Great place to stop by to get gas or food. It has liquor, food, snacks, bathrooms for the public, and anything else you would need. They are NOT understaffed and the place is spacious read more

See all

Deli is a joke, waiting for food 15 minutes, no one works together. Some of my hot food was prepared before the cold sandwiches and sat on the counter getting cold. In fact till we go to our destination it was cold anyway. read more

I re-read my original review and thought "what, no five-star review?" So I changed their score to five stars. The place is clean (recently remodeled) and the folks are still friendly and helpful. read more

Very snowy bad weather night. My order was hot and correct. Staff was friendly. Glad that they had enough staff. When so many places were closed. And for the other jerk customers that was complaining about my large order.. Life is not perfect. Suck it up. I had a crew to feed on this snowy night. Nice job on Rutters part on dealing with the situation. read more

I love Rutter's...however the outdoor seating/dining area in Gap, PA is always a mess. Here are photos from 9:00 AM on Sunday 9/18/22. read more

See all

Stopped here for gas that was decently priced. Went in to grab a snack and was shocked at the mark up. We are used to DC prices and this was still a shock. $18-$20 for regular brands of beef jerky, $2.69 for water. Hold out! We didn't realize there's a Sheetz a few doors down! read more

I give this Rutter's one star because the cashier couldn't have been any nicer or apologetic with my issue. We stopped on Sunday on our way to Gettysburg for gas and coffee. I ordered an iced latte on the kiosk and went to pay. I stood around and watched people who ordered food get it before my latte. I was getting annoyed and continued to stand there as 3 associates talked about other things. After about 15 minutes I was told their espresso machine was broken and that they could make me a smoothie or milkshake. I kindly told the young girl i need caffeine. She directed me to the $1.29 self serve hot coffee or "I could get a refund at the register". Imagine how annoyed I was when I had to wait in line again, just to get a refund. I explained to the nice cashier, who promptly gave me a refund. I left and went to Sheetz to get my coffee. I just don't understand how you know your machine is broken and yet allow me to stand around for at least 15 minutes. I won't be returning to this Rutter's anytime soon. read more

My husband likes to stop here as is per his tradition when traveling to/from upstate NY. This is a convenient location right off Route 15. They have a gas station which the prices are competitive with other places in the area. Inside its a bit dingy, think of sheetz but smaller and dingier and you've summed up Rutter's. You can get sandwiches and stuff made to order but honestly I'd rather go to my preferred stop and this place isn't it. read more

Are they serious with the new pump configuration? After only a few weeks, every metal pump pole/bumper has been hit, can't imagine how many people have damaged their car or truck as it's almost impossible to pull into pump when there is another car present. Went from 6 pumps to 5, why? To sell beer? This is all about greed and no concern for the community where folks have large pick-ups and recreational equipment trying to fuel up. Blatantly obvious this remodel is all about retail/beer sales and not about being a convenient gas station. I will gladly pay .02 more across the street and not damage my vehicle. The sheetz, one block up has abundant pumping stations and great food and service. Rutter's lack of regard for our community and their customer has caused me to take my business elsewhere. This used to be a convenient place for gas, ice, etc....no more. read more

That was one of the worse open faced chicken parm sandwiches I've ever had. Oh...right...they don't *do* open faced sandwiches. Well that's how it was made. Tomatoes were laid *on top* of my sandwich. Lettuce was rolling off like confetti at a parade. Yeah....and the only flavor tasted was the "spicy" sauce I placed on it. In this case this Rutter's needs to give me a star for stopping there and ordering a sandwich. By the way: stay away from the tasteless hash browns. Only good thing about them is you can tell the oil in which they were cooked was clean. Staff was nice, though. read more

Clean Bathroom, Great Salad This gas station/deli market far exceeded my expectations when my brother and I stopped just for a restroom break on our drive south from Grandma's in NY to our home in VA. The restroom had a tile finish and was spotless, likely thanks to the service button available to patrons if they find the cleanliness unsatisfactory. As I walked from the restroom, I grew aware of how famished I was, and my eyes were immediately drawn to the refrigerated island of deli foods. Perusing through the variety of pre-made foods, I decided on a HUGE garden salad that had crisp, fresh lettuce and greens, as well as a carton of cubed swiss cheese and sweet bologna, which turned out to be delicious. Will, the cashier, was polite and welcoming, concluding a pleasant, quick pit stop at Rutter's. Sheetz and WaWa are my gas stations of choice where I live, and Subway is my go-to travel meal, but the food in Rutter's proved to be superior in both freshness and price to the food options available in any of those stores. I wish there was a Rutter's in Fredericksburg, VA because I was surprisingly pleased with my experience. In future trips to NY, Rutter's will be my halfway stop for a very convenient, healthy travel meal. read more