Flat out no question my favorite pizza. But absolutely skip the buffet. Order what you like and you…read morewon't be disappointed. The buffet will load up with mushroom pizza, Hawaiian pizza and chicken with peppers trash and sprinkle in a sausage and pepperoni here and there. 5 stars for order what you want pizza and 2 stars for the buffet.

For starters it was burnt,on top and when looking under the crust...again burnt almost black. We…read moreordered a 14"sausage,mushrooms,black olives,onions,and pineapple pizza... Plenty of mushrooms, about 3 pieces of sausage and 6 pineapples pieces and having onion as their free topping...very little of onion as well. When you spend $38 on a pizza at $4 a topping, and basically got an all mushroom pizza. Only 2nd time eating at Cranky Pat's...we weren't happy the first time...and our 2nd time will be our last. We let the staff know...they did nothing,we only were asked if we wanted it wrapped up to go box...really?

Amazing pizza a little pricey but worth it. 1 large pizza fed 5 people in the house so that's not…read morebad at all

Before coming up to Appleton, I looked at all the pizza places in the area and the pictures of…read moretheir pizza. Sammy looked most like Chicago pizza that I like. I was not disappointed. I came in for the lunch special. There are maybe four or five booths and I would say about the same for tables. They also have seats at the counter like a diner. The gentleman who waited on me was pleasant and helpful. I ordered the lunch special which is between 11 AM and 1 PM. It is a 9 inch pizza with one topping for $7.25. He brought it out to me with my can of soda. It did not disappoint. I watched the people coming in and out. It seem to be a steady stream also it seem to be like Cheers where everyone knows everyone. They all seem to have a personal connection with the owner. What an unassuming place to come and get great pizza. Would you believe I left having met a new friend. When I come back to Neena we're going to get together again.

Officially a top rated restaurant for my family! Pizza and pasta were both phenomenal. The…read morewaitress, Lily, was so great and our mint was even hand picked next to us. Will definitely be back again and again.

Atmosphere: Cute little place with a very eclectic vibe. They have everything from wall sconces, to…read moreblueprints, to neon signs, a giant moose head, and they have a piano in the front window for people to play. The bathrooms were clean. There was also a real sense of family? amongst the patrons, everyone sitting at the bar seemed to know each other and it had small town feel in a city. Service: Friendly waitstaff from the hostess to the server to the busser to the bartender. The young man working as the busser was literally on the go non-stop. He must have had 3000 steps in just in the time we were there. He filled out water glasses 3 times and we were really grateful for him. Drinks: We didn't opt for drinks this time but will for sure be ordering some during our next visit. The blonde bartender was SLAYING drinks. I've never seen someone so confidently make a cosmo and an old fashion within a 3 min. time span. She is a force and knows exactly what she is doing. Food: We ordered an appetizer and two entrees. I really recommend the calamari appetizer, great quality and the spicy sauce that came with it was delicious (I love the spice level it was perfect!). I literally can't stop thinking about the salad I had, it was so diverse in flavor profile and texture...salty, sweet, acidic, bitter, creamy, crunchy, and fresh. I have only one complaint, both of our water glasses on the table that we had to drink out of were dirty (dried food stuck on the outside of the glasses and a sticky residue). Instead of making a fuss we just asked for straws. I can't wait to come back here, I'm hoping it is sooner than later!

I love their pizza. The crust is my favorite part but when it's burnt it's not so good. Little…read moredisappointed in the customer service.

Nice place, larger inside than it looks outside. There is a patio for dining al fresco. It's dark…read moreand cozy inside. The booths have a very private feel. I enjoyed the ambiance. Service was friendly and fast. I think there only two servers working the floor. They were flying! We ordered eggplant fries for an appetizer and they were delicious. Our pizza was the Wiseguy Loaded Extra, and was great. Hand tossed crust was cooked perfectly, not soggy or doughy in the middle at all. Toppings were good, the cheese was very good. The onions were sweet and tasty. We'll be back for more of the pizza. The only false note was the "pint" of Guinness. The wee glass would get you laughed out of the place in Ireland! It looked like a 12 ounce glass, not 16 for sure. Even on the tab it said "pint". But otherwise a fine place and we will come back for sure. Edit: I see our server's name is Zachary. Nice job, man!

Ordered Marco's via GrubHub while traveling. Was taking forever so I called the restaurant to…read moreinquire and the guy copped an attitude when I told him I ordered thru GrubHub. Told me I should have just ordered directly with the store. Well.....I guess he needs to have Yelp update his Yelp page because when you click to order it goes through GrubHub. Guy was a real butthead to me. Won't order from them again. Oh, and the pizza wasn't that good.

I called at 927pm they were not closing for another half hour. I was told if I ordered id have to…read morego through door dash. ?!? Why would I bother. I called dominoes o ordered more that i was planning to. I called back and asked marcos why I would i have had to use do. They said that they didn't have a delivery guy. I can see why. When they first opened some years ago, thing were great the menu was outstanding as the years went on I noticed inconsistantsies in the product, way too much spiced meat in the sub which drowned out the other flavors and probably cost more for the restaurant. I couldn't taste the full flavor of the sandwich. The roulette wheel of staff discouraged me from ordering. Then I noticed the managers. One was a flipping Nazi. I reported him.i just wanted a black and white transaction. I order, I pay, u give me my order..pretty simple huh? So I can see why you can't keep employees and drivers. Im done with Marcos. I'll just sit back and watch it go out of business. Meanwhile, dud you know that dominoes is open later has an Italian sub, pasta and you won't need door dash with scrappy managers running the show. Good luck marcos.

Service-We drove an hour and a half for a medical appointment. We paid for a pizza ahead of time…read moreso we didn't have to wait. I told the girl wih multicolored hair we would be back at 630pm after the appointment. She asked if that was it. I told her we'd get drinks when we came back to eat. I paid, went to the appointment and we came back. We were told it was their policy not to allow carryout orders to eat in the restaurant. When asked why, the rude server said it was their policy. We took our pizza and drove home. It was the last time for us to enter this classless pizza place. Don't buy from this joint.

Tried this place on a whim while visiting Wisconsin. Happened to be the day before this big…read moreblizzard and let me tell you, this pizza SLAPS! It is so delicious and hits the spot you're craving when it comes to a sweeter sauce pizza. Loved our server too, such an upbeat and sweet person! Failed to get his name though :( sorry about that.

We had a great experience here and Joe took fantastic care of us. Our kids came with and they were…read morealso treated well, which isn't always the case. We're excited to try the fish fry! Good pizza, fresh salads and AMAZING gelato (pictured).

Excellent food especially the home made pasta sauces. Friendly staff in a nice setting.read more

I've only had the pizza and I must say that it is delicious. We've gotten many flavors for various…read moreparties and get togethers and people always enjoy it! My favorite is the sausage.

Genuinely how lost in this world must a business be to not put PRICES on their menu in store? And…read morethen when asking your employees, even they're confused. What a way to be exclusive within a community that has a wide economic range. The pizza was good, but I'll never come back to a restaurant that justifies decisions like this.