I have lived in Upstate New York but am not a New Yorker. So I can't attest to that moniker. But I will definitely say that the food was first class. Except maybe the sauce, which was a little cold. Might be because I ordered before the store opened. I really enjoyed the food and it was in good portions. I'll definitely try it out again. read more

I've been eating here since 2018. During that time, I had always been happy with the food and the service, unfortunately a week ago that changed. I placed my order at the counter, as I usually do. I ordered an item that I regularly order so I knew EXACTLY how much money I gave the clerk. She saw fit to keep my 10.00 in change and tried to argue with me about how much I gave her. On the way in the restaurant, I stopped to get 20.00 bucks out of the atm so I KNEW EXACTLY how much I gave her. A shady straight up grifter working the register, and she's still there skimming money off the till even after I called back and asked the manager to review the camera. Not only will I never go in there again, I plan to let anyone that asks about this experience know to go somewhere else so they don't get shortchanged. read more

Did the trick in a pinch, but I won't be returning. The crust had a dried up texture, and there was not really any sauce. Chicken wings were also dried up and hard to enjoy. There was a good amount of sauce on the wings, though, and good portioning of toppings on the pizza. Good prices for good portions, but not my favorite joint. read more

I used to frequent this place during my college years, and I always make it a point to order pizza whenever I return to the area. This pizza is better than any I've had in New York or anywhere else. I ordered extra cheese, and they certainly didn't hold back! The pizza is always hot and fresh, and the customer service is a solid 10/10. I highly recommend it! read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

Great food and friendly service. The pizza and Philly cheesesteaks are delicious. No pork toppings is also a bonus. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

This place is a whole in the wall. I waited close to 20 minutes for my food and YES IT WAS WORTH THE WAIT! I ordered one of the specials, a cheese pizza AND side salad with Greek dressing....FOR $6.99! You can't beat the price OR the quality of food. Their side salad was a great size and SO good. My cheese pizza was perfect!!! I'll definitely be back. I ate at the location but they have a lot of people that pick up, so I'll do that next time! read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Pizza by the slice and side salad - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

Normally get a cheese pie and a pepperoni pie which we have found to be some of the best on the peninsula and very consistent. We tried the calzones and Stromboli for a change and they may be our new favorites from Sal's. There was no leftovers from the calzones or Strombolis. Marinara sauce was warm and just the right spice. Definitely worth a try if you want Italian. read more

The bread was soggy meatballs were mushy and zero flavor . Tried to feed them to my dog she wouldn't even eat them. 100% the worst sub of any kind I've ever had. The fries were good though smh read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Worst meatball sub ever - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

The meat lovers pizza was awful, tasted like barbecue sauce not pizza sauce The Hawaiian was not very good - loaded with bacon bits read more

I'm from New York and this place is the real deal. They have the crust down. Very good, I'm also appreciative of their sauce to cheese ratio. read more

Do not eat there pizza and if you think about getting any of there food please don't because I was there and I sawed this dude in the cooking session after he was done preparing the pizza he put his breath into the dough do not eat their pizza take my advice before it is too late read more

To ordered a pizza to take home dinner. Basic pizza. I loved the crust! Best I've had I. Hampton. Delivered to my office sooner than expected because they didn't update the delivery app, but still the pizza was excellent! Will order again! read more

On Thursday, I wanted a Chicken Philly, so I looked on yelp for places close to me and Sal's popped up. I had never been here before and the reviews were back and forth, but I'm apart of Yelp so I decided to try it. I waited about 20 minutes for my food. It was night time and they stay busy with takeout orders and deliveries. The 20 minute wait was worth it. I did a takeout order and when I got home the food was still hotS This food was soooo good and I love the flavor. I got a Chicken Philly and bacon cheese fries. It's a little hole in the wall spot, but I'll definitely be back! GO TRY IT!!!! read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Deluxe Chicken and Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

Omg don't walk RUN to this pizza place!!! We ordered pizza through their app, Slice. It was delivered within 30min, hot and fresh! We ordered a large meat pizza, bacon cheese fries, garlic knots and grilled chicken Caesar salad. First, the grilled chicken Caesar salad was supposed to have dressing on it, but holy cow it didn't even need it!! It was huge! It was so flavorful!! My husband and I LOVED it! We couldn't finish it! The garlic knots were so good and my husband loved the fries. The pizza was amazing. Great crust, the flavors of the pepperoni, sausage, ham, and meatballs really complimented each other. We would totally order from Sal's again!! read more

