Hands down, the best deli in Mastic, NY ! All day breakfast available Daily specials & Soups Delicious baked goods Overall great home cooked comfort food vibes They also have a punch card for sandwiches so you can get a free sandwich! Totally recommend these when they have it available : The pesto macaroni salad Mac & cheese Chicken chili Rice pudding Lobster Bisque PB&J Muffins Meatloaf read more

Food is ok. Very expensive. Staff was nice. Place is not clean. Also, they are MAGA. If that makes you want to go there than go there. If it makes you not want to go there than don't go there read more

Very clean, lots and lots of choices of sandwiches... large breakfast menu. I have a roast beef panini with melted mozzarella, onions and portobello mushrooms.... It could use a little more sauce bc it was a tiny bit dry but it was big... comes with a small salad ( macaroni/ potato) . The owner is nice!! I would definitely back and try other things . read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

Terrible and over priced every time I get a sandwich from there the order is wrong or there's hardly anything on the over priced sandwich. I will never return for the disappointment. read more

Aside from being overpriced, DON'T order corned beef hash from here. It is NOT CBH! This owners idea of CBH is taking his home fries, throwing in less than a THIN DELI SLICE of corned beef, cut into thin, TINY strips and putting it in a container. There is ZERO flavor or ACTUAL CORNED BEEF. I thought I got home fries with a few pieces of ham. When I called him, he was arrogant and could care less that his food sucks!! Never again! Additionally, I was told that the monte crust was a platter. It's a sandwich which was quite literally thrown together with half the meat out in the container. The home fries had nasty orange cheese in them (never asked for cheese,) and it was all clumped up because it's clearly fake cheese. DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY! read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - This is corned beef hash? - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Prisco's catering was perfect for our family party this weekend. Food was excellent! Very reasonable and ready on time. The counter clerk may have been a part owner. He took care of helping me make good choices, didn't over-order. Took all the stress out of getting ready. It was just right! Highly recommend! Thank you! read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - Sandwiches and salads - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

5 star deli. Best of the best. Service, food, pricing. Does not disappoint. Definitely try it out.

I called an order consisting of three sandwiches in total. They got them correct and they tasted great. They are quick and never disappoint us! read more

Great food. Great selection. Sizeable portions. Fast and friendly service. I highly recommend the Ebbetts Field hero.

Great deli! From the food to the staff this deli is top notch. I realize that some people might not consider this neighborhood a dining destination for what ever reason but if you are looking for a great breakfast/lunch do not miss coming here, Prisco's Gourmet Delicatessen is definitely an oasis. The salads are very well dressed & filling. The sandwiches have just the right combinations of meat, cheese & bread. They build the sandwiches in such a way that they don't fall apart like other places. Lastly this deli is very clean & has an old school deli friendly atmosphere. To put this review in a nutshell Prisco's is a safe bet! read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - Spinach salad with grilled chicken! - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

I am so disappointed, I have been going to this deli for at least 10 years, they used to be so amazing and I hadn't been there in a while, I figured I'd go get a good old bacon egg and cheese. I got there, and I had also ordered a brownie. Came home to eat and realized that the BEC sandwhich had no cheese on it and had a bite of the brownie and spit it right out. I am so sad, this place has seriously gone down hill, what happened ?!?? read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - a piece of chocolate brownie - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

Love getting breakfast from here! great selection, owner is friendly. make your coffee which I like! My daughter enjoys their pink lemonade. loaded home fries are so yummy! although I tend to go for breakfast they are always making up hero's/panini platters that look so delicious. Thinking about getting my next deli catering order from here. They look so yummy! Definitely recommend to check it out. read more

Heroes are great. I called, I order to my specifications and it was delicious. Roast beef garlic bread and provolone with gravy. Amazing chicken parmigiana on garlic bread outstanding I asked for the chicken cutlet thinly sliced and it wasn't a problem. Really do highly recommend the lunches. read more

We ordered hero's for my sons graduation open house and we were very impressed! We ordered American, Italian, chicken bacon cheddar, Cuban, chicken mozzarella and roasted veggies and a grilled veggie hero! Everyone loved them! I would highly recommend! It's was a great price as we will definitely order from them again! read more

