My wife and I have a tradition where we go find the best pizza places on Fridays after work. We usually shoot for the brick oven style of pizza and we have been doing this for years now. Peyton's is our number 1 go to place. We always circle back to this place. Great staff, great service, small town flair, and the best pizza all around!!! Thanks Peyton. read more

I live in Dacula and was excited about a new pizza place and drive 45 minutes. It was a Monday night and only 3 persons were in the restaurant. The hostess was very nice. It was about an hour before closing. I went simple with just a pepperoni and mushroom to go. When I got home to share it with my wife, over half of the pizza was completely charred on the bottom (see photo). Maybe the owner cares more about all the rest of what he owns more than this place, hard to know. read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Yummy black - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

Fun small town pizza shop where you can customize your pizza or choose their curated menu. Pizzas are cooked in a wood fire own! Service is fast and friendly. read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Pineapple, bbq sauce and grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

Great little pizza joint, warm atmosphere due to woodfire oven with a delicious menu. Wings in Alabama white sauce and pepperoni pizza read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

See all

A friend recommended this spot and we decided to give it a try. The location is on the smaller side. They have a brick oven where they cook all over their goods. The service was good. The food was okay. Garlic bread was on the crispier side, pizza had the good pep. I personally felt like there was something missing. Not a bad eat but felt like a flavor was absent, my personal take of course! read more

See all

I recently moved from New Jersey to Georgia and have been searching for quality pizza ever since. This place in downtown Flowery Branch really delivered. The Classic Peyton Pie was excellent--simple, fresh, and full of flavor. The crust was just the right kind of crispy, and the overall vibe was welcoming. Glad to have found a go-to spot this close to home. read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

Great place. The personal pizzas are a great deal. The lunch server is very friendly and very helpful. Love this place. read more

We stopped in on a Friday evening about 45 mins before close. They were packed, so we got a to go order. The waiter was so nice offered us a see when a table opened and brought us to go waters while we waited on our pie. They have a huge pizza oven that makes the crust so light but crispy. All the toppings were high quality and the pizza was huge! Plenty of leftover for the next days lunch. It is a small place so not a lot of seating. I do wish they had more comfortable seating but still a great pizza. read more

See all

Peyton's Pie Company is a must for anyone wanting a delicious pie and pie options that are familiar as well as different. Although all are great, our favorites are the Supreme Leader as well as My Honey is Hotter Than Yours. With all the pizza options around, Peyton's Pie is by far the best of the best! read more

So disappointing. We got here on a Sunday at lunch and it took us an hour to get our pizza. There was only ONE server, and he was hustling trying to wait on 6 tables with more ppl coming in. After waiting an hour, we finally got our pizza and it was BURNT. We were so hungry that my husband and I each ate a slice but couldn't stomach another bc it was burned so bad. We were only offered a partial refund. read more

Nothing quite like a Peyton Pie, yet another place we will miss once we move to AL. We arrived just before the crowd at 6:00 PM on Friday. Plan ahead, or plan to sit next door as they get busy fast but, they turn the tables pretty fast as well. Our waitress Emily did a fine job all night during our meal. We started with garlic bread with marinara dipping sauce, and she had the consistently tasty wild farm greens salad, her favorite. We also had beer and wine. For our entree, she had the wings with AL white sauce appetizer and I had a greasy New Yorker pie. We alrays enjoy the fresh ingredients and the perfect execution of the brick oven. We really enjoy this place and the people. read more

See all

Fantastic pizza fantastic staff lovely spot to check out if you're in flowery branch! read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

Did NOT live up to the 4.5 star rating. Upon opening up the box the pizza looked good, even liked the char on the crust, however there is absolutely no sauce on this pizza. No brightness, tang, or acidity. It just ends up tasting like charred cheesy bread with meat. Also even though the crust is charred on top the bottom of the pizza is still floppy and very chewy Overall not terrible pizza but I would probably never order from here again. read more

