It has been almost twenty years since I first met Ricky of Ricky's Jewelry. He was originally located in the Attias Flea Market. I had gone to a Lia Sophia (costume jewelry) party at a friend's house and fell in LOVE with a ring. As soon as I got the ring delivered, I brought it to Ricky and he took the design and re-created it with White Gold and Diamonds. I still wear it every day! Over the years, Ricky has sold me several watches, more rings, earrings, necklaces, gifts for my Granddaughters, and more. He is very helpful and patient as it takes a while for me to choose from the lovely collection he has from which to choose. Very happy that he moved to down town Sayville when the flea market closed. I already recommend him to all my family, friends and clients. I will never go anywhere else. All I can say is THANKS Ricky!!! Tina read more

I have known Ricky for a few years now; my mom has been a faithful customer for quite some time and she ultimately led me to his store. Ricky is kind, personable and beyond helpful. I recently called him to inquire about a gift idea that I had for my son and his wife....by the time I got there, he had pulled out several choices for me to pick from:) Ricky is really the only jewelry store I would ever consider buying jewelry from. I love his taste and his ability to listen and guide his customers to exactly what they want... it is beyond compare! I am thankful to know him and I am lucky to have him in my town of Sayville. It is the only place to go Great service...enjoyable conversation...and perfect purchases every time:) Thank you Ricky! read more

Needed to to get my moms expensive wrist watch battery replaced and my cheap replica pocket watch battery replaced. I went to another jeweler just before and they claimed the expensive watch might need to be sent out and could cost $60 for hers alone. Instead of paying what i knew was too much for a simple battery, i then went to Rickys Jewelry in Sayville on Main Street and (i think he was the owner) immediately said hello asked if i needed assistance and when i told him about the batteries, he replaced them right there in front of me and only charged me $20 for BOTH. If you DON'T want to be scammed by jewelers who just want to milk your wallet, GO TO RICKYS JEWELRY ON MAIN STREET IN SAYVILLE and you won't be disappointed. read more

I had such a great experience with Ricky Jeweler! Ricky made the whole process feel easy and exciting. He really took the time to listen to what I was looking for and helped guide me through the options without ever making it feel overwhelming. The final ring turned out absolutely beautiful better than I could have imagined. You can tell how much care and craftsmanship went into it. It's clear that Ricky is not only talented, but also genuinely passionate about making something meaningful for each customer. I've gotten so many compliments on my ring, and I couldn't be happier. If you're looking for a beautiful, high-quality piece and a jeweler who truly cares, I highly recommend Ricky Jeweler read more

Ricky Jewelry is the place to go if you want to make your wife to be happy. As soon as we got there, Ricky received us with a smile, and according to the specifications we provided, he started showing us the different rings he had. He explained the description and the quality of the ring and also provided the paperwork to prove the authenticity. We finally agree on the ring and the order was placed. Ricky gave us the approximate date for the ring to be finished, and before we knew it, he was already calling us that the ring was done. I have to say that the ring was gorgeous and the presentation was outstanding. Thank you again Ricky for the way you treated us and for your professionalism. read more

DO NOT go to this jewelry store. They will Sell you fake jewelry. Everyone should get their jewelry inspected if you bought it from here because it's probably fake. Sold my husband a cubic zirconia and gold plated Jewelry set for $400!! Set was worth $30 at most. I cannot believe he scammed my husband like this and refused to give his money back with a receipt, days later. I had to tell my husband he bought me a fake gift for my birthday. Hey scammer do you buy your fugazi jewelry on DHgate and mark it up 4000%?!! Go to another local jewelry store that is decent and doesn't sell fake jewelry like a fucking schmuck. read more

I have known Ricky for many many years . He is not your everyday jewelry store, he is like family. His bright smile, to his knowledge of his products is priceless. I have only purchased through Ricky Jewelers in the last past 15 years. He does not push you, he does not corner you. If he doesn't have it, he will try to get it, or make it. I recommend Ricky's for anybody and everybody. Graduation gifts, bridal gifts, engagement rings, holiday gifts, birthday gifts and just because.... Stop by yourself and take a stroll. You will be pleasantly surprised! read more