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - a table full of sandwiches - Delis Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

The food is so inconsistent. Its unfortunate because wjen its good ITS GOOD. It can be so great but if you get the exact same thing the next morning its completely different and terrible. I really don't get it. The 2 girls at the front are always confused about something and have trouble getting the orders down sometimes. The potential for this place is great I think maybe they've still got some things to figure out. read more

Walked in and my boyfriend and I ordered. We tried to find water bottles just to find the whole section of water bottles in the fridge warm. Also realized how the workers were NOT wearing masks while making a quick simple sandwich that took over 30-45 minutes to make. Walked out and didn't even bother to wait until they made the sandwich. Unsafe and ridiculous. read more

My favorite deli! Hands down best macaroni salad on the island. Tons of fresh, delicious salads, hero's and other options. The egg sandwiches are amazing too. Not your average deli! read more

Catered food for a small family reunion. Service was on time. Employees were friendly and efficient. Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. I even overheard a family member say that the hero was the most fresh they have ever had. Nobody was left disappointed. Highly recommend Sports Deli for your next catering event. Great food, great price, great quality!! read more

I come here often, and every time I have not been disappointed. My family is from pa and when they come to visit, I take them here and they say it's the best breakfast sandwich they have ever had. The staff is really nice and always are patient and kind, this Deli is very well ran. read more

Delicious Fast Super friendly and inviting Girl Scout was selling cookies inside and was so polite read more

We got catering from here for a first birthday! The food was phenomenal! Steve the owner worked with us and prepared dishes to match our barnyard bbq theme. The brisket was amazing, even our waitress who we hired privately to help said she has done so many parties and this was by far the best brisket she has ever had. The ribs were devoured so fast I didn't even see them. Everyone has been raving about the food for days and the owner takes pride in his business and it shows. I definitely would not over look this place when it comes to your catering needs. We will be using them for all our parties from now on. read more

For years now my coworkers and I have been going here for breakfast and lunch, we do our best to save lives in this town, but the people of Priscos save our stomachs, if you're looking for good quality food at a reasonable price, look no further, always friendly staff. And fast turn around. Especially I when we're running around town all day. Always will recommend this deli to anyone! read more

I would have given more stars if the TV wasn't blaring FOX News. Please please please give us all a break and either play cartoons or WALK97.5. read more

I used them for my daughters party this past Sunday. My wife did the order of a hero and a olive tray. Picked it up Sunday was supposed to be ready by 1230 I got there maybe 1245. They told me would be ready in 5 minutes. They gave me two trays of hero and a bag and said that's everything I said ok. My wife calls them they give her a attitude tell her that Steve will call her back. I call they tell me he won't be in today. I got a phone call this morning and call back guy is out again. I feel like it's playing phone tag to get my money back from this place. I'm a volunteer for mastic and I'm sure we use this place for our meetings. I think I'm gonna tell them to find a new place seeing how this place operates. I don't recommend this place to anyone. Go elsewhere for your hero's and sandwiches. The owner will not try to make things right and will play phone tag with you. Something so simple should just be fixed. read more

Great food and awesome staff! I ordered 2 bacon egg and cheese and an order of home fries. The bacon was cooked exactly how I ordered which was well done and crispy! The staff was super nice and helpful, I'll for sure be going back for a great breakfast read more

Let me start out by saying the food is always good here but the service always stinks for delivery drivers. I ALWAYS have to wait here for my food and they ALWAYS lie about how long it will take. After a heated exchange they admitted they lie to get the driver to stay so the customer doesn't have to wait longer for the food however by doing that they are doing a disservice to the driver. I will never take an order for delivery from here again. They made me wait way longer then reasonable and the jerk in the back was laughing at me being upset they lied to me. Also NOBODY there, customers and workers wore masks or were socially distanced. Stay away from this place! read more

Friendly staff, extended menu, but not at the cost of quality. They can make a mean wrap if you want healthier food, or you can cheat, and go with their panini's. Excellent choice as well! And they have a frequent customer program. Buy 10 sandwich/panini or wrap and the 11th is free. Never did try their breakfast menu. read more

Best deli in the area clean and food they mix it up. went in and want something the guy behind the counter suggested HH3. Incredible whites spinach with Swiss crazy good thanks for the tip. Go there whenever I can. read more

This place is great. We used to live over here and go all the time. Now every time we visit my sister in law we try to stop in.

