I had high hopes for this pizza when I looked at it in the box. Crust looked great and was in fact nice and soft and tender. They were a little stingy with their toppings, but OK, fine. I just couldn't make it past how sweet the sauce was. I know, others said it was sweet, but I think this was by far the sweetest sauce I've ever had, by a factor of 2. My hopes have been dashed. Still trying to find a good pizza place in the area. read more

My family was staying at Pioneer Lakes RV Park and our neighboring camper recommended this place for their pizza. So, we decided to give them a try and we ordered 2 pizzas and fries and onion rings. The meat lovers pizza was awesome, and the sauce was sweeter than most places but it did not disappoint!! The buffalo chicken pizza had big chunks of chicken, but it did lack buffalo flavor which was disappointing but it was still solid since the toppings were heavy. The onion rings were good ! They did not pull out of the ring like some places and had good flavor. The French fries were also good and nice sized but we ordered the large. Which is in medium sized container. We called and they turned around the order in 20 minutes, no problem..! We def. recommend if you're staying at the campground or just a local. read more

Rustic Mountain Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Somerset, Pennsylvania

See all

So the pizza had all the components to be great, but the actual pizza wasn't consistently made. Some areas had reallllllllly thin crust, while other areas were okay. There were pockets of excessive sauce... and areas with no sauce... The individual components were good though. The crust was more bready than chewy, but I don't mind that. The sauce is super sweet, but I love a sweet sauce... the bake on the pizza was really good, they let it cook until the cheese caramelized. If the dough would have been stretched evenly and toppings applied evenly, this pizza would have been pretty good! read more

I absolutely love their pepperoni. Love the crust and the marinara. The staff is incredibly helpful and friendly too.

Great service and great pizza. Not far from our location at Hidden Valley and the people erred great and the pizza was done quickly. Thank you. We will return. read more

Yes the sauce is sweet, but all enjoyed the pizza. We had a pepperoni, and another with sausage, onion, and mushroom. The side of garlic sauce was delicious too - reminiscent of Papa John's garlic sauce. The subs were well wrapped in foil and were still hot after a 15 minute drive. The hot wings were definitely hot-spicy! Food was ready quickly. Bring cash. read more

See all

OK, so if you DISLIKE pizza sauce that is on the sweet side, this pizza won't be your thing. But we absolutely love the pizza here. I'm from the DC area, and Ledo's Pizza is very comparable to this. They will cook it to order, more or less done, and the owners are very nice. Our normal go-tos are the pizza, cheese sticks and wings. The wings are perfectly fried and then sauced, no breading. I love this place! If you're in town for a weekend, or if you live here, give it a try. Cash only though. read more

In some ways, this pizza was better than I expected, but it should not be mistaken for great pizza. On the up-side, the pizza is allowed to cook so that the cheese gets caramelized instead of being underdone and flabby. Also, the end crust puffs up nicely when baked, as it should. That's better than you'll get at most pizza places beyond the NY/NJ/CT pizza corridor. On the down-side, as other Yelpers have so clearly noted, that red sauce is remarkably sweet. Not sweet like long stewed ripe tomatoes. It's sweet like sugar. Trusting the Yelp community, I tried to order accordingly, and steered towards white pies and those that might be able to counter the sweetness of the sauce. The Buffalo Chicken was the clear favorite of the household. Second was the white pizza with sausage and sweet peppers. However, the sweet peppers were too sweet for some, and in the future, I'd go for another accompaniment to complement the sausage. Onions, peppers, and mushrooms had no chance of cutting through the cloying nature of the pizza sauce, but I thought the "Heart Attack" special with triple the pepperoni and parmesan cheese might do the trick. Alas, all that smokey, salty, cured meat was no match for the sugar content of the sauce. So if you're at Hidden Valley, and feel like getting pizza, bring some cash down to Rustic Mountain. Just stick to the white pies, and maybe the bread sticks. Save the sugar for dessert. read more

Service was fair. If you like sweet sauce on your pizza it would be ok.. otherwise pizza was way too sweet. Also, very dirty place inside. Overall would not recommend. read more

