I popped in here just before closing and they were incredibly kind and made me a small cheese pizza to go. First off, if you are a fan of matchbox cars you MUST go here in order to take in the decor. On the plus side, you will have a delicious meal as the pizza they made for me was incredibly delicious and I ate the whole thing with absolutely no guilt. Everyone that worked there was incredibly kind and epic views of the lake as well. read more

Solid pizza! Great sauce and cheese blend- staff was attentive and the place was hopping at the bar. We have seasonal camp here and are never disappointed with an occasional stop for beers and pie! read more

This is a fun place for all ages. Kids get a free hot wheels car with their food. Restaurant is decorated in hot wheels. Food is always great and there is way more than their delicious pizza. They have soup of the day and sometimes have special specials. Eggplant palm is just delicious. Service is great with Kim and Zach behind the bar. It's become a favorite of ours. Just wish they were open more. read more

See all

Best comfort food in the state! Right on the water beautiful lake view, fantastic pizza, wings, and sandwiches read more

See all

The wings are crispy & meaty. Lots of sauces to choose from. The pizza was the star of the show. Great crust and cooked perfectly. We had a nice view of the lake in the dining room. read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - Wings with maple apple sauce on the side - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

See all

Amazing staff with a huge delicious menu that was almost impossible to pick just one item from! Very cool hot wheels and moto decor with a lively ambiance. read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - Wooster Street King Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

See all

Conveniently located on the causeway in the heart of Naples, Randy's has a fast paced race car theme with some pretty cool antique pieces. It's a great local spot to pop in for a beer & some apps, a good entree or take out. From the host stand to the bar, service comes with a smile! The hostesses & bartender this evening were very efficient & friendly. We stopped in to grab our take out order & enjoyed a few beers while we waited for the food to be ready. A few recommendations & things to consider- the wings can be ordered half & half if you can't decide on one flavor. We went with garlic Parmesan & honey mustard (usually get buffalo but wanted to try something different). I don't have a favorite, we genuinely enjoyed both flavors & would get them again. If you get the wings they offer fried & grilled-get the grilled, they're SO good! The antipasto salad is huge! A great dish for sharing & it's very well crafted. My fiance loved it. We also got a cheese pizza, it's a thin crust & was cooked perfectly. In my opinion they have the best pizza in town! We'll definitely be back to try more of the menu! read more

The food and service are amazing. Zack is phenomenal on the bar. Remembered our drinks even though we had not been n a while

Pizza and wings are delish! Service is awesome and not a high turnover of staff. They hustle! read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - Fun hot wheels retro decor - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

See all

The crust was probably some of the best I've ever had. The toppings were delicious as well. The pizza had an excellent balance of cheese and sauce. Highly recommend.! Quite a variety of pizzas to choose from. read more

Pizza was delicious, the atmosphere fun. I will go back. The view is beautiful showing Brandy Pond.

walked in for a takeout order. the lady was very rude and wouldn't let me even speak, she asked for a name, i told her they didn't ask for one and then she began to be extremely rude. good food but bad worker. overall good place though read more

We stopped by Randy's on a whim while staying in the Naples area, and we were very glad we did. Fun atmosphere of Hot Wheels and old license plates. Great wood fired pizza! I loved my white pizza with chicken sausage, mushrooms and spinach. I was hesitant about the chicken sausage but our server said they made it in house and that I should go for it. Glad I did. Really delicious. My husband enjoyed his Man Pie with 3 or 4 different kinds of meat. Nice view over the marina and Lake Sabago. The noise level was a bit too much for us but the great food made up for that. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Ok- so the pizza is really, really good here. BUT. When we have ordered ahead through different apps or the restaurant, EVERY TIME we have ended up waiting when we arrived to pick up. Sometimes it's been almost an hour wait, no joke. So my son and I decided to dine in at the restaurant and see if this helped with the timing issues. Here is what happened: We come inside and quickly a woman at the front asks if we're eating here; we say yes and she says "ok take a seat anywhere." It wasn't... rude, but it wasn't super friendly. My son and I find a spot on the deck. Pretty quickly a server brings menus and asks if we want drinks. She is patient while I decide what I want. The drinks arrive fairly quickly and she takes our food order. After this she disappears for ages. Someone else brings the small pizza for my son first. A little later the same server brings his appetizer. Our initial waitress returns and lets us know we might get two of the appetizer, because "another table didn't want theirs." Huh? Much, MUCH later - my son was done eating - my main arrives. It was a salad with grilled chicken, for the record. They did leave the onions off as I asked, so the order was correct, and the salad was decent and the chicken still warm but... it was sooooo late! When we needed a box for leftovers and the bill, the waitress was super fast. By then the place has quieted down a lot. So- food is good. Pizza great. Drinks fine. Servers nice. Timing is terrible. 2.5 stars seems about right (Yelp, when are you introducing half stars!?!?). A note: All the servers are friendly, but they seem overworked during the busiest hours and/or their system is disorganized. One young woman kept coming out to deliver food and NEVER knew where to bring it. So my read is none of this is the fault of the servers- the restaurant manager needs to get it together! read more

