Overtime Cards &amp; Collectibles

Nice store. A fair selection of model rocketry supplies. Helpful staff, one of whom looked up the…read morediameter of a "BT-50" tube which enabled us to select the appropriate-size rocket kit.

Exceptional service. I ordered a part from them that arrived with missing parts (manufacturers…read morefault) and Vortex made it right within no time. I will definitely be ordering from them again. Thank you, Vortex Hobbies!

See all

M R S Hobby Shop

4.2(16 reviews)

1.3 mi

I'm new to the area and stopped in looking for a hobby shop to help with wiring for an N-scale…read moretrain set. While the store primarily focuses on remote control cars, it's fully stocked with everything RC-related. Even though my project wasn't their main specialty, the gentleman there was very helpful and took the time to find exactly the wire I needed. Great customer service and a welcoming experience.

I've gone here for many years and have always enjoyed their selection and the quality service…read moreprovided. The staff members are knowledgeable and friendly, and are willing to help when needed. It doesn't feel like the owner is just there to collect a paycheck but is genuinely interested in providing a wide range of products to customers. Over the years I've seen the same kits around, I would love to buy them but the price just feels too high for what it is. I understand this is somewhat out of their control but when it's the same kit I've seen for years and years I feel like a price drop of some sort would be warranted.

See all

Canyon Hobbies

4.2(12 reviews)

1.5 mi

Amazing place for teenager kids. My boys love this place. Various adventures. Good luck with your…read morebusiness

Pretty good selection of model rocketry supplies, spacious store - not like the hobby shops of my…read moreteenage years.

Radio control truck and stuff

See all

Pop City Utah

4.3(6 reviews)

0.4 mi

Review for Pop City, Utah…read more I've been a loyal Pop City customer for years, both buying and trading Funko Pops under the previous ownership. Since the business was sold, however, my experiences have been consistently frustrating and disappointing under the new ownership team -- particularly with Skyler, who appears to control all major decisions. Communication Issues: * It is nearly impossible to do business without going directly through Skyler, yet he is only in the store one day a week and is slow to respond online. * I have often been told one thing by staff or other owners (that they are interested in certain items) only to have Skyler later respond with "no longer interested," even on items the store later purchased from someone else. Inconsistent & Selective Business Practices: * I brought in a full set of The Office Funko Pops, complete with verified HobbyDB values, offering to sell or trade at a fair percentage. I was told they had "no interest," only to see them buy the exact same set from another customer weeks later. * I have significant store credit from past transactions, but they have repeatedly refused to let me use it on certain in-stock items (such as Pokémon singles), even though those items are sold in-store under the Pop City name. * The offers made on items I've brought in have been far lower than expected based on past Pop City practices. Recent Incident: * After being told they were buying Funko Mystery Minis, I prepared and bagged a large collection, complete with researched values, and brought them to the store. Staff even sent photos to ownership, but I was told again to "message Skyler." * Skyler's eventual reply was abrupt and dismissive -- "not interested" and a firm refusal to consider store credit toward Pokémon cards. The interaction felt unnecessarily hostile given I have never had a negative exchange with him. Why This Matters: Under the previous owner, Pop City had a reputation for fair trade values, consistent practices, and friendly service. The new management has shifted to selective, opaque, and, in my opinion, greedy business practices. Customers deserve clear communication, consistent policies, and the ability to use store credit on in-stock merchandise. Additionally, I believe their selective refusal to honor store credit on certain items raises potential legal concerns and is something that should be looked into by others to ensure compliance with fair business practices. Bottom Line: If you've done business with Pop City in the past, be aware -- this is not the same store it used to be. Based on my experiences, I cannot recommend doing business here under the current management.

Our favorite place to find collectibles! The owner, Skyler is so kind too and great to work with…read more He's always willing to help me look out for pops that I need too. All of the employees engage in conversation and I love that they have the sticker pillar that we can add to each time we go in. My kids love it there too and there's such a large selection of pops and other collectibles at fair prices. This is for sure my first pick of places to get new pops and toys. 1000000/10 recommend!

See all

Gajo Games

4.7(20 reviews)

1.8 mi

They always have an awesome selection and I always impulse buy. The staff is friendly and…read moreknowledgeable and no, they haven't treated me different for being female. In fact, I talk to the guys all the time and they give me advice or tips for painting. They also provide a huge space to play (they have a second gaming only building!) and don't charge to do so. I always spend my money here first because they are awesome for the wargaming community locally.