Fun place. Kind of a carnival booth/living room feel. Seemed to be family run. Pizza is top notch and reasonably priced. I would take this over the big chains any day. Sauce has a nice sweet taste to it. Service was friendly and fun. Family was all happy. No masks or covid protocols being followed if that concerns you. read more

Heart Attack pizza and sausage pizza were great picks! We also enjoyed the wings, fried mushrooms and fries. Delivery was prompt, no complaints! Food was yummy, would order from this spot again! read more

Rustic Mountain Pizza - Heart attack (left) and sausage (right) pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Somerset, Pennsylvania

If you like a sweeter sauce pizza it's great! If not I might recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza from here. Pizza is thicker. I've been going here for multiple years and I have always enjoyed it. read more

The pizza was way WAY too sweet that I actually thought they accidentally confused sugar with salt preparing it... until I read the other reviews. We got the cheese pizza and the veggie pizza. My only complaint is honestly the sweetness. I cant eat anything sweet when im hungry, so ended the night with a bag of chips, since we were already in our hotel room by the time i had a bite in of my slice (post skiing) and its 10pm. Looking forward to a savory breakfast tomorrow. read more

We were at 7 Springs for the weekend and wanted good pizza. This is not the place. The pizza sauce tastes like tomato paste and sugar, it's so sweet it's unbearable. Very unhappy. read more

Awful pizza. Tasted like they put sugar on it. Sauce was all dried up. Expensive too.

Tried this place a couple times. Unfortunately disappointed both times. Vegetables were not cooked on pizza and just not a taste I enjoyed. read more

It's not good. Was told it's the best in the area - but that's not saying much. The sauce is sugary sweet. They were not particularly friendly on the phone. And it is cash only. Oh, and the place is a filthy dump. read more

While at Hidden Valley, a decent place to get food. The red pizza sauce is VERY sweet. As an alternative, we prefer the white pizza. The wings are also decent. Don't plan on eating there. The inside seating area is more of an enlarged play pen for all of their kids. I recommend pickup or delivery. Cash only. It fills the square but nothing to write home about. read more

I have been at seven springs for 3 years. Their pizza is by far the best in the area. I love how they cook the pizza. The cheese gets crusty. The sauce is also fantastic. read more

We have lived in Hidden Valley for a few years and never tried Rustic Mountain because of the reviews. We decided to give it a try a few weeks ago and were pleasantly surprised! I am NOT a fan of sweet sauce so I didn't have too high an expectation, but the pizza was actually pretty good and sauce wasn't as sweet as some reviews indicate. The lady that took the order was super friendly. Hubby said the pizza was even better the next day. read more

Brutal pizza. Brutal. I'd rather get Red Barron. Yelp is forcing me to write more, but there's nothing more to say.

They said they delivered to the seven springs area but they didn't say it would take over two hours. I never was told how long it would take during my order. We ordered a Buffalo chicken pizza but received a chicken Alfredo pizza. Chicken Alfredo pizza was decent but not what we ordered. Pizza was not very warm. Also, we ordered two tossed salads with ranch, and a 25 count of hot wings with ranch - we only received one ranch packet for all three. All of the missed points on the food wouldn't have been so big of an issue if it didn't take over two hours, but it just added to the frustration. read more

A sweet sauce on the pizza, but otherwise not too bad considering these challenging times.

They were so so so rude. Do NOT RECCOMEND!!! We asked for delivery for an air bnb 10 mins away and they said they would not deliver. We offered to tip very well and even meet them half way and they again were very rude. Do not go here.... read more

If you're going to starve to death this will do. Otherwise I recommend going to the grocery store and buying a frozen pizza. It would be better. read more

Food was good for a pizza joint and very reasonably priced! You get the most bang for your buck at this place! We had the large veggie pizza and it was good, but sauce had too much sugar. Kids had chicken tenders, fries and a cheeseburger. The bun was too big so she only ate the burger. Note: cash only! read more

Cash only. It's 2019. Time to stop put away the fax machine with dial tone and accept credit cards.

