Casey's pizza is always a solid choice in Fredonia. Good crust, hearty cheeses, and flavorful…read moretoppings. Easy to order and pay with the mobile app and use rewards or deals for extra savings.

The staff, 99.9 percent of them are so obnoxious and rude that you can't really wait to get out of…read morethere, not only that but Cathy the store manager is such a rude and obnoxious person that I went in and she glared at me the entire time, then as I walked up to the counter she said "what" in a rude tone as she forcebly grabbed the item out of my hand and scanned it, I paid and as I waited for the receipt she crumbled it up and tossed it in the trash. Straight trash of a place to go into. Go to the roundabout Pete's for better service and far better staff

Poor customer service. Found my chicken Parmesan sandwich to have yellow on the inside. I…read morecomplained didn't even eat the food and they still tried to charge me full price for the meal. I asked the young waitress about comping the meal and she said we can either make you a new one or give you half off. I said I would rather have half off.

Food is good, maybe a bit high in price. Service is also good. Really no complaints. Extensive…read moremenu choices.

My dearest Casey, your location was a Godsend to my family and I as we traipsed across the Kansas…read moreterrain. We were coming from out East back to our dainty town of Beverly Hills when we needed to fuel up the Skipper (Our Honda Odyssey). That's when I heard a familiar growling coming from the region between my pectorals and my waistline. It was none other than my TumTum demanding some pizza pie! Usually, the family and I would go for a Papa John's Double Cheeseburger Pizza, but there wasn't enough time. We were hungry, and we were hungry NOW. Thankfully, Casey, your General Store has some of the BEST pizza I have ever eaten. We went with a classic onion and banana pepper pie, and one sausage and pepperoni for my girls Scarlett and Trina. Everyone was howling with delight. You would have thought there was a full moon! Highly recommend! 5 stars! Wish I could give 6! Happy New Year, Casey and Crew!

Great pizza! Great donuts! The cashiers are always nice. One star off for the arrogant, boastful,…read moreunprofessional, and very unpleasant manager. I always avoid the place if I know he is working.

Immediately we were greeted & taken to our table.The Waitress was friendly , didn't rush us & told…read moreus about her favorite's to eat there. I had to ask. The Pizza was to die for. The Cesar Salad is awesome, you can split It as It Is Huge. The garlic not nots are delicious & don't forget to take home your dessert of Cinnamon not nots. Easy to heat up. Going here you will be treated like family. The small town vibe ,ambiance , & People Are Awesome.You Will Never Be Let Down at P Town so go in today as you will be glad you did !!!

This was an enjoyable experience and I was a little surprised how good the pizza was. I ordered…read moreThe Lots of Meat and would recommend it. My wife tried the newest pizza, the MARGHE-REE-TA PIZZA and she enjoyed it immensely. Service was great, the beer was cold and the restaurant was a modern rustic look. Note that the restaurant is on the second floor requiring navigation of a large flight of old stairs from the Main Street.

Always great food, great staff, we love seafood nights. If…read moreyou love pizza try a loafer.

Always scrumptious, the food is amazing, the service is awesome, and the ambiance is always goodread more

Great service! Asked us if we wanted refills and if our pizza was OK. The supreme thin crust was…read morecrispy and very good. Our pepsi's were nice and cold. I would come back here. Seems like a newer building with lots of comfortable seating.

Always good service and good food. Staff is always friendly and love that's food is not made until…read moreyou order.

The service is always friendly and welcoming. They have the best chicken and my son absolutely…read moreloves their pizzas. They do offer delivery which is always a bonus I love the way they have the tables set up it makes it easier to get to the buffet the restaurant is always clean and buffet always has fresh hot food

Yo, this pizza joint is seriously the bomb. The crust is crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the…read moretoppings are fresh. I'm talking next-level deliciousness that'll make your taste buds sing. The atmosphere is super chill, perfect for kicking back with friends or just grabbing a quick slice solo. Trust me, you gotta check this place out, food comes out so quick. the service is so good workers are all nice, nobby is the COOLEST super awesome owner i 100% suggest i drive 4 hrs just for this food.

I took my family here for a dinner. We ordered two of their specialty pizzas and two salad bars…read more They have a really nice salad bar with options. It is also clean and fresh. One thing that could be improved is for the plates for the salad bar, to be larger. The plates, for the salad bar are only about 4 inches in diameter and it's really not a very good value for that amount of food. I'm not going subtract any stars for that, though. This is because the salad is very good. The pizza, itself, was fantastic! We had a deep dish and it would put you to mind of the old-school Pizza Hut deep dish pizza. It was buttery a little bit crispy, but soft and chewy on the inside. The toppings were very plentiful as was the sauce and the cheese. We met the owner and he was very friendly and kind. The inside of the building is very nice. They have an arcade room and a party room. The rest of the dining area is very clean and comfortable. It was well worth a 30 minute drive to visit this location and we will be back !

The quality of food is consistent. Still tastes the same as when I was a kid. They have the best…read moresalad bar with the "good ranch"! I hear it is for sale. I hope someone buys it and doesn't change a thing!

I always drive by and see the signs from the interstate when I'm heading to the lake from Kansas…read moreCity. We were finally driving by at a time that made sense to stop and eat, so we had our first meal here and it won't be the last. Friendly service. Good pizza. Good atmosphere. I was not expecting to order from the counter right when we walked in, but luckily we had already scoped out the menu. We ordered two pizzas and cheese curds. Hopefully the cheese curds are a permanent addition to the menu. They're delicious. And they have the good ranch dressing for dipping. We ordered the all meat pizza on cauliflower crust for the gluten-free diner, and we ordered bbq chicken on regular crust. I know the crust is kind of the main attraction here, but we all actually preferred the cauliflower crust over the regular crust. The regular crust has a nice chew, but we just really enjoyed the cauliflower. The bbq pizza is very sauce heavy and felt a little out of balance to me, but overall we all enjoyed our meal and the service and the break from driving. We will definitely be back. Oh, it's also super affordable whether you're here for pizza, drinks, or the buffet.

Amazing find in such a small town. Had cheese curds, toasted ravs, and the buffalo chicken pizza…read more I'm a big traveler and would put this place up against just about anywhere. Great service too. Always look forward to our annual visit to Lamar for Mother Tucker's!

We stopped by to get some food, pizza was delicious Greg was so nice and sweet! Super helpful and…read moretold us about the deals and the best flavors. The inside seemed super clean. Will be coming back for sure!

We found Papa G's a delightful little drive through pizza joint. There is only outdoor seating,…read morewhich on a hot day was not ideal. However, the pepperoni pizza was delicious. My first impression was "where's the pepperoni?", but then i discovered it was tucked in between two layers of cheese. This was great! Also, I am used to dabbing grease from my pepperoni pizzas with a napkin. Not so here! It had the right amount of grease. The crust was battered with salted butter as well. We will be back!