This is a wonderful dining experience EVERY TIME we go. Mario serves up some fantastic spaghetti and meatballs. His "OIP Special Stromboli " is a real treat and is our personal favorite. His subs, on his homemade bread, are mouthwatering delights. Service is always great because it's a family owned/operated restaurant. read more

The cashier/server was very friendly. The food was hot and delicious! Pricing was reasonable. Definitely will be back to patronize this establishment in the future read more

The food is very overpriced for what you get. The couple times we've ordered from here, the food was either bland or soaking wet with extra oil. Very friendly staff though everytime I've talked to them. read more

Amazing. Let me tell you why. First off I've lived in Italy, two years. The owner being from Italy makes the food that much better. True Italian food! It's fresh, made to order and comes out pumping with flavor and heat. The price you pay for Olive Garden crap mass produced food is a waist!!! Why are you not coming here for not only the quality but to also get your money's worth?. Highly recommend this OIP over any Italian place aroun read more

Original Italian Pizza - Chicken Marsala (so flavorful) - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

The service was quite good. The bread and house dressing were delicious. The entrees were smothered in way too much mozzarella; I just about choked. The sauce tasted like tomato sauce with no spices added, so really bland. I would not go back again. read more

OIPs (Original Italian Pizza) are common throughout central PA. What is special about this one? First, the sauce. There are several options for pizza in Milton. If the sauce on the pie is important, this place has the best. The flavor is sweet with a subtle zing; not overly sweet. Then, the bread. OIPs make their bread on site. The bread is hearty and shaped like a flattened football. When the sandwich is made on the fresh, still warm bread, mmm ..mmm. Can't be beat, even by that place that Jared likes do much. Most important, the reason this place stands above other local pizza places, is the owner - Mario. In fact, I call the OIP "Mario's". He is there almost everyday. He knows his regulars. He takes care of you. If I forget to say "no hot peppers" he knows to not put them on anyway, because he knows me as more than just another customer. And this is true for everyone who orders regularly. If you are not a regular, the service is still fantastic. Prices have gone up over the past year. Most sandwiches come in over the five dollar mark. Some might balk at the price, but it is comparable to other sandwich shops in the area who spread the same amount of meat across 12 inches. The pies (pizzas) are more expensive then the national chains, but they are also larger and taste much better. My first pick for pizza when I am home (Milton) will always be the OIP. read more

Original Italian Pizza - Exterior - Mario's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

See all

Called in a pizza for pickup as a backup plan. We ordered a "supreme" which they said was the OIP classic and listed off all the ingredients to see if that's what we wanted. Went to pick-up the pizza and the employees were too busy talking to each other to say more then the order total to us. Got the pizza home and it was COVERED in mushrooms, something they did not list when we ordered the pizza. The pizza was also very soggy. Will not be ordering from here again. read more

My aunt just ordered food to be delivered. When it was delivered, she paid for it and handed back the receipt. While she was reaching into her pocket for change to tip her, the driver rips the receipt into pieces, throws it on the floor, and says, "That's for not giving me a tip." Storms out. My aunt calls the restaurant to speak to the manager and who picks up but the driver. While she's handing the phone over to the manager, she tells him "I think it's the church." My aunt tells him what happened and he says, "Well all you had to do was tell her you had her tip." Incredibly unprofessional. Incredibly rude. They've lost an entire business as a customer. read more

Too bad these people feel that SKIMPING on most everything that goes into making a sandwich is good for their business! Sad that their sandwiches are only a shadow of what they once were. Stupid business practice. read more

