Very friendly nail salon. The employees always go above and beyond to pamper me when I get a chance to sneak away for a gel mani and pedi. The music they play is always relaxing. I appreciate that they use individual pedicure tool packages and plastic tub liner for every customer. My gel manicure always lasts 3 weeks and never chips. Great color selection and prices. Love this place!! * no matter how long it's been since my last manicure they always remember me and ask about my son. LOVE THAT :) read more

Jinny and her team are fantastic. I have never seen someone as attentive as her for details for a standard manicure. I don't like clear polish and always have my nails buffed. A typical buffing job last 2-3 days tops but Jinny spends extra time to get the best shine I've ever seen that lasts a full week and is perfect. There is nowhere else I will go anymore for a manicure and pedicure and the price is also very reasonable! Thank you! read more

I had a nice experience! Rachel took care of my manicure! She did a good job and was friendly! Nice relaxing music in the background very clean n organize read more

Pick a Color Nails - Nice n clean - Nail Salons Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Went here for the first time for a Mani/Pedi. I was accommodated immediately and received wonderful treatments. Prices are reasonable and service was professional. I even received a free shoulder massage! read more

Update: After 10 days the nail came off altogether like a plastic nail from CVS. Makes me think this guy definitely didn't do a good job. So let me start by saying I've come here 2xs so far and I really think they have incredible pedicures and so very well priced. With that said, I came back for having my nails done, I had the powder SNS service. There was multiple issues with the service, it took an hour and half, I left with polish all over my hands and it's very uneven. I would like to say I have friends who have gotten the gel service which is much cheaper but for the price of powder ($40) I would avoid doing that at this location. My nails are uneven and not filled right. So again, gel is probably a better bet. It also seems the guy doing my nails was upset cause I had him fix it because they were discolored a few times shrug. read more

See all

Best nail salon around. Very clean and very friendly. I would never go anywhere else.

I got gel coffin nails in pink to white ombré. Rachel's so nice, and she's really great at shaping and filing the nails. It looks really nice and even. I originally wanted acrylics, but she told me that acrylic is really bad for your nails because of all the chemicals, so she used nail forms and gel to achieve the coffin shape. It looks the same as acrylics and it doesn't damage your nails as much! :) The process took about 1-2 hrs and it was $69. read more

Pick a Color Nails - Nail Salons Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

I always go out of my way to get pedicures here. They always do a great job and take their time. It is relaxing and clean inside the salon. Highly recommended! read more

Always very friendly and my nails last forever! Definitely a great spot in east Rutherford! ;-)

Complete waste of 68 dollars. I came here to get a new set of acrylic gel and as I was sitting there I decided I wanted french ombré, the guy instantly seemed annoyed. I figured it is late and I'm the last one so i'll choose a regular color. But this guy still seemed so annoyed when i asked him to fix my shape a little bit because it was so flared out. He didn't seem to understand and someone had to come explain what it was I wanted but it felt like he was arguing back and unhappy that i had any comments to make. I instantly felt so uncomfortable about making any comments on what I wanted. I was left with the worst manicure i've ever had in my life and most of all i'm just sad about the money i threw down the drain. Rachel seemed super sweet but sadly I will never be coming back here, not even to get this sad manicure fixed. read more

Pick a Color Nails - Nail Salons Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Pick a Color Nails has reasonable pricing for this area of demographics. They have a wide selection of colors for manis, pedis and gel manicures. They are now offering OPI powder manicures which is amazing! Personally gels never last for me as long as it does for my friends but powder has been a game changer! It last longer than 3 weeks, so you truly get your money's worth. Other than the services they provide, Rachel and Alba are amazing! Rachel remembers everyone's name, even if it's your second time there. Alba is my go to girl for pedicure, manicure, all of it. I love going to her especially for my pedicure because unfortunately Ive had ingrown toe nails since a young girl. It's really hard to find someone who can do a good job when it comes to troubled feet like mine but Alba truly does an amazing job!! read more

Visiting my sister and needed to get a pedicure. Called and made a same day appointment. They were prompt, friendly and very clean place. The hot stone massage and quick shoulder massage was a great bonus. read more

