The service, the ambiance, the quality and quantity of the food; all of this is fantastic and I always enjoy my time and money spent here at Panchos. It's a family friendly vibe, or a chill hangout spot for friends in a local community of the quiet town of New Milford. This place is a gem and I will definitely be back to visit. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Chicken Mole Chiimichanga - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

Yum! Went with 5 friends and we all loved the large portions of very delicious food. It's not cheap but the value is there and I can't wait to order the same thing - it was so good!! Had shrimp and steak kebabs that were excellent! Tres leches was impressive with a beautiful vanilla flavor. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

The food was good and drinks were very good. I ordered the fish tacos and didn't notice the fish was salmon. I hate salmon but it was my mistake, not theirs but they wouldn't let me keep that. So they insisted I order something else, so I asked for the vegetable tacos. I waited for the tacos that never arrived. The waiter insisted I had refused the tacos, at this pointe I just wanted to leave. The watermelon margaritas were delicious and so was the mango mojito. I was going to give them 4 's but the service and the fact they forgot me, and lied about my order was very disappointing. Will definitely not return. read more

See all

Let's get straight to the point... you only come to Pancho's for the tequila and vibes. That's it. You don't come here if you want authentic Mexican food full of flavor. You would be wasting a lot of money eating here. The menu is price gouging at its finest. $20+ for 2 tacos, $20+ for a burrito, $25-$30 for a burrito bowl?! The food quality is similar to high school cafeteria food. You'd probably get better at Chipotle or Taco Bell. Be forreal LOL. Putting the food aside... their drinks are good and beautifully presented. Tons of options for cocktails, beer, and wine ranging from $14-$27. Their margaritas are a must. It's more of a club atmosphere on the weekends, which can be fun IF you're okay with loud music, strobe lights, flashing tv screens, and having to yell at each other to have a conversation. The DJs play a good mix of music-reggaeton, dembow, merengue, salsa, etc. BUT the tables are close together and there isn't a lot of space so it's hard to dance. You're gonna have to dance in your chair or dance around your table area lol. I really wish they had a dance floor. If that's not your vibe, you can go during the day. Whether Pancho's is worth a visit or not is up to personal preference. read more

See all

A great night of partying drinking and eating. The venue staff were excellent as they served us drinks all night. The food was absolutely fantastic as they put out a spread of different dishes all cooked to perfection. The place was festive and truly amazing with people dancing and having a great time. The DJ was entertaining as he kept us on our feet all night even live streaming the party on Twitch. The place is very nicely decorated with balloons and TV's all over the place. The lighting in the bar area is very cool, and the bartender was awesome. A very nice atmosphere and time at Panchos last night. read more

See all

OMG what an amazing NEW YEARS EVE CELEBRATION we had at Pancho's Burritos our party of 16 had. First of all open bar 9-12 at midnight a toast of champagne and the drinks tequila vodka martini margaritas were made exceptional. The food well I expected appetizers but what was served was steak pernil (pork) rice salad full delicious meal -I commend the chef for his savory food. The DJ great selection of music and clicking into New York's falling ball for 2025 closed the whole night-Thank You Jose and the entire serving staff for a night to remember-see you soon! read more

See all

fire. great music and vibes. got the coronarita (2 for 35 on mondays!) and i was floored. will be coming back. read more

Pancho's Burritos - coronarita - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

Everything was very good on Cinco de Mayo. Good food and great waiters. Great live entertainment and great DJ's.

Let's start with the good - the ambiance and service at this place is definitely a 10/10. They have multiple giant screens surrounding the tables where they play music videos as well as a dj booth so I assume this place turns into a fun clurb on the weekends. Our server was constantly coming around asking if we needed anything and clearing the table. The food and drinks came out quickly and they have some parking on the side of the building. We drove 10+ miles to this place because an ad came up on my ig - "happy hour all day everyday!" - that would catch anyone's attention. What I was not prepared for, was the price of everything else. Yes, certain drinks were $5 but it was very limited. One of the options was a frozen classic Marg, we asked if we could get it regular/on the rocks and they said it would be $16 if we did so don't go in there asking for substitutions unless you're ready to pay $$$. I would recommend the sangria or frozen marg from the happy hour menu. I took pics of the menu so you could see the prices of the food - $20+ for only 2 tacos, a burrito with no side $21+, small veggie enchiladas with no side $22 (look at the pic in the menu I mean how is that anything over $12?). We ended up ordering a quesadilla (which happened to be the cheapest thing on the menu) and it was still $17. I don't mind paying that amount, but the food was average, like something I could get in a taco truck in ny for half the price. I appreciate they at least gave free chips and salsa when we sat down. Bottom line - would I return? Yes BUT probably only to drink for happy hour or if they have a deal like taco Tuesday / bottomless Sunday brunch. OR if they change their prices to match the quality/amount of food you get. read more

