The fine citizens of Long Island know a good bagel when they taste one. 5 years of living here and you start to smell like everything bagel seasoning. 10 years? Cream cheese begins to run through your veins (kidding -- if that happens pls see a doctor). It may be named Your Bagel Cafe, but it is MY forever bagel spot (but we can share). Their tasty bagels have the perfect toasted balance of chew and crunch. Their cream cheese cannot be beat in quality, taste, or portion. The order is always friggin' correct -- their heads are clearly in the game, and they have such a wonderful, positive vibe. Their professionalism is aspirational. Their delicious hard work fuels me to do mine, and I am grateful. read more

Ordered a BLT, see if you can find the lettuce cause I couldn't until I had to open the sandwich. Ordered a Blue Monster with Zero sugar, they gave me a low carb one and no pickle. I called and there excuse was there's a new kid. If the kid is new then why isn't there someone to make sure the orders are correct. This store has gone down hill. This was my go to spot for bagels in Shirley but the last few times I've gone it's not as good as it was. Always seems to be an issue with my order for the last few times I've gone. read more

Your Bagel Cafe - BLT, where's the lettuce?!?!?! - Cafes Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

Service, quality, and amazing bagels. The egg Sandy's are on point always and if you want to stay they have plenty of room even on a Sunday.

These guys have been a staple of the CM king kullen lot for years One of the best tasting egg sandwiches I've had (even with a steep price recently) Truly a unique flavor district to the YBC kitchen Great people and service and great environment - much better than the shops in up in manorville or goldbergs down the block which are both chains read more

I went there about 9am on 2-25-2025 bought a dozen bagels and 1/2 pound of sliced Lox's . Drive home ten minutes away put the Lox in refrigerator then about 7 pm took it out to make a sandwich and it was rotten, slimy, with big black spots . Had to throw it out not to get sick or stink up the house. Obviously This bagel shop doesn't care what they sell or how they sell it.Obviously there more interested selling rotten lox rather then taking a loss and throwing it out. I can't imagine this place staying in business doing this because I'll never go back or even ask for a refund. They got me for 18.00 and that will be the last penny they get from me or any of my family or friends. It's Unbelievable they have the nerve to do this ! read more

Your Bagel Cafe - Food poisoning - Cafes Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

See all

Would recommend service is great food is better there is one beautiful lady working there that is the best also.

Awesome bagel store great bagel's fair pricing great quality, always my go to bagel store, always fresh bagels also they participate in too good to go which is a plus, try a plain egg bagel with butter and cream it's to die for, Enjoy. Service is excellent. read more

I've been here and it's very good, but it says they deliver and they don't FYI. Staff is very nice and we love the bagels. read more

Second time ordering from Uber Eats and an item was missing, toast was not toasted. Will not revisiting this establishment. If you can't accommodate simple requests you will lose business read more

Always good always friendly fast and. Reliable phone order ahead of time always ready when I get there and order is right most of the time

Yummy bagel the place was clean and friendly service. Would go definitely go back here read more

Your Bagel Cafe - egg everything bagel with cream cheese - Cafes Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

See all

I was going to visit my daughter at college in Worcester, MA. My daughter, at the last minute, asked that I bring her bagels. It was 8:30pm so I needed to find one that was going to open pretty early. We stopped at this bagel store. It was before 6am and they were open!! Most were closed. The place was busy, clean and friendly. Their veggie cream cheese was great too! Will definitely go again! One last thing, the outside of their bagel is a bit crunchy and the inside is soft. It was SO GOOD! read more

First time coming here. I ordered a regular breakfast sandwich and it was damn good. Sandwich was the perfect temperature. Eggs cooked properly. Ham was cooked exactly how I would cook it if I was home, the staff was very polite and courteous. I will be coming back. read more

The service is not good .The place is not clean .They don't speak English well .Takes a long time to get your food .

