1. Party Thyme Catering Columbus

    0

    ,

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Party Thyme Catering Columbus

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    Party Thyme Catering Columbus Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Party Thyme Catering Columbus

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Party Thyme Catering Columbus

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Jerry Mikeskas BBQ & Catering

    Jerry Mikeskas BBQ & Catering

    (161 reviews)

    $

    I was there on a Sunday when they had the turkey special... It was the moistest, most delicious…read moreturkey that I've ever had. But, what stood out was the carrots and potatoes that were not just add-ons, but delicious dishes on their own. The coleslaw which is always my favorite of any category was as good as it gets. Everyone is talking about how expensive barbecue is nowadays... this was very inexpensive and I carried some out.

    I had always wanted to stop here for decades driving by. Today I finally did it. I ordered a two…read moremeat plate with three sides and for my spouse and I it was $30 which is a fabulous value in times like these. Portions were generous. Brisket was lean and lacked flavor to me. Sausage was straight forward and solid. The bbq sauce was a bit of an off texture to me with a sweet side I don't love. But the stars of my plate that got the 4th star were the potato salad and the banana pudding. Potato salad was glorious texture, temperature, just the right amount of tang from a mustard and pickle vinegar element, rustic with red potato rind, the right amount of cracked black pepper and I would have liked to have eaten on that for days!! The banana pudding was just right. Like straight from grandma's kitchen - perfect texture, flavor, a fresh banana slice buried inside, and a softened vanilla wafer garnish. I love that you could get it as a side with my plate. Also would have liked a Giant margarine container of that in the fridge to eat on all weekend.

    Nancy's Steak House - Garlic Parmesan chicken wings

    Nancy's Steak House

    (147 reviews)

    $$

    4.5 While exploring Columbus, we decided to check out this…read moresteak house. We were seated right away and had no issues with service. The waitress was excellent about helping me with my gluten-free issue. The menu does have several items that are specifically marked GF, but with the hamburger, you can opt for no bun and a lettuce wrap. Now their fries are not gluten-free, but you can get the baked potato, which was really good. They didn't even upcharge me. Very nice! I got refills on my drink to so that's pretty awesome in my book. We got there at opening, and it started to fill up as we left.

    I have read the reviews and they are all over the place. We came to celebrate my son's kickboxing…read morecompetition. We love to try new places while on the road. We were hesitant with the scores, but steak is steak. The place has a weird western theme. I can't quite explain it but I will try. It's like cowboy, but not modern, but not to old, but like early 2000s old? I give up. The staff were amazing!! Polite, and checked on us constantly. It wasn't too empty, but still surprised it wasn't more crowded on the weekend. They stared us off with two rolls of bread and butter. I loved it! The midget not so much. He isn't a fan of any non white bread. Oh well there was two for me! We started off with a wrapped shrimp and chicken appetizer. Ok so I will start with this. For the price we were expecting more than 4 pieces. Yet they were amazing! Perfectly cooked and seasoned. The bed of thinly cut onion rings underneath was a great idea! The only thing we didn't like was a pinkish sauce that tasted a little like thousand island. Just no..... I had the boss top 12 oz medium rare, with a grilled chicken salad, and a side of green beans. The midget had the Nancys cheeseburger. First my steak was cooked perfectly! The only gripe was that it was under seasoned. It needed salt and pepper. The green beans on the side.. I've never had them like this. Grilled and seasoned. They were delicious! Had a snap and very well seasoned! The salad was fresh and the chicken was great. I threw on some of the fried onion from our appetizer and it was WOW! His burger was good. Again just missing the seasoning on the patty. Great bun and ratio of beef to veggies. Tons of fries. For us it was semi affordable. Other than the quantity of the appetizer, we were ok with the portions and prices. If the seasoning on the meats was better may have considered a 5 maybe. We may visit in the future if in the area.

    Party Thyme Catering Columbus - catering - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...