Truly fantastic pizza and the best by far in the area. The crust is nice and crispy and the cheese/ sauce ratio is spot on. These guys make some truly great pizza. Highly recommend. read more

Great Food and Service. Out of the way in a small strip mall. Huge variety of Italian dishes, plus catering.

Get the General Tso pizza it's so good! My second favorite is the Buffalo chicken pizza. The customer service is good they get you out quickly. Definitely a place regulars go to. The wings were good too actually! read more

Should have done this a long time ago! One of just a few restaurants in the vicinity which offer GF pizza ( and I believe pasta). I've tried the others , and just- no. Michelinos is flavorful and crisp. My family enjoy the non GF pies. Psyched that it's walking distance! Do yourself a favor and give it a go and say hi to the owner John. Great guy!! read more

Now this is pizza!! Yum yum yum. Like the place. Like the food and like the people. Keep it up! read more

NOW THIS IS REAL VEGAN PIZZA!!! Guys, I have found the New Jersey holy grails of pizza! I am super excited to have stumbled across this pizza spot in Rahway. The service was immaculate & the vegan options were amazing! The fact that the pepperoni vegan pizza & garlic knots tasted like they were made with love & specifically just for me is mind boggling. The vegan cheese was perfectly melted & the personal size / crust were so tasty. The garlic knots were warmed to perfection & served with a yummy marinara that was finger licking good!! I had the pleasure to meet the owner which was the sweetest & very informative when it came to the food options. The scenery was the cutest. A mixture of greenery & old school comfy seating with wall art frames that were perfect for the eatery ambience. The restroom literally had a homey feel & was super clean along with the rest of the establishment. Do yourself, your kids, your family & friends the favor of stopping by here. You won't regret it! I will definitely be returning. Thank you so much guys!! read more

See all

I love love this place! Totally recommended. We love the pizza and the garlic bread, also the spaghetti with meatballs

Service and the food was delicious. I will definitely be ordering from them again soon.

I love this place, my family loves this place, and all my friends that i've brought here have all had nothing but great things to say. The food is delicious. Seriously, any dish you decide to get from here will not disappoint. The drinks are great- especially the red and white sangria. The service is impeccable and all of the staff are extremely friendly and personable. read more

Came for a slice. Very casual place. It was good. I believe it was $3.75 for a buffalo chicken slice.

I live in old bridge and drive by many pizza shops but there is none like Michelino's the owner John and Alex are very pleasant they understand customer service. The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing a must try I have found my new pizza home . The owner John brought the pizza out to my car and includes a few sodas this kind gestures must be acknowledged. I am humbled and thankful to be appreciated when Spending my money good food but greater customer service . read more

Excellent food, great people and nice ambiance. Their cannoli's are to die for. The only set back is parking read more

My first slice was ok which took awhile to get. Then I ordered another and she forgot me. Slow service! It wasn't that busy either.

Moving from NY, we were worried we weren't gunna find good slice, boy were we wrong. This pizza was surprisingly very very good. Their prices are a bit steep for side stuff and extras but I'll pick this place over Nancy's Townhouse (that got over an 8+ rating from Barstools) any day. Also- the best part- they have BEEF PEPPERONI which is literally unheard of! So impressed by this little shop! read more

I ordered chicken parm with penne vodka in vodka sauce & a order of stuffed shells. The food was covered in garlic, to the point it burned my mouth. Stuffed shells were dry and the sauce was watery. It came with garlic bread - they just took bread and out CHUNKS of garlic on it. Waste of money and do not recommend. read more

Love their pizza. Owner is a super nice guy. I always order from them. I'm obsessed with their sauce. Always good!

We love their pizza!!! And the garlic knots are to die for!!! They literally soak them in garlic!!

