Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Oyster Bay

    5.0 (1 review)

    Services - Oyster Bay

    Apartments

    Oyster Bay Apartments Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Oyster Bay

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of James M.
    133
    1010
    6591

    8 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Apartments 173 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Wilkinson PM

    Wilkinson PM

    (3 reviews)

    We used Wilkinson Property Management for 8 years while my husband served in the military. We…read morethought we would be in the DC area for a long time, so we bought a home. Uncle Sam had different ideas and we had to move away and rent our home. It was very reassuring to know that Wilkinson and our agent, Mary H. were taking care of everything for us while we were away, to include finding new tenants. Our house was never empty. We recently sold our home and Mary and our real estate agent kept us informed every step of the way. We didn't need to travel to the DC area at all. We highly recommend Wilkinson and Mary H.

    I am an owner of a home in southern MD. and had to leave the state for personal reasons. I hired…read moreWPM for short to handle my property in my absense. My local manager Julie P. performed in the most professional manner. In the past two years I or shall I say we had to deal with a continous ongoing issues wich began two weeks into occupancy. Thousands of dollars later along with neglet or disrespect of the property along with very strong verbal abuse both in person and on social media to Julie and any body whom showed to fix the issue, she kept her composure and all issues were addressed imediately. Patrick F. with corporate in VA. also communicated with Julie and I to mend the issues. I highly reccomend this company if you are in need to rent yourself or lease your property persoanlly. Thank you Willkinson Property Management Company for all your support. I will continue to work with them. To tenants, a word of advice, treat the property as if it was your own. The way you act is not only a reflection on you but your children, especiaaly whom live with you. To owners, be careful and Do Not think with your heart. We cut the teants a break beings it was the Holidays at the time and they both were married each with two young girls of their own. With poor credit we only asked for a one month deposit instead of two, because my wife and I met under the sam circumstances. NEVER AGAIN totally MEAN AND UNGRATEFUL. If you want to rent a brand new 2600 sq.ft. home then go and pay $7000 a month. Things go in full circle, God has his way. KARMA is a bitch.

    Horton Realty

    Horton Realty

    (9 reviews)

    One of the worse property management companies I have dealt with in a long time . Maintenance…read morerequest was not excited in a proper manner ,the "Manager" and some of his staff were unprofessional. I wouldn't recommend any property Horton manages to anyone . Horrible experience. First of all , I left this apartment in pristine condition. The bathroom , Kitchen , bedroom and living room was cleaned to perfection. I'm not the only one who has posted a negative review of this company . They currently have two stars and they have this rating for a reason. I don't owe this company any money , never damaged their property . I submitted a Maintenance request it took them three weeks to fulfill . I was the one who moved . When I did move, I owe them nothing . I have never owed them anything . If I had it to chose over again, I would never move in a Horton managed Property . Side note : Notice how this management company attempts to discredit those who don't have a favorable review of them. Read the other reviews then read mine.Do your research. Go on other sites read those reviews. The truth isn't hard to find .

    If I could give them a negative number, I would. I have unfortunately had to resign a lease with…read morethem due to the current housing market . I have made numerous maintenance requests on the house that I am renting that have been completely ignored for months now, one being a safety issue. The one staff member he has is absolutely incompetent and extremely rude. He is no better though. He never responds to maintenance requests even having done a walkthrough and seen the issues himself. I recommend no one renting through this company.

    Oyster Bay - apartments - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...