I've always had a good time here. The deluxe pizza and roast beef sandwich are by far my favorites. Went in the other day and had a tasty deluxe pizza for lunch with some peppercorn ranch. read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - Deluxe no mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

See all

Delicious food and I feel this location makes the best sandwiches out of all the other Papa Vito's in the Belleville area. Recommend for sure.. pics included read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - House salad is large and in charge.. delicious - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

See all

Papa Vito's is one of the few choices for late lunch in Millstadt. It proved to be a good choice no matter. Prices are very reasonable. Casual atmosphere, but plenty of seating. Service was great. I'm a huge fan of a bready dough for my pizza pick, so the thin crust was not really appealing for me. It was also very hard to cut through as if old. The topping was very tasty. read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - Mushroom, pepperoni 16" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

We love Papa Vito's in Millstadt! We always have good service, the food has never failed us. I'm obsessed with the Vito's Garden Salad and their peppercorn ranch is the best I've had. Their pizzas are STL thin crust style, and the pizza sauce is on the sweeter side, but we really enjoy the balance of flavors. It's one of our favorite places in Millstadt! read more

Pizza, salad and sandwiches are excellent. Large portions and especially like roast beef sandwich

Food is amazing!! I've been to three locations and the food is great at all of them. Service was fine, we did get warm beers because they had to refill the kegs and the kegs are out in the shed. That would have been nice to know so we could have ordered something else. read more

See all

Table service was great. The food was good. However too much cheese topping for me. The sauce had a great taste. Recommend well cheese. Ty! Comfortable environment. read more

Food is consistently great each time. Service was extremely friendly which was welcomed. The restaurant was clean and had everything needed to enjoy some pizza and salad. read more

We got our drinks fast, the bread sticks were good. But the pizza sauce was to sweet. My server nice and refilled our drinks when they were empty. Overall though a good experience. read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - Pizza was good - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

Just read a customer comment advising not to order to go from this location. I wish I would have read that before I did. Ordered a French dip sandwich to go. Asked if they would put mayo on the sandwich. I was told they don't do that. What? Employee went to check with the manager who happened to be on the phone with the owner. She came back and confirmed no mayo would be put on my sandwich. I did get mayo packets, but I find this so incredibly odd. To top it off, the sandwich was just okay. Nothing to rave about. Will I come back to this location? Not sure based on the comments about food quality below. I prefer the Belleville location over this one. read more

We have a tradition of stopping by Papa Vito's before or after visiting the Milstadt Eckert's each year, and it's always something to look forward to. The cheese-stuffed breadsticks have always been fresh and rich and are a great appetizer to the St. Louis-style thin-crust pizza. On yesterday's visit, we enjoyed a combo 14" pizza - half Hawaiian and half Buffalo Chicken with ranch on the side. Both halves were an incredibly cheesy, flavorful treat. The service is also always attentive and friendly each time we stop in. We'll definitely be back on our next trip to Eckert's. read more

Service was excellent. Garlic cheese bread never disappoints. The pizza, however, not so good. It tasted like they used butter sauce instead of red pizza sauce. I asked the waitress if they used butter sauce, she said no, maybe it was the cheese. Cheese? Buttery cheese goes on popcorn not pizza. Tasted like a whole stick was on the pizza. Now I have leftovers that probably will go to waste. :( read more

I have always loved Papa Vito's and we always try to order it when we were in town. Last week we ordered it for my grandchildren., I went to pick it up and I was told that it wasn't quite ready and I needed to pull to other window. I pulled up to the window and waited about 10 minutes. They gave me my pizza and I left. When I got home, over have the pizza was burned so badly that it was not edible. We had some other things going on so I didn't take it back or call. It was the worst take out pizza I have ever had and we won't be going back, even though it has always been my favorite read more

This was the first time going to the location. We ordered the Cheesy Garlic Bread, and 2 16" Pizzas. The Garlic Bread was easily the savior for this trip. The flavor of the the bread was amazing, and the crispy outside and soft warm interior made it worth going. The pizza on the other hand was a little bland and could use some better sauce. They also didn't offer beer buckets or pitchers, so that was a bummer. Pro tip: Dip your pizza in the marinara sauce that comes with the Garlic Bread. read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - Half cheese pizza, half sausage onion and mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

