pleasantly surprised with the pizza not many good pizza spots in area. sauce was good. cheese was good. pizza was too thick but still better then usual. read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

The food lately has not been as good . Today was the icing on the cake. No good. Next time I'll just take the drive to Nanuet, IYKYK!

Mr. Crispy's did an amazing job on my Super Bowl Catering order. The 3ft Italian hero was delicious and stuffed with meat. The Penne Vodka was so creamy and tasteful. The Wings were nice and crispy and of course the Pizza was crispy and delicious, even the salad was amazing filled with olives, peppers and sun dried tomatoes. I can't say enough about this place. They definitely did an awesome job and this is definitely my Go to for everything. read more

Great pizza & great people! They truly care about their customers & offer a good variety.

Food is good and very consistent and the house salad which came with a pizza special was amazing! Like wow over exceeded all expectations!. Also best garlic knots I have ever had! read more

New owner! Huge fresh salad, tasty chicken parm and French fries! Definitely get a lot for your money! read more

This is the only place my partner would order their chicken parm from. I've got to say it was some great chicken parm pizza! The beef patty and the cheese and pepperoni roll were really good as well! Nice workers! Area is clean. Food is not overpriced! read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

Overcharge for low quality pizza! 4 plain slice for $20??????????????? Never againnnnnnn!!!!!

Food has changed... definitely not as good as it used to be I don't know if it is a different owner, but I can't say it is worth it anymore.... read more

I'm admittedly grading on a bit of a curve given the location, but I've been very pleased the two times I've ordered from here. There are a TON of pizza places in the area, but I'm finding it's best to look at some of the secondary menu offerings. Case in point, the heros/sandwiches at Mr. Crispy's are the selling point - they dominate the menu compared to the pizza options, and they offer half-sizes, which is perfect for me. (Full disclosure - I have not had the pizza but based solely on superficial optics, it does not look like my jam.) I stopped by most recently this past week for lunch. Mr. Crispy's (like almost every establishment within a 10-mile radius) is located in a strip mall with some other lunchtime spots as well. I ordered from here a few months ago with a co-worker, who didn't get what she asked for, but said that they took down her name if I wanted to reference it for a free meal. Classy when places do that. The girl behind the counter was very friendly, so I figured I'd at least ask about that since it seemed a bit odd that they'd keep track of free meals just by jotting down the customer name in lieu of, say, providing a coupon or something. They literally had a notebook by the counter with all of the names, which cracked me up. I chose to pay for my own meal rather than seriously pursue that, but hey - it's a system. I ordered the half-hero size chicken parm ($5.75). As mentioned, perfect portion and a very competitive price point for what you're getting. I'm not a huge connoisseur of subs/heros since they tend to be pretty heavy, so the only direct comp I have is a place in Jersey City called Milano's, which is well regarded for these types of sandwiches. Honestly though? I prefer this one. Milano's has super fresh, practically dripping mozzy on theirs (the one obvious upside), but I really love that Mr. Crispy's toasts the bread pretty hardcore before serving. Gives it a nice crunch/slight char, the only downside being that every bite ends up like a Nature Valley bar, with crumbs cascading down in front of you. Napkins should be handy. I also like that the chicken is kind of shredded, not one or two hunks; that's certainly personal preference though. The cheese IS a little heavy/thick for me, but it does end up evening out with the decent portion size, and I like that the sauce is very much a subtle secondary player here. The restaurant itself is pretty non-descript - it looks like every other blue collar, by the slice pizza place - but it offers seating with a big window in the front if you want to gaze out at the parking lot while you munch (I chose to catch up on the breaking news on the NY Post website on my phone). The service is also top-notch. Not only was the counterperson/server friendly, but it took less than five minutes to get my sandwich, and she urged me to get the lunch special, which was the same exact price but included a soda/bag of chips - they easily could have saved the minimal inventory. Very pleasant little spot, and I will be returning shortly. read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Chicken Parm Half Hero. - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

Was driving from Nanuet, called to order sandwich and placed on hold. Called 3 more times and placed on hold. As I passed by, there was only 1 customer at the counter. So frustrated, I went to another pizza place. You guys need to work on this. Good is otherwise very good Sorry read more

they undercook every pizza they make and call them selves " Mr crispy". the pizza I order tonight was completely undercooked almost raw and they did nothing about it. what a waste of money, get pizza anywhere else than these losers read more

The pizza was good from this place in the past. Tonight I picked up 2 pies for $58. A Sicilian Pepperoni & a Buffalo chicken pizza that appeared too large to fit in the box. So what do you do when the pizza is too large, you fold it so it fits. I called to let them know that I was not happy with the condition of the pizza. All they could offer is an apology. Never again will they see a $$ of my money. Both pizzas were very soggy! read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

Delicious pizza, perfect sauce, cheese and crust. I'm picky with my pizza but this was absolutely perfect.

