Adopted a cat from the rescue they work with. Worked with Beckie and Marilyn. They were amazing! Then once we got into the store the employees were so helpful and gave us as much time as we needed and answered any questions we had! Sophie was phenomenal! 10/10 would recommend!! read more

Sophia was amazing!!! I was having such a stressful day with getting my cat fixed and then treating my two dogs and my cat for fleas and she made the process so simple and easy and even went in the back to look in the boxes for that was not on the shelf she's an awesome employee and loves Jesus too!!! I asked her if she was a Christian because CHRISTS love oozed out of her!!! thank you so much Sophia for helping me out so much and making my day easier and brighter!!!! read more

Worst customer service ever ! My husband and I came to buy a snake. We wanted to see it but because the girl with the short hair was so rude and didn't even acknowledge me We left We love animals and have been to many pet stores Don't bother coming to this store. As we were leaving the store we told the employees in the front they didn't care either Who ever is running this store needs to have a word with the staff as a business owner myself I feel bad and think you should know what's going on I wouldn't want my staff treating the customers like this behind me my back read more

Always a great experience with friendly staff! Pickup orders make it easy but my pup also loves stopping in for a visit! read more

Pet Supplies Plus Upper Arlington - Pet Stores Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

I submitted an application to adopt a cat. The employees said nobody had put an application in yet. I called to follow up on my application and was notified that someone else had adopted the cat and I was never notified. This is a shady business and I would highly recommend not using them. read more

So much to love about Pet Supplies Plus... Kind & knowledgeable staff who are accessible & helpful. Extensive inventory & selection of everything our furry friends could ever want or need from freeze-dried food that my cat needed due to a dental issue to a great variey of accessories for any house pet to the newest toys. Great location with ample parking. Animals allowed! Be sure to stop by & visit with the cats from Colony Cats that are seeking their fur-ever homes! (I LOVE this!!!) Lots of coupons for those who sign up for their free rewards card! read more

See all

My favorite pet store. The staff is wonderful. The inventory is extensive (over the years our family has had a broad spectrum of pets!) The prices are great. You can bring your pet with you to help select new toys, and they keep a treat at the register for them. For a discount on your first order you can, you can sign up for their newsletter. Today, I ordered on line and they brought the order out to the car.... So easy since i had ordered several heavy items. They are also offering free delivery for orders than $35. read more

Great selection of food and toys with competitive prices! Always have nice and attentive staff as well !

I recently had a situation where what I ordered wasn't in stock. I had a coupon only good for one day. I spoke with Madison about it, not only did she cancel my initial order without any issues she also ordered what I needed, honored the coupon and called me to tell me when it arrived! This level of customer service has been missing since before COVID and I appreciate her going above and beyond! It really was refreshing, thanks Madison!! read more

This pet store always has what I need and it has very nice workers. I always come here for my pet food. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Love this location! Caitlin and Alex are always so helpful! Always a great experience in store, pick up or delivery. Thanks PSP :o)

They are very helpful and helping with me with my Fisk tank needs. very friendly staff and the young man who helped me I really appreciate him!!!! read more

Like it, love it! Cheap pet treats and toys. I get my dog's food somewhere else, because they don't carry the brand he eats. With everything else, they have hands down the best prices. This store is huge. They cover pet needs for most animals: dogs, cats, birds, fish, reptiles (not sure the limits on this one). When I shop, I like to compare. Here, because it is so large, there's space enough for top of the line items as well as true discount products. Sometimes it matters and sometimes, it really doesn't....a toy my dog will destroy in two days does not need to be more than $10. Quality dog food, now that's where we splurge. read more

Pet Supplies Plus Upper Arlington - Pet Stores Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

As always, delivery is a great experience with PSP. I my store!

This is my dog Hank's favorite place. He is always treated kindly and with respect and ALWAYS given a treat when he leaves. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. It's worth the trip to do business with them. Great service is hard to come by anymore. Keep up the great work! Hank loves you! read more

This pet store was very disappointing. Small selections and the aquariums were DISGUSTING. The ferrets were also just hanging out in trash around storage boxes. read more

Items in stock and they even carried them to my car. The staff is always friendly and offer the dogs a treat at checkout.

