First, let me start with the positive: the service was stellar. The girls working are sweet and they get the orders out fast. Maybe we all ordered the wrong things, but we didn't love the ice cream. It was all basically flavorless (except the dreamsicle swirl has a LOT of orange flavor!). I got the soft serve with banana and had them dip it in chocolate. It was a massive portion, but there was zero flavor. No banana at all. And the chocolate shell also had zero flavor and had a weird mouth-feel. My daughter's mint chip shake tasted very artificial, and the color was very bright. My son did enjoy his Oreo shake, so that was good! It seemed like everyone else was ordering the churro ice cream, so maybe we just ordered wrong. read more

Mister Goodies - This is a SMALL. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

My family and I love Mister Goodies. The ice cream is always delicious, served with a smile, and we love the environment. The portion sizes are humongous, but it is so delicious you won't want to stop eating. read more

See all

Saw this place on social media and it looked good so decided to give it a try. Servings are massive and the price is also great. The ice cream was delicious. The cashier was super friendly and helpful. Plenty of tables to sit and eat. Reminds me of carnival or state fair atmosphere. Definitely going back. read more

Service is always really good. It's a bunch of teenagers working there very popular spot and will get busy on the weekends and at night. Prices are a little expensive, but they have to pay for the electricity bill of lighting up the entire block speaking of which you can't miss it it looks like a mini circus. It's so cute. If you are dairy free, do not get the dairy free options. It taste like ice cream flavoring with cornstarch just get something that naturally doesn't have dairy like the Italian ice, but do not get the dairy free substitute ice cream. read more

I always love coming to mister goodies! They have the best menu items and I love that they have fun specials. They're always so fast even if the line is long and always so friendly. I got the Oreo and mint swirl and it was delicious! read more

Mister Goodies - Mint Oreo swirl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Great place to go for ice cream! Such a fun atmosphere and generous portions! Delicious!

Delicious strawberry shortcake sundae! Perfect for summer and nice ambiance in the area! Will be back! read more

Mister Goodies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

This is a great ice cream spot in Lynchburg that always has a multitude of options. I love coming here because I can get something different every time- though I usually stick to my favorites just because they are so good! The employees are always nice and helpful-- especially Mr. Goodie as he helps direct the line! The parking is not the best but that's simply because it's such a popular spot! The line is usually long but always moves very quickly. read more

Mister Goodies - pickup window - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

So many options on menu. Service was kind and very quick. The environment was packed! Very fun would highly recommend

Mr. Goodies is always the place to be! We stopped ot the Timberlake location tonight specifically to try the Cookie Butter and Coffee soft serve! OMG! it was fabulous!!!!! Cookie butter on the front end, coffee on the back! Love the consistency of this soft serve! It is a winner for sure!!!! read more

I love mister goodies, their ice cream is my favorite in Lynchburg but there is this one employee that almost makes me turn around when I see her. She has brown hair, and I believe I've heard her coworkers call her Rebecca, I asked a simple question about what toppings came on a Sunday and she was blatantly condescending in her answer, I also noticed later that she was shooting nasty looks and being passive aggressive to one of her coworkers. I've noticed this has been a reoccurring theme with this girl and I hope whoever is in charge steps in at some point read more

Place is very relaxing good place to hang out and ice cream great and the price just right

I can't believe it has taken me so long to review one of my favorite establishments. Mister Goodies has perhaps the best soft serve ice cream I have ever had. I am frequently blown away by how good the limited edition soft serve options are with the ability to make two of the flavors into a twist (shout out to my favorite, coffee and cookie butter), but I am also a massive fan of their chocolate soft serve that is always available. Believe me when I say that the portions are very generous, and their prices are overall very affordable! Additionally, the staff is always friendly; the cashiers are usually young girls that are likely college students or even high school students. I also love to eat outside when the weather is nice and watch all the dogs (and sometimes cats) that other customers bring. Mister goodies has always been a wonderful place to meet up with friends and to bring family to when they're in town. Mister goodies is one of the places I will miss most since moving away recently. read more

Mister Goodies - a cup of ice cream on a blue table - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Nothing says summer quite like sitting in the outdoor seating area enjoying some tasty ice cream from Mr. Goodies! The ice cream is great and portions are generally large. read more

Mister Goodies had their operation down to a science! We were a bit overwhelmed with all of their ice cream options but found a few that sounded good. Mom got a turtle sundae and dad got a brownie sundae. Both sundaes were the "largest small size" we had ever seen. I opted for a 20oz blueberry cheesecake shake and it was tasty. None of us were disappointed with our dessert and we would love to come back to try other desserts in the future! read more

Mister Goodies - Brownie sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

Happening place with college students.. family and friends. Great deals with the ice cream and they keep the long lines moving fast!

The only reason this review is 4 stars is because the banana split is way to messy. My grandson had one the other day and his shirt and pants were covered with banana split hot fudge and vanilla ice cream liquid. There's a big menu and I highly advise you don't get the large ice cream, it's way too much. The food is delicious. Mr. Goodies is dog friendly so I can bring my two pugs Scout and hamp. It is wheelchair accessible. read more

Thursday night, lady at wimdow taking orders, was rude and seemed to be rushing us. She then asked if.i could take my arm.off.my partner waited as it was inappropriate for other families You see, we were a gay couple. Best ice cream in the world. But don't think we will be back. If tou gay I'd probably think twice before going. Sorry, Mr. Goodies have always loved you, but this kinda ruined if us. read more

