1/12/25 I have never been in Fenstys until now. I really enjoyed meeting the owner he was very proud of his business that he has turned over to his son more or less. Since I hadn't been there he graciously told us the lay of the land. I really enjoyed looking through the market. As with any antique mall there are vendor booths that are well priced and then insanely expensive. There is a lot to see for sure. One main drawback is this is a "CASH ONLY" business. If you read my reviews you know I hate cash only businesses. Luckily I had plenty of cash- as it turns out I ended up not purchasing anything. I was tempted to purchase a few items but did not. I highly recommend visiting- I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area. They have a little snack stand and a nice. Lean restroom to make your shopping spree comfortable. I did not eat here but I thought that was great! I was tempted by the enormous Valentines cards for 1$- but there were no envelopes. There was a cute seasonal booth where everything was a dollar and some booths had decent sales. read more

See all

Worth the trip, I find something everything I stop in when doing my fleamarket and antique run in the area read more

Fensty's Indoor Flea Market - Huge variety! Old and new stuff - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Bally, Pennsylvania

Found unbelievable deal on a new guitar. Guy had a lot of used and a few new ones, great selection, great condition!! Sounds great! Found other good deals here too! Was there for a few hours but didn't feel like it read more

As a comic book enthusiast, I stopped by Fensty's flea market in search of hidden gems, but unfortunately, my experience left much to be desired. The market boasts an impressive collection of long boxes in various areas stocked with books, initially giving me hope for finding some great comics. However, my excitement quickly waned as I delved into the selection. It became evident to me again that there are better places for comic hunting than this flea market (and flea markets in general). This selection of books seemed like they were plucked from random mystery packs and lacked any significant value. It was disheartening to find a complete absence of key issues or anything of actual worth. Moreover, the excessive duplicates of the same comic issues added to the disappointment. It felt like the inventory lacked careful curation and became a jumbled mess of low-quality and redundant comics. While Fensty's may not cater to comic collectors, I can see why it might appeal to other collectors, especially those interested in sports memorabilia, video games, movie posters, and signed items. For them, the store may hold some hidden treasures. On a positive note, the store's location is convenient, right off the main road, with ample parking available. The building is decently sized, not overwhelmingly big, making it easy to navigate. If you're specifically seeking comic books, I recommend exploring other options in the vicinity, such as two nearby flea markets, which I have yet to visit. (This one was the only one open on a Saturday afternoon.) While Fensty's may have some appeal for collectors of different interests, it falls short when it comes to satisfying the desires of passionate comic collectors like myself. Side note: there was an Incredible Hulk pinball machine there by the entrance. I thought it would have been a good omen seeing that when I first walked in. read more

Fensty's Indoor Flea Market - Incredible Hulk pinball machine by the entrance. - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Bally, Pennsylvania

There is so much to look at! And so much I want to buy. And I got a lot of great deals! They have carts and a bunch of registers at all the entrances. The staff are very helpful and chipper. The place was packed with customers all the way up to closing. They have a small restaurant inside and vintage bathrooms. It's in a vintage factory and the space is very eclectic. I will be making this spot a frequent stop since the rotation of items seems to be pretty frequent and displayed nicely. read more

Ok, where to begin? This place is huge! However, it has hardly any antiques, or anything old. When I say "old", I am not referring to items from 10 years ago! Nothing much form the 50's and earlier. There is a booth there that has metal advertising signs, as well as similar memorabilia, if that's what you collect. The place is filled with mostly newer made, garage sale merchandise. There are literally millions of record albums- again, if that's what you collect. Sadly, my brothers both collect military antiques and I collect pottery, which we didn't find any of. This place really has potential, just needs vendors with better merchandise. read more

You can find some random stuff here. As the saying goes, one man's trash is another man's treasure. They have a selection of miscellaneous tools, gadgets, collectibles, shirts etc. In the back, there is also a small food store. They make good cream of broccoli! read more

Fensty's Indoor Flea Market - Outside - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Bally, Pennsylvania

See all

Fensty's Flea Market was a really fun find ~ thanks to Yelp. From Philadelphia to Bally, Pennsylvania, the car ride was absolutely beautiful. Especially during Autumn. The building itself looked like a warehouse and it was quite surprising to see just how big it was inside ~ with plenty to look at from floor to ceiling. Halloween decor (plastic pumpkins, cauldrons, tattoos, trick or treat bags, dress up items, etc.), albums, 45's, vintage dishes, knick knacks, jewelry, cookware....too, too many interesting, cool objects to name everything here. And the prices ~ they ranged from reasonable to amazing! The shop owners made our experience all the more better ~ exceptionally friendly, we were greeted at each counter with a smile, a little history and a lot of warm, cordial conversation. So many things here gifted us with lovely memories from wonderful days gone by ~ and on a rainy, gray afternoon I couldn't think of a better way to spend some time. read more

