this place was run down dirty and you could hear the people next door like they were sitting in…read moreyour room....the staff was non existent ....just horrible ...stay away

This phenomenal place needs more reviews. It is impressively clean and cozy. A little small but I…read moreenjoyed the cleanliness and updated feel of it all and didn't need extra room for anything so it was all good. Also, I really liked the balcony and chairs for people watching. The staff are friendly and try their best to accommodate you and your requests. I will be staying here for each visit to Put in Bay. Thank you!

We stayed in the tiki loft and loved it. Very cute property and well maintained. Affordable golf…read morecarts. Great location close to downtown PIB. Clean rooms and comfortable beds. Highly recommend and would stay here again!

This place is beautiful and clean. However from the moment I arrived the owner was not welcoming at…read moreall. My friend and I were giggling with exciting at noon while checking in and he scolded us and said "this is your warning" to be quiet Or I will evict you! I am a mature 51 year old adult all excited to start a vacation. I was not drinking! Other friends staying at this place were treated the same. i paid this man over $800 for 3 nights and he clearly doesn't appreciate my business. I was treated like a child from the start of the trip. All he did is threaten to evict us if we were loud and would take my golf cart if he found it unlocked. Umm a threat to steal the cart that I paid to rent and signed a rental agreement! So Bungalow Joe, I think that would be theft on your part! I have insurance!! DON'T STAY Here is you want to be treated like a child.

Normally I am pretty lenient and understanding with any hiccups or mishaps during a stay, but I…read morefeel compelled to share my story about my experience at the Ahoy Inn. After checking in on 7/2/18 with my emotional support animal (I suffer from anxiety and have my Yorkie registered with supporting documentation), my boyfriend and I went out to explore the island. As we returned in the evening, the hotel manager informed us that she was leaving a voicemail in regards to our animal, as well as being a "non-couple" in the same room (Ahoy Inn only allows couples to rent a room). I advised the woman that we were indeed a couple, and her demeanor immediately changed to being rude after finding out I identify as a gay male and have a boyfriend. After this encounter, I was then advised my boyfriend and I would need to leave the hotel immediately (it was 9PM at night) as the premises does not permit emotional support animals. Come to find out, the manager later disclosed they do in fact have "specific" rooms for couples staying with emotional support animals, but the room we paid for and were staying in was not one of them. Ahoy Inn refuses to refund payment on a room which was occupied for less than 6 hours, and put us in the position to have to leave the island the same night to try and find a room (being the week of the 4th everything on the island is booked). I am appalled and disappointed at the treatment from Ahoy Inn. Not only do I feel as though I was being discriminated against for being a homosexual couple, I was further discriminated against by not being allowed to stay in a hotel which accommodates emotional support animals, just not in my specific room.

My sister and her husband stayed here on the weekend. Very romantic. Nice, clean rooms. King-sized…read morebeds. Private bathrooms. Friendly atmosphere and owners. Great for couples. Unfortunately, they can not accommodate pets. Rooms are themed for different countries. Greece, Slovakia, etc. Five minutes from town so a short walk to the local pubs. Check out is at 11 a.m.. There is parking onsite. Complimentary bikes!

We had our reservations here over a year ago! My husbands back went out and we couldn't make it! So…read morethey let us postpone for a year!!! We arrived on Monday morning and it has been an amazing time!!! The house is older so that being said you must take that into consideration!!! But it was very clean and comfortable!!! The breakfasts were good and tasty!!! The coffee is awesome!!!! Dave try's to have fresh cucumbers or tomatoes straight from his little garden!!! We rented a golf cart from Dave and went all over the island!!!! The house is centrally located!!!! You could walk to town very easily or to the family entertainment area!!! We took several walks all around town with no problem!!!!! We will be back!!!!

The Ashley house is a charming excursion into hospitality and exemplary service. The proprietor…read moreDave exemplified great dedication to his establishment and his guests. The rooms are clean and cozy. Each room has a theme we stayed in the Sunflower room. The front porch is welcoming and you are likely to make friends there before the night is over. It is nicely situated close to the best places to eat on the island. Dave takes the time to orient his guests to the Island and demonstrates an encyclopedic knowledge of the area. We plan on returning. I highly recommend this establishment.

Spectacular service and good was delicious! We highly recommend everything about the Gateway Inn!…read more5-Stars!

An amazing stay in an amazing place! The detail and comfort were incredible! It is rustic, super…read morewell-kept, great shared spaces, hearty breakfasts, lovely pool and the beds were super comfortable! Each room has its own unique look with different styles. All the amenities are included. You can rent golf carts and they also provide bikes. I would definitely recommend this place and would be happy to visit again! Great location too. Just close enough to all the action and the waterfront and far enough away to enjoy the serenity.