As an Italian, i had certain expectations from this place, I ordered the stuffed shells for delivery and was please to have received a generous serving of 6 shells. Well seasoned ricotta cheese, delicious chunky marinara and to top it off the most generous serving of mozzarella I have seen! It was almost overwhelming. Very filling dinner, the side salad was great to end the meal and cut the grease. I also had the tiramisu for dessert and was very satisfied, up to my expectations. A little small for my taste, but strong coffee flavour, the mascarpone wasn't too sweet. Just a great Italian meal overall with no cut corners. Decent portion and meal for the price! Would definitely return to try all the other pastas!! Hope to have the same experience next time! read more

Ordered a Margarita Pizza. THERE WAS NO SAUCE. It tasted like watered up toilet paper. It had random cherry tomatoes on top, too? Just randomly grouped together in like two chunks, not spread out at all. The next day I became violently ill and I'm STILL feeling sick. Avoid at all costs man. read more

This is hands down the very best Sal's in the area -Southside or Peninsula. Owner cares and is meticulous. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Ground beef, Pepperoni, and extra cheese. Our regular order - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

the worse pizza i e ever had. the cheese was a soft cheese you squeeze out of a bottle. there was hardly any tomatoe sauce. maybe this was just a bad day for them read more

I continue to order from this place even though I'm consistently disappointed in the product because there aren't many options for pizza. Today we ordered online and received our order uncharacteristically fast. No complaint there... but once we opened it up we realized why. The Pizza was undercooked and they did not take care in transporting our order. Both pizzas had a lot of not most of the cheese slide off. The worst part is this place used to be good and now we order hoping it'll be the 1/5 times that it's good. We seriously need a better pizza establishment in Hampton. read more

This pizza restaurant keeps surprises getting me! Excellent pizza each time we ordered great delivery as well!

Wish I would've read all of the reviews. Now, I'm afraid I may get sick eating from a place with a 45 out of 100 health score. Pizza was room temp, barely any cheese or marinara sauce but We were starving so we mustered through. The pepperoni and the pizza was hard. Wings were really small but tasty. I think I'll try the other locations. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

We ordered the Chicken BBQ and Hawaiian Pizza, Buffalo wings, Garlic knots, and Meat Lover Calzone. The pizzas were like warm and the wings were ok, I say ok because the wings were a little over looked but still good. They have a delivery radius of 5 miles and we were at 5.8 so they didnt deliver to us. The price isn't too bad but the lady answering the phone was ready to hang up when they couldn't deliver to us, instead of asking if we wanted pick up. The Calzone was delicious and is the winner of all the things we got. read more

See all

Was trying to find a place close to where my appointment was and since I had been here once for pizza I decided to go here for pasta. Service: very friendly and prompt Food: Side salad; tasty and large Bread; burned, dry, stale Spaghetti and Meatballs; 1. huge portion 2. processed, frozen meatballs 3. spaghetti was baked and swimming in water 4. sauce was too sweet To boot when I pulled into the parking lot of about 75 spots, maybe 15 being filled, I picked an end spot so that I could pull my car close to the curb to avoid dinks. And literally one second later a woman, out of nowhere, zooms right next to me so close that it made it very difficult for me to continue to finish parking. I honked several times but she totally ignored me, (mind you, I had parked far away, and there were like 60 EMPTY spaces much closer!). As she gets out of her car, I roll down my window and say, "really? there are literally dozens of other spots in the lot that are empty but you had to park right on top of me and make it very difficult for me to finish parking". And you know what the entitled jerk said? "You have issues"!!! read more

See all

Ordered 2 Pizzas From Here Easter Sunday. We ordered 1 Large Bianca (Add Spinach) and 1 Half Chesese 1/2 Pepp. Everything Was Delicious!! Hot & Fresh! Definitely will be a return Customer! read more