See all

I really loved the vibes of this place and the music. They also have all day long happy hour on drinks which was great! $5 for margaritas and they hit the spot. I was just disappointed in the food as it's pretty expensive and not the best quality. We ordered chicken nachos which came out to about $29 - the most expensive nachos ever. I also ordered tacos which were $4 a taco. I wasn't a fan of the tortilla but the staff was very nice and accommodating. I would probably give this place another try during the summer for drinks but most likely not for food. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Street Tacos Nachos Gordo Steak Burrito - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

decor is nice, the giant tv screens are interesting but the food is bland and made for people that don't like Mexican food or flavors. It's too expensive to be that bad. The drinks/happy hour is decent and the service is good, but I wouldn't eat there again. read more

Pancho's Burritos - restaurant interior. - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

First time here. When we went in, we were seated in seconds, however it was like 15 minutes before anyone even came to take our drink order. One they did, everything else was excellent. Delicious mole sauce! I got the carne asada mole bowl and it was GREAT! Some fancy drinks at a higher price point but the girls loved them. I was sipping on some tequila with a Dos Equis amber; serenity now. The bowls are HUGE and there was a good amount of steak in it; very nice! Wife had shrimp tacos and enjoyed them. Steak and shrimp bowl looked really good as well. We had the coconut shrimp app, spicy fries, and guacamole....all were really really good. Next time I'm up this way I'll most likely be making a point to stop in again. read more

See all

This is a very hard and disappointing review for me. I'm not one to give 2 stars or less but I honestly have no other choice. We get there and put our name on the list. The girl says it's a 45 minute wait and we need to wait in our car. They'll text us when our table is ready. Ok, we hang in the car with the AC. Before you know it. 7:35pm we get texted. We walk over and get seated immediately. Took 10 minutes tops to look at the menu(I'm giving the benefit of the doubt saying 10 minutes... we all know 10 minutes is a long time). 7:45pm we order drinks, appetizers and dinner. Drinks came right out. 8:50pm(an hour and 5 minutes later), our dinner came out WITH the appetizers. Defeats the purpose of ordering an appetizer. Not once did our waitress check on us. NOT ONCE IN AN HOUR!!! Everything came out and she apologized the appetizers came out with the dinner but the kitchen was backed up. ZERO excuse for not asking if we wanted something else to drink or even ask how we were doing. Horrible service. Clearing my head... let's move on to the food. The appetizers which took an hour to come out was a bowl of chili (which has to be premade) and a cheese quesadilla (piece of cheese melted in a tortilla). I'm going to leave it at that. Chili was decent and quesadilla was ok. My wife got the crispy chicken burrito which she said she liked. I got the sampler which was average at best. We got there in pure daylight and dinner came out and it was pitch dark. Then add the price tag..... my wife thought it was a $60 experience at best.... add $50 to that for a dinner for 2 and she's more on point. read more

See all

SUNDAYS AT PANCHO'S IS LIT! They have DJ entertainment on Sundays turning the restaurant interior into full club mode! Very cool! We ate in the outdoor dining area which was wonderful and spaced out. SERVICE: Our server Jessica was spot on, genuinely friendly and attentive. Food and cocktails were served without delay, fresh, hot and in unison. DRINKS: On point! Miami Vice was delicious but if you want a little kick go for Órale Guey! Yum! FOOD: So incredibly DELICIOUS! Chicken quesadilla was perfect and filling no need for sides and the flavors of the Carne Asada Bowl with Mole was outstanding!!! Overall, solid choice for local Mexican, not only would I go back but also order delivery (which is available). Great experience all around! read more