Food is really good but when I'm trying to call to place an order I would like to not be on hold for 10 minutes. Work on that please.

Had a meeting nearby and stopped for lunch on the way home. This is a small sized place with about 10-12 tables. I was greeted nicely when I walked in. First thing I did was ask if inside dining was allowed. The guy said it was, that they were now in Phase 3. So I asked for a couple of slices. I get told it comes with a can of soda and costs $6. I said great. I am told to sit in the dining area & he will bring it to me. How great it felt to sit inside a restaurant again, like a real live grown-up. The guy brings my slices and I was very pleasantly surprised. I received 2 large slices with a real nice crust. They were delicious. Plenty of cheese and sauce. I would absolutely return. read more

Paid $17 plus tax for a chicken Alfredo. The chicken was boiled unseasoned chicken and the Alfredo sauce has no flavor at all. There was also Spinach inside the pasta which is not stated on their menu. read more

Finally a Pizza Place where they sell a tasty Pizza, I recently moved to Haverstraw in March and I've been looking for a Pizza Spot where they sell Good Pizza. Mr Crispy's is that place, I definitely will be returning to Mr Crispy's for my Pizza Pies read more

Disgusting. I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and the Buffalo sauce was basically ketchup , they over stuffed the wrap and it fell apart in my hand. The fries are bland and soggy, I'm glad I ordered 1 instead of 2 cause it was legit garbage , and I asked for bacon inside the wrap ... they gave me bacon in a small plastic cup read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Gross - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

See all

Good food, but the staff leaves something to be desired. The girl who answers the phone is ALWAYS rude. Simple directions about how you want your food are never honored. If you don't care about customer service this is the place for you. read more

I love this pizza it's the best in the county I've had it delivered many times my problem is I like onion and garlic on my pizza they charge $2.50 for each extra I do not believe they put five dollars worth of onion and garlic on my pizza so I have a hard time buying from them but if you don't like extras that aren't expensive go for it they're great read more

Great Local spot for Pizza! Not only do they have great tasting pizza but they are a big supporter of our local community always willing to help the kids of North Rockland. When i get food delivered its always hot and fresh! read more

This was my first time here. First thing I noticed was its cleanliness which is a plus always. Their display had a wide variety of specialty pizza and everything looked great. The staff was pleasant. My margherita slice was really good; the crust was on the thin side which I prefer and was very crispy and the sauce was good as well. The only thing I would suggest is they highlight their paninis/wraps/sandwiches a little more because I didn't notice them until after I ordered and grabbed a menu on my own. (the options sounded delicious!) Overall, I enjoyed my experience there and will be going there again if I'm in the area. read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - My margherita slice - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

Spoiled Jamaican Beef Pattie This it the third time they are selling us the spoiled Jamaican beef pattie. First time we told them about this issue they said sorry. This is the third time; They have to do something about storing the patties so it wont get spoiled. The meat taste like its been outside for couple of days. read more

Recently moved to the area. Ordered a basic pepperoni pie, pizza was great and ready when we drove by to pick it up. New pizza spot for lazy fridays found! read more

I ordered a large pizza tonight. I got a medium. I called Mr. Crispy to say I got the wrong size. The lady who answered told me she definitely put a large in the box. I have been a customer for years. Not any more. Poor service has become the norm here combined with poor quality. A few years ago, Mr. Crispy was the best in the county. Not anymore. Stay away and don't get ripped off by a "bait and switch". read more

Oil and crappy slices and there is no real brick oven!! WTF? Really? Wow.

Great great thing crust pizza and pasta fagiole!! It's helps their right across the street - considering strong competition in the area these guys make great food!!! read more

Just moved to town looking for new piazza joint. Well I am DONE looking. Hands down super perfect crust sauce cheese ratio. Do not miss. I also Love their sausage read more

See all

Have to say was very impressed by the customer service and quality of food. I originally ordered a out of the norm vegetarian pie without cheese as I am a Vegan. Mistakenly it arrived with cheese (likely out or habit). They sent out a replacement and apologies. Btw it was delicious. Thank you Mr Crispy. read more

Just ordered from this place, paid 35 dollar for a salad and a slice of pizza and an order of garlic knuts. Over priced, just to find hair in my salad and in the marinara sauce. Absolutely dissatisfied and won't be ordering from here again. Pricing is not a big deal but for something that price I wouldn't expect hair to be found in my food. read more