This place is such a nice spot we ran across this afternoon. The staff was very friendly and engaging. They treated my dog Rio like a queen the moment we walked in. And asked many times if we needed assistance which we did. Very appreciated and we will be coming here for now on. Not a big franchise read more

I went in Friday the 23rd and I think the manager helped me.... I asked if I was missing where my dog food was and he informed me that they stopped carrying it. I told him I would just look for treats then. He came back to where I was in the store and offered to help me find another dog food for my dog. He gave me great advice about switching and my dogs stomach issues. He told me all about pumpkin and even helped me out with that too! Great customer service! He kept me as a customer And I will continue to shop here even though it is 15 Minutes from my house and there is a Walmart 1 Minute away. Great service! Thank you for your help!!! read more

Very friendly staff. Loved the convenience of curbside pick up, AND their prices were better than other stores! Definitely will go back.

Such a good store! They had everything I needed when I was getting supplies for my leopard gecko, and their live insects seem healthy, and my gecko loves them. read more

Life saver during COVID...my mom has dementia and I can't change her supplies. They saved me twice. Thank you!

This is my second home delivery during COVID and the team does a great job getting my order right and delivered as promised.. my pup thanks you! read more

My body doesn't take well to fur babies so I got a fishy baby named Tito. He needed some accessories and food today so I jumped on Yelp and found this location of Pet Supplies just up the road from me. It was easy to get to and there was plenty of parking. I walked in and was greeted right away by the staff at the registers. It was easy to find the fish department so I browsed for a while before picking out a nice plant for Tito. They had a good bit of options plant wise, but nothing I've never seen before. Everything was reasonably priced and seemed clean, except for the average dead fish floating around but honestly that's normal. Once I had a plant picked out someone was there to help bag it up for me. The cashier was delightful and we joked about credit card machines always being a pain in the butt. I'll be back when I'm in need of something urgent for Tito but I am going to explore some stores that specialize more in fish. Mainly because I know the selection will be better. read more

Pet Supplies Plus Upper Arlington - All the fishy accessories! - Pet Stores Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

This is my favorite place in the area to shop for my pets. They are always having greats sales, but more importantly, I've never met a rude worker. Cyndi, the cashier, goes out of her way to get me whatever I need, even offering to personally drive to another store to get me a tank that they no longer had in stock. 10/10 read more

We went to the washing station here and it was amazing. It has hooks to hook on your dogs collar, oatmeal shampoo, and it even has a drying tube. Also, they give you towels at the front. $14 for a bath, not bad. read more

Pet Supplies Plus must do great business given location, location and location to the Upper Arlington neighborhoods. Entering a consumer must be blown away by selection, especially in pet foods. Just a huge offering in aisle after aisle. PSP's animal and fish selections are minimal. I was there to try and find driftwood, spiderwood and rocks for terrariums. I struck out but I gotta state for the record one of the employees went out of her way to show me their inventory. The level of sales service seemed very high and that's unusual nowadays given online buying. A-OK for Pet Supplies Plus is a solid plug for a business. I didn't buy a darn thing but sales/service is good. Try it out. read more

I will never go to another store. Selection is great and staff is always friendly and helpfu! Their customer service is above any other stores! read more

Update: This location is absolutely incredible! Today I had to get a lot of supplies to home an abused and neglected stray cat. I have two cats of my own so I needed a cage; something big enough to house a cat with all its basic necessities as well as play space. I'm not sure if he was the manager or not, but when I was explaining my situation, obviously in distress, he knocked off about $50 off my total fee. I bought a large size dog crate (the one that holds up to 90lbs), a feeding bowl, a water bowl, a small litter pan, and two toys. The cage alone was $130 and my *total* was $140! The best service I've ever had! This location truly cares about animal welfare and now my poor stray kitty is sleeping warm and cozy in her temporary home. I've also brought in two fish that weren't getting along in my tank and one of their amazing employees actually took them home! He updated me today and said they're doing great! I love this location and their staff. They should be recognized! I'd recommend this place to anyone! read more

I'm not sure if this is the only location in Columbus, it's the only one I've seen or been to. I actually forgot about it being here until I had to buy my hedgehogs some food and Walmart didn't have anything that Your Highness's would touch with a Hedgie toe. I seriously need to stop patronizing that monopoly anyways. But I digress. The Pet Supplies Store was as I remembered it. Kind of cozy feeling, like the pet supplies store version of Trader Joes. The check out lines are set up similarly. I like that when I came here I was looking for three different types of premium cat food and every single one was here a few were even on sale( you need a in store card to get the sale price like at most every store now) So although I did want to cry at the total ( these hedgehogs better appreciate this. They eat better than my cat does!) the total was at least marginally less heart attack inducing. I like that they have some cool small animals available here as well as a section for fish. I didn't check to see if they had both saltwater and fresh though. I will check that out next time read more