The store is very large and has lots of interesting little nooks and crannies. The whole upstairs…read moreand the basement are filled with tables to play different war games and whatever else you might like. The staff are approachable and friendly. The selection is second to none, and they have some really unique stuff. If you want to get a table go early! In my experience some of the other customers were not the friendliest, using one table for their game and the other one for their belongings. As far as I'm aware there is no way to reserve a table.

See all

Hobby Lobby

2.8(46 reviews)

2.3 mi

I went to Hobby lobby last week to see if there fabric was on sale.it usually on sale every…read moreother week. I checked the price. It was 7.99 for cotton fabric. So I waited until this week ,sale 30 % percent off.( not 40% ) anymore. SAD. The lady that was cutting was having a hard time figuring it out. So I check the price. OH MY ,,,,, FOR A STORE THAT HAS REGLIOUS VALUES.....WAT A LAUGH. THE PRICE WENT UP FROM 7.99 TO 11.99 JULY 4 SALE ( VERY SAD) THAN THEY GIVE YOU 30% OFF. I SHOULD HAVE BOUGHT IT LAST WEEK. IT WOULD HAVE BEEN CHEAPER. DECEITFUL,

I recently witnessed an interaction at Hobby Lobby that was disappointing. A group of young girls…read morewere looking through the squishies section and appeared excited to browse the products. At one point, a worker stood there next to this group of girls and waited for them to leave. There was a toy accidentally dropped and picked up by debbie, when one of the girls was trying to pick it up. What concerned me was the way an employee named debbie spoke about the girls afterward. She referred to them as "sloppy girls" and "brats" and complained about them within earshot. Regardless of whether merchandise needed to be put back, I found the comments unprofessional and unnecessarily rude. One of the girls tried to pick up the toy, but felt uncomfortable by Debbie being there, staring. Young customers deserve to be treated with the same respect as any other customer. Retail employees certainly deal with challenges throughout the day, but speaking negatively about customers where they can hear it creates an unwelcoming environment. I hope management addresses this and reminds staff to treat all customers with courtesy and professionalism.

An excellent to the Grinchmas display

See all

Buyers beware!

Michaels

3.5(21 reviews)

2.2 mi

It's a smaller store, a bit crammed with stuff. I found glass on the floor and had to find an…read moreassociate to sweep it up. They are actually open Sundays unlike the American Fork location. They had minimal scrapbooking supplies which is what I went in for. I did find a few Halloween items I purchased. Self check out.

I just love this store, it's so cozy. I got a lot of almost exactly what I needed for an incredibly…read morespecific project, and for a very reasonable price. one employee (or manager perhaps) named Karen exuded kindness and made us very happy. Another whose name was Miles was incredibly helpful and fun to talk to! overall great experience

See all

Hammond Toy & Hobby

4.0(2 reviews)

0.3 mi

Love it. Classic toys and modern too. Been in business since I was a boy. Thank you for fun.read more

This is the place for you if you like models. And Hot Wheels. It does an especially great job with…read moreboth. There seems to be mostly higher end toys here and I didn't see a lot of stuff on the junkier end of the spectrum. There is not a huge amount of selection, though, so I suppose they had to make some hard choices for shelf space. This was a pretty pleasant visit, despite behavior from one of their staff I will describe as "over eager" and I'd probably come again if I wandered through the mall. I suppose I could be more generous considering this is in a mall, but I didn't put the store there and I was a bit confused as to the motivation to have a shop in that particular place, which is something you have to intentionally try to find, in the first place...This is not what I would consider a particularly necessary stop, though overall pretty good, but definitely not great.

Hard to find toys you remembered as a kid

Fun toys for all ages

See all

New location in shops at south town mall. 2 nd floor about 5 store down from maceys

Game Haven

3.6(32 reviews)