See all

Definitely room for improvemnet. Most of the vendors sell used, newly made merchandise, some sell plain old junk. It is very rare to find true antiques or collectibles here and if you do, the next time you visit, that vendor is gone. The place is huge and has great potential, but needs better merchandise. Also, if you plan on going, don't go during the summer months. The place has NO air conditioning and is hot as a furnace! read more

Clean, organized flea market. Average offerings. Good for bad weather as it is all indoors and sometimes you just need to walk around in a market. No food and/or produce vendors. Not very exciting. read more

My husband and I researched this flea market online, and we were very excited to do some shopping. Upon arrival, we realized that there was no sign on the door indicating that face masks were required to enter. We opened the door, and sure enough, only about half of the customers inside were wearing face masks. We have been trying to follow safety precautions and expect places of business to do so as well. If we want to get back to normal as a community, we need everyone to follow guidlines set forth by the Department of Health. I am disappointed that the owners of this facility are negligent in doing their part to ensure the safety of their customers. read more

I love Fensty's Flea Market! I've been shopping there since they opened (I live locally in Bally). Lots of odd and cool stuff at affordable prices. I take pictures there almost every week. Not sure why someone left a negative review of 'Another Man's Treasure' on Fenstys...they share a building but are two SEPERATE BUSINESSES. I only had positive experiences at both places. Hint: having trouble finding something? Ask the vendors for help. If they don't have it, they might know who does. They have often helped me buy things I've been looking for. I will try to share photos if I can. read more

See all

Great place rain or shine. I always stop by to check out all the vendors. I see new things every week. I also love Smileys Too auction. If you can't find something new every weekend you must be blind I spoke to the manager and told him I was looking for a special item and with in a week he found it read more

See all

I have been a long time shopper at Fensty's and have always enjoyed my visits there. I hadn't visited in a long time due to health reasons and was looking forward to seeing what I could find. I was a bit surprised to see the sign on the door said masks are recommended for customers and if you aren't wearing one we politely assume you have a medical condition. I was surprised it didn't say masks required like the other antique places I've been to. Upon entering I noticed the owners and several dealers all maskless and at least six shoppers with no masks. I just had a portion of my lung removed from cancer and have a damaged esophagus from radiation from another bout with cancer and yet I have no trouble at all wearing masks. I'd love to know what medical condition all of these people suffer from that prevents them from caring for others health or their own. You've lost my business, I'm really bummed that as the owners and employees you chose to set this tone of disrespect for your fellow man. read more

Love this place for antique and flea market finds and something unusual. Great prices, and vendors are willing to negotiate. A little bit of flea market and consignment. There is a big parking lot, however, you can easily miss the entrance. Look for the sign out front. I've gotten some great stuff there, including wrought iron gates, cuckoo clocks, musical instruments, and memorabilia very inexpensively. I think this place is a hidden gem, and it does not have the usual junk you'd find at other flea markets. Well worth the trip to look around and find something old or useful. There are clean restrooms in there, too. The manager is super nice and usually around to ask about anything. read more

Really the only reason to go is to check out the Smiley's Too auction. Be cautious of the buyers fee + tax when you bid, but even with the fees, you can get a steal! All the other vendors try to pawn off the same junk from week to week, with little variation. Some have good deals, others are trying to pawn things off for retail at a flea market. Tread carefully. read more

Great place to shop! Many great vendors and excellent variety of items. If there is something you want or need you'll find it here for sure! read more

Awesome flea markets shops! Lots of great finds and the people there are so friendly. I go there regularly. They have everything from glass items to furniture. We always find something we want! read more

This place has a lot of variety and the prices are decent! I scored a really neat side table here. There's also an "extreme coupon" lady there who sells the deals she finds at low prices! Definitely worth stopping in. If you like it try MadHatter Antiques in Adamstown, it's run by the same people! Oh and don't forget to checkout Jake's! read more

After searching what feels like forever, I finally found that one piece I was looking for. Hidden Jem is an understatement. This is definately a stop that should be on the best kept secrets tour and the vendors and staff were very friendly and helpful. Will be back in next weekend to check on the auction items! read more

Awesome Flea Market - We always have a great time finding treasures and talking to all the vendors. There is much to see and we find new items each time. There is something for everyone from antiques to buttons. We always learn something new....... read more