid street parking and parking garages around the area. My coworker and I shared their Calamari Al Forno, tossed with Italian sausage, hot cherry pepper, and balsamic glaze. And wow. Who would have thought balsamic glaze with calamari would be sooooo good! I'll definitely be ordering that combination again. The mix with the Italian sausage and cherry peppers added a nice kick to the dish. Both of us could not stop eating it even though we wanted to save room for our pastas. Our meal was off to a great start! I ordered their Linguini de Mar which was supposed to have four seafoods: shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams. Unfortunately, mine was missing the calamari. However, the pasta was incredibly flavorful and the seafood was cooked perfectly - not overdone or underdone at all. YUM! My coworker got their Cheese Ravioli with the Bolognese sauce (unsure if it was extra as I didn't see the check). She loved her pasta as well! She's usually a light eater, but she devoured half the calamari appetizer and all of her pasta, which speaks volumes about how much she enjoyed the meal. I felt that the one downside was the unusual amount of water I drank (maybe ten cups?). This was my own personal indicator that there was definitely some sort of flavor enhancer which wasn't a negative thing. I'm not certain, but the food was very good, so kudos to them if that's the case. Overall, definitely a hidden gem! We unfortunately didn't try their pizzas/pies but this will definitely be on my list again the next time I visit. Or I may opt in for another round of calamari al forno and pasta again, haha!

Wood burning oven in the kitchen.

Penne a la Vodka (so dry - not enough sauce)

See all

Margarita Pie (so good)

Nancy's Towne House

3.9(289 reviews)

0.1 mi

Nancy's is a must for a classic old school thin crust pizza. It is one of those subterranean venues…read morew 1970s family basement decor (paneling, brick, wood grain, and corner fireplace now blocked by a table). Bartender Emily was full of cheer and helpful with dining suggestions. I had a beer and the meatball app to start, and a pie for dinner. Nice thin crust which is the reason I sought Nancy's. I observed other diners w pitchers of Sangria, as well as bountiful family-style salads. I took leftover slices with me, and yes... I was "that guy" eating pizza on an early morning flight.

Came here for lunch with a friend. I knew we were off to a great start when there was a line…read moreoutside waiting for them to open when we arrived 8 mins before opening time. I've driven by this place MANY times over the Years but this is my 1st time here. Nancy's is a time capsule. You've get that old school restaurant that has never been updated, but that's what makes it great. Friendly staff that makes everyone feel welcomed. Pretty simple menu, full bar, hometown style crowd of patrons. Food is, of course, made to order but with a reasonable wait time. Casual vibe hometown bar/restaurant vibe. We had the Rice Balls w/cheese & the Italian Pizza. They are known for their pizza, it is a PAPER THIN crust. You can still kinda pick it up the traditional way, lol, if it's a lighter toppings piece. Great experience, will definitely come back. Grades: Rice Balls w/Cheese: A+ Italian Pizza: A+

Inside

Buffalo Wings

See all

Inside

Tony's Pizza & Cafe

3.6(108 reviews)

1.1 mi

Tony's is my favorite local pizzeria. Not just for the pizza; their subs, sandwiches and pasta are…read moredelicious as well! Always fresh. In regards to the pizza- the spinach Florentine will change your life, and their vodka slice is amazing as well. Great mozzarella sticks. You can't go wrong!

Tony's chose to provide poor service. Humans make mistakes but we are able to correct those…read moremistakes. I ordered two pies of pizza but the driver lost the tickets with the address and phone number and did not deliver the pies in a timely manner . After waiting over an hour for the food, I called to find out where the status of our order, I was meeting with unprofessionalism. I asked that order be remade instead they reheated the pies and sent them back out. Tony's chose the easy route, not the correct route. Do better Tony's. You have my number.

Eggplant wrap

Turkey sub

See all

Turkey sub

Plum Tomato

4.1(90 reviews)

0.7 mi

i got a cheese slice there was zero flavor and i mean none. It almost tasted like a grilled cheese…read morewith how hard the bottom was. service was fine it's a pizza place. it was very clean as well but at the end of the day the pizza is shit.