Ran into this place on accident one night as they were one of the few places still open...thankfully we did! By far one of the tastiest pizzas in the Lake Region! We will def be coming back to Randy's. I can't much about the rest of their menu as I've only gotten the pizza every time (margarita) but one day I'll venture. The setting is great too! Good food, nice staff...can't ask for more! Keep up the great work guys read more

kim from randy's wooster 100/10 service. came for the food and left with so much information about the area. i asked about ski rentals and her and her team went on a goose hunt looking for information. read more

Randy's comes as close to an authentic New Haven pizzeria as does the proximity of the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific. I stopped at Randy's for dinner tonight solely on the basis of their sign that signifies they're the equivalent of one of the many fabulous places that peddle pizza in the shadows of Yale University. Woefully, Randy's fails to fulfill that claim. We ordered their Philly Cheese Steak pizza, which I'd rate a 3 on a scale of 1-10. The "steak" was tasteless and burnt to a crisp. A white pizza does not feature American cheese especially cheese that has the texture of rubber. At a cost of $20.00 for a small pizza we should have gone to Hannaford's and picked up three pizzas for the same price. Randy's get a thumbs down from this reviewer along with the caveat that if you want a New Haven pizza go to New Haven, CT and not Naples, Maine. read more

Don't order online unless you you don't mind paying more. Unless you watch it closely they transfer you to order through slice and they charge more plus a "fee" on top of that. read more

We ordered ahead here off of the boat on Brandy Pond and then I ran in to get it. You can't park at the marina unless you are getting gas so try to time it right. There is a town dock at the end of the pier. We just got a basic pepperoni pizza but they were nice enough to cut it up into double slices for the kids and provided napkins to go with it. We will definitely be back off the boat! read more

We have had nothing but great experiences since our review from a year ago! The pizza is consistently delicious, the staff is friendly and the service is great! They do get quite busy but that is certainly not a negative, just something to be mindful of! read more

Excellent thin crust pizza. The right cheese/sauce ratio and good pizza dough. Nice location - seems right sized with both indoor and (covered) outdoor dining. A view of the marina. Comfortable looking bar ( about a dozen stools?) and nice staff. read more

Pizza was great! Service was pleasant and the restaurant/bar had a great vibe. Only down side is they close early and stop taking orders. read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - Pizza with pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

Pizza was thin and crispy and delicious. You can order light, normal or crispy crust. Wood fired pizza. Wings had homemade sauces and were huge and meaty. We tried peanut butter and bacon wings too, next time we'll ask to make them spicy. Service was great. read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

An absolute MUST try. Expect a wait, totally worth it. The restaurant is decked out with hot wheels. Such a cool vibe. Insanely good pizza!!! read more

Love that you can take a boat and pick up your pizza. The pie was a nice thin and delicious crust. Cheese was a little greasy and sauce kind of bland. The Neapolitan was pretty good and cauliflower (gluten free) also had good flavor. I'd order again when in the area. Thanks! Oh, since most of your business (i assume) is in the summer I would recommend not closing two days a week... read more

Randy's Wooster St Pizza - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Maine

See all

Great pizza it was well cooked and the topping were plentiful and tasty. Will definitely be back for takeout again.

I grew up right outside of New Haven Connecticut where the best pizza in the world is. Randy's is just as good as any New Haven pizza joint. I drive from Wayne (59 miles) just for their pizza. The staff is awesome. read more

I really want to give Randy's more stars. I live in the area and we have limited places to order from so we are regulars here. The pizza is good if you like wood fired thin crust pizza. The topping selection and specialty pizzas are great. The apps are good too! The problem is two fold: 1. They ALWAYS forget sauces to go with appetizers. We order the cheese curds often and unless we ask we never get marinara. Sometimes they forget entire appetizers. Twice they forgot to make our wings and we had to wait an extra twenty minutes while our pizza turned ice cold. 2. They ALWAYS give you the wrong time. They say a half hour and it's at least an hour sometimes more. Recently I waited for an extra half hour, sitting in my car, because they told me they would bring my food out. I came in and was handed cold. BONUS PROBLEM: They will tell you they can't find your order and be snippy that's you ordered from the CT place which I have done once, but never again. Multiple times I've ordered online or called this location to be rudely told I ordered from the wrong place only for them to figure out they just missed the order. So good food, but they really need to get their act together. I'll still order from them, but I always expect mistakes. read more

As a Jersey native, I was skeptical. I can't verify anything else on the menu other than the cheese pizza was damn good; thin, crunchy, nice char, and reasonably priced for a large. The beer was cold and the view is hard to beat. Adding it to our list of favs in Naples. read more

