Delicious food, good service. Friendly people wait on you. The hoagie are especially good and large like I appreciate them. Would recommend Vennari's Pizza ! read more

Horrible. Bought 3 pizzas and every single one was burnt!! Unbelievable. This used to be my favorite pizza. I haven't had a good pie in probably 5 years. Paid extra for the deluxe crust that I can't even chew! What happened?? read more

Decided to give this place a try because my brother delivers for them and I'd never tried it. 10/10. The garlic knots were nice and hot, the perfect size, and the sauce was perfect. The pepperoni pizza came out piping hot and was nice and cheesy (how I like it). Really good flavor. The lady working the front was super nice and the service was very quick. read more

Vennari's Pizza - Garlic Knots with Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

What can I say some of the best Pepperoni Pizza around A++++ also price is very fair some of the time it takes a little longer to be served but worth the wait nice little area to eat also has a bigger dining area with ac for the hot days cozy for those hot days also reminds you of a old time pizza place read more

Vennari's Pizza - Cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

Food was good and priced accordingly, if in the area I will order again. Had a pizza and salad

Got the deluxe pizza It was soggy and Doughy It takes a lot for me to not eat a pizza read more

Vennari's Pizza - Deluxe pizza Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

Payed and walked out without taking food. So grossed out by the young guy making the pizza with no gloves on and talking on his dirty cell phone. read more

The pizza is definitely frozen and then cooked again. It's cheesy but way too greasy and doesn't hold up in your mouth. We ordered a slice with mushrooms and onions added on and they literally just threw them ontop of the piece. Clearly the pizza was frozen and then the toppings were thrown on top. It was cheap but honestly not even worth it. read more

While nearby for work, did a quick Yelp! search for local pizza places and this one popped up with good reviews. Upon entering, we were greeted with the smell of weed, which continued for the remainder of our lunch. Had we not been in a rush, we would have left and found somewhere else, as it was off-putting, especially while you were eating. Prices were surprisingly cheap (lunch special: 2 slices, medium soda for ~$4.50 for example), not sure how they compare to the rest of the immediate area. Pizza was OK - dough and crust seemed well enough, nothing special. but there was a lot of grease, either from the cheese or pepperoni, or both. Street parking in front, across the street and down a nearby side street. Seating is limited, maybe 20 max in the main front room, a mixture of booths and tables. we were the only ones in there, maybe this place gets busy at night or on the weekends with the college crowds. there are other pizza places in the area, so we'll try one of those next time. an OK place, but nothing special and not worth repeating. read more

After reading what I interpreted as mixed reviews I decided to give Vennari's a shot. Like some reviews the person that answered that phone was not enthusiastic about my call. He also didn't know what a margherita pizza was, which sent up red flags, but I ordered anyway. When I arrived to pick up my pizza's 45 minutes later they were not ready yet, even though not one person was eating inside. However, it was all worth it because the pizza was fantastic! Best I have had since moving to PA. I think the place is what it is, a small business on a tight budget, that makes outstanding pizza, and I am fine with that. read more

not sure what has happened to this once great pizza shop. hoagies are goofed up and pizzas are burnt. after tonight we are officially done and so sad. it was our favorite pizza but we aren't wasting our money anymore. read more

It's a real shame they are now skimping on most everything that goes into making a sandwich! -and for what? To survive? That business strategy will kick them in the backside. Sad. read more

One of a kind pizza! This pizza has such a unique flavor. Love that the crust is thin with a breadstick like edge. Sauce has great flavor. Loads of cheese even without getting "extra". Great deals on carry out pizzas. Have been getting pizza here for years and never been disappointed. We recently tried their wings and they were great as well! read more

Read all the reviews. Ordered the specialty XL Added chick - pep - meatball - onion and a few other items. This is one of the best pizzas I've eaten in my 49 years. The only reason 5 stars not given is they use canned mushrooms. Each slice is a meal on its own. Staff was pleasant and speed of service was great. I will be back to try other items on their menu. read more

Vennari's Pizza - Specialty with Chicken, meatballs, sausage, olives. Dude each slice is a meal in its own right!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

I come here whenever I'm in Lewisburg! Staff is very friendly! Cozy restaurant feel. Pizza and wings are delicious! read more