Had an office event catered from here today. Flavor of the food was as expected but the pasta vodka…read morewas mushy as was the chicken parm and the garlic knots and the salad wasn't great nor was is visually appealing. Literally iceberg , jarred peppers and olives and tomato cucumber thrown in a pan. I might give it another shot but the over cooked food is a turn off. .

Inside

6 Piece Mozzarella Sticks

See all

O Sole Mio

4.4(68 reviews)

2.4 mi

Wow ! I absolutely loved this place, the owner treated us like we were customers that had always…read morebeen here. Shared a bottle of wine with us and sent over a mini charcuterie board. It is hard nowadays to find such welcoming service in a first visit. The hospitality of the staff and owner was so warming and heart filling that I can't wait to come back with my parents. My husband and I enjoyed our dishes which were rich and full of flavor. The convenience of the parking out back made it super easy to get to. We also took a tiramisu home to try! This might just become our go to spot monthly.

Solid effort; nothing was memorable. The zita lacked cheese. The chicken parm was unevenly cooked…read more Some bites were chewy others delicious. The pepperoni roll was ok. The side penne was good. The dessert was pre made and ok. If we try it again we will dine in. 3.5 stars

Interior

Meat antipasti

See all

Bright, warm dining room for indoor seating!

Doughboy Johnnys

4.2(88 reviews)

3.0 mi

Girls' night after work led us to Doughboy Johnny's, and as a first-timer walking in, I genuinely…read morehad no idea what to expect. Spoiler: I left very happy (and with leftovers). Let's start with the only real challenge of the night: parking. Between regular White Plains parking adventures and the winter snow situation, it took a little patience. But once we got inside, the night immediately got better. The vibe is college-bar casual, but without the trashiness that sometimes comes with that territory. It's lively but still comfortable enough to actually enjoy a conversation. One thing I loved right away, there are games by the front entrance that you can grab and bring to your table. Drinks + games = instant girls' night upgrade. We were seated in the center near the kitchen, which actually gave us a great view of the whole place. Our drinks were really good, though if the bartender's hand had slipped just a tiny bit more on the pour, I wouldn't have complained. Still solid, still enjoyable. Now the food. Holy moly. Everything we ordered was cooked perfectly and tasted amazing. And the portions? I'm not sure if they thought we were feeding an entire soccer team, but honestly... I support the ambition. I don't think I've ever seen mozzarella sticks that size before. I love leftovers and this place clearly believes in sending you home with some. Another thing I appreciated was seeing a whole section of vegan options on the menu. I didn't try them this time, but I love when a restaurant makes it easy for different diets to find something without turning ordering into a complicated group project. Between the fun atmosphere, great food, and generous portions, this was a great first experience. Next time I come back, I'll just plan ahead for parking... and maybe bring an even bigger appetite.

If you're in the Linden or Roselle area and looking for a fun happy hour spot after work look no…read morefurther than DoughBoys! You can play connect 4 or Uno while enjoying drinks music and great food.

Bacon Cheese Burger Slider (2)

See all

Plantain & Chorizo

Jersey Pizza Boys

4.1(104 reviews)

2.0 mi

I got some pizza here for a movie night and it did not disappoint. The pizza was really delicious…read moreand perfectly crispy. The penne vodka was wonderful and it came with a baguette on the side which was great. The salad was good and I appreciated that they gave the dressing on the side because they do put a lot.

With all the hype, I expected a lot more from this restaurant. We ordered 2 pies on a Friday night,…read moreand I was disappointed. Taste wise: the bread was hard and honestly, some frozen brands have tasted better. Maybe it's the style, but I really did not like the misshapen triangular cuts of the pizza.

Pepperoni Pie

See all

The Corner Slice

4.2(5 reviews)

2.0 mi

Overall AMAZING!!! Ample place to sit and enjoy your food. The mushroom calzone was so tasty. The…read morecalzone had the proper crunch as I cut it open. I took a bite of my friend's eggplant Parmesan, and it was so flavorful. The fries were nicely seasoned. The Mac and cheese bites were garlicky and tasty. The staff were very friendly and nice. They even had a magnet to take which had prayers for bentching. Coming again real soon!