Do not book here. I am upset with their lack of professional communication skills. My mother passed…read moreaway the week of a previously booked trip. I texted the owner to ask if there was anything they could do to process a partial refund (I knew a full refund was off the table). They responded fairly quickly with what seemed like thoughtful support and they offered to "see what they could do." After that, after following up on their offer they stopped responding to all correspondence (text, Vrbo messaging, calls etc). This was over a month ago and myself and my guest have tried to contact them. Very rude and unprofessional to ignore customers.

If you are heading to PIB for relaxation and comfort, this will not be the place for you. We were…read moretold we were booking the middle unit, but upon check in, the group before us had received an "upgrade" ( their words) and were given the middle unit and we were placed in the basement unit. This is not a three bedroom unit- two futons, two horribly dates and nasty stained futons do not constitute beds. If you are over 5'6" you will need to crane your neck to fit in the shower. This is a very old basement that someone has attempted to make decent for sleeping quarters. Everyone shares the yard and porch, so if we were to have stayed in the middle unit, i cant imagine a restful sleep there either as the porch is partied on all night. There were 14 people in the top unit, 6 people in the middle and the 5 of us in the basement. The person that owns this property also owns the houses on both sides and it was party central all weekend. If you are bringing your kids, or want relaxation, there are better places to choose than this location. As a lodging owner myself, I just have to add that the bed sucked horribly. Comfort def is not first and foremost.

Stopped by here for a fun little pool day. It was packed full of people. I'm not sure when the best…read moretime is to arrive but we got there shortly after noon and it was standing room only. There were no chairs left and barely any room to stand. The DJ was good. There was quite a variety of music. Not really my vibe but everyone seemed to be happy and enjoying a few songs here and there. The drinks were great. The bartender in the pool was great. Very attentive and friendly. Like most popular places the drinks were expensive and the big "O" drink was all ice, but it was nice to carey around. It seemed like there was enough staff to keep up with the demand of the crowd. Security made regular rounds and was very friendly. It was a nice day overall. There was a booty shaking contest, a belly flop contest and a wet t-shirt contest that never actually happened. I'm old but it was fun to spend a day at the pool drinking and cheering on strangers. I do wish there was a better layout on the upper deck. People tend to line up along the side to people watch and it makes it a tight fit when it's time to go get a drink from the bar upstairs. The upper deck didnt have any umbrellas for shade. I understand that most people would go up there and sunbathe but with the amount of people taking up all the space downstairs it would have been a nice break to sit in a shaded area for a moment. Also there was no food and that kind of stinks. I realize it's better to keep drunk people from trashing the place but it would have been nice to be able to order snacks that we could have eaten off to the side. I'm not a hard-core partier but I enjoyed being able to go hang out during the day and have a good time.

First of all, finding the place was a joke and finding parking was even worse. The staff is…read moreclueless when asked anything. I booked an exterior room because I brought my puppy and they gave me an interior but blamed it on Expedia for the room I was assigned. They corrected it and gave me an exterior room that was not very clean. We found trash under the bed. The toilet felt like it would fall through at any moment and water on the floor when we first walked in. The bed is the most uncomfortable bed I have ever attempted to sleep in. We didn't get any sleep due to rude drunk people yelling outside our room and the people above us jumping around from 1:30am to 3am. As well as loud bumping music playing until 3am from another property close by.. If you want a constant party atmosphere, this is 100% your type of place. We will not be back.

Our stay here was way beyond our expectations. This place is absolutely beautiful, its like a…read moreHallmark movie. The room was bigger than I thought, with a sitting area and a lake house / beach decor. The owner's Paul and Emily are so welcoming and very outgoing people. This place is walking distance to everything on the island. The location is perfect. Now, my favorite part of my stay here was the Breakfast. It was amazing and included in your stay. The owner Paul is the chef and he is creatively talented with the breakfast options. They offer an extra ordinary continental breakfast, regular breakfast items with a upscale added version. You can also order from Paul's special menu. I had a Cast iron blueberry dutch baby which was delicious. My husband had the Chilaqueles, which he has had in Mexico and said Paul did it exceptionally well. I would suggest when getting breakfast to eat it outside on their covered porch and people watch. Looking forward to my next stay here.

We are so thankful that we found this little boutique hotel! It's located in the perfect location…read moreto be able to walk downtown in no time but also be able to get away from the hustle bustle when you want to. Our friend also stayed there, and the rooms were impeccably clean! Very thoughtful amenities were provided! And the common areas were so amazing! The staff were very friendly and helpful! This has to be the best kept secret for lodging on the island!