My go to Italian restaurant. Good food. Reasonable pricing. Friendly service. Poor parking.

Visiting a couple in the area. One said Pamgrazio's in Dover was her favorite; the other's was a place in New Phila. So we decided to taste test with take out pizzas. I ordered the same thing from each place -- large pizza, half with pepperoni and bacon, the other half with sausage, onions, and mushrooms. Pangrazio's was ~$23 and the other was ~$11. I asked the breakdown for the $23 and she told me it was a large with five items. The other place told me, large with 2.5 items. So now you know that Pangrazio's gouges you. Two stars, though, for the delicious, oily crust and cupped pepperonis. Overall, the other place wins for the quality and price. read more

Great service - quality food with an extra homemade feel. Portions are large and the prices are great. Their lunch menu is perfect for the person on the go. read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - One of the many local favorites- Pizzaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

Great food, great service... so glad they are open Sunday evening! The cheese bread and salad are very yummy! Do wish they had a meat or bolognese sauce! Love the homemade pasta! read more

Have you ever watched that show, "IT Crowd"? It's British so that's okay if it is a no. There's this one episode where the characters end up at this place called Messy Joe's. Humor ensues and there are clowns with red rubber shoes. This place is like that during December months because everyone was in Christmas pajamas and T's. The atmosphere was light and family friendly. They were missing a clown, but had a table magician. How was the food? Good question! It was delightful. There's a quality of it that feels classic, to me who has a romantic idea of what classic actually is. The spaghetti is home spun and their sauce with meatball make this affordable family spot, into a diamond in the rough; that is, a culinary surprise. It's as if they've got the creation of homemade spaghetti down to a family science. Thank you for your craft read more

I visit family in Dover twice a year and make a point of eating there at least once each visit. The food is great and the service, friendly. Love the homemade noodles and the cheesy bread sticks. read more

The Dover location is smaller but nicer than their other. Seems they hire very young high school kids, but the service is still decent. The past 3 years the quality has significantly decreased unfortunately, but we still continue to go because the food is good ( depends on what you get) and we love the oil dip with the bread! read more

Things have really gone downhill here. Got a small pizza with extra cheese, of the 9 slices 3 had no cheese whatsoever. Way too much dough was used, was about an inch thick crust with raw dough in the middle. I've ordered my last pizza here. The Dennison location still provides a quality product. read more

Food is always good and the service was great. We really like oil with garlic for the bread

Nice little Italian lunch stop. We got pizza n spaghetti, of course. Side salads were sparsely topped on shedded bed o lettuce. Pizza was good, nice loaves of fresh bread came w/ entrees. Homemade pasta was a treat for the girls. Meatball was dense & hard to cut.. dried out. Dressings were too thick n sweet. Quaint dining room. Prices were very affordable. Server seemed frazzled. Place was full though. read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - Salad looks hungry! - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

See all

The pizza was just ok, the sauce lacked flavor. But what really tipped the scales was the tossed salad. Look at the picture folks, for real! 1 black olive sliced 5 ways, 2 green olives, 1 cherry tomato & the 3 partial croutons that added up to maybe 1 complete crouton - next to a pile of shredded iceburg. Unbelievable! I would've sent it back to the kitchen if I thought it wouldn't embarrass my hubby. As it was, it was worth the entertaining look of horror and pity on his face as he watched me eat it. The creamy garlic dressing that is "new" tastes like miracle whip with mild spices too faint to make out. Yum! read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - Um, can we raise the bar a bit here? - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

Great local restaurant and the pizza is amazing! A little pricey though and they have a unique way of doing carry out. You have to take the alley and park in the back of the restaurant, stay in your car, and they come to the vehicle. Not a big fan of that, as it's just a way to get tips in my opinion for carry out orders. The pizza is definitely good though and you won't be disappointed! read more

we found hair in our pizza and the crust was burnt. first and last time we will ever order from here. read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - hair and burnt crust - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

We picked up a pizza and salad from Pangrazio's on our way to FL. We were told that due to the COVID, they are not delivering after 4 PM, which didn't make much sense to us. So we drove over from our hotel. Anyway, the pizza (rectangular, thin flatbread style) was quite good as was the salad. It was nice to help a local business! read more

Awesome place to eat and a hometown favorite! I ate here many years ago and brought my daughter in law here for the first time. Still as good as I remember. Great pasta great pizza and frat staff!! read more

