Very nice place. Clean, calm, and organized. Very good selection of clothes, shoes, jewelry, and so much more. The service is incredible as well. read more

I've been here a few times to sell items, and all the employees have always been friendly. Selling to them is always quick and easy--a nice way to get rid of items and earn some extra cash. read more

Second time there. Brought in clothes during the correct selling time of year. All brand name clothes, Junior skinny jeans from American Eagle and Hollister that were may be worn once or twice. (Black, Jean color) Sweaters and sweatshirts from Abercrombie, American Eagle and Aerie etc. Didn't buy one item. Girl told me it would take 45 minutes to get pricing. 11 minutes later I get a text saying they're done. Then they told me it's not the style they're looking for. A joke. read more

I had a great experience here there were so many kind employees and they helped me look for items and gave me a good price for the clothes I turned in! read more

Always have good experiences, the workers are great and very friendly. Nice location. Always have a good stock of items, good quality items too. read more

I'm just trying to to understand why they could not sell some name brand shoes I brought in and real leather, saying it's the material huh that doesn't really go with the fact that they are real leather and it's really a good shoe and I paid a nice penny for them from Ross but instead the other shoes I brought in they sold for 4 dollars and those were from fashion nova. Still a name brand shoes I brought is a name brand shoe, that's what suppose to b taken and sold right read more

Better Clothes and they all smell really bad i would rather smell the bottom of my husbands shoe after using a public restroom at a bar. DISGUSTING anyways im off to good will to get my better prices and they actually wash their clothes. Disgusting. Absolutely Embarrassing for your company. read more

A lot of selection in clothing but the girls working in the front never greet me the times I have came to the store to purchase items. They don't smile either, they just make the work environment unpleasant like they don't want to work there. read more

I brought in probably over 15+ items and they said they weren't able to offer me anything due to "low demand" even though it's all name brand stuff that I brought in. In addition, winter is around the corner and most of the items I brought in were sweatshirts. Absolutely a waste of time, don't even bother selling your things here! read more

It's a nice place. They purchase old items that are name brand only. They try to stay with the times.

There's always a good selection of clothes and shoes at discounted prices. I like stopping by, especially to look at the athleticwear!

This has nothing to do with the amount received or the clothes they picked or anything like that - it's all subjective when it comes to what they decide to purchase and that's fine and a part of the rules to the game. But the customer service of this place - especially the tall blonde woman who ran the desk was abysmal. Talk about someone who would spit in your face if given the chance - she was awful to me and yelled at me for just existing in the store. I don't think I've ever seen someone mimic the "tAlKinG liKE tHiS fOnT" in person but she perfected it to an art form with the way she yelled at me in front of other customers when she asked if I was there to pick up. Now I know what you're thinking, maybe I was a being rude too and that's a justified question - and you can choose to believe me or not when I tell you that I actually was just walking in. I will tell ya, she will have a great career in childcare with the way she talked down to me in our interaction - so if you know anybody who needs to be humbled for existing. She's the woman for you. They took a couple shirts so I can't complain, but the bin I brought back with me looked like it was as ravished as the dinner plates left behind from high school teenagers at an Applebees in the Midwest. Such a mess that leaves you in awe. With that said, everyone else was okay. read more

This is such a fun place to shop and I always have a great experience! They always have a great selection of clothes and I can always find something I love. I've been coming here for a while and the staff here is always so friendly and helpful. read more

Great store to triple your school clothes shopping dollars! Great selection & prices. Be sure to sign up for the rewards program! read more

Plato's Closet - Brookfield - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

Always such a great spot for balling on a budget and finding trendy items for a percent of retail value! I went a few months ago to drop off clothes and they took almost everything + were very nice! :) I'd come back! read more

My selling experience was amazing. Staff was quick to check me in and walk me through the process of how it's all done. At the end of it they picked what fit their criteria and returned the other pieces back all in a duration of 30-35 minutes. I made 57 dollars for the clothes they decided to keep and I think it was a fair price. My overall experience was satisfactory. Would recommend for sure! read more

I have been a customer and sold clothes to them and I have been satisfied with both! They can picky about what they buy but if you check beforehand for their most wanted items and follow that, you can get a decent amount for your stuff. People just need to realize that they can't buy everything even if it is perfect. As for shopping, its been 50/50. Sometimes I do find items with stains on them or holes but usually they are small or minor. I think the staff might focus too much on the brands and not the quality. Other times though, I leave with a lot really great stuff! You just have to look. read more

I was scrolling on Instagram and saw there was a Plato's Closet in Brookfield! I'm not familiar with the area so I was happy to see a familiar store. The staff was super friendly. As a student, I was looking to sell some clothes for cash as well as shop for athletic wear. I got a smaller amount of clothes sold, but I was satisfied as any cash is better than none. Their selection for athletic clothes were also nice! A cherry on top is how they organize their clothes! Would return here. read more