Ricky Jewelry has exceeded my expectations. The customized diamond jewelry I got was beautiful and the whole process was just so stress-free and enjoyable. From the instant I walked in the store and met Ricky I felt like I was in good hands. My appraiser confirmed that I got exactly what I ordered, at below retail prices. Rolex watch, diamond earrings and bracelets. It will be my pleasure to shop here again, and tell everyone I know about my experience. I only do business with honest companies, and Ricky Jewelry is on the top of my list. read more

I can't recommend Ricky and the Ricky jewelry team highly enough! Buying an engagement ring is a very daunting task but Ricky took his time to really explained all the nuances attached to diamonds and provided a stunning design. The ring we designed came out even better than I could ever imagine and my wife absolutely loves it. The after care service is also outstanding, we can pop into the shop to get the ring cleaned and the team are always nice and friendly. Again, I cannot recommend Ricky and the team highly enough! read more

Since finding Ricky, All my jewelry needs are completely taken care of.Never any pressure ,He takes the time to get you exactly what you are looking for with out breaking the bank .the quality of his jewelry is beautifull .He does all kinds of repairs and even watch batteries while you wait . You always deal with him,never a sales person,Totally recommend him to anyone who is looking for a jeweler in sayville .Check him out he is great .my wife loves everything I have given her.. Peter from Sayville read more

I bought a ring from Costco, top-end for my wife for Christmas, and was in Sayville so popped into Ricky's Jewelry. I was thrilled with my great value purchase. I asked Ricky how much it would cost to buy the same ring from him, and as a consequence I purchased the identical ring from Ricky's, at only 3/4 the cost of Costco. 10/10 for Costco's return policy! 10/10 for Ricky's value for money! He's the real deal. Now, we won't shop for jewelry anywhere else! BTW. He's also a really nice guy. read more

I have known Ricky for many years and he is a friendly and trust worthy jeweler who will give you the best deals and quality jewelry that you will not find anywhere else . I can assure you that he will treat you like family and help you look for anything that you are looking for because he is all about pleasing his clients .I honestly give him the highest ratings of any jewelry store I know on longisland . read more

Ricky Jewelry was recommended to me by friends to reset my mother's engagement ring. I am so happy I listened. Ricky has a large selection of settings to choose from and he was even able to incorporate the extra stones from the insert . The result is stunning ! Ricky is knowledgeable , friendly, easy to work with, and trustworthy. I have already recommended Ricky Jewelry to a couple getting engaged. read more

Ricky's is the place to go for jewelry! I needed a gold chain for a cross I received as a gift, so I went back to Ricky's, which is where I always buy my jewelry. He helped me find just the right chain and I love the way it looks with my cross! There were so many choices of beautiful chains, but Ricky found the perfect one for me in my price range. Thank you Ricky!! read more

My mother and I have been going to Ricky for about three years. Besides the selection of fine jewelry he carries, he is an expert in the field. I have and will recommend him to absolutely everyone. The quality is incredible and the hospitality Ricky offers to his customers leaves you feeling as family. If I could give him 10 stars I would!!!! Amazing amazing amazing read more

I would highly recommend Ricky & Co. Ricky is such an amazing person who really takes the time to help you choose exactly what you are looking for. He is not pushy and treats you like a person rather than just a sale. He works within your budget and has excellent quality jewelry. We will definitely be returning in the future for additional purchases. read more

I brought my grandmother's diamond tennis bracelet to Ricky's to be reset. I had brought it to another Jeweler before who completely botched it and I wanted it back to the original setting. Ricky was able to make it exactly like the original. I am so happy with how it turned out and thankful to have it look exactly like the one I had before! read more

I've been going to Ricky for over 16 years he is not only my jeweler but we've become good friends through the years. He is truly an amazing man. I would not buy jewelry from anyone body else, His quality of jewelry is exquisite at such a reasonable price and he is so trust worthy. I highly recommend him YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED!! read more

The best jewelry store in my area. I take all of my watches to be serviced there. Great selection of watches and Jewelry for your engagement and your special occasions. The owner is always helpful, knowledgeable and very personable. Shop there with confidence knowing you are in good hands. Thank you Ricky Jewelry! Will S. read more