1.3 mi

In a nut shell, Game Haven is a phenomenal, local business and community…read more This store has just about everything a nerd could want. If you want to find people to play Pokémon or Yu-Gi-Oh with, every Saturday they have tournaments. You like magic cards, there is almost always someone in the store playing magic but every Friday they always have some magic event happening. You like painting figurines and playing war hammer, they have a section set up for you and every Monday is night where people come to paint there figurines. Outside of this they have a great cafe. They have your standard coffees but my favorite thing is they have a ever changing specialty drinks special that changes season to season or if their is a big nerdy event happening. On of my favorite drinks I had was when they made drinks inspired by and to celebrated "Detective Pikachu". The biggest item for me this store offers is their board games. They have a ton of demos you can play in the store and cafe or rent to take home. Every Tuesday night and Sunday their is a community that comes together to play some board games. If their is a game you want to play and not sure you want to buy it yet, come to these events. If you go often enough and I am sure someone will bring your game in and you will get to play it. For me, these events are like a midweek Christmas, always looking forward to them. As for their events, what I have said does not even scratch the surface. Game Have always seems to have something coming down the pipeline. They have Mini-Cons, Halloween events, psychic and fortune-telling events and so so much more. They support local vendors and artists and just as a ridiculously amazing community. Not to get to personal but Game Haven's community is very inviting and accepting. From their customers, to their employees, to the owner himself. I was very anti-social and depressed a few years ago but Game Havens community accepted me, and I have met some outstanding people and made some life long friendships. A lot of these events have been suspended due to the pandemic but once everything is over, I encourage you to come to this location if this is a community you want to be a part of. Come to one of the events, have a cup of coffee or tea, sit down and as long as you come with a positive outlook and are understanding and respectful, you will have a fun and outstanding time that you will not soon forget!

They charge scalper prices for Pokémon tcg items despite getting them from manufacturer and got rid…read moreof their comics section which was the only reason I visited

The Lugia in the shop

This is $250. I think it could be $75-100.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kurt C.

Elite 26

133

105

81

2 years ago

If you're looking for a card shop where passion and expertise shuffle together like a winning deck, Overtime Cards is the place to go. This isn't just a store--it's a sanctuary for card enthusiasts. From sports cards to Pokémon treasures, Overtime is the 1952 Mickey Mantle of card shops: shiny, valuable, and worth bragging about. The employees here are true card lovers. Seriously, I think one of them could identify a rookie card from across the room with just a glance and a whiff of the cardstock. They know their product so well it feels like they moonlight as consultants for Topps and Pokémon International. But what makes them stand out is that they don't gatekeep their knowledge. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just someone trying to figure out what a "rainbow foil" is, they'll treat you like you're bidding on a Babe Ruth signed card at auction--VIP all the way. And don't even get me started on their prices. Other shops might try to charge you "one kidney and a pack of gum" for the same stuff, but Overtime's prices are almost suspiciously good. I'm talking "did they discover a hidden stash in Area 51?" good. This store's competitive pricing is the reason my wallet is lighter, but my collection is so much richer. In short, Overtime Cards is the Hank Aaron rookie card of shops--an absolute legend. Whether you're hunting for the next big hit or just looking for a place where card talk isn't followed by awkward silence, you'll feel right at home here. Just be warned: one visit, and you'll probably need a bigger display case. read more

Michael P.

30

1

0

8 years ago

Worst customer service I have ever had the man lady behind the counter was horrible. She gave me attitude about everything this sucks because this is the only card store. read more

Ty I.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Best Shop and Staff in the Hobby! Best selection of wax and singles. Great place for collectors and to take your kids.

Morgan D.

0

5

1

7 years ago

I have some cards older basketball and baseball and hockey.. what years 1992 down to 1974

Overtime Cards & Collectibles - hobbyshops - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Sandy, Utah Coffee near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Restaurants near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Things to Do near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Breakfast near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Comic Book Stores near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Ski Resorts near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Craft Store near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

BEST of Sandy, Utah Transportation near Overtime Cards & Collectibles

Related Cost Guides

Florists

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Overtime Cards & Collectibles also viewed

Oasis Games

3.9

(51 reviews)

One of the best game stores of all time! My fiance and I have been in multiple times to visit and…read morepartake in several purchases as well as sell a few items too! Oasis Games has a wide variety of games, but we specifically love to go and purchase Magic The Gathering cards. They seem to always have a consistently rotating amount of stock with cards ranging from the first series ever, all the way to the most recent release! They also offer a website for traded-in cards inventory that can be accessed from home, and you can pick up in person, or even access it with one of their available computers in the store! Most of their prices are reasonably close to MSRP, but where they really excel is in their sale value! They provide a fantastic store value percentage that is greater than every other game store I have ever been to. They also offer fun game nights and pre-release events (check their website for dates). Highly recommend Oasis Games for your next gaming purchase!

