Highly recommended!!!!!…read more Been here several times since moving to SC from NY. Definitely the best place we've found south of Brooklyn. Good is great and even more importantly, it's great consistently. The counter staff is always friendly and quick to get you your food. Everything is always spot on, including their homemade Italian ices. More importantly, those ices are available all year long. For anyone who knows good Italian ices, Cucinella's definitely compares to the likes of Marino's. This place has a great NYC pizza joint vibe. Simple yet awesome decor, my kinda music playing discretely in the background. Low enough to enjoy a conversation over lunch but loud enough to hear. Best of all, you can buy a pie (a pizza pie) whole or by the slice. If you're in the area, it would be worth your stopping in. Enjoy!!!

I'm not sure what the hype is about. This pizza really isn't very good. Maybe a bit better than…read moreLittle Caesar's but absolutely not even in the same time zone as NY pizza. Keep in mind, NY style isn't even my favorite style, If the pizza is good, it's good. This was meh. I am being really generous with the three stars. It wasn't horrible. I had the cheese pizza because that's the way to tell how good the pizza is. The cheese tasted like Sysco bulk cheese. The sauce has almost no flavor. The crust was bland but not horrible. I think the frozen pizza from Kroger has more flavor. I thought I got covid again it was so bland. I hate to be so critical of a family owned business and I generally don't blast a place I am trying for the first time. The best thing I can say about this place is that they have a variety of toppings, though I didn't try them.

Listen up, everyone! As a 100% Italian, I'm one of the few people here qualified to give this place…read morea proper review . People complain about it being too soggy, undercooked, or lacking toppings--absolute nonsense. This is a perfectly authentic Italian pizza. If you know good food, you know this is the kind of quality you usually only find in top-tier restaurants in major cities like LA or NY, or back in Italy itself. It is absolutely worth every penny. Sure, you can go to a chain and pay half the price, but you're just paying for unrisen dough, low-quality ingredients, and zero wood-fired aroma. To top it all off, our waitress was great and the pizzas came out incredibly fast, even with the place being packed. This is the real deal. And no, they didn't pay me for this review LOL

Review response: Wow…read moreCliff, your response speaks volumes as to your loyalty to customers you know have been loyal to you. You don't get to change the narrative. If you were to review the video of our transaction last night, you would have quickly noticed, my husband had no reason to hide anything. We were not aware of your strict policies of bringing in anything from the outside and would not have done it if it had not been for a medical emergency. We didn't call ADA, just called you out for the rude way voiced your request. A video review and customers in your establishment can quickly confirm my husband put the can down on your counter when speaking with your hostess and only picked it up to sit and wait for a table to be cleaned. You then proceeded tell us to leave, you did not accept outside trash and you sold refreshments there. I would have had much more respect if you could have genuinely apologized for the error, which despite your claim, is not what you did yesterday or in your response below. Thank you for your input. Original review: We overlooked poor customer service for years because we loved the pizza at Apizza Di Napoli. Last night changed that. My husband is a Type 1 diabetic and his blood sugar was 70 and dropping rapidly just before leaving forthe restaurant. He drank a Sprite while I drove us to treat the low, and to provide time to be seated and to order food while avoiding a medical emergency. We unfortunately brought the can inside with him. Even after we explained the medical situation, the owner refused to let us enter or seat us with the can, which was now empty as there was a wait to be seated, and showed no compassion or understanding. In fact, he was downright rude about it. We were weekly customers, ordering take out so frequently that they didn't have to ask our name when we picked it up but after this experience, we won't be back. Great pizza doesn't make up for poor treatment of loyal customers.

Stopped by Nikki's Pizza today on a rainy afternoon and had one of those unexpectedly great…read moreexperiences. I walked up with my dog planning to tie him to a light post while I ran inside to order, but before I could even get to the door the manager noticed us and invited us to wait in a covered alcove so my dog could stay dry and comfortable. It immediately made me feel welcome. While waiting, I grabbed a drink ,.. they have cocktails, draft beer, and bottled options ....and the whole place had such an easygoing, friendly vibe. The pizza itself was the real deal: true New York-style and absolutely delicious. Great people, great atmosphere, and food that lives up to it. I'll definitely be coming back.

