I knew I wanted to take my husband to Willows Inn for his 40th but rooms there are over $360 a night so I decided to try to find alternate accommodations on the island, which I soon learned is REALLY small. I was lucky enough to find Nettles Farm, owned by Riley Starks (former owner of Willows Inn and the fellow who hired Chef Blaine Wetzel). He's an organic farmer and fisherman who sold Willows Inn to 10 other folks and now just runs Nettles Farm which supplies some of the veggies to Willows Inn. (Do some research and you'll find all the articles that chronicle the very interesting ups and downs of the businesses).
Nettles Farm is a B&B but you make your own breakfast with the goodies he stocks in the fridge for you. We got jars of ginger pears, peaches, farm fresh eggs, coffee he roasted himself, local yogurt, local bacon, and bread. It was such a treat.
A couple tips -- the only grocery store on this island had a bunch of frozen goods and some sad looking fruit and that's it. Bring enough of your own groceries (and booze) for the weekend.
Also, the farmhouse suite has a huge pizza oven so bring ingredients if you want to make a pizza, or do what we did. Get pizza for dinner Friday night at the Beach Store Cafe (run by the Willows Inn group) and heat up the leftovers in the oven for lunch the next day after a lovely 3.5 mile roundtrip hike up Bakers Preserve!
Riley is super friendly and helpful and invites you to tour his farm as long as you keep the gates shut so no animals escape. He has a couple friendly goats that will eat grass out of your hand, many chickens, and deer that come right up to the farmhouse for a visit. We also spotted 4 eagles and an owl.
Riley has a great book and (current) magazine collection if you're a foodie, cook, or gardener, and collection of art house films if you want to watch them on the little TV. There are 4 chairs on the deck out back for sitting, reading, and enjoying the complete absence of city noise. It's so quiet there.
The sheets and towels are luxurious (these things matter), the bed comfy, the room gets quite bright in the morning (bring your sleep mask if you want to sleep in), and the tub is deep for soaking. He even has a couple bathrobes for you. Very highly recommend staying at Nettles Farm, especially if you're dining at Willows Inn. Oh he'll even pick you up if you boat in (apparently our neighbor at the farm did that--cool!) read more