Food was amazing. You watch the staff make it and out it into the wood fire. Pizza is crispy very warm. The staff is so friendly. Everything was great. They make your pizza in front of you. I have never had a bad pizza here and have been many times. The food is very cheap too. Very underrated restaurant and the weekly specials are amazing. Best pizza restaurant in Albany GA. read more

In the are from out of state and looking for a place to eat. We found it on yelp decided to give it a try... it was really good. Personal pie are perfect size made to order and have a large selection to choose from read more

OMG when you walk in the smell is amazing. I am so excited. They have a wonderful array of options on the menus and you can even get a pizza kit to take home for current price 12.00. WOW. They also have specials on Wednesday that I see for wings. I'm sure they have others. Come check them out you will be crazy excited just like me. Yum yum yum.it is a must to try their chicken wings. You get the drumetes, and they look like chicken legs they are so big!!!!! read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - I ordered a whole pizza but I am painting so they served me a slice!!! Wow. what wonderful service! - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

This was our first time visiting. Me, my mom and my sister were looking for a good pizza and decided to give it a try. You walk in and the pizza maker is right there. They have a gluten free crust and a cauliflower crust but we got the traditional crust. They have several pizzas you can choose from or you can do it your own way which gives you up to 6 toppings and you can choose the sauce you want. (They have Traditional, a Spicy one, Alfredo, Garlic & Olive oil, Marina and a couple more but I can't remember what they are). They built it as go kind of like Subway. We chose our toppings and he made it and put it in the oven. We decided to split 2 Garden salads between the 3 of us. They have different salad choices too but the Green salad has Roma tomatoes, cucumbers, shaved carrots and romaine lettuce with a variety of dressings (but not Thousand Island). We chose the Italian. The salad was delicious and so was the dressing. We got drink glasses at the register when we paid. I got unsweetened tea and it tasted like fresh brewed. They have caddies with red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese bottles you can take to your table. Our pizza came out hot and was delivered to our table. It was delicious. We really enjoyed the crust too. We all plan to come back. The employees were very nice and helpful. read more

See all

Both pizzas were absolutely delicious. The day of and the leftovers. I always reheat my pizza in the oven. read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - My Uncle Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

See all

The food was subpar. I tried both the NY Roni and the San Gennaro with my wife and neither of us finished half of a personal pizza. The line to make the pizza was very disorganized. They were surprisingly busy for a Saturday lunch, but it seemed that it was more because they just could not get the line moving. The employees did not engage and interact with the customer. They just expected you to know what to say to them at all times at every "station." There was a glaring lack of coordination and this seemed to back up the line. It took well over 25 minutes to sit down and get the pizza. The NY Roni pizza was greasy and salty. Part of that may have been my fault. I did add a little parmesan to the pizza before trying it, but not very much. However, perhaps it did not need at all. I asked for some marinara sauce to dip the wheat crust into and it was just tomato sauce. No seasoning at all. The San Gennaro was all around just terrible. The peppers and onions were soggy. The sausage was bland. I have nothing positive to say about it at all. The ambiance reminds me of Your Pie. In fact, I'd go so far as to say they have just ripped that chain off. I'd probably give them another shot. Maybe they were just having an off day. I wish them the best. read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - San Gennaro - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

See all

I having been wanting to try this place and finally went. I went on a good night the regular style pizza was 3.14 a pie. I got just a plain cheese one and then I got a.pie my way for 10.00 drinks are 3.50 each. I got.a.cookie and the cinnamon knots. Yes I had 4 take home boxes! The flavor is there. The toppings are fresh and you have a lot to choose from! what I don't like is the crust. It is like a cracker crust to me. I like a thin crust to have a bite to it. Crunchy in the middle and chewy at the edges. Just not my type of crust. I would go back for the cookies!! Pizza..it was ok. . read more

See all

Great product and great variety , but they can't answer the phones and there are only two people running themselves into the ground trying to get the product out . If under new management , why aren't the owners out front doing what they're supposed to do . Felt sorry for the two workers . They would get 5 stars but the service issue reduces the score 2. read more

As good as it looks! Great service too. Friendly people and nice atmosphere. Looking at the picture makes me hungry! read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

My expectations were low but I was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was great as were the garlic knots. Not bad for the south!

This was our first experience with MyPie pizza and it was amazing! Upon entering the restaurant, we were happily greeted. They made sure to ask if it was our first time and happily explained how their restaurant worked. The food was amazing, full of flavor that you can tell it is made fresh. Even being busy, our pizza's came out quickly and hot. Our 3 year old loved the play dough that comes with the kids meal. The restaurant was clean and the employees were so friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back. read more

Phone is 100% busy 100% of the time. The pizza is good but nothing is worth the effort.

I don't get to eat pizza very often but I was starving. Wow! My new favorite pizza place is found! Great service! Wheat crust for the healthy patrons (me) and a great variety of toppings! Loved the garlic knots! We'll be back... as soon as work of the calories from this visit! read more

See all

I have fallen in love with this pizza place!! Yummy!!! The pesto sauce was killer!! The staff are friendly and helpful!! Good job guys!! read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

One of my favorite places to go! Love the pizza and the staff is always so nice and helpful. Very good customer service!

This was my first time visiting this location and everything was wonderful. Our pizzas and wings were delicious and hot. But the service is what made me come write this review. The lady that made our pizzas was so friendly & answered any questions we had. Our cashier & a diff. girl that brought out our order were very personable and kind as well. Great service is hard to find in Albany, but they made my family want to come back again and again! read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - Greek and Mr. White (added chicken) - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

Service is typical Albany service, but the food is great! I recommend the Alfredo sauce. It is the white sauce...very very good.

Make your own thin crust pizza! So delicious and crispy crust which I love, we enjoy going here often and have found the staff friendly and the place clean! read more

Expensive and very greasy food. Great substitute for Pepto Bismol if you catch my drift. read more

My Pie Pizza - Albany, GA - NY Roni Pie, garlic knots, and cheese pie. - Pizza Near Me - Albany, Georgia

This place is cool. We build our own and when we want more of the same ingredients they will pile them on!! 1 pizza and one drink are prefect for us !! read more

Excellent pizza. I really enjoyed the Angry Bird pizza. A great addition Albanys eateries.

Love the pizza at My Pie and so many choices, there is definitely something for everyone. Staff is super friendly and restaurant is very clean. read more

Delicious food.staff is super friendly and attentive. Got the Greek pizza and garlic parm wings with a kids pizza (which can feed two young kids easily). read more

Love the customer service and friendly workers. Clean environment! I love the angry bird!

Pizza was okay but they left out a lot of my order. We went back for the drink and dough that's was omitted... got down the road and realized they never gave us our $5 cookie we ordered. read more