Just moved to town. Was searching for a good nail salon. SO happy I found this place. It's SO clean (they use tub liners!!) , they are so nice, and they do amazing work. My pedicure lasted an hour with an amazing massage and my gel manicure was also paired with an amazing massage. My nails look great. Also - they have good color options and match the gel with the same polish for mani/pedi! Also. Gel mani / pedi is $50 or $45 if you pay cash... so competitive pricing read more

Rachel is the best! I have a 5 month old at home so I was very nervous to start going out and about. They have plexi glass separating all customers, staff is wearing masks, customers are wearing masks, they are limiting the number of people in the salon at once and they sanitize everything constantly! Also, I've been a customer of this salon for years and they do amazing pedicures & gel manicures! read more

I stopped here on a fluke to change my color and was just impressed with how clean, spacious and professional this place was. The ladies are sweet and professional. This is the 1st time in life I had a pedicure last more than 3 weeks. They don't wander down their polished and the work is exceptional. I live in Brooklyn but when I come out here at least once a month because they are affordable and do an excellent job read more

Gel manicure chipped in 3 days and continued to chip everyday until i had them redone

Definitely my new pedi spot! I came here today for a pedicure and they took me right away. The salon is airy, clean and has plenty of pedicure and manicure stations. The girl who took care of me did a wonderful job and gave a great leg massage! The owner is ridiculously sweet, she was chatting with all of the customers and her staff the whole time. The pedicure was very affordable and she discounted it a little because I paid cash! I will definitely come back. read more

This has become my regular monthly spot for gel mani and regular pedi. Rachel is the best, and her staff are all so sweet and good at what they do. I will never go somewhere else. read more

Im all about customer service & cleanliness & Pick a Color Nails tops it. I love how clean the salon is & how friendly everyone is. I love Marina, she is my girl!!! She takes her time, does such an amazing job with my Mami's and pedi's. They have a range of colors & if you make an appointment you don't have to wait. What else can you ask for? read more

New to the area, and this salon was suggested. Marisol, and Rachel are excellent. Very friendly. Clean salon.

Tried this place for the first time last Sunday. The absolute best pedicure and gel manicure I've ever had!! Owner was super friendly and welcoming to myself and my 5 year old daughter. Salon was so clean and spotless. I will definitely come back!! read more

The nail salon that I usually go to unfortunately closed. I went to Pick a Color after reading reviews, it was a great experience. The salon is clean and the staff is friendly. I had an appointment and they took me on time. Rachel did a great job, I think I found my new nail salon read more

One of the most friendly nail salons in the area. Rachel remembers your name and what services you get. Warm atmosphere and great pedicures...ask for an additional 10minute foot massage..,it's worth the extra $10. I've tried other places in the area just out of convenience and I still always end up back here. I've finally decided to throw in the towel and only come here. read more

Pick a Color Nails - Nail Salons Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

best salon in the Rutherford/East Rutherford area! Great pricing. Always so clean, calm and organized. All of the staff members have a wealth of knowledge on the products and give incredible recommendations. not to mention they remember everyone's name and preferences. obsessed read more

Absolutely terrible. That sums up this place to me. I was in a pinch and needed to get my gel fills done and repair of one nail. They made every nail crooked and sharp. The repaired nail has a huge mountain at the tip. I apparently needed my whites redone but they didn't do it, offer it, or mention it till they were done. I got my eye brows waved in a room that seemed to have two washing breed next to each other.... Not sure if they have actually private waving rooms although no one else was being exceed while I was there. The salon sleep lacks any kind of decorations. The entire experience reminded me of a barber shop. Seriously avoid this place ladies unless if you enjoy being pampered at a warehouse. read more

This is my favorite place! Rachel is just the absolute best and loves the people who work for her. She is a nice, funny lady who makes your time there fun. Not to mention the best pedicure and nails you will ever get. I will never go anywhere else. As a matter of fact my kids (2boys and a girl) all want pedicures every time I go!! Annamaria read more

Love this place! I bring my 5 year old daughter with me all the time to get manicures and pedicures. They treat her like royalty. The people are so kind. Love them!!! read more

I've only had pedicures at this Salon so far so I cant post on any other service. The pedicures are the best Ive had in my area. Ive gone to the two younger girls who work there and its been a great experience. The massages actually put me to sleep! Its so relaxing and they totally take their time. The best part is if you pay cash you get a 10% discount, but of course I never have cash on me! I highly recommend them for pedicures. The owner and her staff are so nice!! read more

Terrible, all they care about is money, no proper service. Will NEVER go here.