See all

All the rest of the Papa Vito's are Amazing. This one is not. The employees are run by the son that doesn't care. The servings here are small. And whatever you do don't order from this one to go. read more

Is it customary in the 21st Century to charge a fee to place an order online? I won't be patronizing any businesses that do this. read more

Papa Vito's - Millstadt - $2 fee to place an order for pickup online? That's seems ridiculous. - Pizza Near Me - Millstadt, Illinois

I have never met more rude people. The staff was unhappy to be working and they treaded our large party awful. I would not recommend eating here. read more

Great food. I love their salads and meat lover pizza, but I hate how slow they are preparing an order. Gone are are the days 30 mins or less. If they could figure that out, they could earn that extra star read more

Great place to take family! Great service every time!!! Love the food!!! Manager was super nice!.

All the food is good. Little higher than most places. You get the best quality. There is no other pizza like theirs. All other items are good too. read more

Love the BLT salad! Great pizza if you enjoy a cracker crust you're in luck. We love the sandwiches especially the French Dip.

My friend called in for a pick up and when I arrived I had to wait while one if the workers took a customer's order. Meanwhile two other workers just stood behind the counter doing nothing. When I was finally helped they gave me the wrong pizza. I was almost home when I got a call saying I received the wrong order. I had to turn back around and to get the correct pizza. They didn't even apologize. When I finally arrived back home an hour later the pizza was cold. Awful service. read more

We were sent here for lunch. We were told to order a salad and pizza. We were told the portions were huge. We got there around 1ish and they had many tables filled. We were immediately seated and Patty was our server. Our order consisted of a 9" Deluxe pizza and the Vito's Garden Salad. The portions are HUGE! The salad was fantastic and is large enough to feed 4-6 people. We split the 9" (loaded with toppings) pizza. The toppings and cheese were the perfect proportions for a complete meal! Patty provided awesome service from start to finish. I highly recommend this local restaurant! Thank you for the great meal and experience!!! read more

Amazing!!! Awesome service, good food! Worth the drive from St. Louis! We'll be back.

Papa's pizza is hands down my favorite pizza in the world. With that being said I am from Waterloo where the original Papa's is. I live out of town now and make sure I get Papa's at least once every time I come back home. Unfortunately the Waterloo location was closed while the family went on vacation and because of this we ordered from Millstadt. This was the first time I have tried their location and I must say that while it is still very good, it didn't taste the same. I don't know if it's because I am biased or what but that old oven at the Waterloo location just did it better in my mind. We had the deluxe, BBQ chicken, salad, and toasted ravioli and it was all still good and very much worth it. read more

Sooooo many complaints, but who puts "pre" cooked bacon as the first topping on the pizza. I don't want half raw, stringy bacon underneath my pizza. Also don't want half cooked dough, it's dusgusting. "Worlds best pizza" on the to-go box instantly means don't trust the business. Try Papa Johns owner (sadly from "Sicily") because you don't have the first idea of your pie. Don't start me on the t-ravs or "cheese bread". It's all bad. Please don't waste time on this overpriced POS called "Italian restaurant" save your money and order Dominos (which I hate) or Papa John's because it's better and wayyyyy cheaper! read more

My last time at Vito's. Walked in at 6:50 after checking to make sure they were open and they turned us away. Mind you the place was half full. And then they suggested we order food to go. I'm done! read more

It's New Years Eve. We were coming from Waterloo so we called first to make sure they were open. The lady on the phone assured me they were. We came in and they said they are closed. The room was filled with people and they said they Re not taking any more one in guests. I shared that we had called first and came from Waterloo. They didn't seem to care. I have been here many times but won't be back. read more

Food is always good. Friendly staff. Stuffed cheese bread and salads are our favorite!

Went to this location for the first time 2-6-19... and there will be plenty more visit in the future. The restaurant was very clean, the staff was exceptional and the food was GREAT. We ordered the French dip and the Chef salad, both had large portions and were very good quality. This is the second location we have been to and have mentioned both of them to anyone who would listen. So this seemed the next logical step to spread the word of a great dining experience that is very reasonably priced. read more