2 Small Pizzas, one cheese one Pepperoni came to $32.. I was shocked they charge a 5% credit card fee... Ouch!! Pizza is ok, but not worth the up charge vs Other local Pizza places in The area... read more

If you go here get the grilled chicken,mozzarella and prosciutto on garlic bread . This is the best in Rockland . You will be happy I told you to get it plus it's fairly priced . The staff can be more attentive theY have young people at counter need to learnn how to make customers feel at home . read more

Been going to Mr Crispy's for years, Very great and authentic italian food, even the burgers, wraps, and heroes are off the hook. One of the only pizzerias in rockland that hook you up with chicken slices(portions are HUGE!) dinners are phenomenal, biggest portions you get with dinners as well, that come with a salad, zeppeli garlic knots, and a hot fresh dinner roll, About everytime I end up splitting the dinner with my girlfriend its so much food... Amazing pizzas on the crispy side, if you like it softer just let them know(lightly cooked) they're very laid back down to earth people. When you're in the mood for Italian food this is the place to go! read more

I am a big fan of the Chicken parm slice. I live in CT and whenever I'm in town I always make it a priority to stop by. Today the slice was completely different. The chicken wasn't cut up and the slice barely had any sauce. The whole taste was off and I was greatly disappointed. It was as if whoever was making the pizzas today was super lazy. I didn't finish my slice and just paid and walked out. I hope this isn't a permanent thing in which no real effort is being made to satisfy paying customers. Hesitating whether I'll come back or not because I'm sure any other pizza shop could put together what I had to eat today. read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - What is this. Chicken isn't cut up. Barely any sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

See all

I've delivered from them multiple times and they messed up at least once everytime. They didn't mention to us they ran out of wings and just brought up BBQ chicken tenders when we asked for mild bone in wings. They came to us 3 times until we just gave up and ordered from somewhere else. read more

Hidden gem in northern Rockland right off of 202. Used to live right across the street from this place and it was def a staple meal in my house. I can honestly say I haven't had anything bad from here and everything is delicious. One of the best pizza places in Rockland. They have a big variety of specialty pies, sandwhiches and meals. All are very generous portions and you get what you pay for. Most dinners and meals come with bread, salad, pasta and garlic knots for free. It's def worth the trip to northern Rockland! read more

Mr Crispy's Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garnerville, New York

I truly used to enjoy the pizza at Mr. Crispy's but unfortunately I can't bring myself to order from there anymore. Every time I call to place an order I get confronted with rude people. The call is answered with "Yea" and "what do you want". Not to mention that you have to repeat your address and phone number several times because teens are always fooling around in the background and your address is never understood. They always mess up the order as well. The owner should train his staff to be cordial and professional. The other pizza shop down the street is always a pleasant phone call away. Sorry Mr. Crispy's but pleasantries go a long way. read more

I never leave reviews but some people just deserve for you to let them have it.. I called and order a chicken bacon ranch pie for pick up the girl who takes my order tells me itll be 15-20 minutes.. i said ok thank you ill b there n we both hang up.. i go pick up the pizza and they start with the excuses.. the first was i never got your phone # .. the second was i was getting allot of calls .. etc.. First of you said thank you and you hung up.. if your job is to take name n number than you should ask that.. second you getting lots of calls has nothing to do with me or any customer calling you to order.. last you have CAllER ID.. its 2018.. So the persons solution to me not gettn my pizza that i order 20 min ago is to say i can have them cook it now.. NO if you did your job right i would have to donate another 20 minutes to you.. Finally NEVER AGAIN.. they wanna play with peoples time .. hell no.. customer beware.. super incompetent.. cant even get a phone order for 1 pie correct.. imagine if it was a big order.. or an order for a party or sumthing.. big disappointment.. When i left angry as hell i told them i got you on yelp.. learn not to play with people or their time.. read more

Food is average at best, I just had slices and there was nothing brick oven about it. Too many of these same pizza places around, nothing special. Also, They don't realize thick slices need to stay in longer when you say you want it extra hot and crispy, even when you tell them twice. Crayons and drawing paper on every table, but you need to walk to the counter to get pepper, garlic, and cheese. Next time I'll see if I can shake some crayon shavings on my slices instead. Behind the counter they are chatter boxes, and some, not all, are somewhat rude and don't know how to look at you to tell you your total, and actually take your money when you hand it to them instead of stop talking to coworkers. Businesses get once get to make a good impression and have customers remember them as being great, this place was not great, and I won't be going there again. read more