Lately, Nicky's has become our "Go to" when we're hungry for a tasty pizza, and our last visit did…read morenot disappoint. Nicky's is on Main Street and though one might be worried about parking, there are plenty of spaces available. We parked in the lot by the Ice House Amphitheater. Our friends got a spot right in front of the restaurant. Our server was pleasant and after initially being seated by the window, we requested a move closer to the fire place. We ordered our usual: Grandma's with sausage and mushrooms on one half. When the pie arrived after about 15 minutes, it looked great. The sauce at Nicky's is a bit tangy and slightly sour, which we prefer. The crust is thin and slightly crunchy with a nice chew included. The large pie is cut in eight pieces, so each is us got two nice sized slices. The restaurant is cozy and features two dining areas. There are loots of pizza places to choose from and Nicky's is too good not to check out.

Food was great! The meatball & chicken parm sandwiches were really tasty. Great bread…read more Service was friendly. It's a hole in the wall kinda place but the food makes it a great spot. FYI there's a 4% surcharge for credit cards. Other than that, GREAT!

I wanted to try both things and both were fantastic. They make their own meatballs and the flavor…read moreis on point. The lemon chicken could be a little more lemony but the chicken is super tender and the sauce clings nicely to the noodles. The pasta is perfectly cooked, not mushy. Be patient, because each dish is cooked to order so perfection is going to take a few minutes!

Probably the best pizza there is around Lexington/Columbia area, quick, good price, and always…read moreright around the corner no matter where you are in Lexington. Tuesdays are pizza day in the household without exception and always fresh every time.

Fantastic service, consistently delicious NY style pizza. We are hooked on this place and love…read morecoming here!

We went here on our families recommendation to cater our grandsons first birthday. Food was…read moreincredible and Brian was so helpful and generous which is exactly why we buy local. If you have an occasion or small gathering the pizza and wings deal are incredible and you will not be disappointed. Other prices were double and with the wing chips and breads it was so much food and everyone took some home it was so good! Their sweet tea was a big hit too! These people are all amazing so support a local business - we will be there again before we head back home! Thank you Brian and staff we appreciate you all!

Everything's great and the service is wonderful we try to eat it every week and adding breakfast…read moreand dinners too!

I called on my way home from work and ordered a large cheesesteak sub with extra cheese, extra…read moreonion and mushrooms. They said it was a 30 minute wait. Fine. I get there early and wait in my car and go in to pick up my cheese steak sub and they have nothing. First they had me go out to my car and get my phone to prove that I called the order in!!! which I proved and then nobody remembered taking my order So I verbally gave my order to the girl at the counter, a large steak and cheese sub with extra cheese, extra onions and mushrooms. I wait for them to make it and she tells me it's ready. I walk up to the counter and there's a pizza box there!!! At this point I'm starving and fed up so I just take the pizza, say "that's fine", and I go. They also made me pay for it!!!!!!! When I got home, I opened the pizza box to a large pizza with extra extra extra cheese, onions and a sprinkle of mushrooms! Absolutely no steak!!!!!! With red sauce on the side! So now I'm having cheese for dinner. I don't know what they couldn't understand, but I'm not going back here ever!

Absolutely horrible service. The staff, aside from the cook, were extremely rude and speaking about…read moreus behind the counter. I simply walked up, asked if my pizza was ready, and the girl at the front walked away. I have trouble hearing, not sure if she even said anything to me, but then proceeded to talk with the other girls in the back about how it's not a good day for me to "try her" and that I didn't need to stand at the counter. Mind you, I never once was told anything about my pizza or asked to wait, she just walked away. The pizza is good, but the customer service is HORRIBLE

Pizza was ok but my gosh this place is terrifying when you pull up. It looks abandoned. There are…read morecats living and being fed on the patio. The sign was completely burnt out and faded. Landscape was overgrown. There was not a single diner inside but they had a full lunch buffet set up. Hostess who took my order and brought my food was extremely professional and friendly.

Nice place, very nice people here. Pizza was fresh and hot. Great service, despite of the place…read morelooking abandoned from the outside. Thank you.

Called in an order for a pepperoni pizza. The staff was great, and even called back when the pizza…read morewas ready for pick up as we were running a few minutes late. Plenty of easy free parking. The pizza was three star. The dough was a little thicker than I like, and a few too many herbs and spices in the sauce. Definitely a good spot to grab a pizza if you are in Elloree (or Santee State Park).

From the owner: We cook all food to order!read more

In town for a college visit, tired but in the mood for pizza!! Absolutely delicious! The garlic…read morebread and salads amazing! Then they had this fantastic Italian beer I never had before! Love it! We googled for an hour and so happy we picked this place!

Food was great! We grabbed a seat at the bar and ordered a few items. Proportional, filling and…read morefresh. Pricey but worth it. My only complaint is it's an hour+ away from us. Keep up the good work!