They only have 1 actual flavor of soft serve. The rest of the flavors are syrups the put in the vanilla ice cream. If you don't read the menu outside or the tiny one in the front of the store before you order the red haired gentlemen will be very rude to you. They messed up my friend's order and the cashier was rude to the other worker about it and then was mean about it to my friend. The soft serve wasn't bad but it's too expensive for the staff to be mean! read more

Old Man's Cave General Store - Grocery Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Perfect place to stop for soft serve after a hike. I got blueberry which is amazing. Was a bit of a wait as lots of people stop here read more

Old Man's Cave General Store - Grocery Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Fun little stop! They have tons of flavors of soft serve (amaretto, cinnamon, egg nog, strawberry, etc!) and a lot of the little odds and ends you might need. There's a line sometimes but the middle of a weekday we walked right in and ordered. Old school vibes. read more

Unfortunately, the staff is not friendly and makes you feel like an inconvenience for ordering. Small store that makes it difficult to wait inside for your ice cream. Great selection of flavors but wouldn't go back due to the uncomfy environment. read more

Very poor hygiene grabbed the money and then didnt wash hands served us the ice cream didnt clean it out tasted like the previou flavors and was super expensive read more

Not customer oriented and the staff and most of all the cashier was very monotone, robotic, and came off as rude and standoffish. Seems like staff interpersonal skills and being customer oriented is a problem based on reviews. Purchased soft serve ice cream that was ok. Business has many photos of rules to follow such as the one I attached to this review. Will not go back. read more

Old Man's Cave General Store - Store rule - Grocery Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Just like some of the other stores in town. Pretty basic with necessities. They also have ice cream. It's soft serve that they pump a flavor into and then it is now that flavor. read more

Old Man's Cave General Store - 24 flavors of soft serve - Grocery Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

The whole vibe makes you feel like you're an inconvenience. One staff member was so insanely rude to the point that he openly insulted my sister to another customer because she didn't know where the napkins were. The ice-cream is expensive and flavorless. read more

The sign outside with the bright pics of ice cream makes this place look amazing!! And then when you read the flavors.......oh man; you're in for a treat! But the ice cream was just "ok" not a ton of flavor. But hey, there's not much in the area as far as a cold treat goes so I'm sure they rake in the biz. I'm sure that's the point of this place. It's also a small mart if you're camping close by and need a few things. This is a pretty generic review because there isn't much to say. Next time I'll go for the pistachio:) read more

The food there was of the ice cream just too many flavors. absolutely so many good things about this place. I wouldn't even have enough space but the customer service just amazing. read more

One of the best exotic and convenient ice cream spots in the Hocking Forest region. Pitch a tent, set up the stove, relax... then set up the entire campsite again 10 feet away when the officer informs you you're in the wrong spot, one over. After that and a runaway dog at Old Man's Cave later, stick those muddy shoes in a bag and get a lick of this! Ohio. Hocking Hills, Ohio. Find it here. Wish they gave samples. Bonus points for ice cream scoopers singing songs as they serve. I'd like to request "Genesis" by $uicideBoy$ next. read more

The young guy with the dark beard was a total jerk. He was so annoyed by us. My husband ordered a flurry and wanted both peanut butter cup and butterfinger. He was quick to bark at us " 1 flavor!" We ordered a carmel shake and a small chocolate cone. The vanilla in the flurry was light green? The chocolate cone tasted like carmel the feral cats were the only enjoyable part of our experience. ​ read more

Ice cream is OK... just softserve with a flavored syrup that makes the ice cream melt faster... There's a sign on the front door that basically says, you don't have to wear a mask if you don't want to and specifically states that they're not responsible for your health and wellbeing while on their property, but they strictly stick to a capacity limit of six people inside at a time... I vehemently disagree with their statement about public health responsibility. During a public health crisis, we should all be working together to ensure that we're not putting anyone at risk. Oh yeah, NONE of the employees wore masks. Go to another store. read more

First and last stop on our way to Hocking Hills and I was not disappointed after hiking all morning and day to have custom flavored soft serve for the family!! Super cheap too! My sis had the german chocolate, which she described as a light chocolate flavor and enjoyed. My mom had coconut, which she devoured. I had a pineapple coconut swirl which revived me after all that hiking! read more

Small store but quick, friendly service and awesome ice cream flavors. Over 20 to choose from!