UPDATE: I used to love Sal's, but have taken my business elsewhere. The first incident that happened that was my 2liter being left off my delivery order so I had to call. They offered to come back with it(taking 30mins) Or mention it to get it with my next order (I opted for the latter). The 2nd incident- they gave me peanut butter cheesecake when I ordered turtle cheesecake with my delivery order. The options for a correction were the same and in my opinion all forgivable. The last incident was the horrible customer service I received over the phone while attempting to place an order(Jordan). Not sure if he was having a bad day or just simply didn't want to be at work. Twice I've been spoken to rudely over the phone and is why I refuse to spend my money here any longer. The quality of the food unchanged but the quality of service unacceptable! Too many chances! read more

Two words: "only okay." My garlic knots were simply baked dough. I didn't notice any garlic, spices, cheese, or oil/butter on them. I was incredibly disappointed with these especially after looking at other yelp pics of their garlic knots. Also they were burned. Additionally, the side of marinara included tasted watered down. No flavor. The pizza was only okay. It looked amazing but it was greatly lacking in flavor. The prices are great though. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

I was a little worried about placing an order here with so many recent negative reviews. I ordered a side salad & ham & pineapple calzone for under $15. When I called for delivery, they said 30-40 minutes and they arrived in about 25. My salad was fresh and the shredded cheese wasn't gooey. The flavor of the calzone was delicious. It was diced ham instead of sliced luncheon meat so it had good flavor. Nice proportion of cheese go topping. It wasn't soggy and the beat part was the seasoning & grated parmesan on top. I definitely recommend them & will order again in the future. Only negative thing to say is that they didn't include plastic silverware or napkins. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Side salad - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

I ordered Sal'a NY Pizza (delivery) as a surprise for my husband. Not only are we both Portuguese and Italian, we're from Rhode Island and our Italian food is out of this world..he was beyond impressed. He actually has ordered from them several times since. Update - My daughter and I are visiting my husband and I didn't feel like cooking so we ordered Sal's! We ordered chicken parm and a single slice of cheese pizza. The chicken parm was huge. Tons of chicken and the sauce was phenomenal. Not only that, it came with a large slice of garlic bread AND side salad! The pizza could've passed for a personal pizza, not a slice. Thin crust. Lots of cheese. Not a lot of grease. The perfect pizza slice. Delivery was quick and the food was steaming hot!!! So not only was my husband impressed, my daughter and I were too!!! We will FOR SURE be ordering from them again! Thanks Sal's!! read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Chicken Parm!! So yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

See all

Man I was excited to have NY styled pizza, until I received It. Have you ever had little ceasers pizza and left it out for awhile and the cheese looked lifeless and stiff, well I got this pizza from sals fresh and the cheese looked just like that. So I take a bite, no flavor what so ever so I decided to put it in the oven maybe it'll taste better hot. Actually the heat made it worse I had to spit it out and throw the whole pizza away never again. I've never made a yelp review before cause I don't care, but this pizza was so bad I had to let someone know read more

You're missing out on this place! Wow.. So amazingly good! I ordered delivery for the first time to try out a new place since I just moved here. The food is amazing. Cheap! And you get a lot of it! Delivery driver was very nice. Ordered through Yelp.. Said 45 minutes but came before that. read more

Sal's NY Pizza - The regular calzone is giant! Everything is fresh and hot! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia

I'd say this place deserves their four stars. The price is decent. I think we paid a little over 15 for a one topping 18 inch pizza. The spaghetti is a bit pricier than I would have liked considering it's noodles and marinara. But oh well. They deliver and were pretty decent. My husband and son enjoyed it so that's all that matters really. Delivery was fast. Food was super hot. So yeah I'd order from here again. read more

This place and the one on north king street ,they have the best ny pizza in the 757 area

This is my first review I was so disappointed with my food I had to leave a review . I made a pizza order vegetarian thin crust pizza I added garlic and basil on the pizza I also ordered wings also with sauce on the side . The 14 inch pizza and wings came to 31 dollars when the pizza came the vegetables were Raw and the crust was wet from to many vegetables it was so under cooked I couldn't eat them I call them and spoke to the manager he told me he would send out a new one he told me he would Sauté the vegetables and he would make the pizza himself when I got the second pizza it was full of oil from the vegetables being sautéed I have never herd of sautéing vegetables for pizza I will never order anything from them again my first and my last time. Awful read more

Sal's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hampton, Virginia