The Pieman Pizza

It's always a delicious treat to eat in the lovely restaurant with tablecloths on the tables or…read moretake out a meal. Never disappoints!

First time stopping here and I love it! The people working were so sweet and accommodating. I…read moreordered dinner to go and it was amazing. Everything tasted fresh and I was happy with my whole experience!! Highly recommend

Broccoli and chicken slice.

See all

Wall art

Dolce Vita

4.4(173 reviews)

2.1 mi

•$$$

Dolce Vita is one of my favorite restaurants in Nyack! The owners are incredibly kind, welcoming,…read moreand truly make you feel at home. The service is always outstanding, the food is absolutely delicious, and the cozy atmosphere makes it a place you'll want to come back to again and again. It's also a wonderful place to meet great people. Highly recommend!

We had an excellent experience here tonight! We decided to bring our 2-month-old son out for dinner…read morefor one of our first family outings, and the staff made the experience so enjoyable. Everyone was welcoming, attentive, and patient, which really helped us relax and enjoy the evening. The food was outstanding. I had the whole grilled fish with roasted potatoes and vegetables, and it was cooked perfectly--crispy skin, tender, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Every part of the meal was fresh and delicious. Great food, exceptional service, and a family-friendly atmosphere made this a memorable dinner. We'll definitely be coming back and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fantastic meal with top-notch hospitality.

A cozy and stylish spot with great food, drinks and a welcoming vibe ..

Mediterranean Meatballs

See all

Our cozy bar offers a great selection of spirits, warm lighting and welcoming vibe...

Broadway Bistro

4.4(190 reviews)

2.1 mi

good food, great drinks, nice ambiance and pleasant service…read more the food is a bit average. but I've been twice and enjoyed my food both times.

cute local eatery serving italian food. it was super busy and i forgot to make reservation. but…read morethey did find seating and accommodated us. food was good my mom liked her fra diavolo seafood pasta. came with lots of seafood. i got the risotto- kinda taste weird with tomato reduction. perhaps a cheese or truffle sauce would have been better. my sister had the salmon which was pretty standard. service was good waitress was busy but never failed to refill water and checked in with us regularly.

Inside

Mussels

See all

Shrimp and scallops

Dutan And Duffy Restauran

4.2(102 reviews)

0.5 mi

Despite having food allergies (shellfish/pork intolerant/lactose intolerant), the restaurant was…read morewilling to make adjustments in the culinary department. I received a six-slice pizza. I have no idea what the size is categorized as or what the price was since I did not pay. This is an old review for Father's Day of 2024. For some reason, I thought this place was called Deanna or Diana Maria, so trying to figure out the correct name took some time. My family enjoys the food here and has been going here for quite some time, too. They enjoy the food here. The vegetables on the pizza and the sauce were not bad. It was just the crust that ruined the experience. Hence, the one-star deduction. The waitress was quite comedic, friendly, and still professional. The other waiter seemed more shy, friendly, and professional. It is mainly the outstanding service, yet I don't know if we received this type of service since my family knows the owner. I would hope everyone receives the same service, haha. Otherwise, the ambiance seems cozy, friendly, and family-style, although it is a bit smaller than I thought it would be. ( :

Brian, Fabio, Heather and Bella thank you so very much for allowing me to celebrate my daughter's 6…read morebday there! Kiddos had a blast and I learned a thing or 2 about pizza making!

Vegetable/Vegetarian Pizza

See all

SALAD SLICE!

La Fontana

3.3(170 reviews)

2.3 mi

Amazing food and amazing service! Owner and staff were so friendly and accommodating! Amazing…read moreenvironment, great restaurant and people!

SERVICE: oh, nicest people on earth. really enthusiastic about trying new things and they for sure…read moreknow the menu by heart. passion? you can feel it in the air. The owner and who i believe is the head chef (molino...?) are people that literally refuse to work with low quality ingredients, guaranteeing excellent food with colorful flavor! FOOD: oh my god, DELICIOUS!!! I personally ate half a plate of chicken francese (the lemon sauce? DELICIOU!! most places don't make the sauce taste like lemon, and i enjoyed the slight sourness to it!!" I tried a bit of their fried calamari and, considering it was my first time ever eating it, 10/10! The Crème Brulee here is absolutely delicious. Not too sweet, just how i, personally, like my desserts. :) I'd come back here again and again and again!

Huge

Penne Alla Vodka (amazing)

See all

The fountain!