The pizza was okay because the dough made up for it, but something about the sauce was almost too herbal and spicy. It's been a minute since I've gone here, so maybe they've changed the recipe, but it was a very different take on your typical red sauce and unfortunately for me, I can't recommend purely for that reason. Cook on the dough was solid, and the people and service was great. Very small establishment, and not a very immersive dining experience as the decor inside seems very dated and bland. read more

Great pizza and wonderful wings!! Wings are the best around! We highly recommend this place

If I could give this place 10 stars I would. Everything from the atmosphere, customer service and of course food was amazing. Perfect little spot in Flowery Branch. Fresh ingredients makes this place to die for. Crispy fall off the bone wings. Buttery crispy perfect pizza. Meaty tender mushrooms and rosemary oil with basil is just such an amazing treat for you mouth, nose and belly! Friendly and fun staff made me feel like a member of a family. Please if you're in the area give this place a try. You will be happy you did. I'm going back for the pot pie next! read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Wings! - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

See all

Pricey but excellent food. Service was friendly and prompt. Peyton's is casual and friendly.

Have been coming to this location for YEARS. Loved the small town vibe, the hi-top tables and the familiarity .. it's gotten WAAAY to busy, high tops are gone.. toooo many ppl. The pizza had way less pepperoni than original . Food still good.. but the ambiance has changed.. read more

We love this place. The food is wonderful. We always get the garlic cheese bread, my son gets wings, and we get lot's of cheese pizza. The crust is amazing and the Gouda cheese just makes it so much better. I always get in trouble with red sauces like end up in the hospital trouble. But I can honestly tell you I have No idea what they do to their pizza sauce but it's fantastic and I have yet to have an issue with it and we've been coming for a few years now. One of the best parts is no indigestion, that's HUGE!! lol (If you know, you know)verything is absolutely amazing here. They might not look busy at times but take out wise is another story. Service is great it's just at times we've had to wait a little bit due to he seems obsessed with cartoons that they always seem to have on their TV instead of real things. I'd understand it the place was full of small kids but definitely not the issue. ‍ read more

See all

This place is overpriced and arrogant. You cannot get toppings or a decent amount of cheese on their pizza. I've been twice and experienced the same bare crust pizza and arrogant staff. I politely pointed out that there was NO cheese or toppings, just bare crust and received the dreaded "first time" response. Gas station pizza is better than this joint! read more

One of the best pizzas i have had in a while. Love the crust and the staff are great too!

Great pies nice side bar better says to hang out they have karaokes on some days a month very fun

Crust is too thick. Not enough cheese. Service was attentive. Sitting area away from pizza.

We heard great things and decided to give it a try. Do yourself a favor Don't!! Especially if you want to eat in the bar and have a drink as well. I suggest you DONT! Have at least two people working your bar on a Friday!! We ordered a simple second round where all she needed to do was open a bottle and pour. Well she didn't have clean glasses so she offered to pour in the ones we had... well she poured over old ice no offer to give me new ice in a dirty glass. The restaurant side the waitress had an attitude too. Over priced and under impressed!!! DONT BOTHER!! I only had one interaction with the bartender and apparently she fabricated a good lie to the owner read more

See all

The best pizza I have ever eaten, well seasoned, and simply delicious. Highly recommend!

Best pizza in my area! Plan on trying all their pizzas! Fresh ingredients and very good dough!! Love eating the crust as it's crispy and airy!! Good location in Gainesville too! read more

Fantastic pizza! Best crust ever! There is a wide variety of special pizzas and toppings...you won't be C disappointed

Pizza was really tasty. We had the Supreme, and it was delicious. The service was great. We will definitely be back.