When we had a mix-up with our order, Vennari's went above and beyond to make it right. Their pizza is simple, no-frills, comfort-food and delightfully, so is the price. If you're a dip-your-crust-in-ranch lover, Vennari's is definitely for you. Looking forward to our next order! read more

First time I've gotten bad pizza from here. It was all sauce and crust was 3 to 4 inches wide around the edges. Not what I've come to expect from this place. read more

Restaurant took a vastly unreasonable amount of time to be finished and delivered. It was mediocre on arrival. Waste of time and money. Will be choosing one of the many other local pizza places. I don't know if they are understaffed or what the problem is. read more

Very positive experience today ordering delivery through Grubhub. Food was warm and arrived on time.

This is our favorite comfort food pizza. We have had pizza in most of the locations in Lewisburg, but Vennari's is always our favorite. I love their crust. It is delicious. The staff is super friendly. I know most of the staff by name, since I have been bringing my family here for years. Enjoy!!! read more

This place is great...if you like uncooked cheese piled on top of barely cooked dough that seems like it was put in a EZ-Bake oven. Steer way clear of this poor excuse for pizza. read more

It has been said that pizza is like sex. Even when it's bad, it's pretty good. That's the highest praise I can offer Vennari's pizza. It's the worst pizza I've paid for in a really long time. I brown my cheese better at home. The bread sticks were totally burned on the bottom. It became clear over time why we were the only party in there. Keep on walkin'. read more

Delicious! Went to eat here with my husband and mother in-law. So delicious! I only tried a sandwich and a little of my husbands stromboli. I have to say both were delicious. read more

Vennari's Pizza - Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Yummy!!!! Fresh homemade food. Pesto pizza was delicious and enjoyed their ravioli's as well. read more

Vennari's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

The pizza was adequate but the service was horrible! Almost 2 hours to have a pizza delivered on a Monday?! The woman taking the Order was rude and the delivery man noted the pizza was SUPER late with just a brush off sorry. Really disappointed. read more

This is the best pizza in TOWN!!! Wow, what an amazing surprise. Was in town for a friend's wedding, and this might have been the highlight of the whole weekend?! Everything done the way it should be when it comes to good 'za. Definitely stop here. read more

Ok... I travel many places for pizza! This pizza is now at the top of my list for a thicker pizza! Make sure you tell them to cook it a little longer to make sure its perfect! The sauce and the amoumt of cheese matched perfect with the thickness of the crust!! Was awesome! In addition I ordered a Italian Sub to go, perfect - definitely a winner in my book!! Great Pizza and Subs! I will be returning frequently! Gary! read more

Hands down - the best pizza in Lewisburg. I don't mean that as a slight to la Casa de Pizza (House of Pizza) though, as I like that place, too. Vennari's is an easy walk from Bucknell University, and a great place to go after a movie or on the way home from the bar (if it's not too late, as they don't have hours like the Pizza Window in downtown boston or a NYC pizza joint). The restaurant is not too big, though the new (in the 90s) back room was a good addition. You order from the counter and take your slice with you, or they'll bring you your pie. It's good thin crust pizza - a slice hits the spot, or a pie is good for a group. The owners were friendly back in the day, and am sure they still are. The walls are lined with talent agency photos (from a family member's agency, if I remember correctly). All headshots signed to Vennari's - it's fun to look around and see the pictures. If you want a sub, go to OIPS (reviewed by me, too). If you want Pizza, go here. read more

THIS IS THE CLOSEST TO REAL PIZZA THAT YOU ARE GOING TO FIND IN LEWISBURG-- TOWN BY THE RIVER. Yes, I am Pizza connoisseur and the other so called pizza joints are cracker crust wannabees, they skimp on sauce, and do not add enough cheese ! Vennaris has the great chewy crust, East coast lovin it dough+++ Oh yeah. PLUS Their sauce tastes good, and the cheese oozy slurp slurp stretches-- The Finest in the town. .........Ah,..........................SOON though, many will be rerouted over the NEW highway away from this hood. read more