Do. Not. Bother. Going. Here. There are (literally) over FIFTEEN signs at the front door telling you what you can and cannot do. One of them says they sell over 24 flavors of ice cream n you MUST know your order prior to entering. Upon entering I went they FOUR flavors as they out of everything. She showed me a list of everything they're out of- it's longer than the list of what they offers. Btw, the list was an aged list ie It appeared to be common they were out of most flavors on a daily basis. I ended up with vanilla and asked for some toppings. They are literally out of every topping but sprinkles. Could not be more disappointed. On a positive note, the staff was very very nice. Won't waste my time again to go back. read more

Tried to order a pizza at 5:45 and the place closed at 7. The two girls working told us there wasn't enough time to make a pizza before they closed. That's ok though. We ended up at Pizza Crossing and that was amazing. read more

The chubby bearded boy at checkout needs to find another line of work, something without interpersonal communication. I can handle general rudeness, but he was a special flavor of jerk-off. As the other 1-star reviews expressed, he came across as completely inconvenienced by customers, and annoyed at having to tell them their requested ice cream flavor is out and having to wait while they pick an alternative. He seemed especially irked at having to show me the difference in cup sizes, then when my order came out in a cone instead of a cup, he claimed I didn't tell him cup. Did he think I was just taking a poll on ice cream cup sizes? Does "small cup" mean something different here? Ridiculous boy. Ice cream was alright. read more

Spent Friday and Saturday here. Everything was great. Food, ice cream and ALOT of great beer choices. Craft and core alike. Everyone was laughing and was nice to see. Good stop. read more

DO NOT EVEN BOTHER GOING HERE the ice cream was horrible pretty sure the milk was expired the service was also horrible. The guy at the counter was a complete jerk didn't even care. HORRIBLE. read more

Great bunch of staff! Very Friendly, and overall wonderful! Selection of items available is plentiful, considering the "out in the sticks" location. The store has a rustic small-town feel! AGAIN, wonderful and friendly staff! read more

The German chocolate cake is probably the best soft serve I've ever had! Highly recommend

I want back and forth on what star rating to give, and decided to average it between the two elements we experienced. First the good: the soft serve. This is a 4, maybe 5 star experience in soft serve. It was excellent and they have a crazy flavor selection. Now the bad: got a pizza after a long day of hiking, and it was not good. The toppings were average, but the crust was bad. Too soft in the middle and flavorless and chalky on the edges. This place would gain a star if the just got rid of the pizza so you couldn't make that mistake. Other reviewers have said the deli is good, and I do plan on trying that in the future, because I will definitely be back for the ice cream. Overall impression: definitely stop here for the soft serve. Pack a lunch so you can skip the pizza. read more

Went into this store before the park. Went to use the out prior to going in. Believe it or not but the tank was almost full to the top. Can you believe that a business owner would not empty his outhouse prior to the weekend ans put his/ hers customers in this position. The four of turned around and left. I figure if that's their way of doing business I won't spend a dime there. DISGUSTING should be ashamed of yourselves read more

DO NOT GO HERE!! Not only do they offer bare minimum groceries or items, the service is TERRIBLE, the layout is AWFUL, the employees are GRUMPY and lack all knowledge, higher level thinking or ability to solve problems. Additionally, management is not accommodating in any way and just flat out RUDE! If you want pizza or ice cream, drive just down the road to Captain Ron's- kind, accommodating and yummy! Do yourself a favor and skip this place altogether! read more

Stopped by about 15 mins before closing (close at 9pm on saturday, when it's still daylight in the summer?) to get ice cream that they are heavily advertising only to be told they stopped making ice cream-which is just a soft serve machine with flavored syrups. What kind of business is that where you stop selling your prime item before you close? Just close early! So disappointing. read more

I hit this place mid-day after a long hike. The numerous flavors were posted outside for easy access, and i have to say the ice-cream was AMAZING. the flavor you chose actually tasted like it should. my german chocolate cake shake had hints of coconut and nuts in a smooth chocolate. my dad loved his butterscotch and blackberry. i 100% recommend this place!!!! read more

Great place to get an ice cream if you are staying at the state park! Plenty of parking if you need to pull in with your RV.

