Wish I could give more than 5 stars!! The cutest restaurant and the food is so good. Their gluten free crust is delicious. Very different than traditional GF crust. Thicker, but still chewy and crispy. The toppings are fresh and their homemade salad dressings are amazing. The staff is so nice and friendly and helpful. I cannot say enough good things! They also have gluten free desserts. read more

Prohibition Pizza - Gluten free BYO with mushrooms and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

I followed my fellow yelpers advice and stopped here on the way out of town. A sweet atmosphere, nice staff and great pizza. I had the personal supreme minus mushrooms and it was awesome . They have 4 different sizes to choose from which is great if you are alone. It was done in a reasonable time and was served hot. They also have a lot of different salads and they come in two different sizes too. I was so tempted to get a dessert, they had several I would like to try but I was full and traveling so I had to pass it up this time. The dining room was super clean, even the bathroom was clean. I will stop here again when I am in town. read more

See all

Wow, what a gem of a hidden little treasure in the High Springs area. We found this place only by accident as it is not on the main strip in town but on a secondary street. The locals recommended it to us and I lived in the area for most of my life until I turned 21 and did not know there was a entire second street of businesses in this town. Take the trip, enjoy the scenery of the "prohibition era" theme and try one of their signature pies, such as the Dillinger and Capone. You won't be disappointed! read more

Prohibition Pizza - Love trying new places in small towns. - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

The decor was interesting, dining room, small, but not cramped small, just not a large space but comfortable- especially the padded chairs-loved those, and could probably seat around 20 guests. The person taking our order and making our food was friendly, knowledgeable, efficient, thoughtful and makes delicious pizza. They also checked on us a couple of times while we were eating. We will definitely stop by again when we're in the area. read more

See all

Prohibition Pizza is a good option for a meal in the small city of High Springs, Florida. Prohibition Pizza has a great ambiance and the service was friendly and professional. High Springs is very fortunate to have Prohibition Pizza as part of its community. I would definitely recommend a visit here. read more

Prohibition Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Good pizza with small but fun dining area. Service was fine - no complaints. We ordered deluxe extra crispy. The advertisement claims New York style pizza but I don't agree - failed the fold test. read more

They had the best gluten free pizza I've ever had. Staff was friendly. A very small place with the choice of inside or outside dining. Will definitely be back! read more

Well, I came across this Pizza spot during a internet search. Had never heard of it, so I figured, why not? Took a nice Sunday drive in the afternoon to go out and try it. We were met by friendly staff. You place your order at the counter. could get it either, just sit down at 1 of their tables or they have some outdoor seating, or you can take it to go which while we were there there were numerous people coming to pick up to go orders.So that was a good sign. We got the pretzel for an appetizer, that thing was huge! We got the Margarita Pizza, which also while we were there. Three more people had ordered the same pizza, so it must be one of their more popular pizzas. Now there is no table service, so their only drink option is either bottled sodas or waters with some select bottled beers. They have a lot of historic décor in the building as that area of High springs is part of the historic area. If you're looking to get away from the hustle and bustle of gainesville, prohibition pizza is the spot to check out read more

See all

Wow!! If you're gluten free you must come here. So of the best gluten free pizza I've ever had. They also may a GF cheese bread as well as GF desserts. I actually thought the GF pizza tasted better than their regular pizza. Had the meat combo. Service was great and talked with the owner a bit after our meal. Medium size sitting area as well as outdoor seating, love the warm feeling. If you're ever in high springs do not skip this eatery! read more

This is the best pizza I've ever had, I think it was brick oven pizza it had a nice crust and sauce was really good and you tell it's fresh house made sauce !!! Everyone was super nice and didn't kick us out at close we were there about 30 past 9 (sorry), this is my one and only pizza place now. I can't wait to bring my husband here and anyone else I know I'm telling them to come here ! The inside is really pretty too, comfy beautiful chairs, nice bathroom, I came on Halloween night with my sis and her family and we were just blown away ! We will be back ! read more

Prohibition Pizza - Pepperoni , garlic, oregano, extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Their pizza is always amazing!! I've tried several different topping combos and they never disappoint. Pictured in the photo is the Dillinger - vodka sauce, mozzarella, provolone, sliced meatballs, caramelized onions, jalapeños, ricotta and hot honey. The honey really makes it a stand out! The Bad Betty dessert is also to die for! Absolute must have food when in High Springs. The small is a perfect size for one. read more

Prohibition Pizza - The Dillinger - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

I was here because I was across the street at High Springs Brewing and wanted dinner. Already parked, already hungry, already starting my first beer. What to eat? And then, the "sandwich board" in the entrance got me and I didn't even have to look at the menu. The combination of ingredients just had me. The Dillinger which is "Vodka sauce, mozzarella & provolone cheese with sliced meatballs, bacon, caramelized onions, jalapenos, ricotta dollops finished with hot honey drizzle." About 15 minutes after ordering (and after my first beer was done), I was back over here to pick it up. Perfection. Spicy, meaty, cheesy, simply delicious. [Review 1037 of 2024 - 1912 in Florida - 22065 overall] read more

See all

Interesting casual prohibition-themed atmosphere. The pizza is delicious and has diced plum tomatoes in the sauce. The restaurant is small and menu options are limited. Service was quick. read more

I have been here twice now but if I lived closer it would be more like fifty times... I love Probibition Pizza. The best gluten-free pizza I've ever had--Prohibition has filled a Satchel's-shaped hole in my Celiac heart. The Bee's Knees pizza is absolutely wonderful, and the cheesy garlic bread and GF key lime pie are fantastic too. Staff is clearly well-versed in what gluten-free means and what allergy precautions are. I have yet to dine in the restaurant but the vibe of the outdoor seating looks like it would be nice, so I am hoping to try that in the future. I will definitely be returning so I can steadily work my way through their very appetizing vintage-inspired menu. read more

Best GF crust EVER!!!! I am Obsessed I am gluten & dairy free, not by choice. I was so impressed by Prohibition Pizza accommodates both dietary restrictions and does so with outstanding service and as I said at the beginning the BEST GF crust EVER!!!! read more

My husband and I were visiting the area, and it was our anniversary so I was looking for some place to eat, not feeling like doing the drive into Alachua. I wasn't feeling like pizza but the better half could eat the stuff evry day. Nothing else in area tickled my fancy so I said let's suprise him with pizza. Man! it was a suprise, it was delicious. Crispy crust, just the right amount of sauce, and good amount of toppings. While waiting for our pizza a couple next to us did their fair share of raving about it too. So go ahead and stop in, you won't regret it. We're moving to the area so this will be come our regular pizza place. read more

The underground pizza is to die for. The theme of the place ties in perfectly for a great atmosphere. We visited on a home-buying trip from Maryland. I grew up in the Northeast around the Philadelphia area, and this was by far the best pizza I've ever had. This place is Florida's hidden gem! read more

Prohibition Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

Very unique pizza place. Options were very creative and the two pies we ordered were delicious! Friendly staff--the owner came outside to the patio and greeted us and asked if everything was good. read more

Prohibition Pizza - Blue Bomb pizza--delicious! - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

This place is a great pizza spot. The inside decor looks like back in the old Prohibition days. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Bathroom is very clean. The chairs inside are super comfortable. The pizza and wings are the best I've had in this area. I highly recommend Prohibition Pizza read more

The meatballs appetizer was delicious. Their sauce with the meatballs very tasty. Their Margherita pizza was very good. Highly recommend stopping here to get some pizza. read more

Incredible pizza with a great selection of beverages. Even the decor is tastefully done and with great music!

This is a wonderful establishment! It's a beautiful place with so many cute details. The pizzas are delicious. We had the pepperoni, margherita, and the goodfella. We also had the Sin NY Bites. Would love to go here again to try the other toppings and other desserts. read more

See all

Cute little place with great pizza. Service was great. The have a selection of alcoholic drinks - beer, wine, cider and seltzers. read more

See all

If I keep reviewing this place, someone's going to get suspicious. I just saved $5 on my flight to Alaska in October so I'm celebrating by treating myself to the BEST DARN PIZZA in High Springs (or maybe anywhere). Today I opted for the Capone (Supreme). Again ... not disappointed. In fact, overjoyed! This place has the skinny on delicious crusts and when's the last time you got a pizza where the ingredients were lovingly placed right up to the edge rather than hurriedly plopped in the middle? And who uses fresh mushrooms and Kalamata olives? Prohibition Pizza ... that's who!! Just because I haven't posted a picture of their awesome bathroom, I'm adding some to this review. Go for the pizza ... stay for the bathroom read more

See all

The crust is perfectly done--crispy on the outside, soft on the inside--and every bite is packed with flavor. The food is consistently outstanding, and we make a point to stop here every time we drive through the area. Always worth it! read more

Absolutely amazing pizza , stopped in for our first time ever in the way in for vacation! The gluten free pizza and cheese bread is the best hands down !! 10/10 try you wouldn't be disappointed read more

Prohibition Pizza - Gluten free cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

It was very good but not as exceptional as others described. I guess it's the best for Florida. New York knows how to make real pizza!

Super nice place, super great pizza and super great service. Shaded outdoor area if you have your pup with you. read more

Prohibition Pizza - This pie was a beauty!!! One of the best pies I have had the pleasure of devouring!! - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Hands down the best gluten free pizza I have ever eaten. The combination of toppings are truly inspired. They were very kind and welcoming. If you are gluten free do not miss the opportunity to eat there. read more

Prohibition Pizza - Arugula, sausage, onions peppers and drizzled with very good balsamic vinegar. - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

Don't walk run... This place is a gem in High Springs. I really enjoyed a small Gorgonzola salad along with a personal (8") margarita pizza and they were both outstanding. Very clean restaurant and bathrooms and the staff was extremely polite. read more

My family and I are pizza nerds! That being said we were VERY excited to try Prohibition Pizza, as the pizza selection in the area isn't the greatest. For our first foray, we decided on an order of the cheesy garlic bread, one large Goodfella, and one large old world. I'll preface my critiques with this message for Prohibition Pizza: you guys did one heck of a job! I truly feel like you guys are going to do well. Do not take my constructive criticism to heart. The cheesy garlic bread was delicious. Crispy on the edges (they bake it in what looked to be like a Detroit style pan). The cheese was definitely the way to go. If I had to choose one negative it would be that we felt there could have been more garlic. That could be a personal taste thing, we want to be hit in the face with the garlic when we order garlic bread. All in all, 4/5 for the cheesy garlic bread. The Goodfella was undoubtedly the star of the show. The combination of the ingredients really hit different, and the light sweetness of the peas offsets the salty prosciutto. An amazing combination to say the least. My gripe is that there didn't seem to be a lot of vodka sauce on the pie. I don't know if that was intentional, or if the folks at Prohibition were so busy (because they were slammed when we ordered) that they tried to rush it. If you guys read this, MORE VODKA SAUCE! 5/5 The Old World was also a well put together pie. The sauce was so flavorful and not lacking whatsoever. It kind of reminded me of a NY "Grandma" style pie with the plum tomatoes garlic and oregano, but those are traditionally square pies. Overall we'd give this one a 4/5. I hope that this place keeps at it and stays in business. We look forward to eating more pizza from them soon! read more

See all

Amazing taste really good very clean love the atmosphere great attitude very pleasant read more

Prohibition Pizza - Hawaiian pizza/pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

This is by far the absolute best pizza I have EVER had! Amazingly fresh ingredients, loads of pure love in every bite!! Beautiful ambiance also!! read more

See all

THE BEST GF PIZZA IVE EVER HAD!! Prohibition Pizza was not only delicious, but they have a really cool atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating. The staff is SOOO friendly and really care for their customers. They were extra careful with my allergy, which I appreciate so much!! 10/10 recommend, do yourself a favor and go get some pizza from Prohibition Pizza, trust me. read more

See all

Overview: 5/5 I am admittedly a New York pizza snob. This place passes the test with 5 stars across the board. Thank Heavens for a new restaurant choice in High Springs!!! Ambiance : 5/5 Love, LOVE, love the decor throughout this place. The women's bathroom was AMAZING. No expense spared on new pizza ovens, plenty of tables inside and out for smaller groups. Large parties might have trouble getting seated together. Food/Drink 5/5 I order a Margarita pizza that was perfect. The crust was just right, sauce was not too sweet and fresh mozzarella and basil. Beautiful presentation. My wife had a build your own with pepperoni, mushroom, peppers and onions. It was outstanding. It was crisp on the bottom but light and not too thick. Only thing that would have made this better is a beer from High Springs brewery (which is right next door). This place is working on a liquor license so fingers crossed. They have a unique dessert with a clever name called the "Beeramisu" which is a spin-off on Tiramisu. The owner created the recipe and it was delicious. Service : 5/5 Wonderful!! Kelly the owner brought the food to our table and checked on us a couple of times. I always think it's pretty important afor a new establishment (open about month) that the owners keep tabs on the customers. Well done Kelly. Conclusion : We live in Alachua but I will have no problems jumping in a car to ride to this place. Hopefully many, many times. read more

This is probably the best pizza I have ever had. The variety of toppings is amazing. The pizza is very filling. Prices are reasonable. The staff is helpful. We love visiting High Springs and treating ourselves here. read more

Me and my family were in dire need for some good eats after a long day of swimming and adventure at ginnie springs, we found prohibition pizza and were beyond impressed with the quality, taste, service and atmosphere, this is a GEM in high springs, Fl. Congrats on 1 year of delicious pizza P.S. shout out to our server Makayla for excellent service, she really brought this whole experience together! read more

Prohibition Pizza - "The underground" - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

First time here and we're SOLD! Menu is good and they have a few unique specialties to choose from as well. Mini craft beer fridge had some great options too. We got the pretzel app with beer cheese and honey mustard. Came out fast and hot... delicious. We ordered the large Capone pizza and it didn't disappoint either. Fresh toppings were loaded onto a doggy but still crispy crust. There's limited seating inside, but more outside and since it's cooling off, we opted for outside. Pizza came pretty quick too, and we listened to the music coming from the brewery. If you haven't been yet, GO! If you have, GO BACK! I'm really hoping they do very well because this is now a favorite! read more

Prohibition Pizza - Pretzel app with beer cheese and honey mustard, accompanied by our ACE ciders. - Pizza Near Me - High Springs, Florida

See all

The pizza was great! We were not expecting to order from the counter, but that was ok. Very few tables inside though, and we had no ice for our drinks. read more

Pizza was outstanding. Seating is very limited though. Better to order and pick it up. Restaurant is clean and they are very prompt on getting food out. If you plan to visit Itchnetucknee this should be your next destination. read more