Best dinner and bar in Dane County. The bartender, Sam, was absolutely awesome to interact with…read more Will always come back here when in Dane County. Rick the owner is great too!

Food service. Everything was great. Pizza is one of the best in Dane County…read moreThey have a large menu besides pizza and all are satisfying

We love coming here! They subs are very good - I love getting them toasted. This little pizza was…read moredelish and seemed fresh. The sausage on the pizza was bomb. They also have UW Babcock ice cream in the summer which is the best ice cream! Follow me on Instagram at yelpershawn for more reviews!

Service is really good. The food has been going downhill calzone only had spoonful of pizza sauce…read morewas dry and overcooked. Also the subs I have to ask for extra lettuce because they hardly put any lettuce on a I believe that is the staple of sub. I shouldn't have to ask for extra lettuce.

Everything I've ordered from this place is so good! And Tovi our server was very attentive. I like…read morethe lighting and that the music is at a low enough level you can hear each other speak.

We finally ate in this restaurant since our previous experiences had been take-out during Covid…read more Actually I forget how long after they opened in 2020 did they open the sit down restaurant. We decided it was time to go in person especially given it is only about a mile down the road from us. We called for a reservation on a Saturday evening which looks like it was needed since it is a very small space. Even with the reservation we opted to eat at the bar since the two top they offered us was shoved in a bleak corner. The bartender was friendly and helpful and sitting at the bar gave us the option of watching a few football games on TV. After ordering some beers we ordered the Fat Uncle Tony pizza, though there were many other tempting choices. The large pizza was very tasty though the bacon was hard to find. The prices were similar to our usual Glass Nickel. We will definitely be back since there are some other pizzas we want to sample.

Always consistently delicious! Service is impeccable and the restaurant is like a wonderful old…read morefriend! Please never change!!

So I was honestly back and forth between 2 and 3 stars on this one. I hadn't been here in close to…read morea decade, if not longer, and came here with a friend on a Friday night. The place was pretty steady in the bar area but not crazy packed. I get that this is a local spot, and I love supporting my local businesses, but this one was a bit uncomfortable. Everybody in there stared at us as we walked in and walked around the bar to find a table. Like long stares that followed us as we moved around. We both commented on it as we took our seats. I've been to places that obviously have a regular crowd when I'm clearly an outsider, but they've at least been nice and welcoming. This didn't feel that way. Nobody outwardly acted like they wanted us to leave or anything, but it was still really weird. We each ordered a beer and took some time to look over the menu. They have a lot of options, and we both each decided to go with the smaller 7" pizza. I love that they do have a smaller pizza option for an individual, but so often I find the "personal" pizzas might feed a small toddler, but certainly not an adult who loves pizza. This was a lovely size and I was full when done. Each pizza came out on the kind of paper plate you might buy at the grocery store. We both thought our pizzas tasted like a frozen pizza you might buy at the grocery store, but honestly I really love frozen pizza so I don't necessarily mean that in a bad way. Nothing remarkable, but it was good and I ate my whole pizza. It was a torrential downpour while we were there, so we were considering getting another drink and trying to wait it out. But then our server dropped off our bill without saying anything else or asking if there was anything else we needed. We already felt a bit outsider-ish and this was just kind of the final reminder that we weren't regulars here so we decided to pay the bill and go. While this wouldn't be my first option to come back to, I'd happily eat here again if someone else wanted to drop in.

Food always good subs are huge Only thing is tough time…read morewhen school is open. Lunch time is impossible to go then.

My boos bestie has been raving about this place so we finally tried it. This review is food only,…read morewe've only done takeout. So far we've had pizza, salad, and a couple pasta dishes. The pizza was VERY good, definitely in my top three for the area now. Salad was a little bit plain but honestly, still good. No wilted lettuces or anything like that, all very fresh. But what made me want to write a review was the Sausage Parm and the Eggplant Parm--omg both so good! Literally obsessed with both. Never had a sausage parm before & it slaaaaaps. And the eggplant parm was one of the best I've had in my life, ever, anywhere. Not too oily, not too chewy. This chef was like, "what like it's hard?" When it seems like it is for so many others. Bravo, baby! We love it. The whole place has a bit of an east coast vibe going on which we are INTO...no garlic knots on the menu though & that's a shame. Thanks for the recommendation, H.