Fantastic pizza! They have a large selection of specialty pizzas, and they'll be happy to customize…read moreone for you if you want it. Their spicy fries also should not be missed. The garlic knots are also great, with a nice chewy inside, with tons of garlic flavor.

Brooklyn Pizza

2.9(97 reviews)

0.7 mi

Good food and service . Delivery service is good as well. I have no complaints. So go ahead and…read moreorder from them.

Haven't been here in years but the pizza is still so delicious!! Grabbed some Grandma pizza slices…read moreto go and they were perfect for a nice lunch. Thank you for your delicious food!!!!!!!!

Grilled chicken Caesar wrap w/ fries always delicious .

As always our favorite in the family , the delicious Garlic knots. Yummy as always and the rice balls at the bottom ... a must try item.

See all

Ok let me tell you about this bread it's so soft and fresh I really enjoyed this eggplant parm

Linwood Inn Taphouse and Pizza

4.3(304 reviews)

2.1 mi

Came in with a buddy off a long run and the bartender fed us water on water and was extremely…read morefriendly. We didn't order anything and his hospitality was still a 10/10. Highly recommend stopping by

Best hottsy tottsy shrimp ever . Sausage pie outstanding great crust great serviceread more

Dining area

Large House Salad, Buffalo Wings

See all

Separate dining room

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cristian G.

Elite 26

207

206

20

3 years ago

Tucked away in Rahway, this charming pizzeria captivated us the moment we stepped in, seeking a slice each. Greeted warmly by who we believe was Michelino, possibly the owner, the ambiance instantly won us over. The decor, quintessentially pizzeria with a touch of elegance, from the thoughtfully placed decorations to the perfectly balanced dim lighting, made for a cozy yet vibrant setting for delightful conversations and dining pleasure. The proprietor, a figure of kindness, humility, and warmth, personally served our food, adding a special touch to the already stellar service. It's rare to find such attentive service in a pizzeria, and it left us pleasantly surprised. Despite a tough crowd, it's bewildering how this gem hasn't secured a 4-star rating at the very least. Our large slices were nothing short of spectacular. The sauce, perfectly seasoned, complemented the high-quality ingredients without being overpowering or overly greasy. While the pricing might be on the higher side, the exceptional service more than makes up for it. We left with a sense of gratitude for having discovered this place and are eagerly looking forward to our next visit. It's a delightful spot that truly deserves recognition. Thanks! read more

Anabella F.

0

1

0

9 months ago

I've been going here for the last 4 years and the quality and service has always been great! I love coming here it's my favorite pizza place for family or for dates. read more

John M.

0

1

2

6 years ago

Love this place! Had the Chicken Alfredo pizza and it was amazing! They have different gourmet pizzas available daily... great spot!

Aimal K.

122

5

73

9 years ago

Best service best tastes pizza and other food is always fresh friendly people, I love this place and recommend to all of u

Jonathan C.

0

1

0

3 years ago

excellent pizza and great service !! best pizza in New Jersey! Jon the owner is very attentive

MaKenzie C.

0

1

0

3 years ago

wonderful place great customer service there so sweet and kind recommend

Jaime C.

54

19

20

14 years ago

Nothing special.

Michelino's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Michelino's Pizzeria also viewed

Tony's Pizza & Cafe

3.6

(108 reviews)

Tony's is my favorite local pizzeria. Not just for the pizza; their subs, sandwiches and pasta are…read moredelicious as well! Always fresh. In regards to the pizza- the spinach Florentine will change your life, and their vodka slice is amazing as well. Great mozzarella sticks. You can't go wrong!

Tony's chose to provide poor service. Humans make mistakes but we are able to correct those…read moremistakes. I ordered two pies of pizza but the driver lost the tickets with the address and phone number and did not deliver the pies in a timely manner . After waiting over an hour for the food, I called to find out where the status of our order, I was meeting with unprofessionalism. I asked that order be remade instead they reheated the pies and sent them back out. Tony's chose the easy route, not the correct route. Do better Tony's. You have my number.

Bella Pizza

3.9

(75 reviews)

Good food, good service! Your typical NY/NJ pizza place! The money is spent o the ingredients not…read morethe decor! This is why for those who grew up out here love these places and visitors don't get it! The chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce is delicious and filling! Definitely a winner!