The staff was very helpful and guided me through the outfit picking process. The atmosphere was comforting as well, I will definitely be coming back! read more

Price of everything got you down? The upscale resale environment offers a thrifty alternative to traditional clothing shopping especially for the wishy-washy, cost conscious, ever changing teenage mindset. Plato's Closet is located in the VRichards shopping center in Brookfield on Blue Mound Road. Some of the most fashionable clothing in town is offered at a tremendous discount, prices reflect in some cases 60-70% less than your average prices at Hot Topic and boutiques at the Mall. The price of jeans averages between 10 and 30 dollars a pair for brand name slightly used, but in excellent condition for its second handedness. Cotton t-shirts average between 5 and 10 dollars a piece. An Abercrombie women's XS navy blue sweatshirt in excellent condition was purchased by our entourage for $14. The selection of vintage dresses in a multitude of styles and sizes were well worth the trip to Brookfield. The selection of designer hand bags was excellent. Several coach bags were for sale for around fifty dollars and they were as close to "new" as possible. The selection of shoes was also quite impressive. No Halloween costumes were discovered, however the vintage portion of the dresses could offer a unique idea for the fashion conscious individual. Pinching pennies may be the ultimate reward in discovering some of what upscale resale has to offer, yet the adventure into the world of thrifty fashionable clothing has its own immeasurable value. Check out the website for additional information at http://www.platosclosetbrookfield.com/ read more

Plato's Closet - Brookfield - Vintage clothing - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

Love this place! The staff is always very welcoming and super happy to help, whether it's just grabbing a fitting room or offering to put my items in a bin when my hands are full. I have never left the place empty handed! read more

Staff is friendly and helpful and the store is clean and organized!! Plato's is a great way to save the environment by buying recycled clothing for a fraction of the price you'd pay elsewhere. I love that Plato's is committed to the environment with recycled clothing and being a bagless store!! They also make it easy to social distance and are disinfecting things regularly. read more

I recently brought in three bags of jeans. At least half of the jeans were Levi's--many of them 501's in excellent condition and freshly laundered. I was trying to sell them because I lost weight and they no longer fit. There were other jeans in the bags as well (Paige, Ann Taylor, Lauren Conrad) and although I certainly didn't expect every pair to be purchased, I thought some (esp the 501's) were good contenders. The young lady at the counter spent less than 3 minutes looking at my items. In fact, she only looked at the contents of one bag. She barely touched the other two bags--she didn't even so much as remove the contents to examine them but sort of glanced in them and saw more jeans and dismissed them. I've done business at Plato's before and have been happy with my transactions. I would think if a customer would take the time to bring many items to sell, and there appeared to be something of value in that stack to purchase from them it would be better to buy something from them than to turn them all away completely and then tell them "So sorry, none of your items are what we're looking for today". Really? They're Levi's! So now you've completely lost a once happy customer because a short sighted employee didn't take the time to look at the items and isn't trained to see the bigger picture. Sorry Plato's....bad call. read more

Came in with a bin full of brand new designer items and was told that I would be contacted when they were finished sorting through them. As I waited, I overheard the workers talking about how incompetent another coworker was. I waited for over an hour before asking how much longer it would be until they were done sorting through my clothes, accessories and shoes. The workers informed me that my things have been ready for a long time. I never received any notification that my order was ready. They then let me know that there wasn't a manager available to authenticate my designer items, so they had to pass on almost everything. The couple of pieces that they were willing to take were worth over $100 together. They offered me $10. If I would have known how big of a waste of my time, the trip to Plato's closet would've been, I never would have driven over an hour. Will be finding a new consignment shop. read more

This place is a fricking joke and a complete and utter waste of your time if you are planning on cleaning your closet of any of your high end fashionable items. Pretty sure these "stylanistas" are taking inspiration from 5 year+ older Vogues although walking through aisles reflects more of a Farmers Almanac vibe! Don't Bother!!! read more

By far the worst experience ever. My mom and I drove 40 minutes to Plato's with a basket filled with name brand clothes. We waited 15 minutes for them to look through my clothes and out of a full basket they picked 2 pairs of pants and gave me $7.21 all together! More than half of these clothes had the tags on them and were only worn twice. I was told they don't take "youth sizes", I am a small girl but I don't wear youth sizes. Most of those clothes were a xsmall, small, or a medium which by the way they sell in store. I wasn't expecting to make a fortune off of these clothes. But what I brought in was basically brand new compared to the run down clothes that they had in store. You refuse to take clothes and shoes with the tags on them but are willing to take run down stuff with stains or shoes that are not gently worn. Complete waste of my time! read more

I came to this store pretty recently to sell a few items that I had. All of the stuff was new (with tags) or lightly worn. I signed in and completed the check in and headed back to my car to wait. I was told it would take around 30 minutes, but I received my alert in 10. I was offered $5 for a BRAND NEW Adidas skirt (that still had the tag on it and that I paid $30 for) and a pair of jeans. I will never return to this store to sell anymore of my clothing. It is a complete rip off and waste of time . If I could give it less than one star, I would. I also had to travel pretty far to complete this transaction so it's safe to say that I'm very disappointed! read more