Our new favorite pie. This combo is amazing and a must try! Per usual the service/food is always a good experience. read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Half buffalo chicken half beef pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

I don't know why this place doesn't have 5 stars. My husband and I never ate inside but always do take out. Every time we call they are always courteous on the phone and double checks the order. Our order is always delicious, hot and on time! What more do you want from a pizzeria? We love to get 2 personal size pies and garlic knots! Our recent favor is pepperoni peppers and white cheese with spinach. Love this local spot!!! So glad we have this pizzeria in the neighborhood!! read more

See all

On my first night in town my coworker and I visited this spot by accident - it was a Monday and many other options were closed. Ryan spoiled us and entertained us on our visit. We first shared a huge slice of pizza with a crispy crust. My coworker was very hungry and downed some steamy bread knots, a slice of very garlicky bread, and an order of manicotti. I tried a mini cannoli which was yummy. We really appreciated the service (and the show) especially after the busy day we had. read more

The owner John is great. We had an issue with my order and fixed it right away. I will be ordering from now on just because of this great customer service. read more

YUM!!! I travel to NJ quite often, which is how I found this little gem. The staff is very friendly and accommodating and their pizza is by far the best in New Jersey! read more

The pizza is very good, many varieties of pizza if you like your pizza with different ingredients. The service was very good, the workers have very positive attitude. And there are many condiments if you like to add spices to your pizza. read more

Excellent food and above and beyond customer service John did a special order for us. Amazing dinner! can't wait to go back thank you

Best Garlic Knots I've ever had, pizza is solid and the staff is really nice. Multiple good pizza places in the area but Michelino's is definitely worth a try! read more

Once a friend always a friend, the owner treats you always with respect and the pizza is great ... Thank you so much.... read more

Is full menu of delicious Italian food. Staff is attentive. Parking is available. Ask for co-owner John.

Oh my god I love this pizzeria I went with my boyfriend gabriel and with my dog and I wasn't sure if they would've allowed my dog in. I went in with my boyfriend to eat and soon as we were done eating the owner of the restaurant was so friendly and nice to us and they ALLOW dogs in the pizzeria. The food is so good!! read more

The vegan pizza cheese here is delicious. The crust and sauce are great. They use violife. read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Vegan pizza with violife - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

Solid pizza place. As a pizza pro I was a bit hesitant having read the reviews. I wasn't in town for long so I wanted to make sure wherever I got my pizza that it was worth it. And it was! I had to wait about five minutes as there was a line at lunchtime but that's a good sign. Then they heated up my two slices which can either be really good or really bad. It was really good here so if you're looking for a quick slice they got you. There were quite a few people actually eating in there. Also a good sign! I got a slice of pepperoni and a slice of cheese to go (gotta stock up seeing as there are zero food options at the Watt Hotel across the street where I was staying!) I was pleasantly surprised with my first slice when it was hot and delicious. I mean it was REALLY good and had the perfect proportion of ingredients. My cold slice of cheese later on in the day wasn't as tasty. So I recommend eating their pizza right when you get it. If I lived nearby I'd have probably heated up the cheese slice in my cast iron and it would have been better. My only major complaint is that if you're getting pizza to go they simply put it on a paper plate and stuff it in a paper bag (think the 40oz version of a slice of pizza). This can lead to serious sogginess. A foil tent on top might help. Overall, I really enjoyed their pizza and will be back next time I'm in town! read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - They might look closed but they're not! - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