Staying at 7 Springs, tired of their cardboard pizza, went to Rustic Mountain for a new experience and wow, great pizza and wings and the prices were good. Wish they took credit card. Had ice cream also and no complaints, great service, great food, and great prices. YOU NEED TO GO! read more

7SPRINGS DELIVERY - they deliver to seven springs. I've been to seven springs many times, but this is the first time I've stayed at the resort and the first time I've been worried about food...rustic mountain saved the day. Additionally, their pizza is absolutely fantastic. Many people have commented on their sweet sauce - it's true the sauce is sweeter than normal, but it is amazing. Not sure if i would've even commented on the sweetness if i hadn't read about it or anything. It's great pizza. Highly recommended. read more

Best pizza in town. Staff is amazing. Always treated well. Yes, it is a sweet sause but its a favorite of our family.

Pizza was good, but don't go "inside" unless you've got a strong stomach. Health department inspections must not be a thing in these parts. Also, very pricey. read more

Was skeptical at first due to the look of the building on the outside but the pizza was one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The delivery service was so fast when I got a knock at my door I thought to my self that there was no way that the pizza was here already. The fries were really good, kind of like a beer batted fry. Was very satisfied with the quality and speediness of the delivery. Will be ordering again for our next pizza night. read more

Ordered a meatball and chicken parm sub to our condo at 7springs. The content of the subs (meatballs and chicken parm) were pretty good; however, the sub roll they use is overly sweet tasting and off putting. I took the middle out and put it on some bread and it was tasty. Haven't tried their pizza. read more

Rustic Mountain Pizza - Meatball sub - their bread is super sweet and doesn't taste good with Italian - Pizza Near Me - Somerset, Pennsylvania

See all

This family owned restaurant is a sweet memorable place. We stopped on our road trip to the east coast. They love kids and have a family recipe for the pizza sauce. I thought it was delicious. So did my 6 year old. My 4 year had a different opinion. We will look back fondly on the hospitality and our meal. read more

First time stopping here after passing it for many years while up in the area. Ordered a basic plain small pizza, which is what I normally do the first time ordering, and I was not disappointed!! First, the nice woman who took my order could not have been any sweeter or nicer. Second,the pizza was delicious!! A small is prett big size. The sauce is sweet, the vmcrust is thin with a nice thick edge, and excellent cheese. Can't wait to try other menu items. Much better pizza than most places in the area. read more

The woman taking orders over the phone was very rude and short with us. She told one from our group that they wouldn't deliver to our air bnb and hung up on our friend abruptly, then I called (not knowing somebody had already called them) and they said they deliver but it would be 1.5 hours, we weren't quite ready to order so when we were about 5 min later another from our group was told delivery was 2.5 hours, all the while she was still being rude. When we finally got the pizza the sauce was way too sweet and not worth all of the hassle we went through. I will never recommend this restaurant to anyone for the terrible customer service and food. read more

We have ordered from Rustic Mountain Pizza multiple times and each time something is just slightly off, but considering we are usually on our way up the mountain we have brushed it off without much thought. Today we ordered a single large pepperoni pizza. It took over 2 hours to be prepared and when it finally arrived it was missing its toppings and freezing cold. We never received a receipt nor was there explanation as to why we were charged the amount that was well above that of a single large pizza. I don't mind if there was a delivery fee, it would be expected, but I would have liked to be informed why I was overcharged. read more

No frills little place. We stopped in there to grab a pizza during our camping trip at Kooser State Park. The pizza was a good and had a bit of a sweeter sauce which definitely sets it apart in my mind. Not a long wait for our pizza and you can't beat the price of $10 for a large 1 topping pizza. Keep in mind before visiting this place is CASH ONLY! read more

Hey gang, the other folks who mentioned the sweetness of the sauce are spot on. It's wayyyy too sweet. Wings were good though, and you're not exactly spoiled for choice if you're staying in Hidden Valley like we were. read more

Great pizza that has that sweet sauce taste, very nice owners, we go there as often as we are in the mountains!