Pizza delicious and I love it because no pork products…read more the customer service is very good and nice

Benny’s Pizza

4.4

(124 reviews)

A must try pizza spot in the Woodbridge area. We stopped in for lunch on Good Friday and there were…read moreso many meatless options. The plain is a classic favorite. You cannot go wrong there. The tomato sauce is sweet and the crunch of the thin style crust is delcious. The garlic knots ooh they were garlicky and fluffy. The marinara sauce pairs well to tone done the garlic as they were potent for my liking. But my boyfriend inhaled them. The Sicilian slice was different as the crust itself was fluffy and not dense at all. The vodka margherita was amazing and easily my favorite. We also ordered a tricolor pizza to go which had their tomato sauce, vodka sauce, pesto, and fresh mozzarella on top. They have their own parking lot and it's easy to get in and out of. Service was fantastic and extremely friendly. The inside had ample tables and chairs to eat at and was extremely clean.

Solid and consistently good pizza spot in northern Jersey. Always great to stop for a quick slice…read more Service and staff are amazing. I definitely make this a stop every time I'm in the area.

Pies on Stiles

3.2

(35 reviews)

I live 5 minutes from this establishment and decided to give it a try on my way home from work. I…read morewas there 6:30 on a Saturday night place was empty. I was greeted immediately placed my to go order. I ordered a large cheese calzone which is basically the size of half a pizza. I also ordered a bbq chicken slice. The slice was a nice sized slice and was great tasting. The calzone was good not spectacular but good

Usually always a good meal when we come here! Tonight was a huge miss! I tried some new bacon…read morechicken pinwheel that was burnt along with my husband's white pizza slice. I hate to report the disappointment but with money being tight for most....this was disappointing.

Al & Tucky's Pizza

3.1

(47 reviews)

love the food , great service , everytime I visit I notice incredible changes under New management…read more. Great job

Best sicilian iver ever had. Hands down. No competition. Great customer service always.read more

Plum Tomato

4.1

(90 reviews)

i got a cheese slice there was zero flavor and i mean none. It almost tasted like a grilled cheese…read morewith how hard the bottom was. service was fine it's a pizza place. it was very clean as well but at the end of the day the pizza is shit.

Had an office event catered from here today. Flavor of the food was as expected but the pasta vodka…read morewas mushy as was the chicken parm and the garlic knots and the salad wasn't great nor was is visually appealing. Literally iceberg , jarred peppers and olives and tomato cucumber thrown in a pan. I might give it another shot but the over cooked food is a turn off. .

Luna Pizza

3.0

(72 reviews)

This place is underrated. Food is great! I've had everything from pizza, pasta, soup, salad, and…read moreevery time I order from here my friends love it! As a NY'er I know pizza. This is place is fantastic!

I love their pizza! I love their Margarita pizza and their…read morechicken bacon ranch. The service has always been good and the place is nice inside. Clean and modern.

La Nonna Pizzeria

4.4

(13 reviews)

Chester, my order was very good. The food was very good and reasonable delivery was great. The…read morepizza came steaming hot.

First time using La Nonna for delivery & a catering order. We were all very pleased and well-fed…read more Any time I called the staff was very eager and helpful to get everything just right. We ordered a hot tray of sausage peppers onions and meatballs. It was delivered on-time, hot and fresh. Plus a large pizza. Everyone enjoyed it very much. Very pleased with our food and service and recommend La Nonna.

John's Caffe & Pizza

4.0

(162 reviews)

I absolutely love the bee sting pie here. Also delivery is always fast for me and pizza is at a…read moregood temp when delivered.

Didn't eat at the location, so I do not know the ambiance of this location, placed a delivery…read moreorder. Ordered 2 meat lover pizzas and a 12 wing bbq appetizer. Ordered and food showed up to the hotel within 55 minutes of order placed. Food was a great condition, not piping hot as you would get at the restaurant, but understand delivery will lose some warmth over food. Was still warm enough to enjoy. Delivery driver was friendly when dropping off order.

Michelinos Pizzeria

3.9

(175 reviews)