The food is good and restaurant is clean. If thats all your looking for, this is the place for you because your coustomer service expierence will lack. I refuse to patronize an establishment who puts someone on phones who has no etiquette. We have delt with her rudeness thus far because the food is good however, at the rate at which our orders are wrong and after our experience today we are offically done with the place. After enduring the rude person on the phone and having to pick up our own order because they don't start delivering until 4pm, half of our order was left on the shelf and the other half was wrong. When my husband reentered the establishment to retrieve the rest of our $40 order, instead of being met with a smile and a sorry for the mistake he was met with a waitress who didn't leave her seat but instead rolled her eyes at him. We spend a lot of money here and are always pleasant (think 3 $40/$50 orders a week). There is no excuse for being rude to coustomers who are not rude to you. We will take our business to an establishment who respects and appreciates their coustomers. read more

I've been a loyal customer for years their food is Great but this will be my last order. The lady who sounds like she smokes 2 packs a day takes the cake. She is so rude every time I call well today she just hung up on me with saying bye or anything so I'm not picking it up. I can't believe she is allowed to work the phones. read more

Most times their delivery orders are spot on but some times they are not so great especially when the lady with the cigarette voice takes the call-in order answers the phone then the orders are messed up. On occasion she messes up the order and we don't get what we ordered. High-co-dis for the delivery guy, he does a great job, I don't know his name but he is awesome. Food is always good but can't say much about the that one lady who takes the orders over the phone. read more

Wings not bad. Just hot sauce. Not special. Pizza kinda bland. Hardly any sauce. Not great for $15. Extra .75 for Ken's blue cheese and .50 for a refill on a 1.99 drink! Not a good value! In NC wouldn't make it. Overall, disappointed! I guess there isn't a lot of competition! I think Domino's is better. Want to buy local but not when it's fair to poor. Service was good. read more

Original Italian Pizza - View from my table. Ordered wings and pizza. We'll see! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

DO NOT ORDER THE PARTY PIZZA. It was UNCOOKED in the middle and BURNT on the edges. I called the restaurant to get my money back and the owner refused. He said he could not give me my money back because he is not a franchise. How does that even make sense? He also said he did not believe me that it was uncooked and said I would have had to bring it back in so that he could inspect it. I ORDERED CARRY-OUT FOR A REASON! How was I supposed to get it back in without a car? I told him he could have come back to the house and he just kept droning on and on about bringing it back in. He obviously did not understand my clear voice when I said, "I do not want another pizza because this one took an hour to get here, I would like my money back." Whatever happened to good customer service? I really would have liked to have tried their other pizza when I visit Milton next time because I have heard good things. However, after a very rude and potentially sickening first-time experience with this restaurant, I will never venture back. I'd rather just order from Domino's, because at least I know the pizza will be cooked. All I can say is thank goodness my friends and I did not get sick. Feel free to try your luck :) read more

Their pizza matches the surrounding neighborhood of Milton, dirty and depressing. Ordered a white pizza and received a pizza overflowing with Alfredo sauce topped with a bag of frozen broccoli. I threw it in the trash. read more

I've been here many times and never had any issues. The main waitress, an elderly lady makes me laugh with her personality. The food is always great and I feel as if I can always count on having a delicious meal anytime I stop in or order out. Milton needs more great places to eat like this and less places like the sickening Chinese restaurant next to it. read more

The pita cheese steak was fabulous, and our food was done very quickly. Definitely will come again.

Wandered in by accident because the cafe next door only serves beer and bags of chips.. The place was clean from what I saw. No paper menus so I was standing there staring at the front of the counter and was told that it's on top of the counter too. Thankfully no one else was at the counter or a line.. Found it strange that toppings on a sub that aren't listed are $.50 extra. This means if you get the OIP steak and cheese, you pay extra for lettuce, tomato, mayo. I specifically asked because I'd never seen that before unless you get bacon or another premium topping. The wings come in quantities of 10 or 50 so you either order something else or have 20 leftover. My waitress was really nice, brought tons of napkins because I bought wings. Ordered 10 wings, sauce was the same thing you get anywhere that's not a chain. They were more dry than I like and generally I prefer them on the dry side. Ordered the steak and cheese with lettuce, tomato and mayo. Left the oil off. It was piping hot, the bread was amazing. Top 3 on my list of subs. Waitress brought the bill without asking me if I wanted anything else, which is a pet peeve of mine. I asked about dessert and was told that they had cannoli. Asked what it was and got an underwhelming explanation; ordered it anyway. Ordered the cannoli and they didn't have any in the refrigerator out front. Waitress asked a guy behind the counter because "he wants one" (didn't enjoy being called out for actually ordering food) and the guy behind the counter seemed miffed about having to get one out of the back. It was good, I would order again. Knowing what I know now, when I come back to town, I'll get delivery, order 2 subs, the cannoli and spare myself the time in the restaurant.. read more

