We took the Grand Circle Island Tour. My goal for this review is to be as constructive as possible and provide actionable feedback that Robert's can take steps, if they choose, to improve their tour for future patrons.
TOUR ADMINISTRATION: Extremely Poor - 1 Star
Other than the original confirmation that we received from Costco Travel Services, we never received anything from Robert's in advance of the tour; no phone call, no email, and no confirmation. I called the number listed for the tour the day before its scheduled date and left a message on Robert's voicemail stating that I wanted to confirm our tour and inquire where we should meet the tour bus. I left my cell number and requested a callback but never did receive a call. The morning of the tour, I called again and spoke to someone in the administration offices. The representative was nice enough but didn't offer an apology for not responding to my voice message. She told me that the tour bus would pick us up at a nearby hotel. It would have been good to know this in advance. We had to leave our car in the hotel's lot for the day and this cost another $18 for parking. Again, another detail that would have been nice to know with a little bit of notice.
TOUR MATERIALS: Extremely Poor - 1 Star
The tour has approximately 7 stops. The places are all interesting and significant but other than our tour guide's verbal and thorough overview of each place, the relevance of the place and its history, the only stop we received any kind of printed materials was the free brochure that was put together by the National Park Service for the Volcanoes National Park; it was excellent and while some of the stops don't warrant a pamphlet of this caliber, most stops (and the history of the island gods) should be accompanied by something written. We were told that tour guides are put through an extensive training program. Robert's should formalize some of that training by putting it into print and pictures.
LUNCH: Below Average - 2 Stars
The place that we stopped for lunch was sub-par. We were strongly discouraged from ordering off of the menu in the interest of time. The alternative was to choose the buffet for $17. We are not really buffet lovers but we decided on this option to ensure that the tour group remained on schedule. The food was just okay; cafeteria-standard at best. The place, which I believe is an observatory or science center, seemed to be closed except for the dining area. There wasn't a view to speak of and there really wasn't any compelling reason that we could understand for choosing this place for lunch other than maybe the convenience and speed of the buffet. Is there some place in Hilo with a view of the bay that Robert's could partner with to provide lunch on a regular basis. Or maybe there is a destination like a food court where people on the tour could choose from a variety of options?
THE TOUR (Stops, Accommodations, Logistics, etc.): Very Good - 4 Stars
The bus was nice, clean and relatively new. It did unexpectedly stop a couple of times but the tour guide assured us that it was a normal occurrence and that it had something to do with electronic frequencies on that particular location of the island. The route and timing of stops was good as well. We really did hit most of the highlights on the island (Coffee plantation, nut factory, Hilo, falls, lava tube, National Park, Black Sand beach and shopping stops). It is a long day and the hum of the engine, length of the drive and soothing slack-key guitar put most of us to sleep after lunch. The time we spent at each stop was appropriate. We never felt rushed or like we over-stayed at any one stop. The whole family enjoyed the circumnavigation of the island.
THE GUIDE: Excellent - 5 Stars
We were lucky enough to get Luke Wong as our guide. Luke's attitude, demeanor, friendliness, and knowledge were all fantastic. He played music, sang, shared stories about his family and childhood growing up on the island. He recounted the history of the island and landmarks that left us doubting whether other tour guides would have covered the same material. Luke is a honest to goodness local born and raised Hawaiian. Some of the advice, tips, must-see places to visit, etc. that Luke shared with us were things that we carried with us during our stay and we found his opinions to be spot-on with our experience. The Original Big Island Shave Ice really is the best on the Island!
Overall, we were glad we did the tour but there is much room for improvement with a little bit of effort on the part of Robert's. read more