My girlfriend and I had a lovely experience here! We loved the oddities collections and we both…read moreended up buying pearls. Nadia helped us and was so fun and sweet- definitely a highlight of our day in Port Jeff.

Still my favorite shop down port! Worth the visit! Always something adorable lurking about, and the…read morecustomer service is always great! Love me some Luna Nova.

I visited this unique boutique in November 2025, while visiting Huntington where my grandparents…read morelived when I was a child. I hadn't been back since 1974. I walked in and the aroma was breathtaking! I asked what the scent was and it was "Winter Forest" by Cow Harbor Candle Co. I bought one little candle to take home to NV. Burning the candle at home, I just couldn't get enough. They were out of Winter Forest, so I ordered an assortment of different scents from the same maker. Unfortunately, when they arrived a few were broken. I spoke to the owner, Jacquelyn, and she immediately replaced the broken candles at no charge, no questions whatsoever. They texted me when more Winter Forest was available. I order more of those too. I think I've gotten about 8 candles and I have to say that these are the BEST SCENTED CANDLES I've EVER had the pleasure to enjoy! Highly recommend this shop, the customer service is fantastic, and I hope to visit Huntington and Wit & Whim again next year. Also, wow has Huntington grown (well of course, in 50 years!) Gorgeous area. And, yes, I found my grandparents home. It's not the same, but I found it!! Ahhh, the childhood memories!!!

What a charming local spot I happened upon one chilly day. It turned out to be a hotbed for finding…read moreChristmas gifts for families and friends. Filled with tchotchkes, vintage ideas, local artisan crafts, and so much more, it really lives up to its name of wit and whim. The two people working at the store were incredibly friendly and did such a wonderful job gift-wrapping the gifts I purchased and I picked up a bunch of business cards from local creators that I wanted to follow and see what else they have in store. A lot of the items don't have prices listed, so you do have to ask which was my only minor grievance. I will definitely make a few more trips here, especially for gifts, when the need arises.

I LOVE this store!!! There are so many unique items here that you either won't find in other places…read moreor you will find here for less. I always end up talking to the very friendly owner for a good half hour. He is hilarious by the way! If you need incense, summer dresses, fun jewelry, beach blankets...this is your store. Happy shopping!!!

I have been coming here for decades to buy unique summer dresses and earrings. The owners are…read moreterrific- nice and down to earth!

The service was great. I felt bad because this one lady was so nice and she took care of us. I kept…read moreasking her questions where things was and she was always so kind and helpful with a smile and on point. The selection is amazing you can go in there and do your whole home in one shot. They have everything from furniture to gardening stuff to garbage cans to rugs to blankets and so on. I can go on and on about the selection with all beautiful stuff to choose from. The value is good they're have a 50% off sale of certain things so go check them out. Trust me you will be happy with this store I promise!

Request 498879 I have received two emails that an order was…read moreshipped NHDt20EDK1YZ-26718542 and 7J5MKN78fUYO-26717143. I did not order this. I was just requiring how to add a gift card. I have been emailing with little satisfaction from at home customer care. The store has no idea what I'm talking about either. Request #498879. I'm not able to reach out to anyone regarding this issue and it's been going on for about 5 days with no response. I certainly will have to think twice before dealing with this organization So much for customer service and customer satisfaction. dianeo33@hotmail.com

I had been looking forward to visiting the store; after seeing many advertisements in my Social…read moreFeed. I saw a pair of embroidered jeans. I was told that the pictures on line are not of current items. They did not have what I went in for. The clothing is beautiful but way over priced. Due to circumstances out of my control. I arrived 5 minutes before closing. 5 other customers where in the store, I was greeted with the announcement that they where closing in 5 minutes. When 5 more people came in the store, it was announced they had 4 minutes to shop. We all where rushed to pick our items, and get out of the store. I found the staff abrasive and I will not be returning.

Absolutely love this store! Walked in on a whim a week ago and spent at least an hour just pursuing…read moreall the cute items. If you want anything Long Island related I mean clothing, jewelry, pillows, glasses, mirrors, wall art, books, purses, kitchen towels, coasters, they have you covered. They also have a ton of those Mud Pie pieces. It may be a little pricier than home goods but you're out there supporting local businesses that Willy Nilly partners with so it's totally worth it. Staff was very helpful and when they saw I was struggling to hold all the cute things I had in my hands they took everything behind the cash register for me. They offer free gift wrapping too!

Came today to support my niece/goddaughter who is shopping for her First Communion dress. The store…read moreis adorable and very girly, with chandeliers and cute little antique-styled decor. The racks are organized by size. There are a few fitting rooms and one large pedestal/mirror area. The customer service was top-notch, helping to hold and carry dresses and organizing the wait for the fitting rooms. When we arrived, the store was packed with several families doing the same thing that we were. The staff was calm and was able to organize everyone while not making anyone feel rushed or impatient. They paid equal amounts of attention to each girl trying on dresses, making everyone feel special. One of the ladies who helped us is also a designer, who makes some of the dresses that are available in the store. It seems they also handle all fittings and alternations, and many items like the color of little flowers, pearls and crystals and other embellishments can be customized.

I want to love this store, but it definitely has a lot of room for improvement…read more Main Pros -Their dress selection is beautiful - A variety of prices to fit many budgets -Staff is sweet, one did bring over a singing toy which calmed down my niece a lot Cons -It's a kid's store but it has a lot of things kids shouldn't touch right at their eye levels -They mandate booking a changing room in advance but we waited for an extensive amount of time while they let someone else into our charging room- and then rushed us out of the room after only one dress instead of allowing my niece time to get used to the space and possibly be okay with trying on more dresses. Ultimately I would return since I like being able to see items in person instead of buying online. But I really recommend sticking to appointment times or making the rooms first come, first serve.

Had a great time rummaging through a vast selection of action figures and VHS tapes which were very…read morereasonably priced. Even walked out with a grail piece. Had a good convo with the Bearded Hoarder himself too - service was great. Will definitely be going back.

The bearded hoarder is a great location in the heart of Sayville. 279 Railroad avenue is the new…read morelocation. Here you can find toys from your childhood, pokemon, viral Tik Tok squishy toys, comics, and more! Kevin (The owner) also does trading too. Bring in your treasures and leave with something new or a wad of cash!

I went into this shop for the first time not that long ago and I am in LOVE with it. The shop has a…read morelot of sea things, which I love the sea. There is a mixture of items in this shop. I came across some towels, and I had bought two. I loved the sayings on them. They have some handmade items also, which I love. When I entered the shop, the owner was sitting at the cashier and painting an item, I'm assuming that is for sale. Seeing something like that makes me happy. I saw the same item she was painting on the wall to be bought. She was sweet too. She had a table. In front of the cashier, for safe distance for the both of us. Like everything else, you have to wear a mask. I will definitely be coming back to buy more items from this shop.

I went here when I was visiting my aunt this summer, it is my favorite place to go when we would…read morego to babylon!!!! I definitely recommend this little shop to anyone that goes to Babylon! They have really nice stuff and very cheap. If you ever get a chance go here!