I am sick & weak at home on chemo for terminal brain cancer, my husband was in Rahway for work, so I asked if I could order it would he pick it up for dinner for us. I got penne vodka with chicken with an orange Fanta, he got chicken parm sub. Well my soda wasn't with our order, which I told the gentleman when I ordered my husband didn't have his cell phone on him and I couldn't ask him to get it for me so please just put it into the order. He agreed to. I get my first serving and it's fine. Everything I wanted. Then, second serving not so fine. I'm eating a fork full of noodles and I feel this scraping on the roof of my mouth and my tongue, I get it out into my fingers and show my husband. He tells me to call. I asked for the receipt but as a creature of habit he had thrown it out already. I call and ask for record of my receipt he asks why and I tell him what I had found in my food, he places me on a hold and "the sustainer service supervisor" answered and I told him what I had found. He offered another meal, I said I am doing chemo and can't leave to go get it we only got it earlier because my hubs was in the area. They don't even offer to deliver it. So I'm mad by now. "I'll make you another order. You come and get it. "I don't really want to eat your food after this."well that's all I can do". No, you definitely could have refunded my money. Also I get mri's a lot, if that had gotten lodged somewhere and I went in for a scan, it could have done SO much damage. I grew up on Michelino's in Elizabeth. my family would hog the pool table and dart board, spend hundreds of dollars in a night. Foods, drinks, tips. I'm sure my brothers and sister could still walk in and know everyone. My friends and I would swing by for a slice after getting out of the high school on pearl. read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Michelinos of Rahway, NJ. Penne vodka with chicken and a shard of metal. - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

Delicious Pizza, fresh Pizza , cheap pizza, clean Restaurant, nice Personal Near at the Rahway station read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - #bbqchickenpizza yummy - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

The best pizza i ever had tried in my life. Came in for dinner and for lunch next day. Fireeeee 10/10 for sureeee.

Service was amazing - the owner personally made sure we got seats and table service. Pizza was excellent too.

I ordered 1/2 Buffalo 1/2 plain pie and I got 1/2 chicken 1/2 plain. And obvious disappointment after an hour wait. I miss the old Michelino's read more

I love this place! I've been ordering from here a very long time, and It recently dawned on me like " wow! This place never disappoints me, I need to leave them a review". They make delicious pizza the BEST wings, and there service is great. Keep in mind, this is coming from a person who is a really tough critic. read more

Coming from NYC, this is one of the best Sicilian slices I've had so far. Can't get better than this. The dough is light and not so heavy like most. I love the taste for sure read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

So I decided to walk my dog yesterday before picking up my pie that I ordered from michelino's which clearly turned out to be a dreadful experience. I walked in the restaurant with my dog only to find out if my order was ready, immediately the blonde guy behind the counter tells me the dog cannot be in the restaurant then he ignores my question and picks up a phone call. I placed my dog outside the door while still holding the leash through the door. During his call another patron walks in, he finishes his call then proceeds to take her order as if I wasn't standing there the whole time. I patiently waited for them to finish and kindly asked him about my order again! Only for him to respond " my dog can't be in the store" which he wasn't because I removed him the moment he mentioned it. Nonetheless I don't appreciate this type of service and I will not be returning! read more

This is a solid pizza choice, including sandwiches, salads, and Italian meals offering a gluttonous amount of sauce and mozzarella cheese. The bill however, makes me cringe a bit every time I see it. Pizza is still a bargain meal compared to others, but you're dropping a cool $13 for a standard 16" pie + $2.75 per topping. Yes I am willing to pay for quality and food, but a single pizza nearing the $20 mark (sausage and peppers, pepperoni and onions, olives and mushrooms - I'm a combination type girl) makes me frown. Cheese fries are cheeseylicious. Eggplant parm is a bit greasy and more like a vegetarian late night drinking food then meat alternative dinner. Service is friendly enough, and there 7 large-ish and 2 two-seater booths. I come. I eat. I am satisfied. I don't swear my allegiance, but location near the train and downtown is pretty clutch. read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Pizzeria from one of the booths - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

I live close to this pizzeria, so I pick up food here about once every month or two when I'm too lazy to cook. You definitely get a great value. I like the Margherita and Special Combo pizzas, as well as the garlic knots. The garden salad is large, nicely dressed, and extremely fresh. Can't speak much to the service, as I typically order online (which is very easy and convenient), but the staff is pleasant enough when I go over there to pick up. read more

Michelino's Pizzeria - Deep-dish special combo, garden salad, and garlic knots! - Pizza Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey