Pie Town Pie was totally worth the trip. It was a bit chilly and too windy to sit outside on November 22, 2025, but there was patio dining. Service was a bit slow when we walked in. That all quickly changed soon after we played musical chairs to find a clean table we wanted. Lol. The only other weird thing was, they did not have menus. It was all verbally listed for us. In approximately 15 minutes, our food came out hot and fresh. I had the quiche, which was perfect, but I tried both of my daughters' dishes too. Talk about wholesome, comforting flavor town! Not only that, but they add extra touches to each dish to make them aesthetically pleasing. Our lunch consisted of: Pizza SLAB = $9.95 Pot Pie = $14.95 Quiche Meal = $9.95 Slice of Brookie pie = $7.50 Beverage × 2 = $5.00 ($2.50 ea.) Highly recommend if you get the chance to travel this desolate area of New Mexico. RATING BREAKDOWN Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Ambiance: 4| Price: 4 read more

See all

I have never had such awful service in any establishment. It doesn't matter how good the food is if nearly every employee ignores you, forgets what you ordered, still does not bring all of your order after asking repeatedly, and over charges. This is definitely not worth a stop. We stumbled upon this restaurant while passing through on a road trip. It is out of the way from anywhere and located in the middle of nowhere. If you are not a local, don't bother going. read more

You must stop if you're anywhere nearby! A town named after pie Good friendly service Charming atmosphere Great selection of pie! You can lunch pies too Seriously, just go read more

Pie Town Pie - Pie Town Pie Company exterior - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

For years, I heard about Pie Town Pie and wanted to visit. I finally had the chance to visit there recently. The drive out there from Socorro NM was long and remote, but then we finally arrived - Very excited to try their pies. Unfortunately, it was a disappointing experience. Very limited selection of pies. The pies were not that good and cost about $7.50 a slice. The coffee also wasn't good. Additionally, our waitress kept forgetting what we ordered and that we were ready to pay our bill. Two groups of people were in the diner: a loud group of volunteer local firefighters, and a local older couple who kept glaring at us angrily (ie. Some people in NM are not friendly to tourists). The Pie Lady (Kathy) was friendly and happy; however, her pies were not worth the drive, sorry to say. read more

Everything I had hoped and more. Got there later in the day so some of the food and pie options were limited--but didn't matter because what they had was awesome. Chili with corn "bread" (was more like heavenly cake) and salad was delicious. The pies were as good as you could want. Super fresh. Service was fantastic. Couldn't have been more friendly. This is a stop worth planning for on any trip through the area. Couldn't recommend more highly. read more

See all

This place was a surprise find on our road trip to California from Tennessee. Me and my dad had a great time. As well as AMAZING pie, there was live music that day and lots of amazing local art. I really hope it's still happening that way....it's was before COVID when we stumbled through Pie Town. read more

This is homemade food-not fast food and it was delicious! A simple tasty menu that changes daily. The service was quick and friendly, even when it got busy. A rustic country setting that was clean and shared the history of the town. We had the green chile tomato quiche, the far east feast, and the deep dish pizza. So much food. Each served with its own little dessert. The Oreo cream pie was rich, thick, and meet all your chocolate needs with a buttery flakey crust. The perfect little spot to stop driving through. read more

See all

I love this place! Great food, pies, and people. The place itself has an interesting and comfy atmosphere. It's nice that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. Everyone that works here is friendly and kind and happy to fill you in on the offerings for the day. Each time I come by there's an interesting mix of locals and those traveling through the area. Everyone appreciates the fantastic food and wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend. read more

My students and I visited Pie-O-Neer Pies during our summer school session of June 2024. My coworkers and I brought 7 middle school students. Sara and her wonderful workers Isabel, Irene and Heather were all so patient and kind to our students. We enjoy their pizza and the students were able to each make their own mini 6inch pie. We all went home with different slices and 6in pies as well. Trying a variety of types, peaches and cream pie, New Mexico apple (with the secret ingredient of green chile), chocolate cream pie, triple lemon cream, cherry pie and Las Cruces pecan pie. I truly enjoy all the memorabilia hung inside the cafe and how much pride Sara takes in her cafe the pies and caring for her customers and staff. Worth stopping in when driving through New Mexico on Highway 60. We also got the pleasure of meeting the Infamous Paul of Pie Town. read more

Pie Town Pie - 6ish mini pies my students were able to make with the help of Sara and her staff - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

Friendly service and delicious pie! A must stop if you're in the area. Had a delicious pie in here 26 years ago and it's still awesome. read more

Pie Town Pie - Peanut butter pie - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

So I was on my way to Truth or Consequences New Mexico. Yes that is the correct name of where I was going. Saw this huge sign on the road that said, 'Stop' Now I took this not as a warning but as a suggestion. I went to this restaurant and saw the most Delicious pies on display. It was very cozy and quaint inside. Much like all the establishments in New Mexico I'm noticing. Well, I had a multitude of choices I decided on the blueberry. I waited till I got to my hotel and had it after my steak dinner. It was the most delicious pie I've ever had. read more

See all

Mmmm the pot pie was a clear winner-it's a heavy meal don't let the size fool you-bring a friend and share. They also have cold pie to go if you're in a hurry. read more

See all

Planned a stop in Pie Town on our last day of vacation and was very disappointed. The food looked great but we left because there was absolutely zero customer service. When we walked in there was a table that had been served and one person at the register buying some pie. We stood there waiting for someone to acknowledge us but were completely ignored. I don't have any patience for lousy service so we left and had a great meal in Show Low. read more

The pies and ice cream are really good. The cookies are amazing as well. Now for the bad news . Showed up on a Friday and the sign says they open at 10am. Waited outside for 30 minutes and the manager said well this is the country and the animals come first. The next Monday we thought we would get there at 10:30 since they open at 10am. Pulled up and what do you know not open. We called and they said we will open in 20 min and that they ran out of pies yesterday. One hour later we noticed a local get out of his truck and they let him in through the back door. We saw him sitting in the music room through the window Eventually they opened. The young girl who helped us both days was always polite and helpful. The pie and ice cream were great as usual but the management is beyond horrible. Very Sad this place has so much potential read more

What do you expect when you come to a wide spot in the road called Pie Town? Me - stop with any cafe with Pie in the name. So we did. Long motorcycle ride, about halfway around a loop and needed time to get out of the saddle, eat and quench the thirst. We entered a building probably out of the 1930's knickknacks galore and historical pics of the town in the 40's. Small menu board at the counter - only 4 items to chose from. Chicken & green chile pot pie & a slice of coconut cream pie. A generous slice of pie was served 1st. Sweet & topped with toasted coconut it was delicious. 1/2 way thru it the pot pie is delivered. Pot pie is hot, nice brown crust and a good sized amount of green chile on top. No it doesn't compare to anything I've eaten before. Not much broth in the middle. Instead loaded with slices of chicken, cheese & chile. Comfort food at its finest. It was a lot of food - couldn't finish my dessert or entree. Cost was on the higher side. But again large portions and it was a meal - not a snack. Out of the way, wide spot in the road serving up a great meal. read more

See all

This was our first time here and everything was amazing. I pies were great, the people are amazing and so nice, and the entire interior is just so homey it's wonderful. We came here after being less than impressed with the pie shop down the road that we had been going to for so long and I think we just found our new favorite pie shop. read more

Always wanted to have pie in Pie Town and the trip didn't disappoint! Everyone I talked to consistently said that all the pies were good - so pick whichever sounds yummiest to you. My friend had the New Mexico Apple with (lots) of ice cream. I ordered the Lemon Blueberry Buttermilk. They were both amazing. Portion sizes are very generous - ended up having to box up what we couldn't finish. Also bought a slice of the Peach to go for my friend who couldn't make the trip. The atmosphere is super cute and folksy. Lots of local goodies available for purchase. The owner was very friendly and we struck up a wonderful conversation when things slowed down enough for her to chat. read more

See all

I had the pleasure of surprising a friend on his birthday with a entire cherry pie . Not only was he surprised to receive the entire pie but he consumed the entire pie in less than 24 hours. What started out as a piece of pie after dinner, then as a midnight snack or two. Before he knew it he finished it off as breakfast. A rare treat that he did not share. Chefs kiss and a big thank you to Kathy read more

Oh, my.... What a treasure in the middle of nowhere. Well, don't get me wrong, the ride there was phenomenal scenery. The pies (yes, I had two slices) were too good yet true. The quiche was fresh, hot, served with a salad and a muffin. Yum! Friendly crew, great stop for lunch! read more

See all

The pies are fantastic but get their early or call ahead and they will try to make your favorite . My husband loves the green chili apple pie and I love the triple berry and the coconut. Everyone is so friendly. It's a very good day out! read more

Our family stops in here every 6 months or so as we visit relatives in New Mexico. First off, you walk in and the decor is everything! It is country eclectic with a very homey feel. The staff is welcoming and even remembers our family when we stop in. The pies... oh the pies! there is always a wide variety of homemade never store bought (there is not a super market within 50 miles of this place) pies. You will not be disappointed when you stop in for a quick bite or a leisurely afternoon. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND PIE-O-NEER. read more

Be prepared for a long wait and no sense of urgency. They also added a tip without my knowledge. There is so much stuff inside it's a bit claustrophobic. Food was good but their menu is too big to handle with little help. I repeated my order several times and was glad to see that it was actually accurate. read more

Pie Town, NM is one of those places you could miss if you blink. But keep your eyes peeled, because this fabulous little pie shop is worth the stop. Fabulous, homemade pies. Sunday supper is fun and unique, and at the whim of the chef. Don't be in a hurry. Just relax and enjoy some pie. read more

See all

I stopped here on a whim and I am sure glad I did. I got to speak to the pie lady and she was the best. Amazing customer service that made you feel like family. Am I family? I think I might be. The place is so cute inside. Rustic and classic. Real wood burning stove for heat. This place is one of a kind Oh and the PIES!!!! Get there early before they run out!!! read more

See all

This is a gem of a pie shop! Pie-Town you did not disappoint! Great combinations of flavors and traditional pies. We hope to one day be back through and visit the fine people of pie-o-neer. We each had a different flavor of pie, 5 of us, and each one was excellent. The best was surprisingly the Triple Lemon pie my daughter had... read more

Pie Town Pie - Pies on display - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

See all

Super good pies, I stopped by on my way to go camping in the Gila, picked up a 6inch snickerdoodle and a slice of strawberry lemon. So tasty and love the sweet tea. The walls are decorated with pie town history which was fun to read while I waited. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Passing through on the way to Socorro. Hubby and I both had a piece of coconut cream pie. It was amazing. Next time I want to try the pot pie! read more

Everything on the menu is out of this world delicious. You can't go wrong with any choices at Pie O Neer. No matter where one may roam, this place will be a stand out. It is obvious that Sarah, the owner, puts her whole heart into the quality, flavor and service at her incredible establishment. Everyone who works there is terrific, too. In a world that has forgotten the value of thank you, welcome, uncompromising standards and a smile, this place is a desert oasis. I have come every day they are open for the past week and can't wait to return! Oh ya, and the pies are stratospheric greatness, anything but ordinary. Enjoy! read more

Pie Town Pie - Denali Wildberry Crumb Pie Good Gawd - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

Really good chicken sandwich! Fresh and tasty! Got a variety sampler of the pies, husband said the Apple was the BEST he has ever had! Trust me when I say he had tried a whole bunch of apple pies, this one is absolutely TOPS!!! Stop in and try for yourself!!! read more

Long drive, but worth it. The pies are like your great-grandmother would have made if she made really, really good pies.

