I work with Janet and Scott on a regular basis. Both are excellent for customer service, providing intricate details on insurance, and being able to complete what you request with minimal effort. Everything I do with them is either via email or over the phone. I've never had to go into the office, which is great because I don't live anywhere near where they are. Their only loss he appears to be with you, the customer. They'll do what they can to get you the best rate with the conditions that you set. They won't give you insurance from a carrier that offers them a sign-up bonus. Again, they are there for you. read more

I was a long time Mills customer. Several Decades long. They used to be a family owned company and I had an agent and she was amazing. Then they were acquired by or merged with Acrisure and its HORRIBLE. I will no longer be a customer after today. Got a notice that my homeowners insurance was being cancelled on July 18 (today is the 20th) and tried to return the call. There were 36 callers in the que and the wait time was over 200 minutes. UNACCEPTABLE. read more

what in the hell happened. this place was sold to a larger insurance company and is now a nightmare. prepare to be on hold for 85 minutes, no call back all these new people who have no knowledge. you are so fired! F minus read more

Like many in the recent past, I was a longtime Mills Insurance client. Used to be so nice calling up & speaking to a live person if you need be. Then Acrisure either acquired them or somehow, Mills became affiliated w/ them. Phone wait times are very long. Expect an hour on average. You may get a friendly cust svc rep, or like today, you definitely may not. I will be seeking out another option than Mills now, as I don't see any "value added" by using them. read more

These guys used to be great, but ever since they got bought out by Acrisure (which sounds like a painful skin disease), the customer service has declined. Average wait times to talk to someone on the phone now range from 15 to 30 minutes. To be fair, if you do manage to talk to someone, they are helpful. read more

Prior to 2022 I was with Mills for years for my Auto Insurance. In 2022 I went with a home owners policy with them on a new home purchase. All was well during the transaction with Stuart. Come 2023 I was notified by Mail from Guard that my Policy would non-renew. I contacted sturart promptly and he said dont worry about it until the month its going to end and he will find me another carrier. Two months later still no contact. Come two days before im going to lapse. I just go on my own and get a policy from Gieco. I sent an email to Stuart telling him I never heard back from him and was ghosted by him. Not even an email back saying sorry or tying to get the business back next time. Do yourself a favor if you are gonna use a broker find another one. Or just DIY its easier and usually cheaper from what im finding. read more

Any agency purchased by Mills/Acrisure is sure to go downhill. They don't care about anything but upselling and/or getting you off the phone as soon as possible. I could go on and on about their horrible customer service practices. Customer Service is not their priority. Look for a different agency. Don't get bamboozled by them. I will be moving my insurance policies and I will be telling my family and friends who have their insurance through them to change. I will be helping them to do this because I was an agent for 46 years, this is how I know exactly how awful this place is. P.S. Its middle and upper management to blame. The CSR's are only doing what they are being told to do or risk losing their jobs. read more

Got renewal policy corrected by phone and made a payment on early April. Never received a corrected policy. Now find that policy has the wrong address and name. Everything that was updated and corrected in April is not on file now, called to walk through this again by phone. They show the policy cancelled even though a payment had been made?! Again, 45 year customer with Mills, wife added on 40 years ago, 2 sons customers for over 20 years each. Home policy has been with them for over 25 years SAME ADDRESS. The problem was 1 son had an accident and they no longer wanted to insure. Placed him on a separate policy elsewhere. But Mills still had him in their system. read more

My mom had had this insurance for years and has had zero problems until lately. She received the worst customer service from Kevin and called me incredibly flustered. Being in customer service myself for years, I am appalled at the lack of professionalism she received. read more

Have been doing business with this company for over 20+ years. Agent always lookout for you and find ways to save you money. Be sure to ask for multiple cars discount plus multiple policy discount with it. Gave couple options to choose from.. Excellent customer services. read more

Scott finally called me back and gave me a quote. He said that there are so many insurance companies backing out of California, so they are overwhelmed to look for other insurance companies to cover those customers. Which is true as far as I know about the home owners insurance. But I could've been sent a text or email by them. I've been worried about this for 2 months. Not happy, but I understand the problems, more communications are needed. read more

