Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Horse and Buggy

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    The Horse and Buggy Photos

    More like The Horse and Buggy

    Recommended Reviews - The Horse and Buggy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Horse and Buggy

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Pie Town Pie - 11.22.2025

    Pie Town Pie

    4.3(117 reviews)
    21.0 mi
    $

    So, we had seen this place on the map many times while driving to New Mexico, and I've always said…read more"oh we should go have pie in Pie Town." We finally did! First of all, this place is pretty much the town. I'm not sure of the history - - which came first the cafe or the town, but there's not much more to it than this place. My son looked up the population of the town and it's under 200. This place is absolutely adorable. There's a big front porch with tables, and there were people sitting at the tables when we arrived. Inside there is a lot of Americana decor and antiques. We just stopped for pie, and ordered an apple pie, a peach pie, and a custard pie. They were all absolutely amazing - - the crust is to die for! I wish we hadn't already eaten because they also have quiche and pot pie and lots of other things on the menu that sounded delicious. If you find yourself you're not very remote area, you have to stop and get a piece of pie, if not an entire lunch. You won't be sorry!

    Pie Town Pie was totally worth the trip…read more It was a bit chilly and too windy to sit outside on November 22, 2025, but there was patio dining. Service was a bit slow when we walked in. That all quickly changed soon after we played musical chairs to find a clean table we wanted. Lol. The only other weird thing was, they did not have menus. It was all verbally listed for us. In approximately 15 minutes, our food came out hot and fresh. I had the quiche, which was perfect, but I tried both of my daughters' dishes too. Talk about wholesome, comforting flavor town! Not only that, but they add extra touches to each dish to make them aesthetically pleasing. Our lunch consisted of: Pizza SLAB = $9.95 Pot Pie = $14.95 Quiche Meal = $9.95 Slice of Brookie pie = $7.50 Beverage × 2 = $5.00 ($2.50 ea.) Highly recommend if you get the chance to travel this desolate area of New Mexico. RATING BREAKDOWN Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Ambiance: 4| Price: 4

    Photos
    Pie Town Pie - Front of store

    Front of store

    Pie Town Pie - Exterior

    Exterior

    Pie Town Pie

    See all

    Foxfire at Alpine - Supreme Pizza

    Foxfire at Alpine

    4.1(87 reviews)
    50.4 mi
    $$

    We were camping at Luna Lake where it had been raging most of the afternoon. Didn't want to cook so…read moretook the dogs out for some food. We called ahead to reserve a table. When we arrived, our table was ready with two dishes of water and milk bones for our dogs. Our service was great and our server very friendly. The margaritas are very good. The cheese curds were cooked perfectly and tasted great. The juicy flavorful brisket was served on Texas toast with crispy French fries. The buffalo pizza had great flavor but the crust was not crisp at all, I think it needed few more minutes in the oven. (Reheated in our air fryer the next night and it was even better and crispy) The dessert options were plenty. We ended up with a peach crisp and the butter cake. Both were delicious. Foxfire at Alpine is a cozy place, often with wonderful live music. We will be back again next time we go camping.

    Charged more than the menu prices -- receipt + current menu attached…read more We ordered a cheese pizza with five toppings. The menu card we were handed showed a cheese pizza at $17.99, with green pepper, mushrooms, black olives and onions at $1.00 each and pepperoni at $1.75. The menu was removed after we placed our order. According to those prices, the pizza should have been: Cheese pizza: $17.99 Green pepper: $1.00 Mushrooms: $1.00 Pepperoni: $1.75 Black olives: $1.00 Onions: $1.00 Total: $23.74 Our receipt shows the pizza at $27.99. It also shows the toppings at higher prices -- $1.50 each for green pepper, mushrooms, black olives and caramelized onions, and $2.00 for pepperoni. When we got home I checked their website, and its menu matched the prices on the menu we had been given. I've attached a screenshot of that menu along with our receipt. The crust was also soft, limp, grey and very floppy. The toppings themselves were good, but the foundation of the pizza was a letdown. The owner stopped at our table and chatted with us. We mentioned the crust, although we didn't really understand his explanation. He also offered us a sample of a porter-style beer, which was very good. The service was very good as well. With relatively few dinner choices in Alpine, I would simply recommend checking the menu prices against your bill carefully before paying.

    Photos
    Foxfire at Alpine - Outside seating area.

    Outside seating area.

    Foxfire at Alpine - Kilt Lifter

    Kilt Lifter

    Foxfire at Alpine

    See all

    The Horse and Buggy - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...