They are the best pizza place in town it can't get no better, so if I was you I would bring your…read morefamily your friends your neighbors anybody you can think of because it is the best best pizza I've had yet of all the places I have eaten before which is a lot

It was warm not hot looked like it sat around for a long time cheese wasn't stringy pepperoni was…read moreover cooked cheese was hard the pizza looked like it was yesterday's this was not the first time pizza was this way we tried several times No more never buy theirs again

Stopped in for lunch today and their name is now "The Wing" as the owner retired and a long time…read moreemployee took it over and dropped "Broken". Had their 16" one topping pizza (pepperoni) and the crust is thick and tasty but could have probably been in the oven a bit longer. The sauce could use a bit more flavor however was satisfying. Had 10 of the Buffalo style wings (5 mild and 5 sweet chili) which were fried with a slight crisp, both good. Had a couple of side salads which were very nice, not to much and not to little. Recommend this restaurant!

Every one was so friendly and the cook was pretty cool even asked how it was and how we wanted ifread more

3.5 for sure. It deff has a very old outdated casual look inside because it's an old repurpused…read morebuilding. Needs a remodel and actual plates and silverware. Self serve everything from order, pickup, getting to go boxes, and bussing yourself. Pizza was 100% better under new owners in the new location! The last time I had it in the mall years ago was one of the worst sloppy gross pizzas I've ever had in my life. This time was great! A little soggy in the middle, but that was my only complaint. Great ranch! We'll gladly go again! Glad to see them getting back to their former glory of my childhood.

Pizza's are fantastic! Only downside is only one size available (but you can by pizza by the…read moreslice). Service was quick and accurate. Definitely will be back!

Consistently great food, friendly staff, and quick service. Going in for food always brings lots of…read morenostalgia.

You can't ever go writing here. The food is the best comfort food (pizza, subs, wings) around…read more Definitely a staple when I am in Olean. Great friendly staff.

So...pizza. It has become rather an innocuous cuisine in the American lexicon of food. Friday…read morenights spent at the local take-out sitting in front of Netflix for the evening, though fun and relaxing, is not usually a gastronomically orgasmic experience. But every so often, the moon and the stars and the planets align and The One is born. Renna's Pizza is the Chosen One. I believe it is housed in a Super Fund site at the old Olean Center Mall. A tiny hole in the wall to be sure with cramped, though ample seating. But the smells are to die for. And the crust...light, crispy, airy, crackly, flaky and bursting with that flavor you crave in pizza. And the cheese is not too much but just right. The sauce straddles the line of perfection. I was greeted with quick smiles by the staff and lightning fast service. 3 hour drive for pizza...oh yeah. And I'm doing it again.

We get pizza from Renna's East on most Friday nights. The ordering is easy on the Slice app. It is…read morealways ready when I get there to pick it up. The staff know me and are always friendly & positive. Renna's had been around for most of my life so it is like a bit of nostalgia. I really love the pizza and I am SO glad they have the "original" pizza oven!

Had AJ's Subs, Pizza & Grill delivered to my hotel in Olean. I ordered 3 plain pizzas and a small…read morechef salad, all for just over $50. The pizzas? Honestly great. Hot, cheesy, classic--and for the price? Can't beat it. But that "chef salad"? Oh. My. God. What I received looked like something you'd win as a consolation prize at a school raffle. I paid $8 for a plastic container of lettuce, one slice of tomato, a green pepper ring, and like... three croutons trying to hold it all together. No meat. No cheese. No egg. Not even a shred of effort. I've seen more toppings on a flight snack. This wasn't a salad made by a chef--it was a salad that called in sick. It looked like it was assembled by someone who whispered, "Good enough," and walked away. AJ's--your food is good. Your pizza? A hit. Your prices? More than fair. But that salad? That salad needs to be exorcised from the menu. For $8, I expected at least a garnish of dignity. That container of sadness was delivered to my hotel and somehow still found a way to disrespect me. Rest in peace to my $8--you were tossed, not dressed.

The service is good but the food is overcooked and portions are small for the price. The sugar in…read morethe pizza sauce is the only thing I taste. Much better pizza elsewhere.

Just visiting the area and stying at a B&B in Allegany. Found this gem online so we tried it! We…read morehad an awesome NY style pizza and decided we wanted the same thing for dinner the next night! Good Job Mangia2.0!!

New to the area, so far this is my favorite pizza place. They have what they say they have, and…read moreeverything's delicious. One slice is $4 and bigger than your head, as opposed to other nearby pizza places, who say on their website they have things, and then don't, gelato or a meat-lovers pizza for example. The slices at the other place are also smaller and only 50¢ cheaper, so not worth their value. Mangia's customer service is pristine and they definitely have their fans, as shown by the tip envelopes on the wall. It's open later so definitey a good late night stop, but only until 9 so I wish it was later still. They're open until 10 on Fridays and Saturdays. Every time I go in, there are almost no people which doesn't make a ton of sense but they also offer carry-out and delivery, and I also come at weird times. The vibes are phenomenal. Will be back and will add photos!