What a gem in a gorgeous part of New Mexico. I couldn't move to NM and not visit a place called Pie Town. So glad we made the drive. We were greeted by the smell of baked goodness and iced tea. Then, we waited. This is obviously the small town hang out and food is made to order. Be prepared to wait for your food. I took the time to look at their merch and souvenirs for sale. The food was worth the wait. I got a half sub (which was still huge) and the bread was amazing. Rivals hoagies that I've had in Pennsylvania. Next time, we'll order the pizza. The orders of pizza around us looked delish. The real star of the show was the pie, of course. We ordered the coconut buttermilk, as it had just come out of the oven. It was decadent and tasted like a macaroon pie. We'll be back. May order pie first while waiting for the remainder of our order. Why not eat dessert first when you're in Pie Town? read more

See all

You have to love it when dessert is served first, and then wait for the meal We had the pozole, and the pepperoni pot pie Home cooked deliciousness, absolutely worth the stop and small wait Food was sooo good!!! The servers were very kind read more

The friendliest cafe in pie town with the best food! Worth waiting for- don't bother with the other ones, this one wins for atmosphere, the best cooking and baking, and sweet employees. Have visited a few times, and always so good! read more

See all

Today my partner and I drove from Flagstaff. Pie Town is the half way point where we met a friend to pick up our new Pug. The owner and staff could not have been any nicer accommodating us with our dogs. This place is absolutely adorable, and nostalgic without being totally kitschy. Now onto the food. Of course I was expecting good pie, but our lunch was amazing. The menu is limited, but I actually like that because you know they are paying attention to detail. I order the taco salad and my partner and friend ordered the tamale pie. Keep in mind the menu changes, so this just happened to be the specials today. My taco salad was beyond good. Everything is scratch made. It's not your Taco Bell shell. It was freshly made and fried to perfection and filled with delicious meat and all the things you expect in a taco salad. Super fresh and flavorful. They swooned over the tamale pie and freshly fried chips. The server then brought out 3 apple pie breads. A take on Navajo fry bread. It was light and flaky, with sweet syrupy apples on top. Of course we couldn't leave without getting a slice of pie to come home. I chose the sweet potato pineapple pie. I haven't eaten it yet because I'm still full from lunch. This place is a gem! We can't wait to go back. read more

See all

We drove over 2 hours. Got there at 12:30 and it wasn't open yet. Some people had been waiting over an hour. Finally opened the doors and were told pies weren't ready yet. Would be an hour or so before they were cool enough to cut. What? Also website has menu listed but they do not serve food. Cool building but obviously won't go back. read more

Very nice pie place. The inside is warm and inviting. Gives the feeling of a very relaxed laid back oasis off the road. Very nice ladies serving pies and explaining what each pie is. Wonderful... read more

Pie Town Pie - Coconut cream pie - yummy - Bakeries Near Me - Pie Town, New Mexico

The food is great, the service is great, very friendly staff. Ambiance is old time and pictures are hung to help with its local history. Very interesting place to stop in, get a slice of pie, learn a bit of history, shake a few hands then be on your way. read more

In the middle of nowhere NM, there is Pie Town. And in Pie Town, NM, there is pio-o-ne'er pies. I had apple berry pie (apples and blueberry. It was flavorful and delicious. read more

A Must Stop for NM travelers!!! We stayed off freeways from Alamagordo to Flagstaff after a truly awe inspiring visit to White Sands Missile Range Museum. On the way to Flagstaff, we were lured to the Pie o Neer shop. The best pies and legacy photos of Pietown awaited us. The owner took time to walk through the historical photographs and memorabilia. A great experience! read more

Worth the stop! If you're in a hurry, do yourself a favor and at least stop for pie. They usually have a variety of fresh baked pies to choose from, a slice or the whole pie. Last time we passed through, we got six different slices and they were all amazing! Today we stopped for lunch. They only had pizza available (day before Thanksgiving, they were so busy filling all their pie orders ), and it was so good! Took about 25minutes for food to be ready, so we settled in and looked at all the pictures on the walls and fun memorabilia. Everything was so fresh and delicious, their supreme was unlike anything we'd ever had, each bite an explosion of flavors. Service was excellent, lovely conversation all around. If you stop, don't be in a hurry. Slow down and enjoy this Pie Town gem! read more