Best mani & pedi place! Always love my nails. Not only is their service excellent but everyone is always so nice! Great atmosphere!

Absolutely love their pedi's! Rachel, the owner is always so nice! I always leave her happy with my mani/pedi. I even did gel tips one time and they came out great too! read more

Decided to go this place today celebrating mother and daughter day with my 12 year old. Very excited until I was treated so rudely upon entering. Right away NO! In a passive aggressive manner. Hoping the I misunderstood I said, Mani and pedi. Response NO! There was no explanation or apology from who I believe to be the owner. I responded by telling her that this is the SECOND time of turning me away and I was going to review them. The first turnaway was was for eyebrow waxing and the 2nd time was today with my daughter for a mani and pedi. I would have completely understood if she would have said " oh I'm sorry we are understaff in the busiest day of the week". Nope - she didn't care and doesn't respect customers period. Good luck! Because if they continue like this in no time they will be closing down. Went down the block to Coco Nails- NOW they do know how to treat customers and most importantly great mani and pedi with a sincere smile. read more

I have been coming to these ladies since they were at a different location in Rutherford - great, lasting manicures and professional, efficient, pleasant staff. There is a very negative review on this site which complains of a lack of decoration in the salon. I don't know where this person went to get their nails done but the salon is new, tastefully decorated and makes me think she reviewed the wrong business. In any event, I never have been dissatisfied. read more

I heard of this place from a friend that so I decided to give it a try. I got a gel mani which was okay, nothing fabulous. The technician pretty much rushed through the whole process and didn't say two words to me except when she asked about the color I wanted. My cuticles look messy and it's only been 3 days and my nails are chipping. I've never had that happen to me. But I think the kicker is that they are so overpriced. I paid $35 for a gel mani plus I was nice enough to give her a $5 tip. So I basically paid $40 for a crappy gel mani that is already chipping and I felt rushed when there was barely anyone in the salon. I've never paid that much for a gel mani in NYC nevertheless East Rutherford. Won't be going back. read more

I just went to this nail salon today. I had a great pedicure and a very professional gel fill and gel polish. I was a mess after all the cooking and cleaning during the holidays. Can't wait to go back. Jenny and Kim are great. read more

I had an appointment and when I arrived I had to wait for a pretty long time. They had taken walk-ins and had a complete disregard for my appointment time. I paid $35 for a gel manicure which is higher than most around. The manicure did not include cuticles etc. The just put oil on my cuticles. Considering so many other options in the area- this place is a really bad choice! read more

Overpriced. Rude owner. I went there 3 times. After doing the regular gel manicure twice but was only lasting less than a week; I asked the owner for a recommendation for something that will last longer. She said the French UV gel manicure will last at least two weeks. So I paid a hefty amount for the gel French manicure (+ almost a 20% tip) and less than a week later I had one nail chipped and 3 others the gel was bubbling up which I showed it to the owner exactly a week after doing them. When going back to see the best way to remove the gel she was very rude and had the nerve to tell me that it was at least two weeks since I did them. My conclusion don't argue with people that don't have a clue of what they are talking about. For sure I won't go back there again and wouldn't recommend the place to anyone!! read more

Can't say enough how amazing this place is. Best in Rutherford area. Everyone is very nice and helpful and it's so clean. Rachel does the best gel manicures! Pedicures rock! Great pricing and weekly drawing for free mani/pedi! read more

I went here last week, the staff was rude And completely rushed my service. Will likely not return