My pizza was so good! I got a half cheese half pepperoni well done and it was awesome. Flavorful and exactly how I wanted it. Service was quick and friendly. Overall 10/10 I took the pizza togo and it was ready at the exact time she quoted me over the phone. read more

Great pizza it seemed fresh with nice atmosphere and friendly people. There is a beer place two doors over and you can bring the beer from there into the pizza place. They also have a walk way behind the bathrooms that connects both properties. read more

See all

There is no denying that their pizza is top notch, it's gourmet and superb. We get take out from Peyton's on Sundays (buy one get one 1/2 off day). I love their little pepperonis and the peppadew peppers are addicting. We have ordered from both locations and prefer Flowery Branch, more bang for your buck, the pizzas in Gainesville are smaller for some odd reason. The price point is high, but the quality is high too. read more

I had left a good review a few years ago. Unfortunately, today, we were kicked out of the restaurant. We had our emotional support chihuahua with us. He has been with us every time we have come to dine here. But not today. They have lost a customer for life. NOT DOG FRIENDLY. Avoid if possible. read more

The pizza is authentic brick oven, the service is very friendly and the ambience makes you feel like you were in a pizzeria. It is a secret place in Flowery Branch small Main Street, across from antebellum. You can order any pizza and be happy with it. Service is, happy to accommodate whatever you request. We had the greasy New Yorker, a plain cheese pie, and. a beer, which was cold and delicious. If you have a yearning for pizza, this is a place to go in Flowery Branch, Georgia. I would have given it five stars, but I am a New York pizza snob. i've had Ray's pizza, Joe's pizza, and many others in NY, so believe me when I say this pizza is good. read more

Second time, this time dine in. We were greeted and seated almost immediately. There was one woman working the seating area and she is a rock star. For the pizza it is just average. The pizzas we had the dough wouldn't stand up to the toppings. It was just limp and a little on the soggy side. The sauce is good. Toppings were good but somehow the mushrooms were a little colder than the rest of the pizza. I also expected them to have some white sauce options, but they didn't. I don't have anything overly critical or negative to say, but with other options in the area, this is just middle of the road. There are better options in the area. read more

See all

This is not your average pizza place. The ingredients are fresh and well thought out. There's plenty of sauce, but too much. The cheese is rich, but not overwhelming. The smally greasy pepperoni are by far the best part. Once you have small pepperonis, you can't go back! The wood burning oven gives the whole place a delicious smell. I knew an appetizer was a must! We decided on wings and chose the alabama white BBQ sauce. The wings were large, and the sauce was tangy and creamy. I will gladly get them again. Service was great, although they were busy, we did not wait for drink refills, or food. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Used to be so good, this was our go-to pizza place, but now it's so thin, undercooked and greasy we couldn't eat it. Too expensive to throw in the trash, but we just had to. There was no salvaging it, we tried. Never again. Why would you think this is okay to serve to people? Awful! read more

The pizza at Peyton's is always great, hot, and flavorful. Definitely try this place if you're in the area. The greasy New Yorker is so good! read more

Peyton's Pie Company - Pizza Near Me - Flowery Branch, Georgia

First time here, staff was very welcoming. Location is very quaint and plenty of parking around little flowery branch downtown. Was a little Smokey from the oven, I didn't mind it , just made me hungrier. They had a couple of salad options, my wife and I chose the Caesar salad and it was great. Next time we need to get the Alabama white sauce roasted wings. The pizza is the star of the show. Very flavorful sauce and great crust. Our server was very friendly and offered extra sauces. Forgot the name of the white vinaigrette sauce but it was phenomenal with the left over crust. This was a great pizza, especially the pepperdews gave each slice a sweet heat kick. read more

Food was good when it was good, but often burned. People were usually very friendly.

Great pizza stop with quality crust and ingredients. A nice stop in a smaller town, enjoyed the updated interior and quality food. We had a half pepperoni and half specialty. The crust was delicious and crispy and just a little chewy which was nice. The toppings were all quality (the little pepperoni great curls just a little when it hits the high heat). They have a small alcohol selection but you can get beers from the store next door which has a larger draft selection. read more

See all