Aime Leon is an outstanding and personable customer service rep. She took care of my request very quickly. She is always very helpful when I call. read more

I've been a customer since 2005. I never bothered them since I haven't had any unfortunate vehicle situation (yet! - knock on wood). Just about this month, I added another vehicle to my policy. The agent I had transaction with did not explain thoroughly all additional fees I should expect for the next billing cycle. The agent should've advised me to wait for the end of my 6 month term to avoid excess amount to pay. I went from one agent to another and another. The last two were able to explain what should've been discussed in the beginning. I told the last two agents that I was not pleased with what had happened but you won't hear even the faintest apology. Customer Service should be bounded by taking the heat and find solutions to appease the client. When I realized that they did not bother to give an apology, I told them that I will no longer continue with their service but they seem to be okay losing a 2 car policy... that just simply means that they don't value their customers. Even if they did, it was never felt. read more

My home and rental have both been serviced by Mills for a number of years. I recently contacted Mills to have earthquake coverage added. Aime L. was attentive, knowledgeable and followed through with my questions and requests. She was able to provide me with several quotes within the morning and get me the proper coverage for what I needed. Thank you Aime!! read more

My family and I have received consistent, quality, customer service from Mills Insurance. Each of the agents I have interacted with have been friendly, helpful have offered sound advice as well as presenting some of the best products out there. We've purchased several insurance products ranging from Home insurance to auto insurance. If you are ever in need in getting several quotes generated to shop for insurance, do not hesitate in contacting Mills insurance. They will take care of you and treat you right. read more

Aime Leon was so helpful and informative . She answered my questions and concerns and was able to help me with my policy. Thank you read more

Such a helpful insurance broker by the name of Scott Keating was so helpful really cares about his Clint's and went over and beyond to help us with insurance . Highly recommend his services. Great job keep it up read more

Aime Leon is an excellent customer service rep. I got to work with her this morning and felt supported and valued. Molly read more

We ran into Mills Insurance by default as our previous insurance agent retired (he was a one man shop) and turned his clients over to Mills. I thought initially that we would find a broker closer to home but my wife said that she was impressed with Mills. She is out of town today and we had an insurance issue with our homeowners. I called, spoke to a lady named Janet and BOOM! Problem solved. we are very happy with Mills. read more

I'm the one who rents out my mom's house. I finally decided to look for a better landlord insurance policy than the high priced one I've had for years. My husband and I have car & home owner's insurance with Mills Insurance and have had good prices and great service with them. I talked with one of their insurance advisors, Aime Leon. She changed the insurer, bundled the landlord policy with our policies, and saved me almost $500 per year with better coverage!! It just doesn't get any better than that!! Thanks, Aime! Thanks, Mills Insurance! read more

The customer service I've received from mills, Indian well, has been exceptional throughout the years. I am very grateful for the care they have always provided me. read more

Aime was very helpful and informative. Great Agent. If you need insurance I do recommend going to Aime.

Been with Mills Insurance for several years, Janet has always took great care of me. She was very helpful and friendly that I switch my parents coverage to Mills Insurance as well. Super friendly and professional people. Highly recommended. read more

Melissa Mar is always so helpful and a joy to talk to! She makes business easy and approachable! Thank you!

I'm giving a 5 stars rating to Aime Leon for the professional and friendly way she handled my request and answered my numerous questions. She has a warm and jovial personality and it came across clearly during our phone conversation. Thanks. Phil read more

Becky was such a nice person to work with. She gave me many options to choose from for my home/auto/earthquake insurance. She also provided an explanation for each option for which for me to choose from. She's a joy to work with and I look forward to working with her for years to come! read more

Aime Leon is an outstanding and personable customer service rep. She helped straighten out some paperwork my credit union needed. This is why I stick with Mills Insurance -quick and efficient service. read more