Il Fresco

4.0(278 reviews)

4.7 mi

•$$$

Il Fresco has consistently provided excellent and attentive service with tasty Italian dishes. We…read morehad the perfect spot in with the sun shining in on the Sassafras room on this cool, fall day. We ordered calamari as an appetizer which was served with both a sweet and spicy sauce. The calamari were tender but not quite as crispy as we would have liked. The Stracciatella was loaded with spinach and eggs and well seasoned. Our main dishes were wonderful; we tried the Halibut Marechiare, stuffed Zucchini, and Pepper and Egg sandwich. Make reservations if dining in the evening and enjoy one of their many well-appointed dining areas - cozy and comfortable.

i can't rave enough about this place - gorgeous and intimate atmosphere, the kindest wait staff,…read moreincredible full bar (with homemade infused vodkas let me add) but the FOOD???? forget it!!! frank the owner always makes sure we're treated like family (i recall one year him helping us squeeze in for a coveted christmas eve reservation). do yourself a favor and come here (not just once but multiple times -- the human experience is made up of at least one cozy dinner in the wine cellar AND one stunning meal in the summer on the patio). thank you il fresco for being the best!

Indoor seating by the patio

See all

Norcina

4.0(235 reviews)

3.6 mi

uber order some great Sicilian pizza from here it was crispy and thick…read more screwed my order up but still was good. alayws on point never disappointed

Always great. Milan, Nick and the staff are welcoming. Food is on point every time. They are also…read morecommunity minded people. A+

Norcina - Top row - right to left: Roasted Chicken Salmon Trapanese Knots/dipping dough Bottom row: Marinara Rigatoni meatballs Spaghetti Aglio Olio

Top row - right to left: Roasted Chicken Salmon Trapanese Knots/dipping dough Bottom row: Marinara Rigatoni meatballs Spaghetti Aglio Olio

Fried Calamari

See all

Confetti Ristorante & Vinoteca

3.5(294 reviews)

5.3 mi

Really enjoyed the food here on Mother's Day…read more Made a reservation for an early dinner online, for outside seating. Didn't think to check if they were honoring that given the holiday, since it turned out to be first come first serve no reservations. Inside reservations were being taken, there was a bit of a wait but it was well worth it. Our party of 3 ordered the octopus and an arugula salad as an appetizer. The octopus was divine - would come back for this specifically. We split entrées and ordered the short ribs, orrecchiette, and Chilean sea bass. Pretty big portions and the flavor to match! A huge kudos to the hostess up front, who navigated a pretty grumpy crowd with such grace. Understandably, it was a very busy day, and the restaurant was packed. We probably could've used a bit more attention from the waiter after we were seated, as we would've liked another cocktail, but overall a great experience. Looking forward to coming back.

Came here to echo others' feeling that the front of the house REALLY needs work. The food is good…read more(although overpriced), and the shrimp in the fritto misto was awesome. Thing is, seating and service leave a LOT to be desired. We had a reservation, the place was empty, and they still weren't ready for us. My impression is this is one of those places where the chef knows how to cook, but rules with an iron fist and has no clue how to train or empower a staff to be focused on the diners' experience. The place was a ghost town when we went in this week, and my prediction is this place doesn't have long to live.

Dining room

Seafood with spaghetti

See all

Primavera Pizzeria

4.2(66 reviews)

2.4 mi

Legitimately some of the best pizza in Rockland. I really…read morelike what they do and they come up with some interesting topping for their pizza and the best part is the service. I would definitely come again.

The MVP slice is my go-to!!! Every-time I come here the owners are always so nice. This place…read morereminds me of a little spot in Europe, the music is so jazzy and it's honestly a vibe inside. 10/10 I love coming here!!

Things to do in Valley Cottage

MVP slice

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

William K.

0

1

0

4 years ago

I did not like the pieman. When I sat down with my friends we all asked for Shirley temples they said that they were out. Then we asked for lemonades and I asked for a Caesar salad. I never got the salad. When the waitress came with a pitcher of lemonade, She poured lemonade to everyone except me including the person that never asked for lemonade! Then they came out with the pizza, (it was nothing special) it tasted like every other pizza. The plates they gave us were still wet and had cheese on them, from the people that used them before. Ten minutes later my mom went up to the waiter to ask for to Caesar salads for me and my friend. They put it on the table and we tried it, like everything at the pieman it isn't that good (it tasted weird). This is hard to describe but I will try, inside the dressing it felt like it had a bunch of salt which left a weird feeling in my mouth. This is why I will never go back to the pieman read more

Travis K.

0

6

4

2 years ago

Great service. Great ambiance! Great craft beer selection! Amazing thin crust pizza! Definitely recommend!

Ashley M.

143

16

4

4 years ago

Great pizza! Awesome service! Great atmosphere! Great prices! Great for easy family night dinner.

Max N.

283

3

0

4 years ago

The best of the best. I'll be back forever and ever. Order the wings and a cold one. Enjoy!