I went to sell my cards today and they low ballede so bad. Didn't even go through the he bulk of…read morethem just gave me an offer for 50 bucks for a prismatic new binder, box and over ,400 rares. Ill never go back there again.

Hastur Games

3.3

(38 reviews)

The best game store in SLC!!!! Whenever I'm looking for a new board game, Pokémon card or pieces…read morefor DND my first thought is to go to Hastur. They'll have everything you need and more! I have been on the hunt for Fromage for months and they were the only store that had it!! Staff is super helpful and willing to double check stock. They're also happy to suggest other games based on your areas of interest. They have a huge selection of games that you can play in the store! It's a great place to grab a group of friends and go hangout to test out a game before buying.

My son and I went in with his birthday money and he had been saving for a card that was over $200…read moreand the guy working on 7/9/25 completely disregarded my son and basically told him these cards are for adults. My son has been been collecting pokemon for the last 4 years and has a collection that is valued at over $13000. Not a very good idea to judge a book by its cover. My son was very disappointed and we won't be back

Utah Premier Sports Cards & Memorabilia

(1 review)

Really cool little sports card shop in midway! They just opened up summer or 2024. Good selection…read moreof old and new packs. Some really good singles and graded slabs also. Shop isn't big so don't bring a caravan in here. Young guy working at the counter is respectful and fun to chat with. Oh - lots of stuff for lakers fans : ) Keep up the good work and hope the best for your shop! I'll be back in 4-6 months!

Pop City Utah

4.3

(6 reviews)

Review for Pop City, Utah…read more I've been a loyal Pop City customer for years, both buying and trading Funko Pops under the previous ownership. Since the business was sold, however, my experiences have been consistently frustrating and disappointing under the new ownership team -- particularly with Skyler, who appears to control all major decisions. Communication Issues: * It is nearly impossible to do business without going directly through Skyler, yet he is only in the store one day a week and is slow to respond online. * I have often been told one thing by staff or other owners (that they are interested in certain items) only to have Skyler later respond with "no longer interested," even on items the store later purchased from someone else. Inconsistent & Selective Business Practices: * I brought in a full set of The Office Funko Pops, complete with verified HobbyDB values, offering to sell or trade at a fair percentage. I was told they had "no interest," only to see them buy the exact same set from another customer weeks later. * I have significant store credit from past transactions, but they have repeatedly refused to let me use it on certain in-stock items (such as Pokémon singles), even though those items are sold in-store under the Pop City name. * The offers made on items I've brought in have been far lower than expected based on past Pop City practices. Recent Incident: * After being told they were buying Funko Mystery Minis, I prepared and bagged a large collection, complete with researched values, and brought them to the store. Staff even sent photos to ownership, but I was told again to "message Skyler." * Skyler's eventual reply was abrupt and dismissive -- "not interested" and a firm refusal to consider store credit toward Pokémon cards. The interaction felt unnecessarily hostile given I have never had a negative exchange with him. Why This Matters: Under the previous owner, Pop City had a reputation for fair trade values, consistent practices, and friendly service. The new management has shifted to selective, opaque, and, in my opinion, greedy business practices. Customers deserve clear communication, consistent policies, and the ability to use store credit on in-stock merchandise. Additionally, I believe their selective refusal to honor store credit on certain items raises potential legal concerns and is something that should be looked into by others to ensure compliance with fair business practices. Bottom Line: If you've done business with Pop City in the past, be aware -- this is not the same store it used to be. Based on my experiences, I cannot recommend doing business here under the current management.

Our favorite place to find collectibles! The owner, Skyler is so kind too and great to work with…read more He's always willing to help me look out for pops that I need too. All of the employees engage in conversation and I love that they have the sticker pillar that we can add to each time we go in. My kids love it there too and there's such a large selection of pops and other collectibles at fair prices. This is for sure my first pick of places to get new pops and toys. 1000000/10 recommend!

Finders Keepers Cards and Collectibles

(1 review)

I was introduced to Finders Keepers by a friend, and have been to the store several times since…read more Their wide selection of sports cards, non-sports, toys, and autographed items has always led to my picking up more than expected. VERY fair pricing, and Brian is one of the nicest card shop owners I've ever met. This store is definitely worth checking out!