Aime Leon was a breath of fresh air. I was verifying three different policies, requiring verification and assessment for savings because occupancy changed. Aime was very knowledge about the products offered. She handled my questions with speed and accuracy, and coordinated the computer signing of the policy cancellation for one home. She made a frustrating morning pleasant and I appreciate it. I am a retired school administrator with lots of experience identifying gifted and talented students. Aime should be at the top of the list when you are promoting. read more

Lisa Merrill at Mills insurance is the best. She will always return my calls right away and will always searching for the best policy for me and my family. I think Mills Insurance is the best company. Thank you again Lisa for all your hard work. read more

Been working with Mills insurance for all of my insurance needs for 2 decades. Homes, auto, business, etc. Highs and lows they have been there for me! Quick response times, prompt, professional and courteous service. Janet and Scott are on top of there game! Angelia read more

I have been a very satisfied customer of Mills Insurance for the past 12 years and had never required any special assistance or service from the company with my Homeowners Insurance Policy. However, this year when I received my annual premium notification there was a perceived lowering of my dwelling coverage by my Insurance company.. I called Mills and was introduced to Janet, who became the Insurance Agent to help me resolve the problem. Janet was extremely thorough, persistent, professional and patient in helping me get the problem resolved to my complete satisfaction. She kept me informed throughout the process both with e-mails and telephone calls. Thanks again Janet for all of your assistance. read more

I've been with Mills for three years now. I have quoted out but have never been able to find rates as low as I have with them. There has been some issues on the insurance provider's end, but Mills has always gotten it taken care of right away for me. They keep detailed notes so when I call and they pull up my record, they know what I'm referring to. Janet in particular is very friendly and helpful. They don't make you feel like you're bugging them, which unfortunately is common! read more

Mills insurance is great and I have worked with them for over 10 years and now I really enjoy working with Becky.

Lisa Merrill is an awesome customer service representative. She always saves the day when I need something quickly. She's very professional and prompt. I've always had a terrific experience dealing with her. Thank you Mills Insurance for having such an awesome employee! read more

I would like to Thank Mrs. Becky Stoltz for such a way to present her self and make me feel at home, such a WONDERFUL Lady i'm a person whom makes me hard to talk in the phone and she was there to help me with my questions and resolved my problems immediately such a good customer oriented THANK YOU ! Again mrs. Becky Stoltz Rene Ortiz 10/23/2018 read more

I've been using Mills Insurance Services for years! They handle my Auto Insurance and Umbrella Policies and much more. My go to in the office is always Janet S. as she is quick to respond to emails and always gets the job done. What more can you ask for in a company that employees a great staff that does exactly what they say they are going to! read more

I have been a customer of Mills Insurance Agency for several years and have been extremely pleased with their courtesy and professionalism. Today, I had several inquiries and changes to make and Janet was so pleasant to work with. At no time did I ever feel that I was an interruption of her day. She not only took great care of me on the phone but then we had excellent correspondence via e-mail as I had other insurance inquiries. I will always recommend Mills Insurance Agency to my family and friends. Thank You Janet! You are a star in my books! read more

I have used Mills for 20 years and they are great! I recently contacted them and Aime was wonderful, very helpful and knowledgeable and got me the information I needed right away. read more

Ashley Bowden is my new insurance agent. I called for quotes with NO notice. She personally handled my complications, including 3 VIN numbers when I couldn't decide which car I was going to buy. She got the job done in an efficient, timely and personable manner! I mean timely! I signed online for insurance one hour before signing the documents on my new car. Call Ashley Bowden for good service and good insurance rates from a trusted Mercury Insurance agent today! Thank you, Ashley! read more

I have been a customer of Mills Insurance for more than 10 years. Over the last year the level of service that I have received as become poor. My account representative always sounds bothered and is rude. I spent an hour on the phone giving details for a homeowners policy that I needed in order to close escrow. I had to go to another broker to get my policy in order to close my escrow since my rep. didn't bother to send anything over. I tried again after escrow closed and she to date still hasn't bothered to send me any new policy information. She called today regarding a form that didn't apply to me. Once again, was rude during the middle of my work day. After 10 years, I'm pretty done. read more