What time does Rider's Choice Saddlery open?

Rider's Choice Saddlery opens at 10:30 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Rider's Choice Saddlery opens at 11:00 AM on Sunday.

What time does Rider's Choice Saddlery close?

Rider's Choice Saddlery is closed on Monday.Rider's Choice Saddlery closes at 5:30 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Rider's Choice Saddlery closes at 4:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon ClosedTue-Sat 10:30 AM - 5:30 PMSun 11:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Does Rider's Choice Saddlery take credit cards?

Yes, Rider's Choice Saddlery takes credit cards.

Does Rider's Choice Saddlery allow dogs?

No, Rider's Choice Saddlery does not allow dogs.

Does Rider's Choice Saddlery have parking?

Yes, Rider's Choice Saddlery has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Specialties

Riders Choice Saddlery is more than a tack shop—it’s a community hub for riders on Long Island. Locally owned and operated in Bohemia, New York, we proudly carry both English and Western riding equipment, apparel, gifts, and essentials for horse and rider. What sets us apart is our blend of heritage and modern curation. For over 30 years, Riders Choice has been a trusted name in the equestrian community, and under new ownership, we continue that tradition while bringing in fresh, carefully selected brands that reflect today’s riders’ needs for quality, performance, and timeless style. Our staff has a combined 100+ years of equestrian experience and understands the unique needs of riders at every level—from first lessons to top-level competition. Whether you’re shopping for everyday barn gear, competition apparel, or the perfect equestrian gift, we are here to help. At Riders Choice, our customers aren’t just shoppers—they’re friends and fellow riders. That’s why we pair affordable prices with personalized service, ensuring every rider feels supported on their journey. Stop by our Bohemia store to experience why Riders Choice has been trusted for generations, and discover the thoughtfully curated brands that make us stand out.

History

Established in 1980.

Riders Choice Saddlery has been serving the Long Island equestrian community for over 30 years. Founded in Bohemia, New York, the store quickly became a trusted source for riders of every discipline, offering reliable tack, apparel, and horse care products at fair prices. Over the decades, it built a reputation not just as a shop, but as a gathering place where riders could count on knowledgeable advice and friendly service. In 2025, Riders Choice entered an exciting new chapter under new ownership. While honoring the legacy of the past three decades, the store has been refreshed with a modern approach—bringing in curated brands, updated styles, and a renewed commitment to serving our community. Today, Riders Choice is proud to blend tradition with innovation, carrying forward its heritage while supporting the next generation of riders.

Meet the Business Owner: Jaclyn V.

Hi, I'm Jaclyn, the proud new owner of Riders Choice Saddlery. Horses have been part of my life since childhood, and the lessons I learned in the barn--dedication, patience, and passion--have shaped who I am today. When the opportunity came to carry Riders Choice into its next chapter, I knew it was a chance to honor its 30+ year legacy while creating something fresh, modern, and community-centered. I'm passionate about curating brands and products that blend quality, performance, and timeless style, all while keeping the needs of local riders at heart. More importantly, I'm excited to continue the tradition of Riders Choice as a place where customers are treated like friends and every rider feels supported on their journey. Whether you're stepping into the ring, riding for joy, or just starting out, I can't wait to welcome you into the Riders Choice family.