My family LOVES Mister Goodies for their pleasant service, friendly atmosphere, and excellent ice cream. This is the perfect place to go because each of us has different tastes: from vegan/non-dairy options, to salty/sweet, to traditional soft serve cones and sundaes! We love being personally greeted and told about the newest flavors. We go as often as we can before the season comes to an end! read more

Mister Goodies - Soft-serve: Strawberry Flavorburst - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

Their icecream is always amazing and the vibe is family friendly and makes for a great summer evening. I love getting the sundae brownie with the hard chocolate. read more

Mister Goodies is the perfect ice cream place! There is always a line here and for a reason! The ice cream is amazing with a great variety on the menu and even run specials. Somehow despite the popularity very cheap. They are generous with the sizes, even a kids size is satisfying. I don't have a go to here because really everything is great! Staff is friendly and they get you your ice cream fast. read more

Mister Goodies - Strawberry flavorburst cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

As far as I can tell - this is the best soft serve ice cream option in Lynchburg. I'm particularly fond of the Banana Nutella Malted Milkshake (don't knock it until you try it). You do have to ask they be extra thorough on mixing it though. Their other options are good as well. I'm personally not a fan of their brownies, but I see others like them. read more

Love this place! Ice cream and plenty of it! Always delicious! The only downside is that they are soooo busy in the summer but the line moves pretty quickly! read more

My husband and I had the best milkshakes from Mister Goodies. He had chocolate and I had strawberry. They were so thick you almost had to eat them with a long handle spoon. Delicious! I got another milkshake at another time. It was vanilla and I added chocolate chips. I love that you can add things to your milkshake to personalize it. Yummy! These were the best milkshakes! read more

This place is impressive in what it sets out to do. The prices are low (although this may be just my disillusionment with other non-lynchburg prices) and the ice cream quality is good. The things that I'm most impressed with is the speed of service as well as the flavors that rotate on the daily. Most places have a flavor of the week or the month but this place? FLAVOR OF THE DAY. Absolute madlads. And they do it crazy fast too! Who woulda guessed. The only reason why its a 4 is that there's nothing that screams to me "this place is to die for." It just a solid ice cream place full of unmasked people. Can't do much about the customers though. read more

See all

Amazing soft serve! One of my favorite ice cream places I found in the area. The portions are huge

The Ice cream AS ALWAYS was amazing! Love that their menu has so many different options. The service was quick and the cashier girl was very nice. Our orders came out so delicious and overall was the best for price, size, and quality! I will definitely come back! read more

Best ice cream place in Lynchburg hands down. Customer service is always speedy no matter how long the line is. Employees are always nice. Ice cream always taste perfect read more

How can you go wrong at Mr. Goodies? You can't go wrong. There is a reason they're always crowded; great ice cream, great service, great prices. Mr. Goodies is the best. Always a good time to go there. Everything on the menu is wonderful. read more

Mister Goodies is a Lynchburg staple. I've eaten there a couple times since we've moved here and it's never failed to disappoint. The workers are friendly and kind, and there are so many different treats to choose from ! read more

If you are on a trip I definitely recommend!! This place is so good any time I got an iced or ice cream it was good. There was a line but it was worth it. Also the service was very fast and sweet. You should go!!! read more

Best tasting soft serve in the burg. Best service! What I like is that it's great to bring one of my kids to treat once in a while or meet up with groups. read more

Literally order anything on this menu and you won't be disappointed! Very large portions and some of their special menu items are crafty, but also end up being a great combination of things to eat. Definitely a must to visit while in the area, but come hungry for dessert!! read more

Mister Goodies - Funky Monkey Banana Split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

This place beats all the ice scream places in VA!! It has such a huge menu filled with so many fun and delicious options. The service is great. You never have to wait long for your order. Love how it has so many tables to enjoy your ice scream. Highly recommend this place! read more

The best ice cream around, made on premises. They offer both soft serve and hand dipped. Today, I tried their "Just 8" frozen yogurt (low cal and carb). It was available in coconut and chocolate, which I got swirled together. Delicious! Nice and tangy, real yogurt taste. Highly recommend. read more

Always great ice cream and prices are good. You totally get your money's worth. A kids cone is equivalent to a Dairy Queen large. A large is huge! My husband got it once and there was no way he could finish it. The hot apple dumplings are amazing! The new cookie sandwich is amazing. Everything from a regular cone to their specialities are amazing. If you plan on going on a Wednesday or Friday - Sunday evening, expect to stand in line. However, it goes fast and is worth it. read more

Mister Goodies - Ice cream cookie sandwich with sprinkles. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

This is my second time here. The ice cream is excellent! The taste and texture are of great quality. The mouthfeel is luscious! The hot chocolate fudge is YUMMY! This time I had a simple small cup with chocolate vanilla twist and hot fudge. Whereas my first visit I had a brownie sundae. I enjoyed both but the simple cup was more enjoyable! I was able to distinguish the ice cream quality and would have to rate it the best soft serve ice cream for me! It was a fundraiser night this time and it was crowded. I have to give compliments for smooth and quick service! read more

Mister Goodies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Always a great environment, usually busy but quick! Lemon blueberry or brownie sundae with mocha ice cream are my favorites!

You can't beat Mr. Goodies, it's a Lynchburg staple. This location focuses on food truck style soft serve ice cream. The Boonsboro location is more on regular ice cream but both are equally delicious. This location always has a line but they run this place like a Chick-fil-A so it's quick and efficient! I personally love the dirt and worms sundae as well as the apple dumplings! read more

This is the place to get Ice Cream in Lynchburg! They have so many flavors and all of it is a reasonable price! I recommend getting a small cone (which is not small at all...) of vanilla or orange swirl. I have never tasted a bad ice cream from them! read more