One of our family favs! Johnny's has some freaking amazing pizza (as well as other items!) including our family's favorite "Johnny's White w/ Pepperoni added.) Their beer selection is top notch and I can't say enough about their bourbon. Their monthly bourbon tastings are one of our favorite event for a "guys night" and the offerings do not disappoint! The staff is super awesome and always on top of it. The atmosphere is family friendly and one of the best places to end the week or relax at during the weekend. Give them a try, I am sure they will quickly become one of your favorites as well! read more

I really want to bump these guys up to at least 4 stars because we historically have had good pizzas here, but one again we were let down. Out of the beer we wanted again, Classic City. Ordered the meat deluxe and a pepperoni. Both were what I feel were under cooked. They weren't raw, but a little doughy. Both had the same consistency. Maybe another minute in the oven and it would have perfect. Tasted fine and the toppings were more evenly distributed than before, but still not as good as it has been. Service was good as always. read more

See all

We love going to Johnny's Pizza and getting a custom ordered pIzza made and cooked how we prefer. We enjoy their covered patio area as the ambiance and friendliness of those most who are regulars and frequently go sit out here to let the kids enjoy a little space too. The service is great and quick. I even use my Suwanee Area Mom's Club discount so we go at minimum once a month. read more

See all

The pizza is great but take out is a mess every time. The last time I came here they kept saying 5 more minutes about 4 times. This time, they told me only 3 more minutes and then told me that they burnt one of our pizzas and it would be another 10 minutes. They apologize but do nothing about it. This may be my last visit here. read more

Omg! We gave this establishment another chance after our fiasco 6 years ago. It hasn't improved one bit. We ordered a pitcher of beer, we brought only 2 glasses of beer. Then I asked for garlic to be brought out, instead of normal powdered garlic she brings me minced garlic in a cup After getting our soggy, runny, horrible pizza she never came back to the table. I think she already knew. This was the utmost worst pizza we've had in our lives And we are regular once a week pizza eaters. I'm really surprised this place is still in business it really should be closed read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Johnny's pizza in Buford, Ga off Hamilton Mill - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

The food was good for a pizza place. I really liked the mini garlic knots. I thought the pizza was going to be a little more NY thin but guess I need to get a large pizza, some of the toppings were just sitting on there but the crust was amazing. The lemon pepper wings were a dry rub but super good! I'd order it again. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

I like their lunch specials. I get the slice and salad. Last visit I tried the Greek salad and wasn't impressed. I'll stick to the regular garden salad from now on. Friendly wait staff. read more

Was very pleased with the service and the food and I greatly appreciate everyone that was there. They were very nice.

This pizza is the closest to New York style pizza I've had since I moved to Georgia a few months ago. The options are vast in the food is really good. I've tried their meatball sub, chicken parmesan sub, cheesy bread, garlic bread, and cheese pizza; obviously my family likes this place. I have no complaints. The establishment is family friendly and laid back. Also, the staff are attentive and kind. I definitely recommend this business. read more

If you havent already you have to go and try their wings. I recommend going Wednesday for the Bogo special. This past Wednesday I had the best tasting wings I've had there yet. I might go as far as to say; the best wings I've ever had, anywhere! Then the amazing service brought it all together making it an experience I won't soon forget. read more

The Pizza had minimal toppings. We ordered sliced meatballs and pepperoni. We received 3-4 tiny shavings on 2 slices of pizza. The pizza was not cooked entirely and arrived cold. The person I spoke to on the phone blamed it on Door Dash but the pizza was undercooked to begin with. The gluten free pizza we ordered arrived with black burned crust. read more

Great bar , Nice to have with the pizza joints that usually only serves beer and wine. Not a fan of the metal chairs at the bar but here you can have everything. The pizzas are pretty darn good and only 10 bucks on Monday. They could probably make pizza crust just a wee bit crisper for a true New York style. Pleasant and fast service all around good experience. read more

See all

Our rec baseball team wanted to meet up for pizza after a game on Saturday night. I stopped by earlier in the day to see if they could fit our group of over 20 people. They said they would hold half the patio for us. When we got there, it was ready for us. They picked the perfect server for us. He handled it all on his own. All of our orders were accurate and brought to us quickly. read more

Most of the servers are nice and took great care of me, but the host, Ava, stood out to me. She was very welcoming when I walked in the door, and it's clear that she loves her job. The food was pretty good, and it was a Monday when I went so it was pretty peaceful. read more

I don't understand why cheese is an issue in this matter. It HOLDS the toppings I would want a better representation of pizza. Two additional stars for the service. Ladies are good read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - When does the cheese get added? Toppings just falling everywhere‍ - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Went to Johnnys Pizza and it is no better. The pizzas are literally more than a dollar up in price now it's been two weeks since I went there. Before it was just a little more than a quarter now it's up more than $2. A couple slices is $10. Fix it Johnny or every social media platform will know about this. I'm not trying to screw you but how does two slice of pizza comes to ten dollars? Your customer service is not all that to black people either. As for the people praising the pizza that is not the issue if you are raising your prices everyday! Also I know you all are white! read more

Pepperoni flatbread pizza for $9 was a joke, size appropriate for a child; as for taste, it was too salty. For price vs. quality I don't see the value here. Worse, paid $15.99 for 12 teriyaki wings and got 9. A bit over-sauced but taste and size were ok. All flats, mo drumsticks, not a big deal to me. I guess you have to count the wings before you leave. Maybe someone ate half the pizza and 3 wings? On principle we called about the wings and were offered to come back, but I'm not driving 30 minutes round trip for 3 wings. Dropped over $30 with tip, disappointed read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Order ticket - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Had dinner here 3 times and has been great food and excellent service every time! Staff friendly, restaurant is clean. Check it out.