See all

Pancho's food and service are very good BUT ridiculously expensive! $45 for a grill shrimp burrito, a piece of tres leches cake & 2 cans of Lipton ice tea! read more

Pancho's Burritos - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

The food took over 2 hours to come out without any explanation or apology. The worst service and food I have ever had. we have been there before and liked it but will not go back and do not recommend anyone else going either. read more

I had dinner at Pancho's recently with a friend and had a great experience. We had come on a Thursday night and there was no wait which was great. It has been a while since my last visit and they added some new decor which added to the aesthetic of the restaurant. Right when you walk in there are beautiful flowers hanging above. And then flowers also on the walls. You are also welcomed in by the DJ playing a great selection of songs that you cannot help but dance and sing along to. A little bit on the louder side so it made conversations a little bit hard. Our waitress came to the table with chips and salsa and took our drink orders. I had ordered the Miami vice and my friend had ordered the Mexican mule. She was looking to get the bulldog which is still on the menu but unfortunately it is only available as a frozen drink which she didn't want. Our drinks came out fairly quickly and they were good and made strong. We had ordered our food. And our orders had come out in less than 10 minutes which was great. I had ordered the mar y tierra burrito bowl and my friend ordered the carne asada burrito. The bowl was delicious with marinated rice, with a choice of beans I picked black beans, and topped a generous helping of steak and shrimp. It was delicious! The burrito was huge and filled with rice and their delicious carne asada steak. My friend had enjoyed her meal. Overall we had a great experience during our dinner. Our waitress was great and attentive to our needs. The food is always good and they have a great variety of entrees. Their drinks are good! The vibe of the restaurant is nice and the DJ never disappoints with what is playing. If you are looking to have good conversation, then this might not be the right place. There is plenty of street parking. I will be back again soon! read more

See all

Decent on the fly southwestern restaurant featuring all things Burrito whether packed or in a bowl. The guac and chips followed by the carne asada burrito were just okay provided you showered it in picante sauce - kinda like the miracle of wasabi at a mediocre sushi joint. Nothing here was memorable except for the pricey departure. It's much too far to travel for a return but if I'm ever in the mood for approximate Mexican, there's always six or seven local Chipotle's to choose from. The good news is the memory (good or bad) doesn't linger. Three perfectly average stars. read more

Take out always prepared properly. Food good. I'm typing nonsense as yelp requires 85 letter minimum to post, and won't post unless 85 letters used. One wonders why some don't rate? read more

Service and food was ok until I received the check. CAVEAT EMPTOR. First, no one told me we would be charged extra for paying with a credit card. And worse, the check total did not match what they charged my Credit Card. I know, it was negligible, yet when we called it out to the staff, they said "nothing we can do about it. It seems to be a glitch and u fortunately you need to pay that amount". Really?!?! It was just $1.50, yet the least they could do was fix it or offer something in return. If they did that to us, they will certainly be doing that to others. It should amount to a large amount at the end of the day. They are stealing in our faces. They played dumb, and I decided not to fight it. BUT, everyone beware, this place is NOT TO BE TRUSTED. I will reach out to the appropriate agencies to do my civic duty and prevent other unsuspecting clients be fleeced... read more

Pancho's Burritos - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

This place is so much fun!!! I love the vibe and while we were there a table was celebrating a birthday and they change the music and the strobe lights come one and it literally changes to a party vibe. Although i wouldn't categorize this place as a family restaurant. I was literally yelling all night to speak over the music. But i was there to have a fun time so it totally met my expectation on that level. The drinks where tasty and cute. The food was good. Great flavor and came out quickly. read more

See all

My sister went to eat on a Friday night. The next day, she was nice enough to give me her left overs. As was finishing up the mediocre burrito I noticed a dead insect / fly that camouflaged with the black beans. Disgusting!! read more

See all

Went here with a small group for dinner. Extremely Overpriced drink and food which was not that good. Dj/club atmosphere on weekend nights after 9pm if you are into that scene. read more