I kinda wish the descriptions that accompany the star ratings with Yelp had something between 3 stars, (A-OK), and two stars, (Meh I've experienced better.) In my opinion this place fits squarely in-between.the twain. Due, (I hope). to the hour, 2:15 P.M. on a weekday, the place was just this side of deserted. The sign at the reception kiosk said "Seat Yourself", and we did, and also grabbed menus as we passed the station. Basically true to it's name, not much beyond the two Italian categories. A few salads and a few sandwiches, most with an Italian Genesis. A "Wheat" crust option under the personal pizzas caught my eye. Call me a stickler, but I kinda think ALL their crusts and noodles were made from wheat, as ther was no proud exclamation of "gluten-free" anywhere to be seen! I asked the waitress if they were attempting to say "Whole wheat", and she confirmed my suspicion. So that's what I ordered, the lady ordered their luncheon pasta plate which, when it arrived 15 minutes before my pizza, (have you heard of timing the service MR. Pangrazio?), was comprised of a quite small salad bowl of pasta in a "meat sauce" that forgot the meat and a few freshly baked bread knots with dipping sauce. The lady is not a huge consumer of protein, so it's total absence left her unphased. My tardy pizza arrived when she was nicely completing her dining experience, and, as one must do with bread at the grocery, one must check the fine print. Based simply on the color of the crust, it might have contained some whole-wheat, but it certainly was not entirely whole-wheat, unless it was bleached-whole wheat, which is difficult to come by. Nonethess, it was a fairly light and airy, and not exactly "thin" crust as the waitress described, indeed it was medium crust at the least and thick to some. While somewhat sparse, the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Service for the entire room was left to a single waitress, and while stretched, was just this side of marginally adequate, If we were to return, it would not be with any excited anticipation, just a means to a full belly. and a nonplussed palate. read more

This place has changed good and bad over the years. This past visit here was exceptional! I LOVE the pasta and cheese sticks. The house salad dressing is great. The service is very good. I have never had a wait here. I enjoy stopping in when I am in town. read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

See all

Pangrazio Pizza 3rd street in Dover,Ohio has great pizza,spaghetti and salads.. affordable prices

Great pasta,pizza and cheese stix. Menu is small but if traditional Italian is what you're looking for it fills the bill. Perfect for the whole family. read more

Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House - Pizza Near Me - Dover, Ohio

Good pizza only the sauce is sweet I'm not about that but it does taste good won't lie here, price a bit high for what you get but this is my opinion, take it as you will read more

Ordered their Gluten Free pizza well they made a mistake and I ate a regular pizza. I have celiac. Well I spent the night in misery in the bathroom. All I got was Sorry. Not looking for anything Butt. That is not a mistake to make owning a restaraunt. EDUCATE your staff on what a mistake like that can do to a person. It is serious. Oh and thanks for your concern and not even calling me to make sure I was alive. As you seemed concerned at the time. I will never set foot in the place again. read more

Web states that they are open until 10:30pm. Called at 8:45pm on a Thursday and they answered and said that they were closed and taking no carry out orders. read more

Ok place - good for families. My husband and I went here on date night and I was disappointed that I could not have a glass of wine - no alcoholic beverages served here. Cheese breadsticks ok, pasta so so, southwest chicken pizza best dish we had. Service was fine- ok place overall just not really a date night destination. read more

Nice environment and good food. Grew up loving Pangrazios pizza in Dennison. Yelp says my review is too short so here are some more words.

The pizza here is thin. The service is a little slow. We had the pepperoni pizza and buffalo chicken pizza. We liked then both The buffalo chicken pizza wasn't very spicy and the chicken wasnt that great but the atmosphere is nice and clean. The pepperoni pizza sauce was a little sweet. I will be going back to try other things on their menu. read more

The variety of food here is severely lacking. If you have a meat lover in your family, don't go here. They only really serve pasta and pizza. Other than that I think the service is normal. read more

We were served salad, pasta and pizza. Salad was delicious, fresh fresh fresh with grated cheese olives and tomatoes. The homemade pasta sauce was so yummy I used my pizza and homemade bread to sop up every last drop. Ended the meal with a strawberry torte of sorts. So delightful!!! Will definitely eat hear next time I am in town. read more

This restaurant had great service. The food tasted amazing. Highly recommend the lasagna.

I was very pleased with the food and service. Wait staff was kind and courteous, impressing me throughout the night. It's a family restaurant after all, and some woman at the other table was trying to have drinks. I don't bring my kids out to eat so they can be around that kind of environment. If you want to have drinks, got to a bar, please. read more