Madison's best! Great pizza with a friendly, professional staff and a cozy atmosphere…read more I loved the heatonism bot specialty pizza -- It was the perfect combination of spicy, acidic, sweet, and savory flavors. The dough was cooked perfectly -- crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Seating is limited and first come, first served, so come quick!

Got takeout from here on a Friday night, which is definitely the way to go. The space is pretty…read moresmall inside and they were packed with a wait, but our order was ready ahead of when it said. Super easy pickup. We ordered the tik tik boom and the not on the first date pizzas, unsliced so that the toppings stayed on better. It's nice that they make this recommendation when ordering. It's a good Detoit style, which we likened to a focaccia with toppings and a nice crust of cheese around the sides. The tik tik boom was our favorite, as the toppings paired well together and it's a unique flavor. The not on the first date had my favorite sauce of the two as even though it didn't say it, there seemed to be a little lime in the crema. Overall, would recommend!

Peaceful outdoor seating, with some delicious food (especially that ginger cake). Our serve Parker…read morewas so chill and brought really great vibes to the table. One of my favorite joints!!

I just want to start by saying the service and ambiance was great. The drinks were wonderful. Hence…read morethe three stars. But the reason we're here is for pizza... and I was disappointed as most of the bottom of the pizza was burnt. From above it looked fantastic. But the taste was burnt, and it didn't settle well in my stomach which I dealt with when I got home. I tried to have a couple slices on the inside but when you ate any of the pieces, there was a heavy bitter burnt taste. The pizzeria did offer to replace my pizza but i've always been fearful of something coming back that maybe worse with spit or something. I just feel food should have been looked at by the head chef before sending out of the kitchen. We may comeback next time, but it would just be for drinks and appetizers.

Good stuff. Thin Crust is not sweet like east coast. It's more Chicago style. Sausage and sauce…read moreboth are flavorful.

I order once or twice a week. The owner is a great guy with good food. The sausage and hot…read moregiardiniera thin crust is definitely a go to. Keep up the great job. The lunch deals are great.

Food was delicious! Maggie was our server, and she was incredible. She was super informative and…read moreknowledgeable. We had a big group for a birthday and she was super patient. Overall experience, all thanks to Maggie!

My review is based on the quality of the food - not the poor service…read more My party was a group of four. We had a pretty irritating experience including our table being given to another party after waiting 75 minutes. And had to wait an additional 20 minutes. Food wasn't delivered on time. One of the appetizers came worth the pizza (40 minutes later) and my personal pizza was missed and was delivered 20 minutes after everyone else was finished eating. Food itself was enjoyable. The stand out for me was the curds and the deep dish.

Where does one begin..I ordered $75 dollars worth of stuff from here and got home and most of it…read morewas missing. I called them and quickly found out they don't even have a working phone. A month later, I have spoken to customer service 8 times, been back to the restaurant where the cashier, i think, called her friend and pretended that they were the General Manager to avoid paying me back (Here's her number in case I'm wrong and she is just horrible at her job 325-201-1201). The food they did send was trash. Avoid this location at all cost if possible or be prepared for whatever consequences come from it. I have since contacted corporate and sent a message to everyone including the CEO, COO, Head of supply Chain, and the brand that owns the company. WE shall see what comes from that.

Everything was cooked fresh and our order was spot-on. The service was great, and the dining area…read moreis clean and roomy. It was pretty quiet inside--seems like most people grab their food to go. The location is a bit tucked away and easy to miss; bigger signage would definitely help. That said, the food was excellent!