Delicious ice cream, great service, friendly staff, and a really nice, down-to-Earth owner! I had…read moretrouble setting up my cash app to Apple pay, and the owner let me get the ice cream before paying. This place is great! They have a lot of options, too, and they definitely don't skimp on portion sizes

Quick, friendly service and served quick. Little disappointed blackberry didn't come with any…read moreactual fruit. Taste was good and satisfying.

I have always enjoyed the black raspberry flavor between the lemon cookies. When I first came to…read morecollege in Lynchburg, Rookie's was the first place I went with my hall. There are good memories behind it and the staff have always been so nice. I love the outdoor string lights and just the vibe of it in general.

Rookies was a college staple for me and I try to make my way back there every time I'm in town. I…read moreremember back when it was just a small operation, and so I'm impressed with just how much farther it's come. The cookies + ice cream are so yummy and I also really recommend their chocolate milk. Pair the great desserts with the fun vibe and it just makes for a nice place to grab a great late night treat.

Outside the Cone is an awesome local spot, the staff were very sweet and kind! The whole place…read morefeels so welcoming and very clean. Four of us tried a mix of vegan salty s'mores, vegan chocolate, banana pudding, Buttah Finger, melted brownie, and banana chunk ice creams, and every single flavor was rich, and absolutely delicious. I loved that they have so many quality vegan options, too. I'm bringing my family and I highly recommend stopping here if you're anywhere near Forest and Lynchburg!!

Last Monday we went in for the first time. I was served a gluten free waffle cone or at least I was…read moretold. This Monday I was told only Saturday and Sunday are when the gluten free waffle cones are available. I'm worried about last Monday and the possibility that I could have had a non gluten waffle especially because I'm pregnant and don't want to harm my baby. Would have been 5 stars if I had known that last week. I really craved for a gluten waffle cone with the ice cream because I've never found a place that had the option. The staff is nice and the shop smells delicious! Wish they made the gluten free cones on the week days too. GLUTEN FREE WAFFLE CONES ARE ONLY AVAILABLE ON THE WEEKENDS!

Ice cream is great I recommend the dirt cake and the mint moose tracks. I lived near this area for…read morea long time this used to be a sonic. I didn't know they had coffee until last year. Service is experienced and hard working. It is wheelchair accessible.

You're typical "over the top" summer night ice cream joint!!…read more Lots of flavors from ice cream, sno cones, Italian ice, etc. This seems to be a neighborhood favorite!! Always packed out in the summers with teenagers and adults alike! I highly recommend this place and hope to be back again! Thanks for the memories!

I took my grandson to the store on September 29 and we both got a SMALL yogurt - in the pink cup…read more Mine was only half full and it was over six dollars. My grandson filled his to the top and his was over $14 which I think is absolutely ridiculous. Also, they have a tip screen when you try to pay with your credit card and it feels very pressured even though the employee does nothing the whole time you are there. I contacted the store (manager) and they stand by their policy that they charge $.75 an ounce as well as leaving the tip option on the credit card screen. I have no problem with them having a tip jar, but I do not like being pressured into leaving a tip. They need to have a sign up at the toppings warning that the toppings may greatly increase the price of your yogurt to a ridiculous amount of money if you add anything to it I will not be going back to this store. I would rather go to a place that lets you know the price upfront and does not charge outrageous fees.

Spent my money and VERY few selections to choose from. Come on SweetFrog!!!!! We really thought…read morethis place was going to be a real experience, but it turn into a disappointment.

Update! This review is for the Winchester VA location. I mistakenly picked Lynchburg as I'm not…read morelocal to the area.

Will was so amazing and helpful. Super kind staff and nice seating area. The ice cream is…read morephenomenally delicious and the prices are unbeatable. I love this place and Will was the nicest service worker I've ever encountered.

Maylynn's is a staple in Lynchburg and we used to enjoy it all the time when we lived locally. We…read moremoved away for years and recently came back for a visit. It was on the list of places we had to visit! We went with friends and it was just as good if not better than I remembered. The ice cream was on point, the prices were right, and the vibe was fun and relaxing. The kids had lots of fun activities to do while the adults gathered and talked, and it was just a great evening with a beautiful sunset to top it off. The service is always great and everyone that works there is friendly and helpful. Parking is never an issue and they are quick to get your treats out to you! I have no complaints and highly recommend everyone should visit!

First of all, please let me apologize for the pics of the half-eaten Cookiewich. I am usually so…read moregood about taking the pre-eating pic for my review, but I sort of got...overly excited to dive in. Let me explain. We were eating dinner with the family at Mi Patron (across the parking lot) and my wife showed me a video of this Cookiewich thing at the food truck in the same parking lot. It being made, it being eaten, etc. I had to do it. I did. It was SOOOOO worth it, and was literally a Magical Ice Cream Experience. I just made up that term, but it works. I LOVED it, and almost stopped here again during my quick three-day trip to Lynchburg. I still regret NOT stopping by again, and sometimes have dreams about it while back in Colorado. But, that is neither here nor there. Anyway, you need to get yourself one of these awesomeness-in-an-ice-cream-treat things. In addition to the actual ice cream being awesome, they have the ring game (so you can entertain yourself while stuffing your face like I did), AND the value of what you pay and what you get is...sort of absurd in this day and age. It was $4.75, I believe and that is insane. Go and get it before they raise the price. I would have paid like $12 for that thing. I highly recommend making the dessert stop at this place when in the area, and see you there (no, seriously, the next time I am in Lynchburg, I am beelining it there)...

Visited in late afternoon on a weekday. Service was fast and the ice cream was amazing. I ordered…read morethe honey crunch rolled iced cream.

We came here on a Friday night after dinner. Although it was very crowded it didn't take long for…read moreus to get our sweet treats. I enjoyed the friendly service as well as the delicious ice cream! Mint chocolate chip has been my jam as of late and it did not disappoint. I ordered the flat top size and it was the perfect amount of creamy/delicious ice cream. This isn't a really big space at all but I did appreciate their being a line for cash and a line for card payments. This really helped with the flow since it was busy when I visited. MayLynn's is worth checking out if you happen to be in the downtown Lynchburg area. It's YUMMY!

Nitro Cow offers a fun atmosphere and a wide variety of Mexican-inspired ice cream and desserts,…read morebut I found the prices to be much higher than other Mexican ice cream shops. While the treats are good, they didn't feel worth the cost. Compared to similar places, the portions and flavors were decent, but the overall value was disappointing. There are other Mexican ice cream shops that offer comparable desserts for a more reasonable price.

Given how unique this establishment seems, I had to give it a try. The environment and the…read moreaesthetics of the establishment was really cool. The ice cream was good and they offer a wide range of unique flavors, but expect to pay around $9 for a milkshake. Elotes were good, but a bit on the heavier side in terms of chili powder. I also tried the walking taco (with Doritos) and found this item to be the worst. I expected more protein, and instead 80% or more of it was cucumber and some sort of onion that wasn't flavorful. The staff were nice, and service was very fast. Granted, it was about half an hour prior to close that I visited.