Amazing ice cream! Horrible customer service. I never write reviews but this is the 2nd time I've had the bigger young man at the counter cashing people out be as rude as he was. Won't be in again for another year after this last encounter. What a jerk! read more

Honestly, it's horrible. I can't even believe it's so busy. Probably because there's really not a lot of other options around. The ice cream is super disappointing, and all of the "flavors" are vanilla based made with squirting flavored syrups.. but still taste like vanilla ice cream. So if Vanilla ice cream is your jam, this will probably be your favorite place. I took one bite of my "butter pecan" and threw it in the trash when I realized it was basically just vanilla ice cream. Save your money. read more

Place advantageously near Old Man's Cave, Conkel's Hollow, Rock House and other hiking and tourism favorites, Old Man's Cave General Store services the visitors very well. Sure, you get clipped a little bit for their convenient location. But you are, after all, out for a day in beautiful Hocking Hills. The price is right because location, location, location. Two things I thought were great. First, management makes fresh sandwiches every morning. I got there early one morning and the sandwich shop was busy. Roast beef and swiss, turkey and swiss, ham and cheese, and other sandwiches were all being wrapped and placed in the front-view coolers. And they're cutting meat fresh. Nice! Then there is the ice-cream offer: 24-flavors of creamy whip ice cream cones. Boo yeah! There's nothing like a tall curly top chocolate or vanilla or pumpkin ice cream cone after a long hike. Another nice twist: outdoor seating. You can use picnic tables and 2-top and 4-top tables on the store's veranda to rest up before leaving Hocking Hills or heading back to a cabin rental following restocking of goods. IMPORTANT: This is not a bathroom stop. Lastly, the bag ice is small bag. No large bags so if you're going for big cooler fill-ups, you'll pay a bit more. read more

If you like dusty boxes of cereal, Vienna sausages, and over priced water, this is your place! While camping at Hocking Hills State Park, we needed to pick up some more water. I wasn't very impressed with overall cleanliness, but the real shock was at the register. $13 for a case of water!! Indignant millennials running the place couldn't care less. Steer clear. read more

Don't bother. The kids working there are some of the most disrespectful and rude people I've run across. There are signs all over the store about how you need to order, where you need to stand and so on. It's similar to the soup Nazi episode on Seinfeld. Maybe you should rearrange the store a little so there isn't a 2ft space for everyone to check out and order ice-cream. I highly recommend Grandma Fayes as an alternative. Everyone there was very friendly and polite. read more

The best ice cream around. It's so simple, but so tasty. Choose from a lot of flavors, but make sure to look at the options outside because they don't have them on the inside! Trickery. Still an awesome place to stop after going to old mans cave. read more

Stopped 40 minutes before close to get milkshakes and they said ice cream part of the store was closed even through sign on door said that part closed half hour before close will never do business again there read more

We were drawn in by the signs claiming 20-30 flavors of soft serve. We were disappointed to find that this wide range of offerings was accomplished by mixing in flavored syrups to vanilla soft serve. The mixing process actually breaks down the soft serve causing it to melt very fast. Need to consume quickly if you don't want a melted mess. Also, it was concerning to see the cashier touch money and then cones, especially during a pandemic. read more

Kids enjoyed the ice cream and the parents enjoyed the selection of carry out local brews. Basic store for essentials if you are camping. With current Covid precautions, only six people are allowed at a time. Didn't love being yelled at when we walked in... maybe have someone at the door monitoring capacity instead of yelling at customers... you can't see inside the store from outside so there's no way to know. Felt a little attacked but let it go. read more

I struggled writing this review. Let me start by saying that the ice cream is amazing. The 1 star review is because of the horrible service that we received during multiple visits. Whoever owns this business needs to whoop the children that work there. Be aware that the ice cream closes 30 minutes prior to the posted closing time. We were in line before the 30 minute mark, along with six other people who were in front of us. The workers announced at the 30 minute mark that "the ice cream machines have been turned off." I don't understand how a business can just stop serving while they have a line of customers...? I'm assuming that if the machines aren't shutoff at exactly 30 minutes prior to closing they must burst into flames. Again, where are the adults?! Then, on two separate occasions the boy, that appears to be a more senior employee, talked to the female employees like they were absolute garbage. Again, where are the adults?! Totally inappropriate for the boy to be talking to the female employees as disrespectfully as he was in front of a store full of customers. He's lucky that wasn't my daughter. My 11 year old daughter even noticed and asked why he was being so mean to that girl. I would love for the owner of this business to contact me. I could definitely give them an earful on how their business is being ran in their absence. If the ice cream wasn't as good as it is I would have walked out the first time. Maybe I'll tell him about himself on our last day here. read more

Horrible doesn't service ice cream the last 45 minutes they are open went in after picking our flavor outside at 732 pm there were 3 other people doing the same thing said they shut down their ice cream machine 1/2 hour before closing which makes no sense anyways lost at least 100 bucks since I walked out and told the other people the same thing we all left read more

After many hot, sweaty hours of hiking, we just wanted ice cream, and this was the first place we came across. Holy moly! $3 for an huge cone and whatever custom flavor you want? Sign me up. I had espresso with sprinkles, my sister had german chocolate cake and red velvet, both were delicious. read more