Food is awesome! But front service lacks FOOD: We order here weekly, as the restaurant is so convenient to our marina. I'll start by saying we LOVE the food. From the pizzas, sandwiches (bread is superb), salads and apps. Haven't had a dish we didn't like yet! And we have tried a lot! Serving size is great. 4.5 star for food! EATING IN: We took my in-laws here to celebrate my birthday and our waitress on the deck was super fun! She brought little cars out for our kids to play with, was super understanding and made jokes. 5 stars for her! ORDER OUT: The negative is there is a women at the front who always seems annoyed. From speaking with her on the phone, to picking up. I feel like I am bothering her. Plus she can never seem to get the wait time right. I have been told an hour wait (no issue) but then am waiting another 30 minutes at the door for the food. I asked if they could just call me next time when the food was ready (I'm walking distance) and I was told they don't do that, and it was my responsible to call them to check. I'm really concerned this restaurant isn't going to make it solely because the front is disorganized. It would be terrible for the area if this happens. So I hope next season they regroup! 1 star for order out SOLEY because of the front service. And WHY close at 8pm in the summers?!? Maybe this is just for their first year, but I would imagine they would do a great business after 8pm too. read more

The pizza is great the production is slow. If they tell you 25 minutes plan on 45. I once stood in the lobby with a woman that claimed she'd been there for an hour. Good things come to those that wait but this place pushes the envelope. read more

Delicious pizza! There's also outdoor seating. Service can be a little slow, but it is worth the wait.

This place is great. They are doing everything right, in my opinion. We have been in three times for lunch and each time sat on the small outside deck. A view to Brandy Pond and the Naples causeway is provided. We have watched folks park their boats and come in for food that they must have ordered by phone. The interior looks nice, decorated in a hot-rod theme. The food is fantastic. I have had the boneless wings twice, once with the bacon & peanut butter sauce and once with traditional buffalo sauce. The portion was more than enough for one person and very tender and juicy. These were the best boneless wings that I have ever had. Twice I ordered different pizzas and they were both great. They even offer a choice of doneness on the crust. I have also had a turkey sandwich with roasted red peppers and pesto with bread that was so fresh I asked if they baked it on site. (The answer was no, but they get the bread locally and daily) My spouse is fixated on the chicken sausage grinder. She orders it every time and our server told us that the sausage is made on-site. They have a full bar and a great beer selection including three Maine-made IPAs. A+ for nice clean bathrooms with plenty of hot water. This place is a great addition to the lakes region dining scene and the usual pub-grub found in the area. read more

The friendliest people work here! Great service! Pizza was very good. They have the best wings. Great view of water!!

The best pizza I've found in Maine after searching for 3 years. Thin crisp crust. Also the best wings. Nice crisp exterior with delicious sauces. Great service, fair prices. Can't wait to check out the rest of the menu. read more

Service was completely abysmal, took 25 minutes for our server to get our drink orders, another 10 to take a food order, and our appetizer took about 45 min to come out. The restaurant was not very busy, a few people at the bar, we were the only ones at a table. Once we told our server we wanted to close out and leave, he was rude and made sure to shame us for a lack of patience. Come to find out our server was the closest thing to a manager, and there was not one actually present. Would not recommend, even if you are completely desperate. read more

Spur-of-the-moment visit caused by power outage at our house up the road. Very pleasant surprise. We sat at the bar, tended by Zack, a friendly, capable young man clearly in charge of his domain. Food prepared by Nilfa was the real pleasure: superb black-n-blue burger with top-notch fries; taco boat. Fresh, hot, flavorful, nicely presented. We'll be back. (Caution: not a fine-dining ambience. Diner-like with an auto-enthusiast theme all around. Clean and neat.) read more

Our party of nine was given the impression we were an inconvenience. The waitress hesitated at adding another table to ours, she announced that no sandwiches were available. When we mentioned separate checks, she showed a visible reaction of impatience. The pizzas were all overcooked. I waited over an hour for an appetizer and we were the only ones in the restaurant. read more

The Best pizza in the area. It used to be the New Jersey couple who owned Naples Pizza. Alas, they retired and the new owners, well I'll be kind can't begin to match the old or this place. Great take out pizza. Highly recommend it. read more

The best pizza you can get in town because it's New Haven style and it's Maine so all other options are inedible, but the service is atrocious and embarrassing. I called 3 separate times tonight to ask for pizza and they claimed to be too busy to accommodate any orders or even a sit down. The woman on the phone said to call back in 30 and reiterated the same speech within the allotted time. I am from New York and have never been "turned away" from a pizza establishment and more so in a state that has FAR better quality pizza. Furthermore, I have dined in person and the service is awful. For starters, please serve your guests waters, especially on a hot summer day when people are drinking. The drinks and food took an inappropriate amount of time, considering the lack of business. They also need to learn how to make a proper margarita - I'm not sure what ocean spray odd concoction we were served, but it was alarmingly poisonous. No offense but we're in Naples, Maine not on a waiting list for 5 Hertford Street in London. Again, while the pizza is exceptional (for the area), I advise the employees curb the attitude and rectify service quality. read more