Placed a huge lunch order. They got several orders totally wrong. Three of the Mediterranean salads screwed up- 2!without quinoa, one without feta, one was ordered with chicken and they just made a regular house salad with chicken. To add insult to injury he chicken was tasteless and dry . All the orders had one thing wrong or missing as well. This has happened quite a few times in the past when we've ordered . Our order was faxed early in the morning and it was delivered 30 min late. Total disappointment. read more

This place has gone straight DOWN THE GUTTER. They know it and they dont care. The staff is incompetent. Your order will be wrong every time. They are way overpriced. read more

this deli has great food. They also provide amazing service. The counter people are super friendly and nice. It is also very sanitary -- but it is so overpriced read more

The first time, I ordered from this deli they made a mistake while charging my card. Completely Minor not only did they make it right they made it better! Customer Service is awesome over there. I order with a co-worker and we order a new sandwich everytime. 4 Deliveries later, I'm still willing to go back. The only thing is I need to order Extra sauce on the side. I must like more sauce then most. I have nothing bad to say about my sandwiches! read more

We provide lunches regularly for all staff members as a reward and thanks for all their efforts during our very busy summer months. We turn to Steve and his crew at Prisco's Gourmet for their creative sandwiches, terrific salads, pickle and relish trays, which are always delivered fresh as can be, on time, every time. Every DunRite employee responds very positively to what Steve creates and we look forward to ordering our next lunch from Prisco's Gourmet after just ordering for Friday the 13th. You won't be disappointed with their food quality, creativity and terrific service. Thanks to everyone at Prisco's Gourmet, Charlie Mal/DunRite Appliances read more

Our FAVORITE place to order our lunch!! Our pharmacy orders from their delicious "Specials Menu" just about EVERYDAY and we are never disappointed! They are friendly, professional, and the food is amazing...from breakfast to lunch....there's something for everyone! If you haven't tried their "Chicken Pot Pie" soup.....your in for a treat! A special shout out for our favorite delivery guy John! Thank you for coming out in all kinds of weather to bring us hot food! You Rock!! read more

Please read the dangers of this gross slop hole I really wanted the place to shine, the outside is cute but it hides the nightmare The place in the summer is loaded with flies. Flies is never a good sign. They also keep the food for the fryer out in the open so the flies can feast. I ordered a strawberry cream cheese bagel toasted. They gave me a bagel not toasted with fresh, badly cut strawberries and regular plain cream cheese. IM ALLERGIC to fresh fruits and vegetables and started having a attack (closing of pipe). I alerted to talk to a cashier who gave me a bad attitude like it's my fault. Besides the fact I almost died, that is not strawberry cream chesese. And the fact I was treated like garbage for there mistake. BESIDES the flies. I don't know WTF that whole experience was but Do not go there. If you read this owner. I'd suggest you hire a new crew, teach them about food allergies and food handling or clean the store or shut down. I do not appreciate this and I do not believe a business should operate like this either. I will not be returning. read more

My boyfriend and I have been going here for years! It is our Sunday morning routine to grab breakfast at Prisco's. The food is always delicious and Steve and his lovely staff are a delight each and every visit! read more

No stars aweful attitudes As for Gourmet they should try cooking school. Better service

We have been using Mastic Sports Deli for years! Whether it was my daughter's christening, my husband's birthday or just a family party, they have been there for us. The food is always amazing and we are always asked "where did we get the food from?" I would absolutely recommend them for catering your next event. Not only will your belly be happy, but so will your wallet! read more

After going here for years and getting breakfast and lunch I could honestly say I never had a bad experience! It is a family run business, and the family has pride and great customer service skills. I recently placed an order for catering and I cannot say how happy everyone was with the tastiness and freshness of the food. The ordering process was professional and handled with care. I highly recommend this deli! Try the Lucy for breakfast-it's healthy and yummy...they always have great tuna too. Thanks to Steve and his great family for having this awesome deli:) read more