I can't believe no one has reviewed Neiman's! It's everything you want a village candy shoppe (with an "e") to be! Hand dipped chocolates, fudge treats, and to top it all off homemade ice cream! Specifically the chocolate malt flavor, it is ridiculous. Neiman's is a well kept Tosa secret. It is very small, very local and 100% awesome. And if you go to Saturday mass at St Bernards (across the street) you can grab some ice cream on your way home. Church attendance + super ice cream goodness = heaven! read more

In case you have never had the pleasure of "sheer" goodness on your taste buds. I recommend all of the candies at Niemann's, plus the ice cream. All Holiday's have special candies to please each member of your family. Wonderful presents! My favorite candy is homemade toffee and ice cream "Chocolate Marshmallow". I have enjoy visiting the charming little store for 50 years, and the pleasure of knowing their family. Girl scouts and cub scouts have always been welcome in a group to "watch" candymaking. Jim, as his father and Grandfather have been wonderful participants in our City of Wauwatosa. Nothing better than coming after school, buying a scoop of ice cream and sitting outside the shop with friends !! Joan Riggin read more

For being open for so long, Niemann's should not be a hidden gem, but it is. With a small, unassuming store front, you'd never guess such delicious, decently priced goodness is behind its doors. My friend and I stumbled upon this place walking to downtown Tosa, and we were blown away! The ice cream was delicious, and I cannot wait to try their chocolates and other sweets. I'm coming back. read more

One of those great little places that aren't easily discovered except through word of mouth. My 98 year-old aunt told us that her husband always bought her candy from Niemann's for her birthday, and since Christmas was coming-- well, you get the idea. Almond-dusted English toffee made her day! And we couldn't leave without buying some ice cream and some other items for ourselves. Great place to buy a gift for somone if you're laying off chocolate for a while (grins) and a nice tip to pass on to others-- now that you know how to find the place. Old Tosa is where it's at! read more

My husband and I have lived in Wauwatosa for over twenty five years and have shopped at Niemann's over the years for their toffee and had great memories of the quality and good service. We went there today to send some toffee out of town and were treated very rudely. There was no signage saying products were limited to two bags per customer, due to a chocolate shortage and low stock, but that is what the clerk said. There wasn't any effort to explain or apologize by anyone working there and we were the only customers. We were reluctantly allowed four quarter ounce bags eventually, however it left us feeling our business wasn't in the least important to them. We continued our candy shopping at Confections on 68th & Wells and the experience was like night and day. The shelves were overflowing with great selections and the customer service was exceptional. We will never return to Niemann's read more

This is a Tosa gem that most people have never heard of. Having grown up down the street from it, my grandmother, brother and I were regulars. They have delicious chocolate and nuts. White, milk, dark, cashews, pecans, covering pretzels, Oreo, marshmallows, graham crackers...hungry yet? You can purchase individual pieces or boxes. If you are planning of giving them as Christmas gifts be sure to pre-order as they literally run out of candy. The ice cream is amazing!! I'm a Yo Mama fan, but sometimes I want the creamy decadence of real ice cream and this is the place to go. Not the flavor selection of Yo Mama or Baskin Robbins but high quality that you won't regret (until you go to the gym the next day). read more

Cute little independent chocolate shop with delicious ice cream! The store is a bit small for a big group to eat in there, so as long as the weather is nice, you can enjoy your ice cream outside. I tried the chocolate peanut butter kind and it was some of the best chocolate peanut butter ice cream that I've had! I can understand people going to Yo Mama if they're into frozen yogurt, but if you're the Baskin Robbin's type, you should definitely do a detour across the street and check this place out. Seriously tasty ice cream! Next time I have a gift to give, I'll consider buying some of their specialty- the chocolate! read more

This is one of the best in the Milwaukee area! I have been coming here since I was a child and it has never disappointed me! From the homemade toffee to the specialty candies for each holiday season. What would a holiday be without them? I love shopping for special little treats for just that right extra special gift for friends and family whether it is is for Easter, Christmas or even St. Patrick's day! It is a must buy if you have wanted that personal touch and handmade chocolate taste. read more

A nice mom-and-pop shop serving the Wauwatosa and Greater Milwaukee community's chocolate needs for many years. The level of the chocolate is at Godiva's and other specialty chocolate shop's level. read more

Great little local candy and ice cream shop. What's better than homemade ice cream and candy? Not too much. Always friendly service. Located in the village across from St Bernard's parish. They are remodeling the space next door for an Anodyne Coffee shop. Another reason to stop here for dessert. read more

We had the best experience here last night. I do t think enough people in Wauwatosa know about it. Fantastic ice cream and chocolates. We had malted milk balls. The best part was this young woman Grace that helped us! She was incredible. Great service and so kind to our little kiddos. We'll definitely be back! Everyone should go here! read more

If you are looking for hand made candies this is the place without a doubt. The chocaltes are excellent, but the best of all is the hand made ice cream. Skip all the other places for ice cream you need to stop in and get any of flavor with a hand made waffle you will not be disappointed. Hidden gem in the Tosa village. read more

A piece of East Tosa history. Not much has changed over the decades. Always glad to see these types of places still in operation. Good selection of candies with emphasis on chocolate and surprisingly ice cream which is kind of a little known item. A decent place to stop if in the Village for some reason. Unfortunately hours limited for those coming in evening which is not unusual for these types of places. If open later would definitely go more regularly since I live in area read more

This place is great! I haven't had their candy, but the homemade ice cream is delicious! If you live in Tosa or if you're ever around, you have check this place out! I could see myself becoming a regular very soon! read more

When I was going to Tosa High back in the 50's, it was a special treat to walk to Niemann's on our lunch hour for a piece of their delicious toffee and a chocolate marshmallow ice cream cone. Imagine my surprise and delight when my sister who still lives in the area sent me a box of Niemann's delicious chocolates and toffee for my birthday.. The only thing that would have topped my pleasure would have been one of those delicious ice cream cones. I'll have to get one on my next trip back home. Mary Conlon Hammond Mobile Alabama read more

I walked into this place on a whim today and I love it! I met the owner who gave me the lowdown on the neighborhood I've just moved into while letting me sample some of his amazing candy and ice cream. He was friendly and willing to talk about his family owned business which has been around for 3 generations. The ice cream is amazing (I got the chocolate cranberry which has delicious silky chocolate and dried cranberries), but the candy blew me away even more (I walked away with some chocolate covered orange peel and ginger, plus got to try some fairy dust courtesy of Mr. Niemann). Prices are more than reasonable and the quality is wonderful. I'll be back for the delicious treats and more conversation with Jim. read more

I go out of my way to eat ice cream handmade by Niemanns! I mean come on! They make their own marshmallow for their delicious Chocolate Marshmallow Ice Cream!! Why go to a "chain" ice cream or yogurt store when you can enjoy and support an old fashioned, charming, respectable family business like Niemanns read more