Stopped by on a whim when driving through the area. We called to pre-order and they said it would take 30 mins. We parked and walked over after about 30 mins had passed, went inside and still had to wait probably another 15-20 minutes. They were incredibly busy with orders and had some outdoor dining (only a couple tables doing indoor dining). We ordered a couple of tacos (al pastor and shrimp - they were out of the fried fish taco). When I called I asked if the al pastor taco had pineapple (they said yes) but it didn't. The taco was tasty but small and was wished it had pineapple. The burrito bowls were really good - I got surf and turf one - and a to-go mojito. I probably shouldn't have had all of this because my acid reflux flared up so bad I went to urgent care that night. But that's my own fault. read more

Overall **** Rock solid 4 Stars! Bored and by myself, hunting for something different and with not many options in the area I threw caution to the wind. I couldn't have been happier to have spent my time here as it is a nice environment, service was friendly and engaged, the food very good and the bill not outrageous. I'm already thinking about the next time I'm in the area so I can return. I also appreciate the Covid precautions they are taking but the sign in the bathroom (see picture) puts it over the top that they are really trying to run this establishment the right way. Setting **** At 5:00 on a Thursday night it was very quiet so I took a chance and sat inside at the bar and while small it was very comfortable, decorated with ledge stone, red walls and black ceilings. Inside they have removed multiple tables and there was actually only two bar stools at the wall facing bar that sits 10+. In the bar area there is a pub height banquet that I bet would be a blast if things ever return to normal. Outside they have tables covered by an awning and a sizable tented area behind the restaurant. This is truly a Mexican Restaurant between the music blasting and with soccer on nearly all the TV's. There was one tv with ESPN on but I appreciated the relative authenticity of the place. Parking definitely looks like problem as the lot itself only holds 10 cars or so and their is parking on the side street but it is restricted. Street parking is available but not a lot of it so carpooling is the way to go. Service **** From the host to the bartender to the food runner all were very friendly, engaged and seemed proud of the restaurant. They are taking precautions seriously here as everyone was wearing masks, gloves and took my information for tracing purposes. I could get overly picky here about eating out of a tin to go container but I get it with them taking every precaution they can. Food **** It is nearly impossible for me to pass up a Chicken Chimichanga and I'm glad I didn't. First off it is huge and I thought there is no way I will finish it, well that turned out not to be a problem. It probably had too much rice but the chicken was tender, flavorful and with the accompanying Guacamole, sour cream and hot sauce it came too life and I inhaled the whole thing. Value **** I originally planned on going 3 Stars here as $17.50 seemed steep for a Chimichanga but when the bill arrived and I saw that my generously poured top shelf G&T was only $8 I nearly fell off my stool, that alone is worth an extra Star! read more

Pancho's Burritos - Management gets it. - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

I wouldn't suggest going out to dinner at Pancho's unless you want to spend a butt load on average food. They used to be a decent place years ago but the food, service and price has changed drastically over the years. I'll pay money for good food but this doesn't hit the mark for me. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Mojito - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

The food is pretty mediocre and is way overpriced. The ambiance is fun for a Saturday night and the service was really good. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

This is a cute spot nicely decorated with big TV screens. We were seated right away and the service was great. The food on the other hand was not as great. The beef and chicken tacos were mediocre and were not very tasty. The margaritas were good but overpriced. I tried the house sangria and it just did not taste good. read more

See all

As you can see I have visited here many times in the past for my most favorite Chili Con Carne burrito. During this COVID-19 pandemic, we ordered our take-out over the phone using my credit card for my 5:30 pm dinner pick-up. This was my first time here for COVID-19 contactless pick-up. When I arrived in my car I entered their front entrance, where a staff member gave me my take-out bag. I again enjoyed my Chili Con carne burrito. A grilled shrimp burrito totaled almost $39. I will continue to return here for our favorite burritos. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Front - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

See all

We have way too much fun when we come here! Food is delicious and drinks are good! Dj plays what we like, the only negative thing I would say is they can cut back on the strobe lights and fog machine. read more

I used to be a regular, even during COVID eating in the tent to support local businesses. Then prices doubled and I will no longer be supporting. I understand an increase as prices have risen but double just seems like gouging. read more