Disappointed to find Plato's really doesn't take name-brand items for resale. I brought in some higher end pieces and they passed over them, instead taking an H&M t-shirt. This resale store definitely caters to a younger crowd. I was surprised to find resale plaid pajama pants and sweatshirts among the aisles. Overall bummed I drove out here expecting to maybe sell some nicer items! Anyone have any recommendations for Milwaukee area resale boutiques that are a bit more upscale? read more

I went to drop off clothes, some brand new in style clothes right now, clothes from shein, hollister, american eagle, and all that, they bought vans and 3 or 4 shirts from me for $11 I do not recommend. read more

I was kind of hesitant to sell my clothes because of the previous reviews but I thought I had pretty good trendy clothes and I was able to get 50$ for basically 2 joggers and 2 sweatshirts/shirts overall beats sitting in my closet very happy! read more

Rude 12 yr olds working there. No greeting when you walk in and they stare you down while browsing.

Since there's no response button on the owner's response to my review, I would just like to add that "dirty and grungy" is NOT in style. I'm talking deodorant stains, spots and heavily "pilled" sweaters. I think cleanliness is close to godliness. Second, The clothing I was bringing for consignment consideration ranged from size 0 to a size 6. I am now a size 8/10, so I had no reason to keep the items. I'm in my late 20s and I worked as a fashion model in Los Angeles and New York (mostly Los Angeles) until deciding to pursue my PhD. So why would you want me to take the clothing items to a "mature" women's store? Most of the items were classic, ageless or straight off the runway or no different than what we see in anchor stores currently. It's called fashion. But hey, I guess you have a different image of how a Wisconsin girl is supposed to be dressed. I wish your business well. To each his own. (BTW, I still send clothing to Decades on Melrose Avenue in West Hollywood and also, Real Real buys many of my items, including designer handbags). I've never been accused of having mature woman's clothes. read more

I've been here twice. The place is alright. Pretty organized and the staff is nice. They are picky on the items they receive which I could understand. But I had VERY good condition shirts (Hollister, AE, Abercrombie, etc, some not even used!), that looks like every other recent style that they are currently selling in the store. But apparently they were more than 1 years old so they denied all of them! So unless you bought clothing from the retail store, couldn't return it for some reason, and sell it to Plato the next week. They'd probably give you half or less than half for how much you actually bought the item. read more

Love this store! I love resale shops for sooo many reasons. This location is always friendly, full of great items and has plenty of bargains. I usually wait for their 90% off clearance deals and I was not disappointed. They have really high quality items and even their clearance items were great. read more

This Plato's location is one of my favorites because it carries great brands that I could get at the mall for less than half the price. However, from a seller standpoint this store is not great. They take basically nothing and what they do take you will get hardly any money back in return. So don't expect to walk out with big bucks, but if you have nice quality, name brand, recent purchases that you are looking to get rid of it is a good way to make a little money. read more

The butch employee who works here is completely rude. I came in to sell clothes and I did not have a mask on, as it is not a mandate anymore and other employees have never made me wear one or have asked me to. I stated that when came into the store to sell my clothes that none of the other employees said anything to me. And she responded with well I wasn't here and laughed at me. I will not be returning here unless this is addressed with the employee. read more

I came in the other day to try and sell some high end clothing. The staff was less than amused when I walked in at 5:00pm to drop clothes off. They told me they needed at least 20-30 minutes to review my items and see if they could take any clothing. That seemed definitely reasonable, if not very quick, when I received a text from them no less than 5 minutes later I was shocked. I walked in to the store where the very rude sales associate basically read off a script of why they would not accept any of my clothes. I was shocked some of my items were brand new and designer. She handed me back my bags of clothes that were UNOPENED. No one looked at my clothes. The store was disheveled and the sales associates were rude. I will never be back to any Plato's Closet again. read more

A nightmare. I've had great experience with other locations .. but this one is a complete rip off. They tried to give me $13 for all my stuff and I know for a fact the location in my home town would have given me at least $50, more than likely $80. I watched the other transactions and everyone got bad deals too. These girls literally have no clue what they're doing. Do NOT bring your stuff here!! read more

I bought jeans from a different Plato's closet 6 hours earlier and needed to return them because when I brought them home I notIced a stain. They would not give me in store credit and said I need to go back to the other Plato's closet. I will not be shopping at this Plato's closet. read more

It was first time and sure as hell the last time there. Simply inconsiderate teenagers at the registers that demean the meaning of customer service. This girl had the audacity to walk away from the counter as she is telling me that she can't accept my bag of clothes(high end , worn max 2 times with good keep). I worked at high end retail , and I guess it's true when they say you get what you pay for. Bless her heart.. read more