uber order some great Sicilian pizza from here it was crispy and thick…read more screwed my order up but still was good. alayws on point never disappointed

Went to the location Sunday 5/24/26 with a party of 10. Checked their website prior to confirm they…read morewould be open. Went to the location only to find they had decided to close for the day and hadn't remembered to update their website. Disappointing. With so many restaurants failures it is troubling to find another that doesn't seem to care about their business and customers.

Amazingly delicious food... Attentive wait staff and wait until you see all the State of the Art…read more Remodeling inside!!!!

Always a great dinner here. They take care of you. Food always on point. Portions are huge . Staff…read moreawesome. They give u garlic knots and they are dangerous. Huge lot.

The pizza is great and the staff is good. I have come here multiple times for a quick slice when…read morein the area. This last time I had decided to get a chicken parm in a wrap. I regret that decision. It's was dry with little cheese. I could only recommend the pizza I would not bother to order another entree. Here. The stars are strictly for the pizza and the customer service.

Just ordered some food from this establishment and have ordered quite frequently in the past from…read morethem. In fact, I was one of their first customers to order when they first opened (was over an hour late - didn't complain off course, since I have been in the business). Now mind you, this has nothing to do with $$ whatsoever, but just a comment on how businesses are run now a days with a lack of logic, decency or customer service. It's indicative of our current culture, which is sad to see. So, quick story - we have accumulated numerous "pizzas cards" that they distributed in the past (collect 12 / get a free pizza; btw, we have so many) etc.. etc... Called in an order, but was told they stopped doing that (which is fine, I get it). Again, not the $$ - its like $20.00. But just the culture of a haphazard way to run a business/organization. (BTW - This person has no idea how long we have been customers :)) And we see it throughout now. I would expect that from a Dominos/ Pizza Hut etc., not from a community establishment. But anyway, just wanted to get the off my chest. There are many other options for pizza, but customer service is so important. Take some advice from an old timer - you need to use common sense when dealing with customers :)

We went to Ella's Saturday night. I'd rate it as mediocre. We had a table in the middle of the…read morerestaurant, close to other tables on the sides, so we couldn't move our chairs. I had to glance directly at the setting sun. The manager came and said "the sun will set soon", but it didn't. Thankfully my husband moved his chair to the side and blocked the sun for me. We'd rather have waited for another table had we known of the sun. Our waitress never read us the specials, which we later heard at nearby tables. Our water had no lemon in it, while everyone around us had lemon. We enjoyed our appetizer of Zucchini chips, and the Tzadiki was fantastic. The dinner rolls were also nice. My husband ordered Fettuccine Alfredo, which he liked, but the portion was small, & he had no problem finishing all of it. I ordered Chicken Milanese. The Milanese wasn't crisp enough, so when they piled salad on top with Balsamic Vinaigrette, it got a little soggy, even though I immediately took the salad off. My chicken cutlet had a large cut halfway across it. Possibly it was cut to see if it was done, but don't they have a meat thermometer? Maybe they figured that with a salad on top, the large cut wouldn't be seen? I noticed it though. Worst for me though was the vegetable side dish. Instead of a healthy vegetable, I was given a mushy, over-cooked Cauliflower covered in Buffalo Hot Sauce and butter. I'm guessing that they had made Buffalo Cauliflower for an appetizer another day, and had some leftover, so they decided to use it as a vegetable side? Hey, if I wanted leftovers, I'd have eaten at home. The waitress who never read us the specials also never came by to ask if everything was okay. I'd like it if someone at Ella's realizes that good customers can recognize when things are not up to the usual high standards. We notice when leftovers are served as side dishes. We notice when entrees are cut into. We don't enjoy being given tables with sun glare. We used to enjoy Ella's, and we hope that this was just an off day.

I came back after a long time of not eating here, and I have to say that the food has reached the…read moregreat level that it used to be when I came many years ago. I don't know if they changed something, but it's much better now and I love it!

Hands down, THE BEST PIZZA and hero sandwiches in New City! Service is excellent with consistent…read morefriendliness and hospitality, both on the phone and in person, no matter lunch or dinner. The ambience is enhanced with a clean vibe, both restaurant and staff. A real treat to look forward to!

Cooking of food not Dealing with situation…read moreConsideration when called about problem Not resolved at

Have had Grandma pies & regular cheese pies from this pizzeria. Both are good. Any time I have been…read morethere, those working there have been friendly and helpful.

Pies were delicious. One of the best pizzas in Rockland. Everything was ready and on time for…read morepickup, and even helped me out to the car.

The quality of the food is declining. We've had hair in our pizza twice and the latest pie smells…read morestrange. Turns out that the wax paper they put in the pizza box smells like mildew, which transferred to the pizza.

Napolis is always a go-to for me especially since it's next to where I do swim practice so every…read moretime I finish up I always grab a bite from there.I always get the garlic knot slider in chicken parm. Everything is so good every time. Definitely one of my favorites!

I've had great pizza in the past at Calabria in Orangeburg. This review is based on my order…read moretonight in New City. My husband enjoyed his meatball parmesan hero (hence the 3 stars and not 0.) I thought the eggplant parm hero was disgusting. It was soft and mushy without flavor or color. I called to ask if it's normally not breaded because I know in the past I've enjoyed an eggplant entree. They stated they do not bread it and "understand" my disappointment. I couldn't finish my piece and threw out the rest. Stick with the pizza.

The pizza here is pretty good…read more The sausage pizza was rather disappointing and thrown together. The grandma pizza was tasty always a go to!