Great spot if you wanna come watch some football games and enjoy cheap drinks. Food is sub par at best, most of the menu items taste frozen and they're extremely overpriced. However, the drinks are very VERY compared to most places. So if you're going to just have drinks, this is a great place. If you want good Mexican food, I wouldn't necessarily come here. The inside is very nice though. Cool date nice spot. read more

Should've checked the Yelp reviews before coming here. Food. No vegetarian options on the lunch menu for my friend. Odd. I ordered a steak+mole burrito bowl w pinto beans and no cheese. I can't eat cheese and the menu says it comes on the side so I said they didn't even have to add it at all. Received the burrito bowl w black beans and cheese mixed in. Told the server who brought back a steak burrito bowl w/o mole. So wrong order twice. Tasteless. I poured the table salsa into my bowl to give it some sort of moisture and flavor. Only ate half. Drinks. Passion fruit frozen margarita. Good. Service. Poor. The restaurant was barely at half capacity and the server acted like she hated her job and all its patrons. Bottom line. Believe the star rating. read more

Great atmosphere. Great service. Great food and drinks! I plan to DJ here and promote this spot! read more

Pancho's Burritos - This drink says it all!! - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

This restaurant has definitely gone down hill. It was such a cool spot years ago. Now it's terrible. Came here on a Tuesday. There was only 2 tables occupied. We ordered and it took a long time for the food to come out. As I sat and waited I randomly looked around and noticed a few odd things. Employees were eating or taking. I also noticed the bar tender eating at the bar with a female friend. I literally saw the bar tender put food I her mouth and lick her fingers. (Restaurant owner please look at your cameras) she also smelled bottles as she toured!I wanted to walk out so bad. I don't even want to come back for drinks! read more

I decided to come back and see if things have changed and you know what? They haven't. Still over priced and no justification. I went the other night with my wife and the place was about 20% full. We asked for a booth and the manager said those were reserved for bigger parties. I understand this but if the place is dead then why not accommodate? We stayed for an hour and not one of those seats were filled. They also charge extra for everything. We got the coconut shrimp as an appetizer and it comes with a 2oz mango sauce. We asked for extra sauce because this clearly wasn't enough. We were charged $3 for a 2oz sauce that should have came with the food anyway. The place looks great and staff are friendly but it doesn't make up for everything else. The place isn't worth the money. They're selling tacos for steak prices. read more

I came here on a sat afternoon and it was packed. They do a happy hour that ends at 6 so I figure thats why the crowd, certanly not from the food. The happy hour on a sat is nice as we enjoyed half off marhgerittas. This review is for the food not the bar scene. The menu is standard tex mex food. I didn't know what to get so i got the pork tacos, can't mess that up I thought. Well they did, the pork chunks in the taco where over cooked and dry. A standard taco shell with a soft tortilla wrapped around it is how the the tacos came. I guess thats there attempt at a double decker taco. Taco bell does it better. All the tacos where bland and unappeling. It also came with rice and beans that I didn't really touch. I would not come back here for food. I would def come back for a drink as they have a nice bar. If you want great authentic mexican food go to La Candelaria in Bergenfield. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Tacos? - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

If I was rating on the vibe it would be 5 stars. There is a fun energy in there, beautiful drinks, and a live Mexican singer. The food is a bit lackluster. Like they don't even fold the burrito, the chicken is dry and salty. The prices are high for the food offered. I'd go back for drinks and dessert. read more

Pancho's Burritos - Burrito - Mexican Near Me - New Milford, New Jersey

See all

Service was great. Food was ghastly. I'd be embarrassed to serve food like that. We got the Vegetarian Tacos with "vegetable of the day" -- which sounds like whatever is in season... it was not. It was clearly the 99 cent frozen block of mixed vegetables from the grocery store - totally gross and not even something I'd make at home ... and the side salad that came with it was straight out of a plastic bag and unwashed. Really pathetic tasteless food honestly ! If you want good Mexican food go to Taqueria in Jersey City. read more

Come here for drinks only and perhap the mediocre guacamole and chips. The food here is not worth it. It's flavorless, soulless and poor quality, especially for the price. read more