My husband and I lived in Milton for almost a year right next to the OIP. We loved it. We tried many pizza places in and around Milton and Lewisburg, PA and this place was by far our favorite. Too be honest, it's still our favorite and we moved to Danville. The pizza just tasted delicious every time and I love that they serve pierogies now. The staff is also friendly and there are a few Italians even :) The OIP in Danville just isn't the same. We occasionally drive to this one just because it's the best in our minds. read more

Service with a smile. Food tasted home cook just like momma use to make, not my momma but the Italian kid's momma who lived down the block. Man could she cook. I think that's why I loved hanging out at their house so much. read more

I received their menu by mail. I loved their spaghetti in tomato sauce before. Best I had ever had. I called to order it. I hadn't had it in so long because I moved out of the area. I'm back and immediately craved it. It's still on the new menu. Called, asked for it and the lady shot me down and said we make no spaghetti without meat sauce. None. Don't mail menus out that reflects the opposite. read more

Good hoagies and subs , in store bread is excellent and makes a great bun for a meatball on cheese steak, pizza is ok and dinners are good , the bread is the bomb though so try a sub. read more

Made an order for delivery. The guy on the phone acted like he didn't know what a pepperoni pizza was. Then said the delivery guy would have to call back because he didn't know the street we lived on when we had deliveries from here before. 2 hours later our food arrives barely warm and the fries were a soggy mess. I would recommend you take the time and go to the Allenwood one instead or go to Pizzatown if you need in town delivery! read more

Took an hour and a half to receive food. Lady on the phone was not very friendly and the driver asked me for a tip. Food was good but service was poor. read more

We have gone here for years, and recently the last few orders have been messed up. At first we thought it happens and never called to get our orders fixed. Today, we ordered 9 hoagies, called the order in almost 6 hours ahead of time, thinking it would help them out. We picked our order up, and when we got home for the party we realized we were missing a hoagie. When we called in, we could hear the guy in the background yelling that he gave us all our food which wasn't true. He refused to talk to me, instead making his other staff relay the message while he yelled in the background. It's really sad, but they've lost our business along with a few others, due to their ignorance. If they wouldn't have been rude on the phone, apologized and offered to fix it... We would probably go back. But instead we will go to Marlins, la casa, or even better Amador. At least there we know we will get better customer service. read more

My family and I were staying in the area and were looking for a pizza place that delivered instead of the usual chain restaurants. OIP was recommended to us so we figured we'd give it a try. I called in our order and was incredibly shocked at how unprofessional the woman was who answered and proceeded to take my order. I ordered a chicken finger dinner with buffalo sauce on the side, a large cheese pizza and three extra crispy slices of pepperoni pizza. You would have thought I had asked for something more complicated. The woman asked me what I meant by buffalo sauce and that they had hot sauce. I asked what sauce they use on their buffalo chicken pizza (buffalo sauce and, say, a tobasco hot sauce are very different) and she said she didn't know (what?!!). The cheese pizza was easy, no issues there. Then I asked what size the individual slices were. She was, again, rude and said, "I don't know". I ordered three anyway and asked them to be extra crispy. She told me they couldn't do that. Unfortunately, one of my kids only likes extra crispy pizza, and didn't need a whole pizza, so I politely cancelled the order to which she responded, "YOU'RE A WIERDO!" and hung up. Classy. read more