Love, love, loved it! I was just overall impressed with the assortment of vintage and how neatly…read moreand smartly organized everything was. A treasure trove, for sure! I left with a 90s vintage tee for $18. It might sound wild, but that's on the cheaper side for "vintage." I'd expect to pay $10 more for the same vintage shirt in Philly. Yes, even one from the 90s. The staff were also very helpful. I can't wait to go back when we're in Lancaster.

Absolutely loved this store and the owner! Extremely friendly and prices were very good compared to…read moreother vintage stores we've been to throughout the US. We will definitely be back just based on our interaction with the owner! Loved talking to her and we made sure to check out My Aunt Debbie down the street where she sells some of her vintage jeans.

if you're looking for an item, it's unusual and retro. This is the place to go. The two guys that…read moreown. It are awesome and they know their stuff.

this was a cool shop! i loved the vintage items. they also have artsy items like mini pyrex bowls…read more:). so cute! i just bought a sticker but they have so many nostalgic things. i wanna go back again!

1/12/25 I have never been in Fenstys until now. I really enjoyed meeting the owner he was very…read moreproud of his business that he has turned over to his son more or less. Since I hadn't been there he graciously told us the lay of the land. I really enjoyed looking through the market. As with any antique mall there are vendor booths that are well priced and then insanely expensive. There is a lot to see for sure. One main drawback is this is a "CASH ONLY" business. If you read my reviews you know I hate cash only businesses. Luckily I had plenty of cash- as it turns out I ended up not purchasing anything. I was tempted to purchase a few items but did not. I highly recommend visiting- I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area. They have a little snack stand and a nice. Lean restroom to make your shopping spree comfortable. I did not eat here but I thought that was great! I was tempted by the enormous Valentines cards for 1$- but there were no envelopes. There was a cute seasonal booth where everything was a dollar and some booths had decent sales.

Found unbelievable deal on a new guitar. Guy had a lot of used and a few new ones, great…read moreselection, great condition!! Sounds great! Found other good deals here too! Was there for a few hours but didn't feel like it

The owner was nice and explained how she runs her shop which was cool. There is street parking you…read morehave to pay for, we got a spot right in front of the store. There was a seller out front of the store also! A lot of vintage clothes and accessories at moderate prices.

Loved this place. Found some amazing pieces including a two-toned denim jacket that I often wear…read morewith different colored denim jeans, to create a Canadian tuxedo of many colors. I also had a great conversation with the owner, who is a cool ass chick. Go there. Buy some stuff.

Scott Mclimans is a really great business owner! He only Carrie's high end used furniture and…read moreantiques. We have visited several times as we have furnished our new home with many furnishings from Mclimans! Natuzzi Italian leather is a very high end leather and beautifully built sofas. We truly enjoy walking through Scott's huge place and spotting that special piece! Scott has educated us on various types of furniture, and we are continuing to learn and return!

We relocated and have been visiting numerous furniture resellers and auction houses to furnish and…read morefill-in what was left behind. Mcliman's is a fabulous shop in the area for selection, quality, and fair pricing. Owner Scott is by far one of the most knowledgeable sellers in the area, and just a really decent man to do business with.

This place is a delight! My family was traveling from Hershey Park back to Baltimore and we found…read moreit randomly. It's chocked full of nerdy treasures for all ages, from books to games, costumes and crocheted weapons, and game rooms to rent. The people are great, and the prices are reasonable.

What a delightfully cozy, warm, and fun place to browse. It is a winding collection of stalls with…read morethemed items that appealed to my Gen-X nostalgia as well as my love of artful oddities. I spent time with my son going through the books and games, staring at the googly-eyed Gollum sitting high on a shelf staring across the room at a steampunk glider. A creepy puppet hid in a small alcove around a dark corner near the gaming minis. Their War Room is creepy and delightful. I look forward to gaming there or refering it to the local coven for their new moon meetings. A colorful, smiling young person kept watch and helped guide folks looking for their own unique needful thing. In busy downtown, near the farmer's market, it was a welcome distraction with wands, swords, potions, sculpted pipes, candles, weird vibes and more. Definitely worth stopping in.

If local shopping is your thing, Building Character is a must-visit. Inside one giant building in…read moredowntown Lancaster, dozens and dozens of local businesses have stands inside selling all sorts of goodies- records, clothes, candles, books, toys, jewelry. They have it all! There's a restroom by the printing press.

So much fun! Tons of stuff to look at, including new and old. We spent an hour there!read more

Consigned a multitude of items, each month your check was suppose to be cut on the 22nd, it was…read morenever done on time. Waited 5 months at one point for a check and constant excuses why she couldn't write you a check.. computer was not working, no ink in printer, or she had to pay rent first. My print out of what I sold was constantly missing items and calculations of her' cut' were wrong. No wonder she can't keep consigners..

I got some rings a few months ago and they're amazing I love this store. I even scored a beautiful…read moredresser. The woman that works in there is so sweet and kind.