Steve B.

Elite 26

81

364

314

4 years ago

After thinking and seeing how much my grandkids liked this place I change my mind to a 4.

Betsy B.

0

7

2

3 years ago

I thought it made a comeback of how it used to be, unfortunately not. Nice staff though

Anthony I.

0

5

1

3 years ago

my favorite place love it great food service and family friendly

The Pieman Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Valley Cottage

People found The Pieman Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed The Pieman Pizza also viewed

Dutan And Duffy Restauran

(102 reviews)

Despite having food allergies (shellfish/pork intolerant/lactose intolerant), the restaurant was…read morewilling to make adjustments in the culinary department. I received a six-slice pizza. I have no idea what the size is categorized as or what the price was since I did not pay. This is an old review for Father's Day of 2024. For some reason, I thought this place was called Deanna or Diana Maria, so trying to figure out the correct name took some time. My family enjoys the food here and has been going here for quite some time, too. They enjoy the food here. The vegetables on the pizza and the sauce were not bad. It was just the crust that ruined the experience. Hence, the one-star deduction. The waitress was quite comedic, friendly, and still professional. The other waiter seemed more shy, friendly, and professional. It is mainly the outstanding service, yet I don't know if we received this type of service since my family knows the owner. I would hope everyone receives the same service, haha. Otherwise, the ambiance seems cozy, friendly, and family-style, although it is a bit smaller than I thought it would be. ( :

Brian, Fabio, Heather and Bella thank you so very much for allowing me to celebrate my daughter's 6…read morebday there! Kiddos had a blast and I learned a thing or 2 about pizza making!

Tarantella's Pizzaria & Italian Restaurant

3.2

(153 reviews)

impeccable -- exactly what you want from a NY pizza shop. authentic flavors, incredibly cheese to…read moresauce ratio, light yet crispy crust (that's not overcooked) with just a hint of brick over flavor on the undercarriage. super friendly staff, i could have yapped in there all day! check out their outdoor seating and lil pizza window now that spring is here :)

I order a chicken piccota pasta. And got shrimp piccota when i called back to ask them exchange it…read morethey said it was my fault but meanwhile they charged me for a chicken. Very bad service how the Person spoke to me on the phone trying to blame me and complaining meanwhile he read my order back to me as chicken.

Nonna Rosa Pizza

(55 reviews)

Pie was delicious and reasonably priced, friendly folks, great service, and relatively quiet. Love…read morelittle local spots like this!

Popped in here on a whim. It seems so unassuming, sort of off to the side in a parking lot area…read morewith nothing else going on. It was a Thursday evening around 6:30 and we walked in and ordered a cheese pizza to go. It took only about 10 min. BUT had to we come in 5 min later there would have been a wait. Suddenly groups streamed in and I overheard them ordering everything from sandwiches to pasta and different types of non-pizza items. Seeing this in a pizza shop always is a good sign. There is ample seating and everything looked clean. There is a bathroom on site as well. We were starving so ate the pizza on the car ride home and although it was super warm, it was delicious and flavorful. The sauce was a little sweet for my liking but still very good. I would definitely return if in the area.

Franco's Pizza

4.1

(218 reviews)

Great fast service and delicious food. Quaint atmosphere of a pizza parlor of old which is worth…read morethe odd way to enter the strip mall area behind the PC Richardson store.

Was in the area for my beloved uncle's memorial. I had never been to this particular town but the…read moreservice was in Rockland county so I stayed at a hotel right across the street from Franco's. I went in with my mom and dad. We are from NY but now live in LA. Unfortunately, due to health reasons, my dad and I are both on a gluten free diet. You never know what you're gonna get with a gluten free pie. Sometimes they're like cardboard, others are not crispy enough or too crispy. Franco's offers a cauliflower crust and it's the best gluten free pie I've ever had. My dad agreed and we eat pizza wherever we go. The crust was perfectly crispy. The sauce was amazingly good and the cheese was perfect. My mom got a regular slice and said it was also fantastic. The owner and employees were very chill and nice. I highly recommend this spot.

Turiello's Pizza House & Restaurant

(197 reviews)

Best pizza I've ever had, been 50+ times…read more I am constantly tempted to drive up from DC get a couple slices.

Quick stop on our way to Jersey shore. Two great slices and an eggplant sub. All were perfect ! We…read morecame off hours and had the place to ourselves.