Mr E's Sports Cards and Collectiables

3.8

(10 reviews)

I had. Some old sports cards from the 80 s and wanted to see if there was any value to them so I…read moretook them into this shop to get more of a professional opinion on them hoping my Michael Jordan card could bring me some cash, it was in a nice case, and when Mr E looked at it he was quick to point out the corners had some issues and had a small Crease in it , so not worth much , I hade a box full of cards perhaps I'll try EBay, looks like Mr E sports shop is great for young kids to buy there Topps cards from... Just put your cards in a holder first thing to keep it nice looking in 40 years

I recently got a Wayne Gretzky Hockey stick from a pawn shop and I wanted to get it verified, so I…read moretook it to the place google recommended to see I could get it set up with PSA or DNA or get it verified or have someone take a look at it, When I got there, there was a 16- 18-year-old kid who was running it and there was no one else there, I asked him if he knew anything about signed memorabilia, He knew absolutely nothing about sports, and definitely not the smartest or most socially aware kid when it came to sports, Unfortunetly this was a poor experience and I was heavily disapointed with this

BTNT Toyz

4.9

(7 reviews)

My husband and I have been checking out toy stores throughout SLC so of course we had to make our…read moreway in to this joint before we headed back home to Boise. Conveniently, this shpp was a minute away from the Chinese restaurant we just had lunch at. So we made our way in. This toy store was literally a time capsule of our childhood. There were toys from when we were little that we totally forgot about. Rainbow Brite, Teddy Ruxpin, My Little Ponies, Mr. Potatoe Head. It brought back so many fond memories playing with these gems. You can find a little of everything here. It was neat looking at all the different collectables that the store had. My husband of course gravitated to the Transformers since he's an avid collector. There was a Soundwave that caught his attention but they were asking for 350 bucks for it and the box was pretty beat up. Maybe if the box was in better condition, my husband might have considered purchasing it. I overheard the gentleman behind the counter tell someone that they will be closing this summer. Sad hearing that since novelty stores like these are a rare find. It's hard for small businesses to compete against these big stores selling the big shiny new toys. Who needs a shiny new toy when you can get a dope ass old collectable to hang on to! We did leave without the Soundwave. We both felt bad leaving without buying anything but nothing really caught our eye. I hope that this store stays open a little longer than just summer. Small businesses are the back bone of our community and we need to support them. We will be back in SLC in October and fingers crossed that this joint will be open when we come back.

great store and the owner is knowledgeable, fair and fun to talk too! Was there for Star Wars…read morememoriabilia!

BigReds Toys

(4 reviews)

This one is going to take a little sleuthing to find, so if you're into hunting around for the next…read moregreat hidden shop that no one knows about or are just really into the whole "bazaar of the bizarre" literary trope, that sort of thing might just be right up your alley. Indeed, it was a dark and stormy day on this visit and going down a set of stair into the inner recesses of the building sort of lent that vibe. It is a very cool place, chock full of stuff, ranging from action figures, some of which I haven't seen in over a decade, to other, much more recent stuff, displays as dioramas, arcade cabinets, and a veritable host and slew of other items. Right when you walk in, you will be in a front area with a ton of comic book action figures, always a welcome sight, but there is quite a lot more as you progress further and deeper into the bowels of the store. These kind of places sort of live and die on a couple of things, which are, namely, selection and price, and on both counts, this store excels. Not only can you easily spend hours sifting through the magic on the shelves, but I didn't find a single price I thought was out of line. Most of them were quite reasonable, in fact, which is nice to see, given what the toy market has been doing in recent years. This seems like another passion project and the owner is quite pleasant to visit with as well, so with any luck, this one won't stay super under-the-radar for too long. Probably one of the better toy hunting experiences I've had in recent years and looking forward to the next!

Easily one of the best toys stores I've ever been to. Prices are great, selection is fantastic, and…read moreif you are a collector, you'll be hard pressed to find a better destination.

Game Haven

4.5

(4 reviews)

Board games and miniatures have sure taken of in the last few years and it's fun to see spaces like…read morethis for players to gather. The front half of the store is the retail side where you can buy games and accessories. The back half has tables setup for folks to come play together-it's a perfect third space for gamers! The staff were friendly and welcoming and I'm sure if you were looking for something specific they would be able to help track it down. Game on!

Well I just got physically accosted during a magic game tonight.... I guess they really wanted to…read morewin. The worst part is I was already losing so he came at me for nothing. I don't know what to even say. Not okay. Other than that Riley is awesome. The store is fun and has a giant chess set. They will order in the game you want if it is available and they have a big set of demo games you can try out.

Mind Games