Ordered 2 chicken parms and it came with a tiny piece maybe 4 inches long and then spaghetti with a teespoon of marinara. If u ever want italian food in lewisburg this is def bot the place to order from. read more

Vennari's Pizza - We ordered chicken parm and this is the mess we recieved - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

Came into this restaurant by accident, meant to go to La Casa. We were greeted by a friendly woman, and ordered our food at the counter. As we looked around we noticed how dirty the restaurant was. There were cob webs hanging from everywhere. The salt and pepper shakers were very dirty, so dirty that I took a picture. It looks as if this place hasn't been cleaned in years! The pizza we ordered wasn't horrible, it just lacked taste. We added all the shakers just to give it some oomph. Based on this experience I won't be going back, nor will I recommend this restaurant to anyone. On a positive note, both people working said 'thank you' to us when we left. read more

Vennari's Pizza - The dirty shakers - Pizza Near Me - Lewisburg, Pennsylvania

This place is a nice and quaint restaurant in the town of Lewisburg. The inside is rather small but inviting. I ordered pizza and I enjoyed it. The only con I have to report is the crust. There was too much crust and not enough pizza. I was full after my first slice because there was so much crust. read more

If I could give a worse rating I would. Horrible service. Incompetent delivery driver called me to let me know she was around the corner. I went outside and waited for 20 minutes and called delivery driver twice. She never picked up so I called the restaurant only to be rudely treated and hung up on. I am a college student who will never order from people who have no ethics whatsoever. Might I add that their pizza is terrible and I found a piece of metal in it the first time (like a small metal fragment of some sort). Save your money, Larrys or Pizza Phi is far better and they will treat you right. read more

Was an out of towner and tried this place. It was SO good will be going back here for pizza no questions asked. I would recommend it to friends and strangers alike. Best pizza in town. After trying their pizza the next day tried the cheese steak sandwich... Also very good. The Large is big enough to feed two hungry people. Couldn't eat it fast enough! read more

Pizza is just not very good--overly greasy, not very fresh tasting, don't like the tase of the tomato sauce.

Was going to hit up one of the nearby pubs for dinner, but had to make some phone calls and opted for a quieter atmosphere. When I walked it around 8:30pm or so the place was dead inside and I wasn't sure if I could even order by the slice. They did have one cheese pie still available, so I ordered 2 slices and a drink. Price seemed great...like $3 for the two slices when I realized they didn't ring up my drink. Rather than do another CC swipe, they just gave me the drink for free. The pieces came out super hot (they asked me if I wanted them hot or just warm) and the cheese was a bit gooier than I prefer (in retrospect I should have probably just asked for it warm). Overall though the taste was really good and I considered another slice. Place was totally dead while I was there, one gentleman came in to pick up a pie. Overall, for my 3 day trip out in this area of the country this was one of my meal highlights. read more

Terrible service ordered the pizza at 6:03pm, went to pick up at 625, counter man notified me that he had burned my pizza because of the phone etc., said new pizza would be ready in 8 minutes? Well pizza just got done at 6:49, charged full price, not near the place it use to be, New ownership? read more

If you like gobs of cheese and oil - I'm talking like 1,000 calories of fat cheese on average crust and sauce, you'll love this place. One of our cups of water had a mystery flavor in it from the dispenser nozzle and the tiny cramped dining space was an ambient temperature of 110 degrees. Throw in the creepy Scientology poster and the confusing celebrity photos on the wall, and I'll never go back. Bad pizza. But hey, I'm from Jersey, yo. read more

Vennari's makes easily my favorite pizza of all time, and that's coming from someone who eats pizza as often as possible. I always go with the deluxe crust and a side of ranch, and I'm still not sure if I prefer it fresh out of the oven or reheated. Luckily, that works out perfectly, because I'm also getting a cheesesteak every time I have a chance to get their food. Just writing this review made me so hungry that I checked my calendar to find the next time I can get close enough to have it again. If you're in Lewisburg, it's a must! read more

Best place for pizza in Lewisburg. Don't let the odd pictures on the walls fool you into leaving, Vennaris has got the goods. I have not tried their subs or other options, but considering the quality of their pizza, they must be pretty good too. The staff is courteous and friendly, which makes hanging out among the odd photos a little less painful. read more