Nicky's II Pizza

4.0

(33 reviews)

I've lived in Rockland since 2019 and no one has ever told me about this place! Can't believe I've…read moremissed out on their pizza all this time! I don't have any pictures because I eat the food before I thinnk to take pictures when it comes to this pizzeria lol The VadkaRita is absolutely amazing especially with some hot pepper flakes and a side of Riesling. Salivating right now just writing about it. The salad pizza, plain and grandma slices are delicious too! Ambience is the old school pizzeria feel... With the square pizza boxes piled up on the counter shelves, chef in his white apron working hard, gumball machine, and the Italian ice box full of Good Humor ice cream bars ... No bells and whistles but just the way we like it! Special thanks to Mikey who always hooks us up with the best recs and conversations! Will be going back there probably on a weekly basis.

We love going to Nicky's after boxing! Always freshly made slices!! The staff are all very nice and…read morewelcoming

Three Boys From Italy

(35 reviews)

This is my second trip and after the first trip and todays this was very necessary! This is a…read morepizzeria you can come to and the people remember you and show love. It's a small spot a few tables, tv's and coolers for drinks. It's feels like nostalgia in the best ways without feeling dingy. Ordered a Large pepperoni Pizza, beef patty and zeppoli's. The pizza has a great flavor that compliment by a little spice to the pepperoni. Each bite goes so well and the pizza bone aka crust, is great. Kind of crust you enjoy to eat vs tossing it aside. The beef patty was cooked right and the zeppolis slap! Price is right. Try this local spot out, 5/5 stars

Ordered a Stromboli and a mushroom pizza. The Stromboli was probably the worst thing I have ever…read moreeaten in my life.... I swear it was microwaved... the cheese had this rubbery oily taste and the meat tasted like plastic leather... no way this was heated up in the oven. Mushroom pizza was lackluster. Mushrooms were not fresh but canned, could smell it immediately, and taste verified it, and crust was just average. Cheese tasted cheap quality.. only redeeming aspect was that sauce was well seasoned and not sweet. I don't enjoy giving a bad review but the Stromboli wa just downright shameful.... It could not even be eaten... it was literally inedible and gave indigestion all night, and the pizza was not much better considering what the local competition offers. Prices are cheap, and people at counter were nice, but can't return for the food quality.

Valley Pizza

4.1

(37 reviews)

I am obsessed with their Chicken Marsala pizza and if you need a quick slice or lunch in the…read moreClarkstown area, this is the place to go. I've also enjoyed their rolls (spinach rolls, especially) and chicken parm.

I normally order the sausage and peppers slice. I usually order whatever pizza is available. I…read morethink the reviewer who said the onions and peppers were raw was because he ordered a regular slice and had them add it. Happened one time to me when they did not have any sausage and peppers available. I also get the pasta fagiola soup. Best pizza especially when u have them heat it up in oven. No flop.

Village Pizza

4.6

(33 reviews)

This was the first time we experienced Village Pizza and what a GREAT experience! From our first…read morephone call to the delivery to the taste of their DELICIOUS food... it was beyond our expectations! Dina, who answered our call, was delightful to speak with... James, who delivered the food was a gentleman! The experience was definitely a reflection on the pride of ownership! WE FOUND OUR NEW PIZZA RESTAURANT! We HIGHLY recommend Village Pizza!

Friday, 6/12/2026 at 12:11 PM, we ordered delivery from Village Pizza at 64 S Broadway in Nyack…read more The pizza itself was just average for us -- nothing special, and the crust was dry. Even when you're hungry, it didn't taste delicious. Later that night, we realized the order was missing the one Diet Coke can that we paid for. We were charged $1.80, even though the same soda at a grocery store might cost around 50 cents. I don't know what happened or where the mistake occurred -- whether the restaurant forgot to include the soda or the delivery person didn't bring it -- but the fact is I paid for it and didn't receive it. Today, Saturday 6/13/2026 at 12:27 PM, we called and spoke with Tattiana. She said she would talk to her boss and ask what to do. When I asked when she would call back, she said she didn't know. It shouldn't take a manager to fix a missing $1.80 soda. Any staff member should be able to resolve such a simple issue, but instead it was delayed and ignored. At 3:36 PM, I called again, and no one answered the phone. It felt like they didn't want to pick up because they were avoiding responsibility. I called twice, and I'm not going to keep chasing a can of soda. Until I posted this review, I still didn't receive any call back. This is not about the price -- it's about honesty and giving customers what they paid for. When I called, they could have simply said, "Please come pick it up." Instead, she only said, "I'm so sorry," without offering any solution. I don't like paying for something and not receiving it. As a business, they should be responsive and not ignore customers. Mistakes happen, but they should fix them. When I post this review on Google and Yelp, other customers will read it and take a lesson from this experience. Next time I order from any restaurant, I will check all items upon delivery instead of trusting the delivery person. I will not order from this place again.

Stella Luna

4.0

(34 reviews)