My fiancé and I recently stayed at Greyfield Inn for Memorial Day Weekend, and we are still raving…read moreabout our trip to anyone who will listen. If you are looking for the ultimate romantic escape, this is it. I almost didn't want to post a review out of fear that the Inn will get too popular, but something this extraordinary must be shared.
From the moment you step off the Inn's private ferry, it feels as if you have stepped back in time. The untamed, natural beauty of Cumberland Island seems almost prehistoric, while the understated, casual "Old Money" elegance of the Inn harkens back to the days of the Gilded Age when the Carnegies and their contemporaries galavanted along the beach.
Staying at Greyfield Inn isn't a typical luxury hotel experience; it's more like being a welcomed guest in a grand, historic family home, where your host has an extraordinary attention to detail. Fresh flowers and a handwritten card await you in your room upon your arrival, along with a copy of the Inn's daily meal schedule and a map of the island. A card bearing the day's forecast, including the speed of the current, winds, etc., is slipped under your door each morning while you're at breakfast. There is no front desk; if you require assistance, you need only wander downstairs to the kitchen and ask any available staff member. Speaking of the kitchen, it is open to guests 24-7; you are always free to help yourself to an assortment of delicious beverages and snacks, including homemade cookies (the flavor changes every day).
We loved not having any Wi-Fi or TV; it forced us to completely unplug, slow down, and truly focus on each other. From riding the complimentary beach cruisers down live oak-canopied paths, to walking the beach and seeing no other humans for miles and miles, to lazing about on the Inn's extraordinarily comfortable front porch swings, we treasured every moment. We took advantage of the Inn's many tour offerings, including historic tours of the Dungenness Ruins and Plum Orchard estate, as well as a naturalist-led tour of the beach and an early morning birding tour through the marshland. Our guides, Christina and Nina, were both knowledgeable and engaging, sharing fascinating facts about Cumberland Island's rich history and even richer biodiversity.
The culinary experience was definitely a highlight. From the charming picnic lunches packed for our daytime adventures to the exquisite, garden-to-table communal dinners, every meal was phenomenal. The food was often simple, but perfectly executed. We appreciated the requirement that everyone dress up for dinner, and every day we looked forward to socializing with new friends during the evening cocktail hour, munching on delicious hors d'oeuvres in the drawing room and sipping ice-cold martinis on the front porch.
A word of caution to high-maintenance guests (or those who insist on modern luxuries): you might find some aspects of Greyfield less than ideal (though we found them charming). As my fiance said, sometimes it feels like "camping for fancy rich people." The plumbing, for instance, is quite old-fashioned, and it was virtually impossible to take a hot shower with adequate water pressure in our bathroom (we stayed in the Library Suite, which we adored). However, the Inn offers an excellent outdoor shower, which we thought added to the rustic charm of the experience.
The warmth and attentiveness of Greyfield's staff was unmatched. A special shout-out to Hayley, who took some very special photos of my fiance and I (and who went out of her way to shoot us in multiple spots and from multiple angles!). We cannot thank the folks at Greyfield Inn enough for making our trip so magical. We are already dreaming of our next trip back, and are even considering trying to book the Inn for our wedding!