Well stocked .well displayed.friendly help. Good parking. Great location. Would recommend.read more

lots and lots of things! owner is very helpful and knowledgeable. A little difficult to walk…read morethrough because of all the things.

Great place to thrift and consign. I have been going there for years. The ladies are very nice and…read moreprices are very reasonable.

The quality of clothing is not great. It's very organized and clean but the selection the day I was…read morethere was poor.

Love love love this store! From the time you walk in it's cozy feel and friendly staff make you…read morefeel right at home. There is always something new to see and their prices are reasonable. It's definitely worth stopping in !

From the owner: Cindy's Memory Lane - Consignment & Vintageread more

The Bayville store is a poor representation of Goodwill. It's often a mess, rather dirty,…read moredisorganized and full of worthless, often damaged junk that is over-priced with absolutely no sense whatsoever. clothes are often cheap quality, priced higher than new items that can be bought at stores like Walmart. better quality things are priced to compete with Boscov's or TJ Maxx-- and WHY would you buy the same thing at Goodwill, when you can get it at a nice retailer with better customer service policies? I googled Goodwill... and was shocked to learn they're bringing boycotted for so many reasons that reflect badly on their integrity-- not just on the low quality of their stock. look it up!! OK--anyway, to close, the Bayville store is a low-class image of a Thrift store and, considering the junk on the sales floor, along with the ridiculous overpricing-- you have to wonder where the good donations are going... and where the so-called charitable service is being done, since they pay less than minimum wage and their high-up people make over half a million dollars per year. my opinion of Goodwill has plummeted... and I advise YOU to look online for your own information and benefit.

Great store for all those hard to find items. We stop in every couple weeks ., great choice of…read morebooks, clothing, Halloween items.

This location is no longer open. The shop is closed as of…read moreJune 27, 2025 Drove all the way out in the shop is completely cleared out.

Fab little thrift store. Came after recommendation from cashier at goodwill 5 min away. Staff was…read moresuper friendly and prices where reasonable. Varied assortment of things. Lots of clothing. They were having a 1/2 off sale when I went. Be sure to check them out if your in the area.

Great store with good quality and amazing variety all at very good prices ! Owner is attentive and…read morekind, they've got a great frequent buyer program that's beneficial even for a first time visit I travel and see many many Thrifts across the Country and was totally impressed and got some great summer clothes

They do not care about their customers which is sad considering they are a small business…read more Snobbiest thrift shop I have ever attended.

Ridiculous! Will NOT ever go here again! Ripped me off$10! Very rude people! I wouldn't even rate 1…read morestar! But it makes your order to post review.

I recently donated and shopped in this store again. The VOLUNTEERS work tirelessly to get the…read moremerchandise sorted, priced and out for purchase. The cashier greeted me with a smile when I entered the store. The items as well as the store are clean and very organized. They have clothing, jewelry, collectibles, kitchen items, linens, glassware, books, electronics and much more! The shelves are always stocked with tons of unique finds! Do yourself a favor and go to the Old and New Shop....you won't be disappointed!