Pet Supplies Plus Upper Arlington - The foods I squired for thy Hedgehog Highness's - Pet Stores Near Me - Upper Arlington, Ohio

See all

Two words: Buffalo sticks! My Scottie puppy would need a straight jacket without them! (so would I) I got my rabbit, Buttercup, here. She was a free, rescued bun with soft brown eyes and gentle demeanor that is the love of my life. They carry tropical fish to ferrets. Fat little hamsters to slimy crawly things. Staff are helpful and managers knowledgeable. Dog coats, sweaters and all manner of dog food n treats. Wellness, Merrick, Nutro and more. There are brands of food here that you won't find in conventional pet stores. We need to think about what we feed our best buds, research appropriate brands and know what we're feeding them. Also know where the ingrdients are sourced from. The staff here can help with that. The prices are resonable when compared with other pet stores and there are several locations around the city. You can find supplies for dogs, cats, rodents, ferrets, rabbits, fish, etc... Cages, crates, leashes, collars, i.d. tags, toys, chews and bath supplies even for rabbits and ferrets! Phew, I think I covered just about everything! So, great prices, several locations, supplies aplenty and a knowledgable, caring staff, what's not to love :) And buffalo chews, can't forget them! Keeps my scottie out of trouble,out of the straight jacket and me out of the looney bin! read more

Love Pet Supplies Plus! Their staff is always friendly and helpful! Great prices and products!

Fast and easy pick up of the order. Will definitely use online ordering in the future. Staff was friendly and loading the bags into my car without issues. read more

This is a great store. They always have what I need and prices are excellent with their member card. I have used their vet visit service for microchipping and the price was better than I had paid previously at other places. The vet staff were great with the animals. The retail staff usually can direct me and are knowledgeable about stock. They have special ordered stuff I needed although it took quite a while. The manager has also made food or toy donations for local cat shelter as long as I made the request in the time allowed. I go there all the time. Only problem is I don't have a mobile device to show emailed coupons. read more

The convenience of online ordering is wonderful. We placed our order, received immediate confirmation, and were notified of its readiness within about an hour. Upon arrival at the store we received our dog food in a matter of minutes. As older, retired customers, we appreciate not having to go into stores during the pandemic. Pet Supplies Plus can't be beat for availability of product as well as low prices and discounts. read more

This store is always a pleasure to do business with. They always seem to have plenty of inventory, neatly stocked and clean. From the manager on down, every employee has been a pleasure to be around. Prices are very competitive and a convenient location. read more

I came here to get supplies for my new kitten. I was getting a kitten that afternoon and it was the first time I've ever owned a pet. Erica at the store was absolutely tremendous. She was so helpful and so knowledgeable about everything that I would need and extremely patient with me. I could not have asked for a better experience. This will be the only pet store that I go to for everything that I need. read more

New dog = obsessive compulsive buying of dog treats, toys etc. Oh and guess what there is a place where others like me gather, huzzah! We adopted a Bulldog/Pitbull mix named Leo from Open Arms rescue (shout out), and needed to get him all checked out. On the weekends they have a mobile vet clinic, get there early as the place gets crowded. The best part of waiting in line is petting all of the other lovely creatures. That is besides the point, cheap treats, great selection of collars, leashes and clothes. We got a rad pet fountain that mimics a stream of running water for $16! Customer service could use a little work, the checkout peeps are just a tad grumpy. read more

I was trying to get everything I need for a new puppy. I have a disorder where I can't walk for long. I wanted to have everything ready for the new puppy though. I had to put everything back, which they helped me do. I was very sad as I thought I wouldn't be able to get a dog now. They told me about their "click it and pick it up" service where you can order what you need online and they will bring it to your car. They couldn't have been nicer or more knowledgeable. read more

This is the only pet store I visit. They have a specific cat litter I like, that no one else carries. Parking is easy, and prices are reasonable. Plus, the staff is always so nice and helpful. They always help me load up my car, even if I don't ask. They are always partnering with local shelters for events and donations, which is always a nice bonus. read more