My wife and I come here after church almost every sunday. Definitely one of my favorite places to get a bagel. Never dissapointed, and the place is very well staffed so the wait is never that long (even on a sunday morning) on top of that the staff are very friendly, especially Rebecca! I would recommend this bagel place for sure. read more

Your Bagel Cafe - Egg Everything w/ olive cream cheese (yumm) - Cafes Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

Samantha is always a great help at all times, multi tasking to make sure all customers are being taken care of. always makes sure that your order is correct and complete with always being pleasant and sincere. read more

If you don't mind paying $6.49 for a basic egg, ham and cheese sandwich then this place is great. The food was very good but for me.... I'll stick to the convenience store down the block that charges about $3 for the same sandwich and it tastes just as good. Too rich for my blood. read more

Visit every morning. Service is great and orders are always correct. Would highly recommend

Picked up a few bagels this morning. They are friendly, service is quick and the bagels are delicious. We had 2 of the bagels scooped, all 3 toasted and they were done perfectly. Couldn't have done it better myself. They have seating in the front, which is nice. The seats are not in the middle of the foot traffic coming in, so that's nice too. Also, its clean. I just wished they didn't use styrofoam cups. But, I'll be back for bagels for sure. read more

Bagel are absolutely delicious! Very quick services. Definitely worth every penny. Clean store, friendly staff, and your orders are done right read more

Very disappointed. Called in an egg sandwich order and they got both completely wrong. Bagels are disappointing as well .

Food is pretty good here, but as a community member who works with a lot of the school sports programs, owner wants NOTHING TO DO WITH DONATING OR GIVING DISCOUNTS even when advertising was part of the package. For this reason alone I choose the other bagel store in town. read more

I tried many delis in the area, but nothing compares to this place. Great service! Food is always fresh great egg sandwiches

Has gotten much better over the years. Bagels are good and coffee is decent. I have never had a bad meal. Service can be a bit slow if they are crowded, but that is expected. The place has gotten much busier over the last year. Credit to them. Most of the staff is pleasant and nice to deal with. It is my local stop for bagels and coffee. Glad to have them around. My only wish it that the bagels were cooked a little more, but that is personal preference. I like a crispy bagel on the outside with a soft inside. I just ask for a well-done bagel. read more

I've been stopping at this bagel shop for the past 3months on my way to work. Everyday is something new with this place. Between the huge trucks in the morning taking up the whole parking lot making parking extremely inconvenient..and the guys who drive those trucks get breakfast there as well but make me so uncomfortable because they don't take there eyes off me like I'm a piece of meat. (Sleazy older men staring at young girls) on top of all of that I realized after a month of going there that I was supposed to get a free small drink with my egg sandwich which I've Never once received with my orders instead they have been charging me for drinks. Another thing I don't like is that the prices always change depending on who is ringing you up depends on what you will actually be paying. Some of the staff is nice but most look miserable like they don't want to be bothered helping you. Over all I'm not pleased and today was my last time giving this place a chance! The $15-$20 I was spending on breakfast daily definitely isn't worth it here! read more

Your Bagel Cafe - a close up of a sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

Surprised there aren't more reviews on YBC as the place is always packed on the weekend. Absolutely love the egg everything bagels, always fresh from the oven. Staff is nice and attentive. Highly recommend!!! read more

While they're far from traditional bagels, I'd be lying if I said I didn't love it here! So many memories... I'd go before school sometimes, and it would be so early the bagels would still be hot! The vegetable cream cheese is fantastic, goes great with plain, everything, salt... Anything savory! What I really love is how there's a lot of salt on their everythings... So many places think that a doughy, undercooked bagel with sesame and poppy seeds suffices as an everything, but these bakers get it perfectly, with tons of salt, onion and garlic! It's always fun to find time to sit by the window (like I did when I was still in school) and have a bagel, drink, with coffee or hot chocolate! Treat yo' self! And if you really have the time, have a toasted everything with butter. It's delicious and for me brings back lovely memories! The place is a bit small, but is convenient, has a very kind staff and serves fun food! Enjoy, and sorry I brought up school a hundred times! read more

We were coming from the city, and we stopped by this bagel cafe. To be honest, I was not expecting this taste. Bagels were so fresh and there are lots of different options. The owner and workers are so friendly. Thanks for everything guys, you made our day great read more

Stayed open a few minutes extra to help me, so they earn two stars for that. But the lunch special chicken cutlet sandwich was literally an over microwaved single slice of chicken on a roll three times too big... Needless to say I will not be returning. read more