Best kept pizza secret in the area. Also have a great whiskey and bourbon selection

normally we come here and the food is very quick but today it took over an hour. ridiculous the wait for pizza!

Been here twice. Once for dine in, one for pick up. Both times the food was outstanding. Staff is on point and the service was phenomenal. I highly recommend Johnny's for either a quick lunch slice or dine in experience. You will not be disappointed. read more

I was not impressed at all with the pizza I got from here recently. Years ago there was a Johnny's near my work and I would get a slice or 2 for lunch sometimes and it was very good. What I got from this location a few weeks ago was nothing like the other location. Maybe ingredients have changed since I last had some but definitely not as good and very bland compared to the past experiences. Very disappointed as I had hyped this up to my guests I was providing dinner for. read more

Customer service was lacking. Walked in and there was a man walking behind the bar with a baby in his hand - flag #1. Received my slice of pizza and it was an old slice of cheese pizza (cheese has already baked in a couple of times) they added additional toppings and did not add cheese to blend toppings - flag #2. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

Excellent pizza, subs and wings. I have Celiac and this place has the best Gluten Free pizza I have tasted. Local owners who make sure to put the customer first! Excellent overall menu and very kid friendly. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Inside dining room. - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

Food is delicious! Service is very friendly & servers go the extra mile atmosphere is relaxed and good place to meet.

The driest grilled chicken breast I've ever had. It tastes, smells and looks like it's old. I don't know if they accidentally gave us chicken grilled chicken on the counter overnight or what but it's awful. Gave a 25% tip but it wasn't great. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

Service sucks. The weekend crew was chillin. If I had not paid already I would have walked out. Never coming here again

This place is well run and consistently high quality! We often go weekly for a pizza.

This place is amazing, Matt is great at making strong margaritas and everyone is so friendly here. I absolutely love the chicken bacon ranch flatbread, and also the 4 cheese pepperoni flatbread is seriously on point! There was one point where my boyfriend almost ate the entire flatbread before taking our to go order out of the restaurant. Five stars fooooor sure. Definitely would recommend to anyone. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

Placed an online order and email gave me a time it should be ready, had to wait an additional 15 minutes after I arrived. Staff was super friendly and food was good. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Inside - Italian Near Me - Buford, Georgia

See all

We were going here for lunch after church, and we expected it to be a long wait, but it was not. We were quickly seated, and our food quickly arrived. The Stromboli I had was delicious, and so were the garlic knots. The pizza was great, and the fries were amazing. Our server was really nice too. I LOVED IT. read more

Has anyone else noticed that Jonny's NY Style Pizza located on Hamilton Mill Rd. has reduced the toppings on their pizzas 75% while all other Jonny's locations still pile the toppings on their pizzas? I took my last pizza back and asked for a refund and then the manager conveniently forgot to credit my account until I return 10 days later and had to ask her one more time to please credit me for the skimpy no topping Jonny's deluxe pizza they tried to pawn off on me. I'm just going to start buying my pizzas at the Peachtree Ind. Blvd. location since they still pile on the topping at their location or maybe I'll try the Johns Creek Jonny's. read more

Pizza feels a bit overpriced for the quality. Rather get a Little Caesars or Domino's. Their salad and lasagna is pretty good though.

Could not wait to have a Johnny's open up nearby, and was really hoping they would have their issues ironed out by now but still waiting. Have had several with not the same amount of sauce as the other locations and they haven't been able to get the crust down either. Too expensive if they can't get on the Johnny's train soon. read more

If I wanted a frozen pizza from the next door Publix this place would have been great. Took my wife and kid here. Thinking good pizza wrong. Service sucked pizza sucked. The staff was busy talking to each other did not bother waiting ont the customers in the store. Will never go back to this place. Just a waist of money. Publix next door would have been cheaper and much better. read more

Ate here last night, dine in. Food was great, pizza was really good, and the service was exceptional! Our server, Emma, was the best I ever encountered. She went above and beyond, was friendly, great personality, and very attentive! read more

Was very disappointed with everything, in the past experience with Johnny's I remember everything being great unfortunately this was not the case for this Johnny's. Bartender was busy talking and obviously forgot to put my appetizer in, then when it did come the main and app came together! The app was hot and very good the entrees were cold and undercooked, now let's talk about my side of Alfredo that came out of the refrigerator and brought out and I had to as for it to be heated. Won't be back! read more

Phenomenal pizza, subs and calzones! Awesome service and the staff are very responsible with the latest safety guidelines. The steak and cheese stromboli may be better the pizza. The owners are locals that live in and care about our community and create a local neighborhood feel in the restaurant. We are officially regulars! Thank you Johnny's Buford! read more

The food is great and the staff are awesome. We have a group that dines out regularly and have added this Johnny's to our weekly schedule. They always take such great care of us and the pizza is awesome!!! read more

The food is delicious and the service is amazing!! I love the teamwork of the staff and you can tell the owners truly care about the customer experience right down the the last detail. I have not tried anything that I don't love when I have eaten at this location. A few of my favorites are all of the salads, bruschetta, fried mozzarella sticks, cheese bread, garlic knots, pizza (of course), Italian sub, and the cinnamon knots. I highly recommend you visit and see for yourself. We love Johnnys!! read more